LGBT adoption and parenting in Australia

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Main article: LGBT parenting

Family Law in Australia with regard to children is often based on what is considered to be in the best interest of the child. The traditional and often used assumption is that children need both a mother and a father, which plays an important role in divorce and custodial proceedings, and has carried over into adoption and fertility procedures, even though those assertions find no support in the scientific research literature.[1][2][3][4][5]

Overview[edit]

As laws within the whole of Australia since 1 July 2009 have only begun to recognise de facto same-sex couples under the Family Law Act 1975,[6] there are very limited areas where same-sex couples have rights with respect to conceiving, adopting, and rearing children. Additionally, women (particularly birth mothers) are generally given more rights over children than men, giving more room for lesbian couples to adopt and have genetic children. Male couples have virtually no legal opportunities to become legally recognised parents aside from adoption except in cases of drug abuse, mental illness, and physical, sexual, and emotional abuse from the mother.

LGBT adoption rights in Australia.
  Joint adoption and stepparent adoption legal
  Stepparent adoption legal
  LGBT Foster parenting only
  Joint adoption and stepparent adoption illegal
Same-sex couple joint petition LGBT individual adoption Same-sex stepparent adoption
New South Wales No Yes (since 2010)[7] Yes Yes (since 2000)[8] No Yes (since 2010)
ACT Yes Yes (since 2004) Yes Yes (since 1993)[9] Yes Yes (since 2004)
Western Australia Yes Yes (since 2002) Yes Yes[10] Yes Yes (since 2002)
Tasmania Yes Yes (since 2013) Yes Yes[11] Yes Yes (since 2004)
Queensland No No (under review since 2008) Yes Yes (since 2009)[12] No No
Victoria No No[13] (under review since 2007) Yes Yes[14] Yes Yes (since 2007)
Northern Territory No No Only in exceptional circumstances[15] No No
South Australia No No No singles, must only be an opposite-sex couple (married or cohabitating)[16] No No

Same-sex parent adoption[edit]

Adoption for same-sex couples is currently available in Australian Capital Territory, Western Australia, New South Wales, and Tasmania.[7][17] In Queensland, same-sex couples cannot legally adopt a child under the Adoption Act 2009, but allows single LGBT people to adopt as single or become foster parents.[18][19] Single LGBT people may adopt in some states, but individuals seeking to adopt are considered less of a priority than couples and lengthy waiting lists for adoption make it virtually impossible. Individuals may usually only adopt a child with special needs or in cases of exceptional circumstances. The Northern Territory and South Australia are expected to hand down findings reports by May 2008 to consider legalising adoption for same-sex couples.

Western Australia became the first Australian state to allow same-sex adoptions when its Labor government passed the Acts Amendment (Lesbian and Gay Law Reform) Act 2002 which in turn amended the Adoption Act 1994 (WA). This allowed same-sex couples to adopt in accordance with criteria that assesses the suitability of couples and individuals to be parents, regardless of sexual orientation.

Australia's first legal gay adoption, by two men, occurred in Western Australia in June 2007.[20][21][22][23] Subsequently, on 2 August 2007, the federal government under Prime Minister John Howard announced it would legislate to stop same-sex couples adopting a child from overseas, and would further not recognise adopted children of same-sex couples. The federal Coalition's proposed Family Law (Same Sex Adoption) Bill would amend the Family Law Act 1975 and override state and territory laws that currently cover international adoptions. The bill was due to be introduced in the spring 2007 session of parliament, but has been taken off the agenda following the 2007 federal election.[24][25]

In July 2009 the NSW Law and Justice Committee decided that the Adoption Act 2000 should be amended to allow same-sex couples the right to adopt. Committee chair Christine Robertson said, "The committee has concluded that reform to allow same-sex couples to adopt will help to ensure that the best interests of children are met by our adoption laws and all recommendations were implemented in 2010."[26]

Same-sex step-parent adoption[edit]

In Western Australia, New South Wales and the ACT, lesbian co-mother or gay co-father may use stepparent adoption provisions, although female couples in those states whose children were born through assisted conception may not actually need to adopt them, as the law there presumes the mother's female partner to be a legal parent as long as she consented to the conception.[27] In [Tasmania, same-sex stepparent adoption (where one partner is the biological parent of the child) became legal in 2001.[28][29] As of 2008, half of the states and territories, allow both same-sex partners to have a legally-recognised relationship with their child.

