Nuclear magnetic resonance crystallography
Nuclear magnetic resonance crystallography (NMR crystallography) is a method which utilizes primarily NMR spectroscopy to determine the structure of solid materials on the atomic scale. Thus, solid-state NMR spectroscopy would be used primarily, possibly supplemented by quantum chemistry calculations, powder diffraction etc. If suitable crystals can be grown, any crystallographic method would generally be preferred to determine the crystal structure comprising in case of organic compounds the molecular structures and molecular packing. The main interest in NMR crystallography is in microcrystalline and amorphous materials which are amenable to this method but not to X-ray, neutron and electron diffraction. This is largely because interactions of comparably short range are measured in NMR crystallography.
When applied to organic molecules, NMR crystallography aims at including structural information not only of a single molecule but also on the molecular packing (i.e. crystal structure). E.g. polymorphism is an area of interest for NMR crystallography since this is encountered occasionally (and may often be previously undiscovered) in organic compounds. In this case a change in the molecular structure and/or in the molecular packing can lead to polymorphism, and this can be investigated by NMR crystallography.
Dipolar couplings based approach
The spin interaction that is usually employed for structural analyses via solid state NMR spectroscopy is the magnetic dipolar interaction. Additional knowledge about other interactions within the studied system like the chemical shift or the electric quadrupole interaction can be helpful as well, and in some cases solely the chemical shift has been employed as e.g. for zeolites. The “dipole coupling” based approach parallels protein NMR spectroscopy to some extent in that e.g. multiple residual dipolar couplings are measured for proteins in solution, and these couplings are used as constraints in the protein structure calculation.
In NMR crystallography the observed spins in case of organic molecules would often be spin-1/2 nuclei of moderate frequency (13C, 15N, 31P, etc.). I.e. 1H is excluded due to its large magnetogyric ratio and high spin concentration leading to a network of strong homonuclear dipolar couplings. There are two solutions with respect to 1H: 1H spin diffusion experiments (see below) and specific labelling with 2H spins (spin = 1). The latter is also popular e.g. in NMR spectroscopic investigations of hydrogen bonds in solution and the solid state. Both intra- and intermolecular structural elements can be investigated e.g. via deuterium REDOR (an established solid state NMR pulse sequence to measure dipolar couplings between deuterons and other spins). This can provide an additional constraint for an NMR crystallographic structural investigation in that it can be used to find and characterize e.g. intermolecular hydrogen bonds.
The above mentioned dipolar interaction can be measured directly, e.g. between pairs of heteronuclear spins like 13C/15N in many organic compounds. Furthermore, the strength of the dipolar interaction modulates parameters like the longitudinal relaxation time or the spin diffusion rate which therefore can be examined to obtain structural information. E.g. 1H spin diffusion has been measured providing rich structural information.
Chemical shift interaction
The chemical shift interaction can be used in conjunction with the dipolar interaction to determine the orientation of the dipolar interaction frame (principal axes system) with respect to the molecular frame (dipolar chemical shift spectroscopy). For some cases there are rules for the chemical shift interaction tensor orientation as for the 13C spin in ketones due to symmetry arguments (sp2 hybridisation). If the orientation of a dipolar interaction (between the spin of interest and e.g. another heteronucleus) is measured with respect to the chemical shift interaction coordinate system, these two pieces of information (chemical shift tensor/molecular orientation and the dipole tensor/chemical shift tensor orientation) combined give the orientation of the dipole tensor in the molecular frame. However, this method is only suitable for small molecules (or polymers with a small repetition unit like polyglycine) and it provides only selective (and usually intramolecular) structural information.
Crystal Structure Refinements
The dipolar interaction yields the most direct information with respect to structure as it makes it possible to measure the distances between the spins. The sensitivity of this interaction is however lacking and even though dipolar-based NMR crystallography makes the elucidation of structures possible, other methods are necessary to obtain high resolution structures. For these reasons much work was done to include the use other NMR observables such as chemical shift anisotropy and the quadrupolar interaction. These anisotropic interactions are highly sensitive to the 3D local environment making it possible to refine the structures of powdered samples to structures rivaling the quality of single crystal X-ray diffraction. These however rely on adequate methods for predicting these interactions as they do not depend in a straightforward fashion on the structure.
