Native American boarding schools
An Indian boarding school refers to one of many schools that were established in the United States during the late 19th and early 20th centuries to educate Native American children and youths according to Euro-American standards. They were first established by Christian missionaries of various denominations, who often started schools on reservations and founded boarding schools to provide opportunities for children who did not have schools nearby, especially in the lightly populated areas of the West. The government paid religious societies to provide education to Native American children on reservations. In the late 19th and early 20th centuries, the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA) founded additional boarding schools based on the assimilation model of the Carlisle Indian Industrial School.
Children were usually immersed in European-American culture through appearance changes with haircuts, were forbidden to speak their native languages, and traditional names were replaced by new European-American names. The experience of the schools was often harsh, especially for the younger children who were separated from their families. In numerous ways, they were encouraged or forced to abandon their Native American identities and cultures. The number of Native American children in the boarding schools reached a peak in the 1970s, with an estimated enrollment of 60,000 in 1973. Especially through investigations of the later twentieth century, there have been many documented cases of sexual, physical and mental abuse occurring at such schools. Since those years, tribal nations have increasingly insisted on community-based schools and have also founded numerous tribally controlled colleges. Community schools have also been supported by the federal government through the BIA and legislation. The largest boarding schools have closed. In some cases, reservations or tribes were too small or poor to support independent schools and still wanted an alternative for their children, especially for high school. By 2007, the number of Native American children in boarding schools had declined to 9,500.
History of education of Native Americans
How different would be the sensation of a philosophic mind to reflect that instead of exterminating a part of the human race by our modes of population that we had persevered through all difficulties and at last had imparted our Knowledge of cultivating and the arts, to the Aboriginals of the Country by which the source of future life and happiness had been preserved and extended. But it has been conceived to be impracticable to civilize the Indians of North America — This opinion is probably more convenient than just.
—Henry Knox to George Washington, 1790s.
In the late eighteenth century, reformers starting with Washington and Knox, in efforts to "civilize" or otherwise assimilate Native Americans (as opposed to relegating them to reservations), adopted the practice of educating native children in current American culture, which was at the time largely based on rural agriculture, with some small towns and few large cities. The Civilization Fund Act of 1819 promoted this civilization policy by providing funding to societies (mostly religious) who worked on Native American education, often at schools established in Indian communities.
I rejoice, brothers, to hear you propose to become cultivators of the earth for the maintenance of your families. Be assured you will support them better and with less labor, by raising stock and bread, and by spinning and weaving clothes, than by hunting. A little land cultivated, and a little labor, will procure more provisions than the most successful hunt; and a woman will clothe more by spinning and weaving, than a man by hunting. Compared with you, we are but as of yesterday in this land. Yet see how much more we have multiplied by industry, and the exercise of that reason which you possess in common with us. Follow then our example, brethren, and we will aid you with great pleasure ...
—President Thomas Jefferson, Brothers of the Choctaw Nation, December 17, 1803
Non-reservation boarding schools
Harvard College had an Indian College on its campus in the mid-1600s, supported by the English Society for Propagation of the Gospel. Its few Indian students came from New England, at a time when higher education was very limited for all classes and colleges were more similar to today's high schools. In 1665, Caleb Cheeshahteaumuck, "from the Wampanoag...did graduate from Harvard, the first Indian to do so in the colonial period". In early years, other Indian schools were created by local communities, as with the Indian school in Hanover, New Hampshire in 1769, which gradually developed into Dartmouth College. Other schools were created in the East, where Indian reservations were less common than they became in the late nineteenth century in western states.
West of the Mississippi, schools near Indian settlements and on reservations were first founded by religious missionaries, who believed they could extend education and Christianity to Native Americans. Some of their efforts were part of the progressive movement after the Civil War. As Native Americans were forced onto reservations following the Indian Wars, missionaries founded additional schools with boarding facilities, to accommodate students who lived too far to attend on a daily basis.
The Carlisle Indian Industrial School, founded by the US Army officer Richard Henry Pratt in 1879 at a former military installation, became a model for others established by the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA). Pratt said in a speech in 1892, "A great general has said that the only good Indian is a dead one. In a sense, I agree with the sentiment, but only in this: that all the Indian there is in the race should be dead. Kill the Indian in him and save the man." Pratt professed "assimilation through total immersion." He had arranged for education of some young Indian men at the Hampton Institute, a historically black college, after he had supervised them as prisoners at a fort in Florida.
