Lake Pedder

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Lake Pedder
Original Lake pedder.jpg
Lake Pedder, 1970
Location Tasmania
Coordinates 42°56′S 146°08′E / 42.933°S 146.133°E / -42.933; 146.133Coordinates: 42°56′S 146°08′E / 42.933°S 146.133°E / -42.933; 146.133
Lake type From 1972: reservoir, artificial impoundment, diversion pond; until 1972: natural, Glacial Outwash Lake
Basin countries Australia
Surface area 242 km2 (93 sq mi)
Average depth 13–16 m (43–52 ft) (new)
Max. depth +3 m (9.8 ft) (original) 43 m (141 ft) (new)
Water volume 2.9 km3 (0.70 cu mi)
Islands 2 (original), 45 (new)

Lake Pedder was once a natural lake, located in the southwest of Tasmania, Australia but the name is now used in an official sense to refer to the much larger artificial impoundment and diversion lake formed when the original lake was expanded by damming in 1972 by the Hydro Electric Commission of Tasmania.

The new Lake Pedder has an area of about 242 km²[1] and it is considered to be the largest freshwater lake in Australia.

Original Lake Pedder and the modified Lake Pedder[edit]

In early 20th century the original lake was named after Sir John Pedder, the first Chief Justice of Tasmania. The name of the original lake was officially transferred to the new man-made impoundment. Although the new Lake Pedder incorporates the original lake, it does not resemble it in size, appearance or ecology.

The new lake consists of an impoundment contained by three dams:

The dams were designed and constructed by Tasmania's Hydro Electric Commission (HEC) as part of the Upper Gordon River hydro-electric generation scheme. The aim of this scheme was to increase Tasmania's capacity to generate hydro-electricity in accordance with the Tasmanian Government's policy of attempting to attract secondary industry to the State with the incentive of cheap renewable energy.

The new Huon Serpentine impoundment, which filled after the dams were completed in 1972, drains into Lake Gordon via the McPartlan Pass Canal at 42°51′4″S 146°11′2″E / 42.85111°S 146.18389°E / -42.85111; 146.18389. Together, the lakes form the biggest water catchment and storage system in Australia.

Damming[edit]

Panoramic view of 'new' Lake Pedder from Mount Eliza, Southwest National Park, Tasmania, Australia

There were protests in Tasmania and mainland Australia at the flooding of the original lake, before during and after construction of the dams. Protests began when in 1967 the Tasmanian Government revoked the status of the Lake Pedder National Park that had protected the lake since 1955. The role of the HEC as a surrogate wing of the Tasmanian government was perceived when the political or wider social dissent against the HEC power over the Tasmanian environment seemed impregnable. Tasmania's political leader, Premier Eric Reece and Allan Knight, the HEC Commissioner, were seen as the leading proponents of the 'damming' of Tasmania against any opinion to the contrary, and were not averse to taking their opinions to state wide and national advertising campaigns asserting their right to dam the lake.[3]

Reece was well known for his staunch support of the HEC and its power development schemes on the Gordon River, which earned him the nickname "Electric Eric".[4] In 1972, he approved the flooding of Lake Pedder, which proceeded despite a determined protest movement and a blank cheque offer from Prime Minister Gough Whitlam to preserve the Lake Pedder area. Reece refused Whitlam's offer, stating that he would "not have the Federal Government interfering with the sovereign rights of Tasmania".[5]

Reece was quoted as saying:

"There was a National Park out there, but I can't remember exactly where it was . . . at least, it wasn't of substantial significance in the scheme of things. The thing that was significant was that we had to double the output of power in this state in ten years in order [to] supply the demands of industry and the community. And this was the scheme that looked as though it could do a greater part of [the] job for us."[6]

Flooding[edit]

A series of photographs in the 1976 Tasmanian Year book illustrated the process of flooding of the Lake Pedder area.[7]

Community response[edit]

Opposition to the flooding of Lake Pedder extended well beyond Tasmania and spread throughout Australia and internationally. The focus on the South West Tasmania Wilderness area as an environmental battleground increased interest in the area, and many travelled to Lake Pedder before it was flooded to see what the issues were about.

