Lissadell House

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Lissadell House Copyright Nigel Aspdin.jpg
Benbulbin in the distance

Lissadell House is a neo-classical Greek revivalist style country house, located in County Sligo, Ireland.

The house was built between 1830 to 1835, and inhabited from 1833 onwards, for Sir Robert Gore-Booth, 4th Baronet (1784-1835) by London architect Francis Goodwin. In 1876, Sir Robert left the house and surrounding estate to his son, Sir Henry Gore-Booth, 5th Baronet.

Architecture[edit]

Described as "austere in the extreme"[1] Lissadell house is a Greek Revival style detached nine-bay, two-storey over basement mansion, the last one in this style to be built in Ireland. Constructed of Ballysadare limestone with finely jointed ashlar walling. An entrance front is on the north with a three-bay pedimented central projection, originally open to east and west to form porte-cochere.

Prior to its sale in 2003 Lissadell was the only house in Ireland to retain its original Williams & Gibton furniture which was made especially for the house and designed to harmonise with Goodwin's architectural vision.

Lissadell's was the first country house in Ireland to have an independent gas supply piped into the property.[2]

Location[edit]

The house is located on the south shore of the Magherow peninsula in north County Sligo over looking Drumcliff bay. It is in the townland of Lissadell South, the Barony of Carbury formerly the túath of Cairbre Drom Cliabh. The house takes its name from the Irish placename Lios an Doill Uí Dálaigh or O'Dalys Court of the Blind, perhaps referring to the O Daly school of poetry that existed here in the 13th century.[3]

History[edit]

The estate was formed from land granted in the early 17th century to the Elizabethan soldier Sir Paul Gore for his services to the English crown during the Nine Years' War. The land was confiscated from ecclesiastical lands belonging to the monastery of Drumcliff and the Lords of Ó Conchobhair Sligigh and the Ó hAirt chiefs of the territory. The original seat of the estate was at Ardtermon castle a 17th-century fortified house several kilometres to the west. The present house replaced an earlier 18th century house closer to the shore which was demolished.

The estate was once 32,000 acres but now consists of less than 500 acres, the immediate demesne of the house.

The house was the childhood home of Irish revolutionary, Constance Gore-Booth, her sister the poet and suffragist, Eva Gore-Booth, and their siblings, Mabel Gore-Booth, Mordaunt Gore-Booth and Josslyn Gore-Booth. It was also the sometime holiday retreat of the world-renowned poet, William Butler Yeats. He made the house famous with the opening lines of his poem:

"In Memory of Eva Gore-Booth and Con Markiewicz"

The light of evening, Lissadell,
Great windows open to the south,
Two girls in silk kimonos, both
Beautiful, one a gazelle.

[4]

The estate was bought by the Cassidy-Walsh family in 2003 for an undisclosed sum.[5] They initiated a program of restoration of the house and grounds. In 2006 a 1.1 million euro state grant was made available by Fáilte Ireland towards the restoration of the gardens.[6]

Controversies[edit]

The Clearance of Ballygilgan[edit]

This controversy occurred just prior to the famine and concerned the clearance of a settlement on the Lissadell estate as part of the "improvement" of the estate by consolidation of small holdings into larger more viable farms through "assisted emigration". The issue was whether these people were forced to go or left by choice.

The Lissadell Affair[edit]

This controversy centred around the sacking of Gabrielle Gore Booth by the then Solicitor General amid allegations of mismanagement of the estate, in the late 1950s and early 1960s when the heir Michael was made a ward of court. It generated considerable public indignation when it was first told by English journalist Anne Robinson. Gabrielles counter claim involved the illegal felling of estate timber. Calls for a public inquiry were followed by an investigation by RTÉ’s current affairs programme 'Seven Days', re-examining the claim in respect of the timber, which had been dismissed as ‘absurd’.