At the prison, he made efforts to have the Indians taught English and United States culture, while giving them leeway to govern themselves. From seeing the progress of both his younger prisoners and the ones who attended Hampton, he came to believe that removing Indians from their native culture could result in their successful assimilation into the majority culture of the United States. As at the Hampton Institute, he included in the Carlisle curriculum vocational training for boys and domestic science for girls, including chores around the school and producing goods for market. They also produced a newspaper, had a well-regarded chorus and orchestra, and developed sports programs. The vocational training reflected the administration's understanding of skills needed at most reservations, which were located in rural areas, and reflected a society still based on agriculture. In the summer, students often lived with local farm families and townspeople to continue their immersion in European-American culture, and provide labor at low cost to the families. Carlisle and its curriculum became the model for the Bureau of Indian Affairs; by 1902 there were 25 federally funded non-reservation schools in 15 states and territories, with a total enrollment of over 6,000 students. Federal legislation required Native American children to be educated. Parents had to authorize their children's attendance at boarding schools, but sometimes officials used coercion to gain a quota of students from any given reservation.
As the model of boarding schools was adopted more widely by the US government, many Native American children were separated from their families and tribes when they were sent or sometimes taken to boarding schools far from their home reservations. These schools ranged from those similar to the federal Carlisle Indian Industrial School, which became a model for BIA-run schools; to the many schools sponsored by religious denominations.
In that period, when students arrived at the boarding schools, their lives usually altered dramatically. They were given short haircuts (a source of shame for boys of many tribes), uniforms, and English names; sometimes these were based on their own, other times they were assigned at random, and sometimes children chose new names. They were not allowed to speak their own languages, even between each other, and they were expected to attend church services and encouraged to convert to Christianity. Discipline was stiff in many schools (as it was in families and other areas of society), and it often included chores and punishments.
The following is a quote from Anna Moore regarding the Phoenix Indian School:
- "If we were not finished [scrubbing the dining room floors] when the 8 a.m. whistle sounded, the dining room matron would go around strapping us while we were still on our hands and knees."
The 1928 Meriam Report noted that infectious disease was often widespread at the schools due to insufficient funding for meals providing good nutrition, overcrowding, poor sanitary conditions (an element shared by many towns in the early 20th century) and students weakened by overwork. The report said that death rates for Native American students were six and a half times higher than for other ethnic groups.
The Meriam Report of 1928
In 1926, the Department of Interior (DOI) commissioned the Brookings Institution to conduct a survey of the overall conditions of the American Indians and to assess federal programs and policies. The Meriam Report, officially titled The Problem of Indian Administration, was submitted February 21, 1928 to the Secretary of the Interior Hubert Work. Related to education of Native American children, it recommended:
- abolition of "The Uniform Course of Study", which taught only European-American cultural values;
- education of younger children at community schools near home, while providing for older children to be able to attend non-reservation schools for higher grade work; and
- provision by the Indian Service (now Bureau of Indian Affairs) to Native Americans of the education and skills to adapt both in their own communities and United States society.
Despite the Meriam Report, attendance in Indian boarding schools generally grew throughout the first half of the 20th century and doubled in the 1960s. Enrollment reached its highest point in the 1970s. In 1973, 60,000 American Indian children are estimated to have been enrolled in an Indian boarding school. The rise of pan-Indian activism, tribal nations' continuing complaints about the schools, and studies in the late 1960s and mid-1970s (such as the Kennedy Report and the National Study of American Indian Education) led to passage of the Indian Self-Determination and Education Assistance Act of 1975. This emphasized decentralization of students from boarding schools to community schools. As a result, many large Indian boarding schools closed in the 1980s and early 1990s. By 2007, 9,500 American Indian children were living in Indian boarding school dormitories. This figure includes those in 45 on-reservation boarding schools, seven off-reservation boarding schools, and 14 peripheral dormitories. From 1879 to the present day, it is estimated that hundreds of thousands of American Indians as children attended Indian boarding schools.