However, even those laws contain a general presumption against making an adoption order because an adoption order severs the legal relationship between the child and one of the child's birth parents. Due to the serious consequences of an adoption order, all step-parent adoption laws (including those applying to opposite-sex couples) contain a strong preference for dealing with new parenting arrangements through a parenting order rather than an adoption order.

In states and territories where same-sex stepparent adoptions are not allowed, the lesbian co-mother or gay co-father may apply to the Family Court of Australia for a parenting order, as ‘other people significant to the care, welfare and development’ of the child. It provides an important "status quo" if the birth mother were to die, so for example other family members could not come and take the child. But the lesbian co-mother and gay co-father will be treated in the same way as a social parent is treated under the law; they will not be treated in the same way as a birth parent.[30]

The Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission (HREOC) issued a report in 2007 entitled National Inquiry into Discrimination against People in Same-Sex Relationships recommended amending or creating laws recognising the relationship between a child and both same-sex parents. In particular, "‘Stepparent adoption’ laws should more readily consider adoption by a lesbian co-mother or gay co-father. This will require amendments to remove the prohibition on same-sex stepparent adoption in all state and territory laws other than in WA, the ACT and Tasmania." The final report of the Same-Sex: Same Entitlements Inquiry was tabled in Parliament on 21 June 2007.[31]

Assisted reproduction and surrogacy[edit]

Assisted Reproductive Technology (ART) and surrogacy comes under the jurisdiction of states and territories in Australia so national legislation cannot be used to regulate its practice. In Vitro Fertilization technologies, artificial insemination, and other reproductive technologies are legal in nearly all states and territories. South Australia is the only state that bans altruistic surrogacy for singles and same-sex couples and also limits access to IVF to those who are infertile or carrying a genetic disorder.[32]

Commercial surrogacy and related advertising remains illegal in all states and territories except for the Northern Territory where there are no laws or regulations regarding surrogacy arrangements. Altruistic surrogacy, where the surrogate receives no financial reward for her pregnancy or the relinquishment of the child, is legal in the Australian Capital Territory, New South Wales,[33] Victoria, Tasmania[34] and Queensland.[35] With altruistic surrogacy, only expenses related to the pregnancy and birth are paid by the intended parents such as medical expenses, maternity clothing, and other related expenses.

The practice of altruistic surrogacy for same-sex couples remains illegal only in Western Australia and South Australia.[36] It is believed that only 1 in 20 surrogacy arrangements take place in Australia; almost all involving foreign surrogates from South-East Asia and the United States.[37] In Tasmania, until 30 April 2012 then the Surrogacy Contracts Act 1993 is then repealed and replaced on 1 May 2013 with the Surrogacy Act 2012 becoming effective to allow altruistic surrogacy for all singles and couples of all genders.[34] In Queensland where the newly elected state Liberal National Party government who won the Queenland state election in March 2012 with a massive super-majority, has announced that they will re-criminalise altruistic surrogacy for singles, same-sex couples and opposite-sex couples who have been in a de facto relationship for less than 2 years.[38] In November 2006, Attorneys-Generals from all states and territories agreed in principle to uniform surrogacy regulations which meant couples would no longer have to travel to avoid illegal arrangements in their home state after Victorian Senator Stephen Conroy and his wife, Paula Benson, revealed that their daughter Isabella had been born to a surrogate mother in Sydney via the in-vitro fertilisation of a donated egg.[39][40][41] In April 2007, Federal Attorney-General Philip Ruddock called for national surrogacy laws, so couples in some states no longer have to travel elsewhere to undergo the procedure legally.[42]

Obtaining legal parental rights for same sex partners of birth parents has only recently been addressed in limited ways. All states and territories recognise female co-mothers as birth parents of children conceived through in vitro fertilisation or artificial insemination. Male couples who arrange altruistic surrogacy (since commercial surrogacy is illegal) using one partner's sperm, which may be legally possible in the Australian Capital Territory, New South Wales, Tasmania,[34] Western Australia, Queensland and Victoria, will face legal difficulties gaining rights for the genetic father as a 'sperm donor', and terminating the surrogate mother's rights (ideally through a stepparent adoption), which will be required in order to obtain legal recognition for the non-biological male partner. A growing number of male couples from around the world are attempting to become parents through surrogacy in America due to its favourable laws.[43] However, it is a criminal offence for a person ordinarily resident in Queensland, New South Wales or the ACT to enter into a commercial surrogacy arrangement anywhere in the world.

