Frederick Lindemann, 1st Viscount Cherwell

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
  (Redirected from Lord Cherwell)
Jump to: navigation, search
The Right Honourable
The Viscount Cherwell
FRS CH PC
Lindemann Frederick.jpg
Personal details
Born 5 April 1886
Baden-Baden, Germany
Died 3 July 1957 (aged 71)
Alma mater University of Berlin

Frederick Alexander Lindemann, 1st Viscount Cherwell FRS[1] PC CH (5 April 1886 – 3 July 1957) was an English physicist and an influential scientific adviser to the British government from the early 1940s to the early '50s, particularly to Winston Churchill. He advocated the "area" bombing of German cities during World War II and doubted the sophistication of Nazi Germany's radar technology[2] and the existence of its "V" weapons programme.

Early life, family and personality[edit]

Lindemann was the second of three sons of Adolphus Frederick Lindemann, who had emigrated to the United Kingdom circa 1871[3] and become naturalised.[4] Frederick was born in Baden-Baden in Germany where his American mother Olga Noble, the widow of a wealthy banker, was taking "the cure".

After schooling in Scotland and Darmstadt, he attended the University of Berlin. He did research in physics at the Sorbonne that confirmed theories, first put forward by Albert Einstein, on specific heats at very low temperatures.[5] For this and other scientific work, Lindemann was elected a Fellow of the Royal Society in 1920.[6]

In 1911 he was invited to the Solvay Conference on "Radiation and the Quanta" where he was the youngest attendee.

Lindemann was a teetotaler, non-smoker, and a vegetarian, although Churchill would sometimes induce him to take a glass of brandy. He was an excellent pianist, and sufficiently able as a tennis player to compete at Wimbledon.[7]

He was known to friends as "the Prof" in reference to his position at the University of Oxford, and as "Baron Berlin" to his many detractors because of his German accent, arrogance and aristocratic manner.[8]

Lindemann believed that a small circle of the intelligent and the aristocratic should run the world, resulting in a peaceable and stable society, "led by supermen and served by helots."[9] Sometimes thought to be Jewish,[10] although he was not,[11] anti-democratic, insensitive and elitist, Lindemann supported eugenics, held the working class, homosexuals and blacks in contempt and supported sterilization of the mentally incompetent.[12] Referring to Lindemann's lecture on Eugenics, Mukerjee concludes "Science could yield a race of humans blessed with 'the mental make-up of the worker bee'....At the lower end of the race and class spectrum, one could remove the ability to suffer or to feel ambition....Instead of subscribing to what he called 'the fetish of equality', Lindemann recommended that human differences be accepted and indeed enhanced by means of science. It was no longer necessary, he wrote, to wait for 'the haphazard process of natural selection to ensure that the slow and heavy mind gravitates to the lowest form of activity.'" [13]

World War I and the University of Oxford[edit]

At the outbreak of World War I, Lindemann was playing tennis in Germany and had to leave in haste to avoid internment. In 1915, he joined the staff of the Royal Aircraft Factory at Farnborough. He developed a mathematical theory of aircraft spin recovery, and later learned to fly so that he could test his ideas himself.[1] Prior to Lindemann's work, a spinning aircraft was almost invariably unrecoverable and the result to the pilot fatal.

In 1919 Lindemann was appointed professor of experimental philosophy at the University of Oxford and director of the Clarendon Laboratory, largely on the recommendation of Henry Tizard who had been a colleague in Berlin.[5] In 1919, Lindemann was one of the first people to suggest that in the solar wind particles of both polarities, protons as well as electrons, come from the Sun.[14] He was probably not aware that Kristian Birkeland had made the same prediction three years earlier in 1916.