Today, a few off-reservation boarding schools still operate, but funding for them is in decline. Some American Indians found their experiences and education at such schools to be valuable and have wanted to retain the schools as alternatives to reservation-based education. Many others found their times at boarding schools to be repressive.
Native American boarding schools in the United States were seen as the means for the government to achieve assimilation of American Indians, which it believed was the best way for them to live in the changing society.
A similar system in Canada was known as the Canadian Indian residential school system. On June 11, 2008, Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper issued a 3,600-word formal apology to First Nation, Métis and Inuit people for the legacy of Indian Residential Schools, which he called a "sad chapter in our history." The Anishinabek Nation Grand Council Chief John Beaucage said, "Our first thoughts today are for our elders, many of them have suffered life-long physical and emotional pain because of their residential school experiences."
Similarly, the Anglican Church of Canada, which ran many of the boarding schools and was sued for abuses, has issued an official apology in addition to paying court-ordered settlements. It has further adopted a policy of a "living apology" and has been working to support First Nations and other indigenous peoples within their own cultures.
List of Native American boarding schools
- Albuquerque Indian School, Albuquerque, New Mexico
- Bacone College, Muscogee, Oklahoma, 1881–present
- Bloomfield Seminary, Hendrix/Ardmore, Oklahoma
- Bond's Mission School or Montana Industrial School for Indians, run by Unitarians, Crow Indian Reservation near Custer Station, Montana 1886-1897 
- Carlisle Indian School, Carlisle, Pennsylvania, open 1879-1918
- Chamberlain Indian School, Chamberlain, South Dakota
- Chemawa Indian School, Salem, Oregon
- Cheyenne-Arapaho Boarding School, Concho, Oklahoma
- Chilocco Indian Agricultural School, Chilocco, Oklahoma, open 1884-1980
- Chinle Boarding School, Many Farms, Arizona
- Dwight Mission, Marble City, Oklahoma
- El Meta Bond College, Minco, Oklahoma
- Euchee Boarding School, Sapulpa, Oklahoma
- Eufaula Indian School, Eufaula, Oklahoma
- Flandreau Indian School, South Dakota
- Fort Bidwell School, California
- Fort Shaw Indian School, Fort Shaw, Montana
- Genoa Indian Industrial School, Genoa, Nebraska
- Greenville School, California
- Hampton Institute, began accepting Native students in 1878
- Haskell Indian Industrial Training School, Lawrence, Kansas, 1884–present
- Hayward Indian School, Hayward, Wisconsin
- Holbrook Indian School, Holbrook, Arizona
- Ignacio Boarding School, Colorado
- Intermountain Indian School, Utah
- Jones Male Academy, Hartshorne, Oklahoma
- Mekosukey Academy, Oklahoma
- Morris Industrial School for Indians, Morris, Minnesota, open 1887—1909
- Murray State School of Agriculture, Tishomingo, Oklahoma, est. 1908
- Nenannezed Boarding School, New Mexico
- Nuyaka School and Orphanage (Nuyaka Mission, Presbyterian), Okmulgee, Oklahoma, 1884–1933
- Oklahoma Presbyterian College for Girls, Durant, Oklahoma
- Oklahoma School for the Blind, Muskogee, Oklahoma
- Oklahoma School for the Deaf, Sulphur, Oklahoma
- Old Goodland Indian Orphanage, Hugo, Oklahoma
- Oneida Indian School, Wisconsin
- Osage Boarding School, Pawhuska, Oklahoma
- Pawnee Boarding School, Pawnee, Oklahoma, opened 1878
- Phoenix Indian School, Phoenix, Arizona
- Pierre Indian School, Pierre, South Dakota
- Pine Ridge Boarding School, Pine Ridge, South Dakota
- Pinon Boarding School, Pinon, Arizona
- Pipestone Indian School, Pipestone, Minnesota
- Rapid City Indian School, Rapid City, South Dakota
- Red Moon School, Oklahoma
- Riverside Indian School, Anadarko, Oklahoma
- St. Agnes Academy, Ardmore, Oklahoma
- St. Agnes Mission, Antlers, Oklahoma
- St. Boniface Indian School, Banning, California