ART/IVF for surrogates of male couples ART/IVF for lesbian couples Commercial surrogacy Altruistic surrogacy Automatically recognise non-genetic parent at birth
Queensland Yes Yes Yes Legal No Illegal Yes Legal Yes Yes (for all couples)
ACT Yes Yes Yes Legal No Illegal Yes Legal Yes Yes (for all couples)
Tasmania Yes Yes[34] Yes Legal No Illegal Yes Legal[34] Yes Yes (for all couples)[34]
Victoria Yes Yes Yes Legal No Illegal Yes Legal Yes Yes (for all couples)
New South Wales Yes Yes Yes Legal No Illegal Yes Legal Yes Yes (for all couples)
Northern Territory No No laws at this point in time Yes Legal No No laws at this point in time No No laws at this point in time Yes Yes (female couples), No No laws at this point in time (male couples)
Western Australia No Illegal Yes Legal No Illegal No Illegal (banned for singles and same sex couples); Yes Legal (for heterosexual couples who are married or in a de facto relationship)[44] Yes Yes (for all couples), No No (male couples)
South Australia No Illegal No Only allowed for "medically infertile" women No Illegal No Illegal (banned for singles and same sex couples); Yes Legal (for heterosexual couples who are married or in a de facto relationship)[45] Yes Yes (female couples), No No (male couples)

ACT[edit]

The Parentage Act 2004 made non-commercial surrogacy legal but the birth mother and her husband were deemed to be the parents unless the genetic parents adopt the child back. In 2000, The ACT became the first state or territory to allow the genetic parents who are heterosexual of a child born through surrogacy to become its legal parents, allowing them to easily obtain a parenting order and avoid adoption.[46][47] It is illegal to advertise for a surrogate and to pay for a surrogate or an ovum donor. When two women are in a same-sex relationship, and one of them gives birth as a result of ART, her partner is presumed to be a parent of the child. The ACT's birth registration process allows for a person to be registered as a 'mother', 'father' or 'parent', enabling lesbian couples to be recognised as parents on a child's birth documents.

New South Wales[edit]

Northern Territory[edit]

The Northern Territory was the second jurisdiction to extend a presumption of parentage to lesbian partners in 2003 with its Status of Children Act 2003, following Western Australia's lead in 2002.[48][49]

Queensland[edit]

South Australia[edit]

Tasmania[edit]

The Status of Children Act 1974 states that the woman who gives birth to the child is the mother, regardless of genetics. The Act does make a mention of "parentage" of both co-mothers in section 10C, however a report back in 2003 by the Joint Standing Committee on Community Development proposed amending the Act to recognise the lesbian partner as a parent via the Relationships (Consequential Amendments) Bill 2003 but it failed to pass in the upper house by just one vote.[50] In June 2009, the Relationships (Miscellaneous Amendments) Bill proposed reform to the state's Adoption Act and Status of Children Act, allowing non-biological lesbian parents to be legally considered the parents of a child conceived using IVF.[51] The bill passed the lower house 45-3 on 20 August, opposed by three Liberal MHA's who had been given a conscience vote. The Legislative Council (Upper House) ratified the bill with amendments to back date the law to 1 January 2004 in October without dissent.[52] The lower house approved of the amendments made in the upper house in November 2009 and then passed the Tasmanian parliament.[53]

In 2012, Tasmania passed two pieces of legislation to legally allow altruistic surrogacy. The two laws are called the Surrogacy Act No 34 and the Surrogacy (Consequential Amendments) Act No 31.[34][54] Proposed altruistic surrogacy legislation was drafted and passed by both houses of the Tasmanian parliament - only after a review of the Surrogacy Contracts Act 1993 No 4[55][56] and after an ongoing community consultation process. Under the altruistic surrogacy legislation, the surrogate must be at least 25 years old and it cannot be her first pregnancy. The new altruistic surrogacy laws went into effect on May 1, 2013.[34]

Victoria[edit]

Western Australia[edit]

The Human Reproductive Technology Act 1991 (WA) established that to use any ART, a woman must be unable to conceive a child due to medical reasons (clinical infertility) and "persons seeking to be treated as a couple must be married or in a de facto relationship and must be of the opposite sex to each other".[57]

In 2002, the Artificial Conception Act 1985 was amended to deal with lesbian couples. It stated that, where a woman who is in a de facto relationship with another woman undergoes, with the consent of her de facto partner, an artificial fertilisation procedure, the de facto partner of the pregnant woman is conclusively presumed to be a parent of the unborn child and is a parent of any child born as a result of the pregnancy.[58]

Western Australia's Registry of Births, Deaths and Marriages allows for registration of a parent other than a 'mother' and/or 'father' on the birth documents of the child. The birth registration form provides same-sex couples with the option of describing themselves as 'mother' and ‘parent’; 'mother' and ‘mother’; or 'parent' and 'parent'. Provided proper consent has been given by both the woman and her same-sex partner, the partner will conclusively be presumed to be the parent of any resulting child.