Judgment was delivered in April 1965 by Justice Davitt who summed up by saying "Neither Gabrielle or her mother or sister have any legal rights whatever to any say in the matter as to how Lissadell is to be managed. They have no legal right even to be at Lissadell. They have been allowed to remain there because of the belief that if Sir Michael Gore Booth were under no disability it would be his wish permanently to extend the hospitality of his home to his mother and sisters. That belief may or may not be well founded. I do not consider it necessary to direct that felling of timber be discontinued”.[7]

Sale in 2004[edit]

In 2003, the house was put up for sale by the then owner, Sir Josslyn Gore-Booth (a grand-nephew of the original Josslyn Gore-Booth), for €3 million. The sale was controversial because, as well as being one of Irelands finest houses, the historical associations of the house with Constance Markiewicz, the poet W B Yeats and therefore the events leading to the foundation of the state lead many, including Sir Jossylyn himself, to hope that it would be purchased by the state stating "Suffice it to say I would welcome an interest on the part of the state".[8]

However, the then Fianna Fáil government under Bertie Ahern, waived any interest in the estate, citing a cost report commissioned by Environment Minister Martin Cullen which suggested that the overall cost to the State of purchasing Lissadell and refurbishing it as a major visitor attraction would cost in the region of €28 million. A figure which has been claimed to be inaccurate by many, including Sir Jossylyn himself.[9] The state also waived any interest in the auction of the contents of the house.

A consortium was set up consisting of businessmen and politicians to buy the house in trust for the state,[10] however, the house was eventually sold to a private couple, the prominent Dublin barristers Edward Walsh and Constance Cassidy, who began to restrict access through the estate shortly after, citing privacy and safety concerns.

Access Dispute 2008 to Present[edit]

Background[edit]

Protests over the access through the estate began shortly after with the formation of a group called The Lissadell Action Group campaigning to have public rights of way confirmed through the estate. The protestors claimed that there had been free access through the estate for a hundred years previously, a claim backed up by Sir Jossylyn himself who, in an interview in 1987 recorded in the Lissadell Estate papers, said "This sea drive, or Avenue, then turns inland through the woods to the west of the house, eventually curving round to the north entrance of the house. Today the Avenue is a favourite haunt of picnic and bathing parties but this is not a recent idea; the people of Sligo have been able to use this area for recreation since the beginning of this century."[11]

In 2007, during a visit to the house by then Taoiseach Bertie Ahern to open an art exhibition, protestors claimed that "were Countess Markiewicz here, she would be protesting with them" to which he replied that "the state can't take over every great house in the country. "Lissadell is clearly in very loving hands. The owners have done a wonderful job."[12][13]

Sligo County Council had by 2008 received 40 submissions from citizens and sought legal advice on the issue. On a motion put by Councillor Joe Leonard in December 2008, the council voted unanimously to preserve public rights of way that it contended existed on the estate. This motion began the procedure to vary the County Development Plan to include the four roads through the estate.[14]

In response, the Cassidy's announced the house's closure on 8 January 2009 due to the dispute with Sligo County Council.[15]

First Judgement[edit]

The owners instituted legal proceedings against the council claiming that there are no dedicated public rights of way over the estate and the council counterclaimed, asserting public rights of way over the four main avenues.[16][17] The owners indicated that they would not be reopening Lissadell if the council won the court action.[18]

In Ireland a right of way can be established is if there has been a dedication by its owner to the public and secondly, if the public has accepted this dedication. In the absence of an express dedication, one must be inferred from the behaviour of the owner. General rights of way can also be asserted, and have been since the Land War of the 1880s, by the principle in the common law of Adverse possession. Such rights of way can be upheld if continuous use for an unspecified amount of time, without the owner moving to block this use, can be proved. Proving such use is often difficult.

In order to infer whether a dedication existed, the case focussed on the erection and subsequent removal of a barrier in 1993 by Sir Jossylyn, apparently to keep out New Age Travellers.

The High Court judge (McMahon J) decided on the fact that no objection was made by Sir Jossylyn to its subsequent removal by locals, that this showed that he regarded the rights of way as belonging to the public. The 58-day-long hearings ended in June 2010, with judgement upholding the councils claims over the avenues.[19]

Legal costs for both sides at this stage were estimated at €6 million.[20] The grounds remained closed.