In 1921 Churchill's wife Clementine partnered with Lindemann for a charity tennis match. Although the two men had very different lifestyles, they both excelled at a sport (Churchill's was polo), and Lindemann's ability to explain scientific issues concisely, and his excellent flying skills, probably impressed Churchill, who had given up trying to earn a pilot's license because of Clementine's concern. They became close friends, with the bachelor visiting Chartwell more than 100 times from 1925 to 1939.[15] Lindemann opposed the UK General Strike of 1926 and mobilised the reluctant staff of the Clarendon to produce copies of Churchill's anti-strike newspaper, the British Gazette. He was also alarmed and fearful of political developments in Germany.[5] In the 1930s, Lindemann advised Winston Churchill when the latter was out of Government, and leading a campaign for rearmament. In 1932, he and Churchill completed a road trip throughout Europe and were dismayed at what they saw. Churchill later said, "A terrible process is astir. Germany is arming.".[16] Lindemann also helped a number of German Jewish physicists, primarily at the University of Göttingen, to emigrate to England to work in the Clarendon Laboratory.[1]

Churchill got Lindemann onto the "Committee for the Study of Aerial Defence" which under Sir Henry Tizard was putting its resources behind the development of radar. Lindemann's presence was disruptive, insisting instead that his own ideas of aerial mines and infra-red beams be given priority over radar. To resolve the situation the committee dissolved itself and reformed as a new body without Lindemann.[17]

World War II[edit]

When Churchill became Prime Minister, he appointed Lindemann as the British government's leading scientific adviser, with David Bensusan-Butt as his private secretary.[18] Lindemann attended meetings of the War Cabinet, accompanied the prime minister on conferences abroad, and sent him an average of one missive a day. He saw Churchill almost daily for the duration of the war and wielded more influence than any other civilian adviser.[9] He would hold this office again for the first two years of Churchill's peacetime administration (1951-5[19]).

Lindemann established a special statistical branch, known as 'S-Branch', within the government, constituted from subject specialists, and reporting directly to Churchill. This branch scrutinized the performance of the regular ministries and prioritized the logistical machinery of warfare. S-Branch distilled thousands of sources of data into succinct charts and figures, so that the status of the nation's food supplies (for example) could be instantly evaluated. The bar charts now on display in the Cabinet War Rooms which compare allied shipping tonnage lost to newbuildings delivered each month and those comparing bomb tonnage dropped by Germany on England with that dropped by the allies on Germany each month are mute testaments to both the intellectual and the psychological power of his statistical presentations. Lindemann's statistical branch often caused tensions between government departments, but because it allowed Churchill to make quick decisions based on accurate data which directly affected the war effort, its importance should not be underestimated.[5]

In 1940, Lindemann supported the experimental department MD1.[1][20] He worked on hollow charge weapons, the sticky bomb and other new weapons. General Ismay, who supervised MD1, recalled:

Churchill used to say that the Prof's brain was a beautiful piece of mechanism, and the Prof did not dissent from that judgement. He seemed to have a poor opinion of the intellect of everyone with the exception of Lord Birkenhead, Mr Churchill and Professor Lindemann; and he had a special contempt for the bureaucrat and all his ways. The Ministry of Supply and the Ordnance Board were two of his pet aversions, and he derived a great deal of pleasure from forestalling them with new inventions. In his appointment as Personal Assistant to the Prime Minister no field of activity was closed to him. He was as obstinate as a mule, and unwilling to admit that there was any problem under the sun which he was not qualified to solve. He would write a memorandum on high strategy one day, and a thesis on egg production on the next. He seemed to try to give the impression of wanting to quarrel with everybody, and of preferring everyone’s room to their company; but once he had accepted a man as a friend, he never failed him, and there are many of his war-time colleagues who will ever remember him with deep personal affection. He hated Hitler and all his works, and his contribution to Hitler’s downfall in all sorts of odd ways was considerable.[21]

With power, Cherwell was able to sideline Tizard; especially after Tizard did not acknowledge that the Germans were using radio navigation to bomb Britain.