The Surrogacy Bill 2007 was passed by the Legislative Assembly (Lower House) in September 2007, and was referred to the Standing Committee on Legislation within the Legislative Council (Upper House) in November 2007. It was sent back to the Legislative Council with amendments for a third reading in June 2008. The legislation was passed on 4 December 2008.[59][60]

References[edit]

  1. ^ "Microsoft Word - APA California Amicus Brief - As Filed.DOC" (PDF). Retrieved 20 January 2011. 
  2. ^ Canadian Psychological Association: Brief presented to the Legislative House of Commons Committee on Bill C38 By the Canadian Psychological Association 2 June 2005.
  3. ^ Short, Elizabeth; Damien W. Riggs; Amaryll Perlesz; Rhonda Brown; Graeme Kane (August 2007). "Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender (LGBT) Parented Families – A Literature Review prepared for The Australian Psychological Society". The Australian Psychological Society. Retrieved 2 May 2013. 
  4. ^ "Children's Development of Social Competence Across Family Types" (PDF). Retrieved 20 January 2011. 
  5. ^ Michael Lamb, PhD: Affidavit – United States District Court for the District of Massachusetts (2009)
  6. ^ "FAMILY LAW ACT 1975". Austlii.edu.au. Retrieved 20 January 2011. 
  7. ^ a b "Australian state votes for adoption by same-sex couples". The Hindu (India). Deutsche Presse-Agentur. 2 September 2010. Retrieved 2 September 2010. 
  8. ^ "ADOPTION ACT 2000". Austlii.edu.au. 1 January 2011. Retrieved 20 January 2011. 
  9. ^ "ADOPTION ACT 1993". Austlii.edu.au. Retrieved 20 January 2011. 
  10. ^ "ADOPTION ACT 1994". Austlii.edu.au. 5 March 2010. Retrieved 20 January 2011. 
  11. ^ "Adoption Act 1988 (Tas) – Sect 20. Persons in whose favour adoption orders may be made". Austlii. Retrieved 1 May 2008. 
  12. ^ "ADOPTION ACT 2009 No. 29". Austlii.edu.au. Retrieved 20 January 2011. 
  13. ^ "Adoption Act 1984 – SECT 10A". Austlii. Retrieved 1 May 2008. 
  14. ^ "Adoption Act 1984 – SECT 11". Austlii. Retrieved 1 May 2008. 
  15. ^ "Adoption of Children Act (NT)". Austlii. Retrieved 1 May 2008. 
  16. ^ "Adoption Act 1988 (SA)". South Australia Attorney-General's Department. Retrieved 1 May 2008. 
  17. ^ "Adoption Act 1994 – Section 39 Criteria for application". Austlii. Retrieved 1 May 2008. 
  18. ^ "Adoption Act 2009" (PDF). Retrieved 20 January 2011. 
  19. ^ "Same sex couples". Legal Aid Queensland. Archived from the original on 25 May 2008. Retrieved 1 May 2008. 
  20. ^ "Gay adoption 'groundbreaking'". PerthNow. 12 June 2007. Retrieved 13 May 2008. [dead link]
  21. ^ "First Legal Gay Adoption in Australia". SameSame.com.au. Retrieved 13 May 2008. 
  22. ^ "Australia's First Legal Adoption For Gay Couple". efluxmedia. Retrieved 13 May 2008. 
  23. ^ "Australia's First Gay Adoption". ProudParenting.com. Retrieved 13 May 2008. 
  24. ^ "Green Left – Stop the proposed same-sex adoption ban". Green Left. Retrieved 13 May 2008. 
  25. ^ "Gay couples face overseas adoption ban". Sydney Morning Herald. 2 August 2007. Retrieved 13 May 2008. 
  26. ^ "Adoption Inquiry Backs Same-Sex Couples". SSO Net. 9 July 2009. Retrieved 15 May 2008. 
  27. ^ "Is second parent adoption possible in Australia?". Gay & Lesbian Rights Lobby. Archived from the original on 19 July 2008. Retrieved 13 May 2008. 