Appeal[edit]

The Walsh-Cassidys then appealed to the Supreme Court of Ireland. They claimed that Justice McMahon had "made a fundamental error" in his ruling arguing that he "had erred in converting evidence about use since the 1950s of four routes in the 410-acre estate into an effective presumption about, and significant extension of, the law governing rights of way".[21] The case hinged again on whether a dedication of right of way had been intended by the previous owners of Lissadell. This time the 1993 incident was interpreted to infer that Sir Jossylyn saw the avenue as his to block and only relented in the interest of public relations.

The Supreme Court issued a 117-page judgement on 11 November 2013 that ruled in favour of the owners, excepting a public right of access along the beach.[17]

On 3 April 2014 the Supreme Court found that Sligo County Council must pay 75% of the costs of the appellants, estimated at 5.25 million, and all of its own costs for the 58 day legal battle.[22]

Issues[edit]

The case has brought up the contested nature of property rights in a formerly colonised country, as well as the omission in the 2009 Land and Conveyancing Law Reform Act of any substantial changes to existing law on Rights of Way. The laws relating to rights of way mostly predate the foundation of the state, and therefore stem from the colonial era of British landlordism. Hence Irish public access laws remain some of the most restrictive in Europe.[23][24]

In a broader sense the Lissadell case has been suggested as an example of a link between individualistic capitalism and property rights issues in post colonial countries where the system of law inherited from the coloniser is claimed by some not to be in harmony with what is asserted by some to be the inherited culture of the majority.[25] This asserted disconnection is discussed in Raymond Crotty's 'When Histories Collide'[26] in which the asserted failure of capitalist colonised economies such as Ireland to develop smoothly is explained in terms of "individualism was inappropriately imposed on communitarian societies where land remained the limiting factor. When the former colonies gained independence, the élites made sure not to overthrow the existing system but merely transferred to themselves the privileges that had formerly gone to the colonial élites. In Ireland and elsewhere the élites were primarily those who had managed to secure for themselves the titles to land."[27][28]

In this analysis, Lissadell is a clash between the different conceptions of the nature of property ownership that exist within different regions of modern Ireland, specifically in this case what is asserted to be the greater individualism of the east, and what is asserted to be the more communitarian approach in the west.[27][29]

Recognition of the implications of a precedent being set by the Lissadell case regarding these underlying issues was expressed by several of Sligo Council representatives while discussing the case, who stated "We are opening a can of worms here. 100 years ago there was a mass path across my land." and "while it was Lissadell House today", "what about [the implications for] ordinary farmers in other places".[30]

The Supreme court ruling has also been criticised by advocates of open access[31] to the countryside, including Mountaineering Ireland for "setting the bar too high" effectively making it impossible to assert right of way through long use, instead requiring dedication by the landowner, a position abandoned in most European jurisdictions, including England, as too onerous a proof.[32]

On the other hand the Supreme court decision has been welcomed by the Irish farmers organisation the Irish Creamery Milk Suppliers Association ICSMA. The President of the ICMSA, John Comer said that it was "a victory for common sense" and will help set landowners minds at ease.[33]

It has been noted that the reliance in the Lissadell case on old English common law precedents inherited by the state and the lack of reference to the Constitution of Ireland in both judgements, highlights the continued reliance of the courts of the Republic of Ireland on English law and precedent, and concomitant upholding of English style property rights, which may or may not be suited to the present situation in Ireland.[34]

Rights of way clashes have also occurred at Ashford castle in County Mayo in 2011.[35]