Lindemann wished to limit Germany's ability to re-arm, and was an enthusiastic backer of the Morgenthau Plan, under which Germany would be partitioned and de-industrialised. In wartime Germany, Propaganda Minister Joseph Goebbels presented the plan as Jewish manipulation of Allied policy, and so was able to use the plan to bolster the German resistance on the Western front.[22]

Lindemann has been described as having "an almost pathological hatred for Nazi Germany, and an almost medieval desire for revenge was a part of his character".[23] Fearing food shortages in Britain, he convinced Churchill to divert 56% of the UK merchant ships operating in the Indian Ocean over to the Atlantic, a move that added two million tons of wheat as well as raw materials for war fighting to Britain's stockpile. This meant that few ships would be available to carry wheat from Australia to India. Churchill's Ministry of War Transport warned that such dramatic cuts to shipping capacity in South East Asia would "portend violent changes and perhaps cataclysms in the seaborne trade of large numbers of countries" but was ignored. The "menace of famine suddenly loomed up like a hydra-headed monster with a hundred clamoring mouths," according to C.B.A. Behrens in the official history of wartime British shipping.[24] It has been estimated that this resulted in the starvation of at least three million people in Bengal, while Britain's stockpile of food and raw materials by the end of 1943 totaled 18.5 million tons, greater than ever before.[25] Other British colonies on the Indian Ocean, including Kenya, Tanganyika, and British Somaliland, suffered famine that year as well.[24]

Strategic bombing[edit]

Following the Air Ministry Area bombing directive on 12 February 1942, Lindemann presented in a paper on "Dehousing" to Churchill on 30 March 1942, which calculated the effects of area bombardment by a massive bomber force of German cities to break the spirit of the people.[26]

His proposal that "bombing must be directed to working class houses. Middle class houses have too much space round them, so are bound to waste bombs" changed accepted conventions of limiting civilian casualties in wartime."[citation needed]

His dehousing paper was criticised by many other scientific minds in government service who felt such a force would be a waste of resources.[27] Cherwell's paper was based on the false premise that bombing could cause a breakdown in society[28] but was used in support of Bomber Command's claim for resources.

Lindemann also played a key part in the battle of the beams, championing countermeasures to the Germans use of radio navigation to increase the precision of their bombing campaigns.[5] However, he continuously obstructed and undermined the vital work of Sir Henry Tizard and his team who developed all important radar technology.

V2 Rocket[edit]

Main article: Operation Crossbow

Lindemann also repeatedly made arguments against the rumoured existence of the V-2 rocket, asserting it was "a great hoax to distract our attention from some other weapon".[29] He inaccurately concluded that "to put a four-thousand horsepower turbine in a twenty-inch space is lunacy: it couldn't be done, Mr. Lubbock" and that at the end of the war, the committee would find that the rocket was "a mare's nest".[30] Cherwell took the view that long-range military rockets were feasible only if they were propelled by solid fuels, and would accordingly need to be of enormous size. He repeatedly rejected arguments that relatively compact liquid fuels could be used to propel such weapons.[31] In fairness, "Cherwell had strong scientific grounds for doubting the forecasts that were being made of a 70-80 ton rocket with a 10 ton warhead."[32] A pivotal exchange where Churchill rebuffed Lindemann occurred at the Cabinet Defence Committee (Operations) meeting on 29 June 1943 and was dramatized in the film Operation Crossbow.

Cherwell became notorious for his famous statement, "Space travel is utter bilge!" Of course, his opponents proved correct soon afterward, when V-2 rockets began bombarding London, and the ultimate refutation came a few months after his death when the Soviet Union launched Sputnik I.

Political career[edit]

Lindemann's political career was a function of his close friendship with Winston Churchill, who protected Lindemann from the many in Government he had snubbed and insulted. "Love me, love my dog, and if you don't love my dog, you damn well can't love me," Churchill reportedly said to a member of Parliament who had questioned his reliance on Lindemann, and later to the same MP Churchill added, "Don't you know that he is one of my oldest and greatest friends?".[33] In July 1941 Lindemann was raised to the peerage as Baron Cherwell, of Oxford in the County of Oxford.[34] The following year he was made Paymaster-General by Churchill, an office he retained until 1945. In 1943 he was also sworn of the Privy Council.[35] He enthusiastically supported the controversial Morgenthau Plan, which Churchill subsequently endorsed on 15 September 1944.[36] When Churchill returned as Prime Minister in 1951, Lord Cherwell was once again appointed Paymaster-General, this time with a seat in the cabinet. He continued in this post until 1953.[35] In 1956 he was made Viscount Cherwell of Oxford, in the County of Oxford.[37]

