Necessity and Urgency Decree

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

A Necessity and Urgency Decree[1] (Spanish: Decreto de necesidad y urgencia, also known as DNU) is a special kind of order issued by the President of Argentina. Unlike regular decrees, which are used in Argentina for rulemaking, a DNU has the force of law. Once the President promulgates a DNU, the National Congress must examine it to determine if it to remain in force or not.[2]

Features[edit]

The Argentine National Congress must evaluate every Necessity and Urgency Decree.

The possibility to promulgate DNUs is established in the article 99 of the Constitution of Argentina since 1994. As its name indicates, a Necessity and Urgency Decree is to be used only under exceptional situations, when it is not possible to follow the normal procedure to create laws in the Congress. In addition, the President cannot sanction DNUs legislating about criminal, tributary or electoral matters.[2]

As with regular decrees, Necessity and Urgency Decrees are promulgated by the President, but only with "General Agreement of Ministers" (Spanish: Acuerdo general de ministros). It means that all Ministers and the Chief of Staff must take part in the DNU's creation.[2]

Once the Necessity and Urgency Decree is sanctioned, the Chief of Staff must send the DNU to the Permanent Bicameral Committee of the Congress in no more than ten days. Then, the Bicameral Committee delivers its report to the Chamber of Deputies and the Senate. The Committee has also ten days to elaborate the report. During all this process, the DNU is completely in force.[2][3]

Each legislative chamber must deliver a resolution expressing its approval or rejection of the Necessity and Urgency Decree. If both chambers reject the DNU, it loses validity permanently. However, any rights acquired by people affected by the decree are not automatically terminated.[3]

Background[edit]

In military governments[edit]

All legislation issued by military dictatorships in Argentina was made by the executive. These kinds of orders were known as decree-law (Spanish: decreto ley). Under the self-called Argentine Revolution and the National Reorganization Process (the two latest military governments), the decree-laws were known simply as laws.

Because they were de facto governments, there was a legal controversy about the validity of decree-laws. In 1945, the Supreme Court of Argentina accepted them only if they were needed to fulfill the aims of the government. When the military government dissolved and civilian rule was reestablished, the decree-laws were no longer valid, unless the Congress ratified them.[4]

In 1946, a new judgment by the Supreme Court established that decree-laws would remain valid after the end of the de facto government that promulgated them, and they could be abolished or modified in the same manner as other laws.[4]

In constitutional governments[edit]

Although DNUs were introduced in their present form in the National Constitution in 1994, previous constitutional Presidents have used this type of decree. One example is the Austral Plan, which changed the national currency from the peso argentino to the Austral. This was sanctioned by the President Raúl Alfonsín in 1985, using the decree 1096/85.[5] Currently, Argentina uses the peso as its national currency.

In December 1990, the Supreme Court approved the sanction of Necessity and Urgency Decree in the so-called Peralta Case, in which Luis Peralta requested to declare unconstitutional the decree 36/90, that President Menem promulgated in 1990. The judges of the Court eventually confirmed the validity of the DNU.[6][7]

Irregularities[edit]

Despite the fact that the Constitution says the Congress must create a special law to analyze Necessity and Urgency Decrees, this law was created in 2006, twelve years after the 1994 amendment of the Argentine Constitution, when the DNU were introduced. It means that all Presidents who ruled in this period (Carlos Menem, Fernando de la Rúa, Adolfo Rodríguez Saá, Eduardo Duhalde and Néstor Kirchner) could issue DNU's with no legislative control.[8]

In addition, they are DNU's which were created with no real need or urgency, such as the decrees that modify the Ministries Law to create new executive departments.[9] The abuse of DNU's was also criticized.[10][11]

Former President Néstor Kirchner has the highest average of DNU per year. His wife, President Cristina Fernández, has the lowest average.

Statistics since 1994[edit]

Eduardo Duhalde, interim President between 2002 and 2003, was the President who signed more DNU's per year since the 1983 return to civilian rule. He promulgated 158 DNU's in one year.[12] Those decrees were neither checked by the Congress.

Néstor Kirchner (2003–2007) promulgated 270 Necessity and Urgency Decrees in four years and a half. His DNU's released until 2006 were not controlled by the Congress.[13] His average is 60 Necessity and Urgency Decrees per year.