Concerts[edit]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ http://www.buildingsofireland.ie/niah/search.jsp?type=record&county=SL&regno=32400813
  2. ^ http://www.antiquestradegazette.com/news/2003/dec/06/lights-out-–-but-lissadell-sale-on/#sthash.KyHKoh1a.dpuf
  3. ^ http://www.ucc.ie/celt/published/T100005A/index.html
  4. ^ Yeats, William Butler (2000, originally in "The Winding Stair and other poems", 1933). The collected poems of W. B. Yeats. p. 197. ISBN 1-85326-454-7.  Check date values in: |date= (help)
  5. ^ http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/3144561.stm
  6. ^ http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P2-24829504.html
  7. ^ http://www.lissadellhouse.com/gabrielle.html
  8. ^ http://www.independent.ie/opinion/analysis/why-im-selling-historic-lissadell-house-25948325.html
  9. ^ http://www.independent.ie/regionals/sligochampion/news/final-farewell-at-lissadell-house-27547894.html
  10. ^ http://www.friendsoftheirishenvironment.org/papers-today/34-parks-designations/1416-
  11. ^ http://www.proni.gov.uk/introduction__lissadell_papers_d4131_.pdf
  12. ^ http://www.taoiseach.gov.ie/eng/News/Archives/2007/Taoiseach's_Speeches_Archive_2007/Speech_by_the_Taoiseach,_Mr_Bertie_Ahern_TD,_at_the_opening_of_the_Constance_Markievicz_Exhibition_in_Lissadell,_Sligo_on_Friday,_30_March,_2007_at_4_05_p_m_.html
  13. ^ http://www.thefreelibrary.com/Lissadell+protest+at+Bertie.-a0161301394
  14. ^ "'We jumped the gun on this,' says local councillor". Irish Independent. 3 December 2012. 
  15. ^ Owners to close Lissadell House estate. RTÉ News Report - 8 January 2009
  16. ^ Legal proceedings over Lissadell House, RTÉ News Report - 14 January 2009
  17. ^ a b http://www.irishtimes.com/news/crime-and-law/courts/court-rules-in-favour-of-lissadell-owners-in-right-of-way-case-1.1590985 Irish Times online, 11 November 2013
  18. ^ "Sligo mayor urges talks to end Lissadell House dispute". The Irish Times. 7 July 2009. 
  19. ^ http://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/irish-high-court-judgement-of-mr-justic-48832/
  20. ^ Irish Independent online, 19 June 2010
  21. ^ http://sligoweekender.ie/2013/01/25/lissadell-owners-claim-judge-made-a-fundamental-error/
  22. ^ http://sligonewsfile.com/supreme-court-orders-council-pay-75-lissadell-legal-bill/
  23. ^ http://www.williamfry.ie/Libraries/test/STEP-Article.sflb.ashx
  24. ^ http://www.keepirelandopen.org/Keep_Ireland_Open_1.pdf
  25. ^ http://www3.ul.ie/sociology/socheolas/vol2/1/Fiona%20O'%20Donovan.pdf
  26. ^ http://books.google.ie/books?id=SfuxAAAAQBAJ&pg=PR1&lpg=PR1&dq=when+histories+collide&source=bl&ots=HVjXE17ncu&sig=1W3N5xMJsqBtKwV7qsam1u8iB6A&hl=ga&sa=X&ei=JANhU9TRBujA7Aan74CIAg&ved=0CGMQ6AEwCQ#v=onepage&q=when%20histories%20collide&f=false
  27. ^ a b http://www.historyireland.com/20th-century-contemporary-history/when-histories-collide-the-development-and-impact-of-individualistic-capitalism/
  28. ^ http://books.google.ie/books?id=JqSGsqMHY5AC&pg=PA50&lpg=PA50&dq=english+common+law+in+post+colonial+ireland&source=bl&ots=YiXuntNk3B&sig=djHr91Y5I8QVXHhO3SJ8C86Wggo&hl=ga&sa=X&ei=TolnU4KBLsaM7QbKrICgBw&ved=0CDkQ6AEwAw#v=onepage&q=english%20common%20law%20in%20post%20colonial%20ireland&f=false
  29. ^ http://eprints.nuim.ie/4868/1/GK_Historical%20Geography.pdf
  30. ^ http://www.independent.ie/regionals/sligochampion/news/we-jumped-the-gun-on-this-says-local-councillor-27562027.html
  31. ^ http://www.labour.ie/press/2013/11/11/lisadell-judgement-shows-need-to-overhaul-land-acc/
  32. ^ http://www.keepirelandopen.org/recent_issues.html
  33. ^ https://oceanfm.ie/2013/11/12/icmsa-welcome-lissadell-judgement/
  34. ^ http://www.irishtimes.com/news/crime-and-law/courts/lissadell-ruling-reflects-a-reliance-on-english-law-and-sense-of-property-1.1600162
  35. ^ http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P2-30226738.html

External links[edit]


Coordinates: 54°21′N 8°35′W / 54.350°N 8.583°W / 54.350; -8.583