Personal life[edit]

Despite his abrasive and Teutonic manner, Lord Cherwell was reported to have a sensitive side, which reflected itself in his affection for animals and children. He was popular with women, but never married. He had no great loves, and few friends other than Churchill. Eventually he returned to his old rooms at Oxford. He died in his sleep in 3 July 1957, aged 71, only a year after becoming Viscount of Cherwell, at which point the barony and viscountcy became extinct.[38] He was the first and last Viscount of Cherwell.[39]

Honours[edit]

References and notes[edit]

  1. ^ a b c d Farren, W.; Thomson, G. P. (1958). "Frederick Alexander Lindemann, Viscount Cherwell 1886-1957". Biographical Memoirs of Fellows of the Royal Society 4: 45. doi:10.1098/rsbm.1958.0005. JSTOR 769499.  edit
  2. ^ Secrets of World War II episode 5: The Bruneval Raid. See also Operation Biting.
  3. ^ Berman, R. (June 1987). "Lindemann in Physics". Notes and Records of the Royal Society of London 41 (2): 181–189. doi:10.1098/rsnr.1987.0004. JSTOR 531544. 
  4. ^ Crowther, J. G. (1965). Statesmen of Science. London: Cresset Press. pp. 339–376.  - See especially p. 343.
  5. ^ a b c d e f g h i Blake, R (2004). "Lindemann, Frederick Alexander, Viscount Cherwell (1886–1957)". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography. Oxford University Press. 
  6. ^ "Lists of Royal Society Fellows 1660-2007". Retrieved 2008-12-21. 
  7. ^ Alexander, Robert Charles (2000). The Inventor of Stereo: The Life and Works of Alan Dower Blumlein. Oxford, England: Focal Press. p. 238. ISBN 0-240-51628-1. 
  8. ^ Mukerjee, Madhusree (August 6, 2010). "The Most Powerful Scientist Ever: Winston Churchill's Personal Technocrat". Scientific American. 
  9. ^ a b [[#CITEREFMukerjee2006Category:Articles_with_inconsistent_citation_formats|Mukerjee 2006]]
  10. ^ Ronald Hilton. "Men Behind Roosevelt and Churchill". World Association of International Studies. Retrieved 2012-12-27. 
  11. ^ Furneaux-Smith, F., Earl of Birkenhead (1961). The Professor in Two Worlds: The Official Life of Professor F. A. Lindemann Viscount Cherwell. London & Glasgow, UK: Collins Clear-Type Press. pp. 25–6. 
  12. ^ Mukerjee, Madhusree (November–December 2011). "Confidence Man". World War II (Leesburg, Virginia, USA: Weider History Group, Inc). p. 45. 
  13. ^ Mukerjee, Madhusree (2010). Churchill's Secret War: The British Empire and the Ravaging of India during World War II. New York: Basic Books (Perseus Books Group). ISBN 978-0-465-00201-6. 
  14. ^ Lindemann, F. (December 1919). "On the Solar Wind". Philosophical Magazine, Series 6 38 (228): 674. 
  15. ^ Jones, R.V. (1993). "Churchill and Science". In Blake, Robert B.; Louis, William Roger. Churchill. Oxford: Clarendon Press. pp. 429–430. ISBN 0-19-820626-7. 
  16. ^ Mukerjee 2011, p. 45
  17. ^ Hastings Bomber Command Pan 1999 p 155-156
  18. ^ Fort, A. (2004). Prof: The Life and Times of Frederick Lindemann. Pimlico. ISBN 0-7126-4007-X.  - See p. 237.
  19. ^ Fort, p. 318
  20. ^ Macrae, Stuart (1971). Winston Churchill's Toyshop. Roundwood Press. SBN 900093-22-6. 
  21. ^ Ismay, General Lord (1960). The Memoirs of Lord Ismay. Heinemann.  - See especially p. 173
  22. ^ Dietrich, John (2002). The Morgenthau Plan: Soviet Influence on American Postwar Policy. New York: Algora Publishing. p. 70. ISBN 1-892941-90-2. 
  23. ^ Wheeler-Bennett, J. W. & Nicholls, A. (1972). The Semblance of Peace. London. ISBN 0-333-04302-2.  - See p. 179
  24. ^ a b Mukerjee 2006
  25. ^ Mukerjee 2011, p. 49
  26. ^ "Blitzed by guidebook". BBC News. 27 March 2002. Retrieved 2008-06-19. 
  27. ^ Hastings p153-159
  28. ^ Hastings p159
  29. ^ Mukerjee 2011, p. 47
  30. ^ Irving, David (1964). The Mare's Nest. London: William Kimber and Co. p. 159. 
    NOTE: Macrae's 1971 p. 170 absolute claim that "Prof certainly never suggested that nothing need be done about the V weapons; on the contrary he was always urging us to try to think up some brilliant counter measure against it which we were unable to do." differs with the official records (meeting minutes, etc.) that indicate otherwise.p. 159
  31. ^ John Keegan, page 380 "Intelligence in War, ISBN 0-09-180229-6
  32. ^ Wilson, Thomas (1995). Churchill and the Prof. Cassell. p. 47. ISBN 0-304-34615-2. 
  33. ^ Mukerjee 2011, p. 43
  34. ^ The London Gazette: no. 35217. p. 3991. 11 July 1941.
  35. ^ a b thepeerage.com Frederick Alexander Lindemann, 1st and last Viscount Cherwell
  36. ^ Irving, David (1986). "Introduction". The Morgenthau Plan. Focal Point. Retrieved 2008-06-19. 
  37. ^ The London Gazette: no. 40818. p. 3801. 29 June 1956.
  38. ^ Madhusree 2011, p. 49
  39. ^ thepeerage.com