  28. ^ "Same-sex parenting". PHD Blog It. Retrieved 13 May 2008. 
  29. ^ Grattan, Michelle (27 April 2004). "Gay adoption law to stay". The Age (Melbourne). Retrieved 13 May 2008. 
  30. ^ "Same Sex, Same Entitlements". Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission. Retrieved 13 May 2008. 
  31. ^ "Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission". Hreoc.gov.au. Retrieved 20 January 2011. 
  32. ^ "Victorian IVF win for lesbians". GenerationQ. Archived from the original on 8 February 2008. Retrieved 6 December 2009. 
  33. ^ http://www.lawlink.nsw.gov.au/lawlink/Corporate/ll_corporate.nsf/vwFiles/080510_surrogacy.pdf/$file/080510_surrogacy.pdf
  34. ^ a b c d e f g h "Numerical Table of the Acts of Parliament 2012". Tasmania Department of Premier and Cabinet. 27 February 2013. Retrieved 2 May 2013. 
  35. ^ "SURROGACY ACT 2010 No. 2". Austlii.edu.au. Retrieved 20 January 2011. 
  36. ^ Two dads and a surrogate create legal landmark
  37. ^ Two dads and a surrogate create legal landmark
  38. ^ "Gays face surrogacy ban as LNP pushes civil union changes". Brisbane Times. 22 June 2012. Retrieved 15 August 2012. 
  39. ^ "Desperate plea for end to secret trade in human eggs". Sydney Morning Herald. 12 November 2006. Retrieved 14 May 2008. 
  40. ^ "Church (3 February 2006)". The Age (Melbourne). Retrieved 14 May 2008. 
  41. ^ "Surrogacy laws too varied, Ruddock tells states". Sydney Morning Herald. 8 November 2006. Retrieved 14 May 2008. 
  42. ^ MacNamara, Lisa (7 April 2007). "Call for uniform surrogacy laws". The Australian. Retrieved 14 May 2008. 
  43. ^ "Surrogate mothers fulfilling gay men's parenthood dreams". Sydney Morning Herald. 7 May 2008. Retrieved 14 May 2008. 
  44. ^ [1]
  45. ^ Australia. "Statutes Amendment (Surrogacy) Act 2009". Legislation.sa.gov.au. Retrieved 20 January 2011. 
  46. ^ "Parentage Act 2004" (PDF). Retrieved 20 January 2011. 
  47. ^ "ACT approves surrogacy bill". ABC. Retrieved 14 May 2008. 
  48. ^ Millbank, Jenni (2 April 2008). "One state, one mother". SX News. Retrieved 3 June 2008. 
  49. ^ "Status of Children Act". NT Department of Justice. 17 March 2004. Retrieved 3 June 2008. [dead link]
  50. ^ "Report on Amendments to the Relationships Bill 2003" (PDF). Joint Standing Committee on Community Development. Retrieved 4 June 2008. 
  51. ^ Noonan, Andie (23 June 2009). "Tasmania to grant parental rights". Sydney Star Observer. Retrieved 3 September 2009. 
  52. ^ Hackney, Peter (2 November 2009). "Tasmania approves same-sex family law". MCV. Retrieved 2 November 2009. 
  53. ^ "Parliament of Tasmania – Annual Register of Bills". Parliament.tas.gov.au. Retrieved 20 January 2011. 
  54. ^ "Parliament passes landmark Surrogacy laws". Tasmania Department of Premier and Cabinet. 2012-09-25. Retrieved 2012-12-26. 
  55. ^ "Surrogacy Contracts Act 1993". Thelaw.tas.gov.au. Retrieved 2012-12-26. 
  56. ^ "SURROGACY CONTRACTS ACT 1993". Austlii.edu.au. 1993-04-20. Retrieved 2012-12-26. 
  57. ^ "Human Reproductive Technology Act 1991 (WA)". Austlii. Retrieved 14 May 2008. 
  58. ^ "Artificial Conception Act 1985 – Section 6a. Rule relating to parentage – same sex de facto relationships". Austlii. Retrieved 14 May 2008. 
  59. ^ "Surrogacy Bill 2007". Parliament of Western Australia. Retrieved 6 December 2009. 
  60. ^ "Surrogacy Act 2008". Retrieved 20 January 2011.