The protests included the United Tasmania Group who were the precursor to the Tasmanian Greens and are now recognised as the world's first green party. The group that preceded the Tasmanian Wilderness Society – the South West Tasmania Action Committee continued after the flooding, with the knowledge that surveying and appraising other catchments in the south west and west of Tasmania was well underway by the HEC. Although increasingly sophisticated economic, environmental and engineering arguments were raised by the opponents of the dam, it was not until the Franklin scheme that either the Hydro or its defenders were even considering the critiques. In 1972, the Christian activist Brenda Hean perished with pilot Max Price in a tiger moth aircraft they were flying from Tasmania to Canberra to protest the damming of Lake Pedder; it was alleged that pro-dam campaigners had entered the plane's hangar and placed sugar in one of its fuel tanks.[8]

Hesba Fay Brinsmead, an Australian children's author and environmentalist, wrote two books about the damming of Lake Pedder:

  • Echo in the Wilderness is a children's novel set on Lake Pedder on the eve of its flooding (published 1972)
  • I Will Not Say the Day Is Done (her only non-fiction/adult book) describes the struggle to save Lake Pedder (published 1983)

Concerns over the construction of the dam revolved around the loss of the distinctive pink quartzite beach of the original lake, and an increased understanding of the unique nature of the wilderness quality to the south west of Tasmania. This developed further with the Franklin Dam issue.

In 1994, a campaign group was launched called Pedder 2000.[9][10] They proposed, unsuccessfully, the draining and restoration of the lake to its original state. There is an ongoing low-key campaign with the same goal by the group known as the Lake Pedder Action Committee which remains active[11]

A controversial and contested name[edit]

As is the case in many land use, land ownership and territorial disputes, the name currently officially assigned to this body of water has considerable significance. It is also important in terms of understanding the technical status of the body of water as a component of a hydro-electric scheme.

From a technical, hydro-electric scheme point of view, the current Lake Pedder can be correctly termed a lake or reservoir as the water from Lake Pedder can flow into Lake Gordon via the McPartlan's Pass canal and is thereby connected to the Gordon power station.[12] However, people opposed to the flooding of the original lake do not accept the legitimacy of the official, gazetted name of Lake Pedder for the body of water that drowned it in 1972. Instead, they prefer to use the name Huon-Serpentine Impoundment. This name denotes the two major rivers dammed to create the current lake (Huon and Serpentine) and describes the technical status of the lake as an element of a hydro-electric scheme (impoundment) more accurately than the terms lake or reservoir.[13] Bushwalkers sometimes informally refer to it as "Fake Pedder".[14][15]

Lake Pedder extinctions[edit]

The Lake Pedder earthworm (Hypolimnus pedderensis) is only known by the type specimen collected from a beach on Lake Pedder, Tasmania in 1971. After the flooding of the lake, this invertebrate was never seen again. A 1996 survey that sought to determine whether the species still existed in the area failed to find any examples. Since 2003 the Lake Pedder Earthworm has been listed as extinct on the IUCN Red List of Threatened Species.[16]

An extinction claimed to have occurred after the flooding is that of the Lake Pedder planarian (Romankenkius pedderensis), an endemic flatworm. Since 1996 this invertebrate has also been listed as extinct on the IUCN Red List of Threatened Species.[17] In 2012 the continued existence of this species was reported.[18]

The Pedder galaxias, an Australian freshwater fish, is considered extinct in its natural habitat of Lake Pedder and its tributaries, although it still exists in captivity and in two translocated populations, one at Lake Oberon in the Western Arthurs mountain range.[19] and one at a modified water supply dam near Strathgordon.[20]

