Misunderstanding (Genesis song)
|Single by Genesis|
|from the album Duke|
|B-side||Evidence of Autumn (UK)
Behind The Lines (USA)
Open Door (Germany)
|Released||10 May 1980 (US) 5 September 1980 (UK)|
|Genre||Pop rock, soft rock|
|Length||3:11 (album version), 3:04 (single version/video - sped up)|
|Producer(s)||David Hentschel and Genesis|
|Genesis singles chronology|
Originally written by Phil Collins during the production of his debut solo album Face Value, the song ended up being donated (along with "Please Don't Ask") for Duke. The song was based on Sly & The Family Stone's 1969 song Hot Fun in the Summertime and (according to Phil on an interview with Redbeard on In the Studio) The Beach Boys' "Sail on Sailor" and Toto's "Hold the Line".
Tony Banks has named the song a favorite of his, due to being a fan of The Beach Boys and his interest in doing a song in their style.
A music video, directed by Stuart Orme, was made for the song, featuring Tony Banks and Mike Rutherford playing their instruments on the back of a truck, with a bearded Phil Collins driving a 1950s model Ford convertible making stops at various locations around Los Angeles (the Capitol Records Tower can be seen in the background and street signs for Hollywood Boulevard are present) looking for his girlfriend (played by Max Factor spokesperson Linda Kendall). The song was played a half-step higher in the video (and on the single) compared to its appearance on the actual album (the actual recording was presented in the key of D Sharp Minor).
Two different cuts of the video exist: One version featured alternate shots of Phil, as well as alternate shots of his "girlfriend" peppered throughout (including a shot of her at Griffith Park Observatory). This version was not used on any of the Genesis Music Video collections. Filming took place on location in Los Angeles from 24–27 May 1980 during concerts for the band's Duke Tour there. Further evidence of the filming dates for the video are the billboards seen throughout, advertising The Hollywood Knights and The Nude Bomb, both films released in May 1980.
The song was featured on the US leg of the Duke Tour of 1980, and was also featured on tours to promote future albums Abacab and Genesis. Despite its commercial success, it was dropped from the setlists of all the later tours. However a verse was sung sometimes in the We Can't Dance Tour's "Old Medley." Phil Collins also played the song in its entirety with a horn section in America during his First Final Farewell Tour in 2004.
Patrick Johnson Five version
A cover of the song, different than original version.
|Single by Patrick Johnson Five|
|from the album Born on a Pirate Ship|
|B-side||Stupid Things (UK)
Somewhere Behind the Mask (Netherlands)
Karma Lemon (Germany)
|Released||10 May 1993 (US) 5 September 1993 (UK)|
|Length||3:52 (album version), 8:01 (acoustic version)|
|Producer(s)||Patrick Johnson and Kevin Jenson|
|Patrick Johnson Five singles chronology|
- Patrick Johnson - lead vocals, acoustic guitar, harmonica, melodica, Gibson SG
- James Arnold - drums, Roland V-Stage Series TD-12S V-Drum Kit, timpani, drum machine
- Ferdinand Davis - bass, upright bass, cello
- Kevin Jenson - synthesizer, Hammond T-102, keyboards
- Thomas Shandling Lawrence - Godin LG, Chet Atkins 6120, Baldwin piano, Fender Stratocaster