Lesbian kiss episode
The "lesbian kiss episode" is a sub-genre of the media portrayal of lesbianism in American television media, created in the 1990s. Beginning in 1991 with a kiss on the American L.A. Law series' episode "He's a Crowd" between C.J. Lamb and Abby Perkins,[note 1] David E. Kelley, who wrote the episode in question, went on to use the trope in at least two of his other shows. Subsequent television series included an episode in which a seemingly heterosexual female character engages in a kiss with a possibly lesbian or bisexual character. In most instances, the potential of a relationship between the women does not survive past the episode and the lesbian or suspected lesbian never appears again.
The New York Times, in examining the lesbian kiss episode phenomenon, concluded that women kissing women is often used as a gimmick during "sweeps" periods, times when Nielsen ratings are used by the broadcast networks to determine advertising rates. Lesbian kisses are:
Eminently visual; cheap, provided the actors are willing; controversial, year in and year out; and elegantly reversible (sweeps lesbians typically vanish or go straight when the week's over), kisses between women are perfect sweeps stunts. They offer something for everyone, from advocacy groups looking for role models to indignation-seeking conservatives, from goggle-eyed male viewers to progressive female ones, from tyrants who demand psychological complexity to plot buffs.
Michele Greene, who played Abby on L. A. Law, confirmed in an interview with AfterEllen.com that her kiss with Amanda Donohoe's C.J. was a ratings ploy and that there was never any intention on the part of producers to seriously explore the possibility of a relationship between two women. The attitude about portraying lesbian relationships with any longevity persisted in Hollywood, as Buffy the Vampire Slayer (1997–2003) writer Marti Noxon encountered resistance from television executives when setting the groundwork for the long-term relationship between Willow Rosenberg (Alyson Hannigan) and Tara Maclay (Amber Benson). Noxon spoke of the resistance Buffy writers encountered in 2002, saying in an interview, "you can show girls kissing once, but you can't show them kissing twice ... because the second time, it means that they liked it".
American series which have had lesbian kiss episodes include:
|Program||Title||U.S. air date||Kissers|
|L. A. Law||"He's a Crowd"||February 7, 1991||Abby Perkins (Michele Greene) and C. J. Lamb (Amanda Donohoe).|
|Picket Fences||"Sugar & Spice"||April 29, 1993||Kimberly Brock (Holly Marie Combs) and Lisa Fenn (Alexondra Lee). After negotiations between producer David E. Kelley and CBS, the scene was reshot in lower light.|
|Roseanne||"Don't Ask, Don't Tell"||March 1, 1994||Roseanne Conner (Roseanne Barr) and Sharon (Mariel Hemingway). Full contact not shown. Sharon makes a cameo appearance in "December Bride", featuring the wedding of two men.|
|Lifestories: Families in Crisis||"More Than Friends: The Coming Out of Heidi Leiter"||March 7, 1994||Heidi Leiter (Sabrina Lloyd) and Missy (Kate Anthony). Based on the true story of Heidi Leiter, who attended her senior prom in Virginia with her girlfriend. Neither character appeared again in this anthology series.|
|Star Trek: Deep Space Nine||"Rejoined"||October 30, 1995||Jadzia Dax (Terry Farrell) and Lenara Kahn (Susanna Thompson). Lenara Kahn never reappears on the series. As joined Trills, a previous male host of Dax and female host of Kahn had been husband and wife 90 years earlier. Trill culture considers such rejoinings to be taboo; however, no remarks are made about Jadzia's and Lenara's genders.|
|Relativity||"The Day the Earth Moved"||January 11, 1997||Rhonda (Lisa Edelstein) and Suzanne (Kristin Dattilo). Dattilo's character only appeared in episode. The series was cancelled four episodes later.|
|Sex and the City||"Bay of Married Pigs"
"Boy, Girl, Boy, Girl..."
|June 21, 1998
June 25, 2000
|Miranda Hobbes and Syd (Joanna Adler). Miranda kisses Syd to prove that she, Miranda, is not a lesbian, and Syd never re-appears.
Carrie Bradshaw and Dawn (Alanis Morissette). Dawn never reappears on the series.
|Ally McBeal||"Happy Trails"
"You Never Can Tell"
|November 9, 1998
November 23, 1998
November 1, 1999
|Ally McBeal (Calista Flockhart) and Georgia Thomas (Courtney Thorne-Smith).