Panoramic view of 'new' Lake Pedder

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ "The Gordon Catchment". Hydro Tasmania website. Hydro Tasmania. Retrieved 2009-05-20. [dead link]
  2. ^ a b c Gordon River – more power to Tasmania, www.wheretostay.com.au, Accessed 29 November 2009
  3. ^ McKenry, Keith (1972) A History and critical analysis of the controversy concerning the Gordon River Power Scheme pp.9 – 39 in Australian Conservation Foundation (1972) Pedder Papers – Anatomy of a Decision Parkville, Vic. Australian Conservation Foundation – specially the appendix with examples of the advertising used pp. 30–39
  4. ^ Millwood, Scott Whatever happened to Brenda Hean? Crows Nest, NSW ISBN 9781741756111 offers some details of his autocratic style of dealing with opposition
  5. ^ Lake Pedder 30th Anniversary, Dimensions in Time (ABC TV), 10 June 2002.
  6. ^ TimeFrame: Lake Pedder, ABC TV.
  7. ^ Reid, Vern (1976) B&W photos between p.248 and 249and not indexed Tasmanian Year Book No.10 1976. Australian Bureau of Statistics Tasmanian Office ISSN 0082-2116
  8. ^ Scott Millwood. Whatever Happened to Breanda Hean? Allen &Unwin. Sydney 2008 pp 280–281.
  9. ^ Mosley, J. G. (John Geoffrey); Lake Pedder Study Group; Pedder 2000 (Organization) (1994), How Lake Pedder can be restored, Pedder 2000, ISBN 978-0-646-22388-9 
  10. ^ Sharples, C. E. (Chris E.); University of Tasmania. Centre for Environmental Studies; Symposium on Lake Pedder : Values and Restoration (1995 : University of Tasmania) (2001), Lake Pedder : values and restoration : the proceedings of a symposium held on 8th April 1995 at the University of Tasmania, Hobart (1st ed ed.), Centre for Environmental Studies, Dept. of Geography and Environmental Studies, University of Tasmania, ISBN 978-0-85901-970-5 
  11. ^ Lake Pedder Restoration Committee
  12. ^ "SCOTTS PEAK DAM". The Institution of Engineers, Australia. Retrieved 25 December 2013. 
  13. ^ McConnel, Anne. "The Cultural Heritage of the Huon-Serpentine Impoundment, and an assessment of the effects of the restoration of Lake Pedder". Lake Pedder Restoration Committee. Retrieved 25 December 2013. 
  14. ^ "Lake Pedder – the victim of an ignorant time". The Habitat Advocate. Retrieved 25 December 2013. 
  15. ^ "Pedder campaign gains momentum". Australian Broadcasting Commission. 7 July 2013. Retrieved 25 December 2013. 
  16. ^ * IUCN Red List of Threatened Species: Hypolimnus pedderensis
  17. ^ * IUCN Red List of Threatened Species: Romankenkius pedderensis
  18. ^ Forteath, GNR and Osborn, AW Survival of endemic invertebrates of Lake Pedder and Lake Edgar subsequent to inundation. Records of the Queen Victoria Museum 116:2012
  19. ^ * The Extinction Website
  20. ^ Australian Department of the Environment and Heritage (2006). Galaxias pedderensis in Species Profile and Threats Database, Department of the Environment and Heritage, Canberra.

Further reading[edit]

  • Buckman, Greg (2008), Tasmania's Wilderness Battles A History, Allen & Unwin, ISBN 978-1-74176-487-1 
  • Gee, Helen, (joint ed.); Fenton, Janet, (joint ed.); Australian Conservation Foundation (1978), The south west book : a Tasmanian wilderness, Australian Conservation Foundation, ISBN 978-0-85802-056-6 
  • Green, Roger; Lea, G; Australian Conservation Foundation (1984), Battle for the Franklin : conversations with the combatants in the struggle for south west Tasmania, Fontana/Australian Conservation Foundation, ISBN 978-0-00-636715-4 
  • Lines, William J (2006), Patriots : defending Australia's natural heritage, University of Queensland Press, ISBN 978-0-7022-3554-2 
  • Neilson, David (1975), South West Tasmania : a land of the wild, Rigby, ISBN 978-0-85179-874-5 
  • Thompson, Peter; Australian Conservation Foundation (1981), Power in Tasmania, Australian Conservation Foundation, ISBN 978-0-85802-067-2 

External links[edit]