Further reading[edit]

  • Farmelo, Graham (2013). Churchill's Bomb: How the United States Overtook Britain in the First Nuclear Arms Race. Basic Books. 
  • Furneaux-Smith, F., Earl of Birkenhead (1961). The Professor in Two Worlds: The Official Life of Professor F. A. Lindemann Viscount Cherwell. London & Glasgow: Collins Clear-Type Press. 
  • Harrod, R. F. (1959). The Prof: A Personal Memoir of Lord Cherwell. London: Macmillan. 
  • Jones, R.V. (1978). Most Secret War: British Scientific Intelligence. London: Hamish Hamilton. 
  • Macrae, Stuart (1971). Winston Churchill's Toyshop. Roundwood Press. SBN 900093-22-6. 
  • Mukerjee, Madhusree (August 10, 2010). Churchill's Secret War: The British Empire and the Ravaging of India during World War II. New York: Basic Books. ISBN 978-0-465-00201-6. LCCN 2010003803. OCLC 768097130.  (Lord Cherwell's role in the Bengal famine of 1943)
  • Snow, C. P. (1961). Science and Government. London: Harvard University Press. 
  • Wilson, Thomas (1995). Churchill and the Prof. Cassell. ISBN 0-304-34615-2. 
  • Obituary: The Times, 4 July 1957
  • Obituary: Nature 180, 579–581.
  • For the Nernst-Lindemann melting point equation, see Washburn, Edward Wight (1921). An Introduction to the Principles of Physical Chemistry (2 ed.). New York: McGraw-Hill. p. 304. 
  • Churchill’s Bomb: How the United States Overtook Britain in the First Nuclear Arms Race Graham Farmelo, Basic Books
Political offices
Preceded by
Sir William Jowitt
Paymaster-General
1942–1945
Succeeded by
Vacant
Preceded by
The Lord Macdonald of Gwaenysgor
Paymaster-General
1951–1953
Succeeded by
The Earl of Selkirk
Peerage of the United Kingdom
New creation Viscount Cherwell
1956–1957
Extinct
New creation Baron Cherwell
1941–1957
Extinct