- St. Elizabeth's Boarding School, Purcell, Oklahoma
- St. Josephs Boarding School, Chickasha, Oklahoma
- San Juan Boarding School, New Mexico
- Santa Fe Indian School, Santa Fe, New Mexico
- Seger School, Oklahoma
- Sherman Indian High School, Riverside, California
- Shiprock Boarding School, Shiprock, New Mexico
- Seneca Indian School, Wyandotte, Oklahoma
- Sequoyah High School, Tahlequah, Oklahoma
- Southwestern Indian Polytechnic Institute, Albuquerque, New Mexico
- Springfield Indian School, Springfield, South Dakota
- Stewart Indian School, Carson City, Nevada
- Tomah Indian School, Wisconsin
- Thomas Indian School, near Irvington, New York
- Wahpeton Indian School, North Dakota
- Tuskahoma Female Academy, Muskogee, Oklahoma
- Wheelock Academy, Millerton, Oklahoma
- Wittenberg Indian School, Wittenberg, Wisconsin
- Mount Pleasant Indian Industrial Boarding School, Mount Pleasant, Michigan 1893-1934
- Native Americans in the United States
- Canadian residential school system
- Native schools in New Zealand
- Our Spirits Don't Speak English, documentary on Native American boarding schools
- Stolen Generations, children of Australian Aboriginal descent who were removed from their families by the Australian and state government agencies
- "What Were Boarding Schools Like for Indian Youth?". authorsden.com. Retrieved February 8, 2006.
- "Long-suffering urban Indians find roots in ancient rituals". California's Lost Tribes. Archived from the original on August 29, 2005. Retrieved February 8, 2006.
- "Soul Wound: The Legacy of Native American Schools". Amnesty International USA. Retrieved February 8, 2006.
- Eric Miller (1994). "Washington and the Northwest War, Part One". Retrieved 2010-08-11.
- The Great Confusion in Indian Affairs: Native Americans and Whites in the Progressive Era, Tom Holm, http://www.utexas.edu/utpress/excerpts/exholgre.html
- "To the Brothers of the Choctaw Nation". Yale Law School. 1803. Retrieved 2010-10-24.
- Monaghan, E. J., Learning to Read and Write in Colonial America, University of Massachusetts Press. Boston: MA, 2005, p. 55, 59
- Charla Bear, "American Indian Boarding Schools Haunt Many", Part 1, NPR, 12 May 2008, accessed 5 July 2011
- Author unlisted (2001). Native American Issue: "The Challenges and Limitations of Assimilation", The Brown Quarterly 4(3), accessed 6 July 2011
- Smith, Andrea. "Soul Wound: The Legacy of Native American Schools", Amnesty Magazine, from Amnesty International website, 
-  Union of Ontario Indians press release: "Time will prove apology's sincerity", says Beaucage.
- Carter, Kent, compiler. "Preliminary Inventory of the Office of the Five Civilized Tribes Agency Muscogee Area of the Bureau of Indian Affairs (Record Group 75). Appendix VI: List of Schools (Entry 600 and 601)" RootsWeb. 1994 (retrieved 25 Feb 2010)
- Margery Pease, A Worthy Work in a Needy Time: The Montana Industrial School for Indians (Bond's Mission ) 1886-1897, Self-published in 1986. Reprinted in Billings, Mont.: M. Pease, 
- "Records of the Bureau of Indian Affairs." National Archives. (retrieved 25 Feb 2010)
- "American Indian Boarding Schools." 15 Sept 2003 (retrieved 25 Feb 2010)
- "Indian Boarding and Residential Schools Sites of Conscience Network." International Coalition of Sites of Conscience. (retrieved 25 Feb 2010)
- City of Morris: Morris Human Rights Commission
- Harley, Bruce (1994). Readings in Diocesan Heritage Volume VIII St. Boniface Indian School. San Bernardino, CA: Diocese of San Bernardino. pp. i–137.
- Child, Brenda J. (2000). Boarding School Seasons: American Indian Families, Lincoln: U of Nebraska Press. ISBN 978-0-8032-6405-2.
- Meriam, Lewis et al., The Problem of Indian Administration, Brookings Institution, 1928 (full text online at Alaskool.org)
- Bear, Charla, "American Indian Boarding Schools Haunt Many" NPR, May 12, 2008
- An Indian Boarding School Photo Gallery
- Playing for the World Documentary produced by Montana PBS