During the presidency of Carlos Menem (1989–1999), he signed 545 DNU's in ten years, or 54.5 per year.[13] None of his Necessity and Urgency Decrees were analyzed by the legislative branch of the government.

In Fernando de la Rúa's two-years presidency (1999–2001), 73 special decrees were released. His average is thus 36.5 DNU's per year.[13] The decrees signed by De la Rúa were not analyzed by the Bicameral Committee.

Cristina Fernández de Kirchner, current President since 2007, signed five Necessity and Urgency Decrees until March 2009.[14] Since then, she issued three DNU's creating new ministries,[9][15][16] another one creating a welfare plan,[17] a decree to remove Martín Redrado as president of the Central Bank,[18] and other three Necessity and Urgency Decrees related to the payment of public debt[18] The total number is 13 DNU's in three years of presidency, or four Necessity and Urgency Decrees per year.

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ The National News agency of Argentina, Télam translates decreto de necesidad y urgencia as Necessity and Urgency Decree: "The Necessity and Urgency Decree is enforced", stated Miguel Angel Pichetto
  2. ^ a b c d Constitución Nacional. Senado.gov.ar. Retrieved on 2012-06-07.
  3. ^ a b Regimen Legal De Los Decretos De Necesidad Y Urgencia, De Delegacion Legislativa Y De Promulgacion Parcial De Leyes. Infoleg.mecon.gov.ar. Retrieved on 2012-06-07.
  4. ^ a b HISTORIA IDEOLÓGICA DE LA CORTE SUPREMA DE JUSTICIA DE LA NACIÓN 1947–1955. Universidad del Salvador. IUSHISTORIA (Revista Electrónica) Nº 2. October 2005
  5. ^ La necesidad de decretar la urgencia. politicargentina.com (2009-11-30)
  6. ^ Caso Peralta. Todoiure.com.ar. Retrieved on 2012-06-07.
  7. ^ La legitimidad del dictado de los decretos de necesidad y urgencia. hcdn.gov.ar
  8. ^ El control de los DNU, una vieja deuda de la política. Clarin.com (June 26, 2006). Retrieved on 2012-06-07.
  9. ^ a b Decreto 1365/2009. Modifícase el Decreto N° 438/92 y sus modificatorias. Incorpóranse Ministerios. Infoleg.mecon.gov.ar (October 13, 2009). Retrieved on 2012-06-07.
  10. ^ También este año Kirchner firmó más decretos que leyes. LaNacion (2006-07-03)
  11. ^ Kirchner firma por año más decretos que Menem. deliaferreira.com.ar (2006-06-14)
  12. ^ Diario digital producido por la Cooperativa La Masa. Redaccion Rosario. Retrieved on 2012-06-07.
  13. ^ a b c Kirchner firmó cada seis días un decreto de necesidad y urgencia – 13.04.2008 – lanacion.com. Lanacion.com.ar (April 13, 2008). Retrieved on 2012-06-07.
  14. ^ En 15 meses de gobierno, Cristina Kirchner firmó 5 decretos de necesidad y urgencia. Nueva Mayoria. Retrieved on 2012-06-07.
  15. ^ Decreto 1458/2009. Sustitúyese la denominación del Ministerio de Industria por Ministerio de Industria y Turismo. infoleg.mecon.gov.ar (2009-10-09)
  16. ^ MINISTERIO DE AGRICULTURA, GANADERIA Y PESCA. Decreto 1461/2009. Modifícase la integración de los miembros del Consejo Directivo del Instituto Nacional de Tecnología Agropecuaria. infoleg.mecon.gov.ar (2009-10-09)
  17. ^ SIGNACIONES FAMILIARES. Decreto 1602/2009. Incorpórase el Subsistema no Contributivo de Asignación Universal por hijo para Protección Social. Infoleg.mecon.gov.ar (October 29, 2009). Retrieved on 2012-06-07.
  18. ^ a b BANCO CENTRAL DE LA REPUBLICA ARGENTINA. Decreto 18/2010. Remuévese del cargo al Presidente. Infoleg.mecon.gov.ar (January 7, 2010). Retrieved on 2012-06-07.