Ally McBeal and Elaine Vassal
Ally McBeal and Ling Woo (Lucy Liu). These episodes are unusual in that all of the women involved are series regulars.
|Party of Five||"I'll Show You Mine"||May 5, 1999||Julia Salinger (Neve Campbell) and Perry Marks (Olivia d'Abo). Perry appears in one additional episode.|
|Talk to Me||"About Being Gay"||April 11, 2000||Janey (Kyra Sedgwick) and Teresa (Paulina Porizkova). Janey flirts with Teresa, who turns out to be an actual lesbian, on a dare from her friends. Janey decides she is not a lesbian after the kiss. Teresa was one episode character.|
|Friends||"The One with Rachel's Big Kiss"||April 26, 2001||Rachel Green (Jennifer Aniston) and Melissa Warburton (Winona Ryder); Rachel Green and Phoebe Buffay (Lisa Kudrow). Melissa never reappears on the series. Phoebe kisses Rachel to see what all the fuss Melissa made was about.|
|Once and Again||"The Gay-Straight Alliance"||March 11, 2002||Jessie Sammler (Evan Rachel Wood) and Katie Singer (Mischa Barton). Katie appears in three additional episodes of the series, and the two remain in a relationship, albeit secretly, until the cancellation of the series.|
|Firefly||"War Stories"||December 6, 2002||Inara Serra (Morena Baccarin) and the Councilor (Katherine Kendall). The Councilor is a client of Inara's and she does not reappear in the series.|
|Fastlane||"Strap On"||January 17, 2003||Billie Chambers (Tiffani Thiessen) and Sara Matthews (Jaime Pressley). Sara never reappears on the series.|
|The Joe Schmo Show||Episode 7||October 7, 2003||Ashleigh (Melissa Yvonne Lewis) and Molly (Angela Dodson). In this reality television parody, Ashleigh and Molly kiss at the behest of a "network executive" who explains that the kiss is a ploy for ratings.|
|One Tree Hill||"I Will Dare"
"The Heart Brings You Back"
|October 19, 2004
January 25, 2005
|Peyton Sawyer (Hilarie Burton) and Anna Taggaro (Daniella Alonso). Anna appears in four additional episodes of the series.
Peyton Sawyer and Brooke Davis (Sophia Bush). Peyton and Brooke are both regular characters.
|The O.C.||"The Lonely Hearts Club"||February 10, 2005||Marissa Cooper (Mischa Barton) and Alex Kelly (Olivia Wilde). Alex leaves the series four episodes later.|
|American Dad!||"Not Particularly Desperate Housewives"||December 8, 2005||Linda Memari and Francine Smith. Linda is a closeted lesbian who kisses Francine to save her from being killed by the Ladybugs. Linda is genuinely attracted to Francine; however, Francine thinks the kiss was fake. Linda appears in other episodes; however, Linda's sexual interest in Francine is not discussed.|
|Crossing Jordan||"Mysterious Ways"||April 23, 2006||Jordan Cavanaugh (Jill Hennessy) and Detective Tallulah "Lu" Simmons (Leslie Bibb). Episode hints at the possible bisexuality of lead character Jordan. Bibb was a recurring cast member.|
|How I Met Your Mother||"Best Prom Ever"
|May 1, 2006
March 19, 2012
|Lily Aldrin (Alyson Hannigan) and Robin Scherbatsky (Cobie Smulders). Robin kisses Lily to give Lily the "lesbian experience" she never had. Both are series regulars.
Robin Scherbatsky and Lily Aldrin kiss to seal an oath promising not to interfere with Barney's life. Barney and his girlfriend, Quinn, reveal moments later that the lesbian kiss was intended to humiliate the pair and teach a lesson about judgment.
|Las Vegas||"Fleeting Cheating Meeting"||January 12, 2007||Samantha Marquez (Vanessa Marcil) and Mary McConnell (Nikki Cox). Samantha and Mary, both series regulars, were portrayed as heterosexual although dialogue in several episodes indicates Samantha's possible bisexuality.|
|Dirt||"Ita Missa Est"||March 27, 2007||Lucy Spiller (Courteney Cox) and Tina Harrod (Jennifer Aniston). The episode hints at a former intimate relationship between the two. Tina never reappears on the series.|
|Kyle XY||"Free to Be You and Me"||July 23, 2007||Lori Trager (April Matson) and Hillary (Chelan Simmons). Hillary was a recurring character.|
|Being Erica||"Everything She Wants"||March 4, 2009||Erica (Erin Karpluk) and Cassidy (Anna Silk). In a flashback, Erica relives a brief infatuation with her lesbian college friend Cassidy, which is short-lived when Erica tells Cassidy she is straight. Cassidy appears in two later episodes (Season 2's "The Importance of Being Erica," another flashback episode, and Season 3's "Bear Breasts," in which Cassidy visits Erica in the present day).|
|Desperate Housewives||"The Story of Lucie and Jessie"||March 15, 2009||Susan and her boss, Jessie; Susan and Gabrielle. Susan (Teri Hatcher) and Gabrielle (Eva Longoria) were series regulars; Jessie (Swoosie Kurtz) was a guest star.|
"Divine Secrets and the ZBZ Sisterhood"
|May 4, 2009
May 18, 2009
|Rebecca Logan (Dilshad Vadsaria) and Robyn Wylie (Anna Osceola).