Comparison with diffraction methods
A drawback of NMR crystallography is that the method is typically more time consuming and more expensive (due to spectrometer costs and isotope labelling) than X-ray crystallography, it often elucidates only part of the structure, and isotope labelling and experiments may have to be tailored to obtain key structural information. Also not always is a molecular structure suitable for a pure NMR based NMR crystallographic approach, but it can still play an important role in a multimodality (NMR+diffraction) study.
Unlike in the case of diffraction methods, it appears that NMR crystallography needs to work on a case by case basis. This is the case since difference systems will have different spin physics and different observables which can be probed. The method may therefore not find widespread use as different systems will require qualified individuals to design experiments to study them.
- Harris KDM, Xu M (2009). Combined Analysis of NMR & Powder Diffraction Data. Wiley-Blackwell. ISBN 0-470-69961-2.
- Taulelle F (2004). "NMR crystallography: crystallochemical formula and space group selection". Solid State Sciences 6 (10): 1053–1057. Bibcode:2004SSSci...6.1053T. doi:10.1016/j.solidstatesciences.2004.07.033.
- Macholl S, Börner F, Buntkowsky G (2004). "Revealing the configuration and crystal packing of organic compounds by solid-state NMR spectroscopy: methoxycarbonylurea, a case study". Chemistry 10 (19): 4808–4816. doi:10.1002/chem.200400191. PMID 15372663.
- Harris RK (2006). "NMR studies of organic polymorphs & solvates". Analyst 131: 351–373. Bibcode:2006Ana...131..351H. doi:10.1039/b516057j. PMID 16496044.
- Reutzel-Edens SM (2008). "NMR Crystallography and the Elucidation of Structure-Property Relationships in Crystalline Solids". Engineering of Crystalline Materials Properties, NATO Science for Peace and Security Series B: Physics and Biophysics: 351–374. doi:10.1007/978-1-4020-6823-2_17.
- Schmidt-Rohr K., Spiess H.W. (1994). Multidimensional Solid-State NMR and Polymers. Academic Press. ISBN 0-12-626630-1.
- Brouwer DH (2008). "NMR Crystallography of Zeolites: Refinement of an NMR-Solved Crystal Structure Using ab Initio Calculations of 29Si Chemical Shift Tensors". J. Am. Chem. Soc. 130: 6306–6307. doi:10.1021/ja800227f. PMID 18433131.
- Kohen A., Limbach H.-H. (2005). Isotope Effects In Chemistry and Biology. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press. ISBN 0-8247-2449-6.
- Sack I, Goldbourt A, Vega S, Buntkowsky G (1999). "Deuterium REDOR: principles and applications for distance measurements". J Magn Reson 138 (1): 54–65. Bibcode:1999JMagR.138...54S. doi:10.1006/jmre.1999.1710. PMID 10329226.
- Elena B, Pintacuda G, Mifsud N, Emsley L (2006). "Molecular Structure Determination in Powders by NMR Crystallography from Proton Spin Diffusion". J. Am. Chem. Soc. 128: 9555–9560. doi:10.1021/ja062353p. PMID 16848494.
- Mehring M. (1983). High Resolution NMR Spectroscopy in Solids. Berlin, Heidelberg, New York: Springer. ISBN 0-387-07704-9.
- Wylie, BJ; Schwieters, CD; Oldfield, E; Rienstra, CM (2009). "Protein Structure Refinement Using 13Cα Chemical Shift Tensors". J. Am. Chem. Soc. 131: 985–992. doi:10.1021/ja804041p.
- Macholl S, Lentz D, Börner F, Buntkowsky G (2007). "Polymorphism of N,N-diacetylbiuret studied by solid-state 13C and 15N NMR spectroscopy, DFT calculations, and X-ray diffraction". Chemistry 13 (21): 6139–6149. doi:10.1002/chem.200601843. PMID 17480047.