McGee's years at the University of South Carolina are arguable of his most satisfying. McGee left one "USC" with a storied history of athletic success. At the time, the University of Southern California "Trojans" and "The Women of Troy" (the name of the women's athletic teams) had won nearly 100 total team national championships, including: 26 in men's track & field, 12 in baseball, 9 in football, 6 in women's volleyball, four in men's volleyball, and 2 women's basketball. Its students had won four Heisman trophies, awarded to the best college football player annually (Mike Garrett in 1965, O.J. Simpson in 1968, Charles White in 1979 and Marcus Allen in 1981.), 89 of which are NCAA National Championships.
The University of South Carolina did not have the same history of success. Before McGee's arrival, the Gamecocks had to their credit no national championships. The best example of success was the men's soccer team finishing as the NCAA runner-up in 1993 and the baseball team also finishing as the runner-up in 1975 and 1977. The Gamecocks only featured one Heisman trophy winner in George Rogers during the 1980 football season.
McGee's goal was to build a foundation to foster athletic success for years to come. Upon his retirement, his accomplishments at University of South Carolina include:
After winning only 1 bowl game in the nearly 100 year history of the football team, the Gamecocks had won three straight bowl games, including back-to-back Outback Bowl Championships against Ohio State. Those two victories catapulted USC to consecutive Top 20 national finishes, a first in the history of the program. Included in that stretch (2000–01) were the most wins (17) in consecutive years in the history of the football program.
McGee's ability to attract and hire high-caliber coaches. Among his hires at University of South Carolina have included Curtis Frye (track and field), Lou Holtz (football), Ray Tanner (baseball), Dave Odom (men's basketball) and most recently, Steve Spurrier (football). Over McGee's final eight seasons, 13 Gamecock head coaches had earned either National Coach of the Year or Southeastern Conference Coach of the Year accolades.
Oversaw a dramatic increase in the athletics department's overall revenues, rising from approximately $18 million when he first came to University of South Carolina, to $52.8 million for fiscal year 2004.
The women's track team won the school's first-ever national team championship, claiming the 2002 NCAA Outdoor title.
The baseball team had made three straight appearances in the College World Series and is the winningest program in the country over McGee's final five seasons.
In 2000, for the first time in the history of the Southeastern Conference, USC had three of its athletes named National Athlete of the Year in their respective sports: Kip Bouknight (baseball); Terrence Trammell (men's indoor and outdoor track); and Miki Barber (women's outdoor track).
Won eight SEC team championships, including baseball (3), women's outdoor track (2), men's basketball (1), softball (1), and women's golf (1).
McGee had oversaw more than $110 million in facility improvements at Carolina, including the 18,000-seat Colonial Center and major improvements and additions to Williams-Brice Stadium.