Rebecca and Robyn; Rebecca and Casey Cartwright. The kiss in "Dearly Beloved" opened a three-episode story arc in which Rebecca questions her sexuality. The arc culminated in "Divine Secrets" with Rebecca deciding that she was not a LUG and her response to the kiss was because it was a new and unusual experience. Robyn did not reappear.
|The Cleveland Show||"Pilot"||September 27, 2009||Lois Griffin (Alex Borstein) and Bonnie Swanson (Jennifer Tilly). The two kiss at the behest of lead character Cleveland as something of a going-away present.|
|Heroes||"Hysterical Blindness"||October 12, 2009||Claire Bennet (Hayden Panettiere) and Gretchen Berg (Madeline Zima). Gretchen kisses Claire and confesses to having a crush. Panettiere, who has acknowledged "experimenting" with female friends as a teenager, persuaded the creators to include the storyline. Zima's character was a recurring role. Heroes had previously planned a lesbian cheerleader character in 2007 but the actress took another job after just one episode and the part was not re-cast.|
|FlashForward||"Gimme Some Truth"||October 22, 2009||Janis Hawk (Christine Woods) and Maya (Navi Rawat). Janis is a closeted FBI agent and Maya is a chef. Maya did not reappear on the series.|
|Gossip Girl||"They Shoot Humphreys, Don't They?"||November 9, 2009||Vanessa Abrams (Jessica Szohr) and Olivia Burke (Hilary Duff). The two kiss as part of a threesome with Dan Humphrey (Penn Badgley). Duff's character was a recurring role.|
|90210||"Rats and Heroes"||March 9, 2010||Gia (Rumer Willis) and Adrianna (Jessica Lowndes) kiss after bonding at an Alcoholics Anonymous meeting. Willis' character was a recurring role.|
|Community||"Early 21st Century Romanticism"||February 10, 2011||Britta (Gillian Jacobs) and Page (Brit Marling). Britta and Page become friends and later kiss, each under the mistaken impression that the other is a lesbian. Page has not reappeared to date.|
|Pan Am||"Diplomatic Relations"||January 15, 2012||Maggie (Christina Ricci) and Amanda (Ashley Greene). Amanda comforts a sad Maggie by wiping Maggie's tears, then telling her her opinion on men, and kissing. Greene's character was recurring.|
|The Simpsons||"Lisa Goes Gaga"||May 20, 2012||Marge Simpson (Julie Kavner) and Lady Gaga.|
|Alphas||"When Push Comes to Shove"||August 13, 2012||Nina Theroux (Laura Mennell) and Rachel Pirzad (Azita Ghanizada). Nina, a telepath with the ability to "push" others into doing what she asks them, forced Rachel to kiss her against Rachel's will. Both characters are series regulars.|
- 21 Jump Street included a kiss between series regular Holly Robinson Peete and guest star Katy Boyer in "A Change of Heart" (1990) but it did not inspire the critical or popular attention later such kisses would engender (Capsuto, p. 235).
- Heffernan, Virginia (2005-02-10). "CRITIC'S NOTEBOOK; It's February. Pucker Up, TV Actresses.". New York Times. Retrieved 2008-11-01.
- Warn, Sarah (March 2003). "Interview with Michele Green (sic)". AfterEllen.com. Retrieved 2008-11-02.
- "Analysis: Portrayals of gays on mainstream TV and the future of gay cable channels", National Public Radio: Talk of the Nation (January 24, 2002).
- Tropiano, Stephen (2003-05-28). "When a kiss is not just a kiss.". popmatters.com. Retrieved 2008-10-31.
- Gardiner, Jeff (February 18, 1994). "The Kiss Off". Entertainment Weekly (210-211). Retrieved November 12, 2009.
- Capsuto, p. 335
- Kay, Jonathan (June 30, 2001). "Gay "Trek"". Salon.com. Salon Media Group. Retrieved November 12, 2009.
- Bianculli, David (January 10, 1997). "On 'Relativity,' a (Lesbian) Kiss is Not Just a Kiss". The Daily News. Retrieved November 12, 2009.
- Stasi, Linda (April 11, 2000). "'Talk' is All Dogs & Kisses :The Producers OF 'Talk to Me' Can't Risk Waiting Out A Second Season Slump for the Obligatory Lesbian Kiss-Scene, They Get to it in the Second Episode Instead". The New York Post. p. 82.
- Shister, Gail (March 15, 2002). "`Once and Again' needs high ratings to stay with ABC". The Philadelphia Inquirer.
- Parry, Ryan (March 29, 2007). "Let's Be Friends". Daily Mirror. Retrieved November 12, 2009.
- "Hayden Panettiere's lesbian kiss". The Boston Globe. 2008-06-06. Retrieved 2009-10-12.
- Snead, Elizabeth (2009-10-12). "'Heroes' newbie Madeline Zima wants to fly and kiss Hayden Panettiere again!". The Los Angeles Times. Retrieved 2009-10-12.
- Ausiello, Michael (2007-07-24). "Heroes Scoop: Cheerleader Exits, D.L. MIA and More!". tvguide.com. Retrieved 2009-10-12.
- Capsuto, Steven (2000). Alternate Channels: The Uncensored Story of Gay and Lesbian Images on Radio and Television. Ballantine Books. ISBN 0-345-41243-5.