Neo soul

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
  (Redirected from Neo-soul)
Jump to: navigation, search

"Neo soul" is a term coined by music industry entrepreneur Kedar Massenburg during the late 1990s to market and describe a style of music that emerged from soul and contemporary R&B.[1] Heavily based in soul music, neo soul is distinguished by a less conventional sound than its contemporary R&B counterpart,[1][2] with incorporated elements ranging from jazz, funk, and hip hop to pop, fusion, and African music. It has been noted by music writers for its traditional R&B influences, conscious-driven lyrics, and strong female presence.

Neo soul developed during the 1980s and early 1990s, in the United States and United Kingdom, as a soul "revival" movement.[2][3] It earned mainstream success during the 1990s, with the commercial and critical breakthroughs of several neo soul artists that were marketed as an alternative to the producer-driven, digitally approached R&B of the time.[4] Since its initial mainstream popularity and impact on the sound of contemporary R&B, it has been expanded and diversified musically through the works of both African-American and international artists.[5] According to Mark Anthony Neal, "neo-soul and its various incarnations has helped to redefine the boundaries and contours of black pop".[6]

Etymology[edit]

By definition, neo-soul is a paradox. Neo means new. Soul is timeless. All the neo-soul artists, in various ways, perform balancing acts, exploring classic soul idioms while injecting a living, breathing presence into time-tested formulas. They humanize R&B, which has often been reduced to a factory-perfected product. Like sushi, neo-soul is fresh enough to be served raw.

— Dimitri Ehrlich, Vibe[2]

As a term, neo soul was coined by Kedar Massenburg of Motown Records in the late 1990s as a marketing category following the commercial breakthroughs of artists such as D'Angelo, Erykah Badu, Lauryn Hill, and Maxwell.[1] The commercial breakthrough of D'Angelo's debut album Brown Sugar (1995) has been regarded by several writers and music critics as inspiration behind the term's coinage.[1][3][4] While some artists have ignored the label, others have received the designation with controversy, viewing that it can be seen as contrived by music audiences and implies that soul music had ended at some point in time.[4] In a 2002 interview for Billboard, Massenburg expressed his view on the backlash and intentions of marketing the neo soul term, stating:

In a 2010 article for PopMatters, music writer Tyler Lewis elaborated on the term in retrospect, stating: "The term 'neo-soul' has been the subject of intense debate ever since Kedar Massenburg coined it as a way to market Erykah Badu's Baduizm 13 years ago. Given the way black music has been named by (usually) outsiders ever since the blues, the reaction to the name by artists who ostensibly fit into the 'neo-soul' category represents a wonderful example of black self-determination in an industry that is still defiantly wedded to narrow definitions and images of black folks."[7] Jason Anderson of CBC News compares the etymology of "neo soul" to that of "new wave" and comments: "As imperfect as the term may be, neo-soul is still an effective tag to describe the mix of chic modernity and time-honoured tradition that distinguished the genre's best examples. Neo-soul artists tried to look both backward and forward, acting in the belief that a continuum might exist."[8]

Characteristics[edit]

Produced by musical group Sa-Ra, Bilal's 2003 song "Something to Hold on To" contains yearning lyrics about love and chiming piano in its groove-based sound.[9][10]

Problems playing this file? See media help.

Despite some ambivalence from artists, the term ultimately received widespread use by music critics and writers who wrote about artists and albums associated with the musical style.[4][11] African American studies professor Mark Anthony Neal has described neo soul as "everything from avant-garde R&B to organic soul... a product of trying to develop something outside of the norm in R&B".[12] According to music writers, the genre's works are mostly album-oriented and distinguished by its musicianship and production, incorporating "organic" elements of classic soul music with the use of live instrumentation, in contrast to the more single-oriented, hip hop-based, and producer-driven sampling approach of contemporary R&B.[4][5][13] They also infuse jazz, funk, and African musical elements into R&B.[14] In her book Musical Rhythm in the Age of Digital Reproduction, music author Anne Danielson writes that neo soul toward the end of the 1990s exhibited a musical development that was part of "a remarkable increase in musicians' experimentation with and manipulation of grooves at the microrhythmic level – that is, the level in played music that is usually understood in terms of phrasing and timing."[15]

Noting that most of the genre's artists are singer-songwriters, writers have viewed neo soul artists' lyrical content of as more "conscious-driven" and having a broader range than most other R&B artists.[2][4][13] Allmusic calls it "roughly analogous to contemporary R&B".[16] Dimitri Ehrlich of Vibe comments that neo soul artists "emphasize a mix of elegant, jazz-tinged R&B and subdued hip hop, with a highly idiosyncratic, deeply personal approach to love and politics".[2] Music writers have noted that neo soul artists are predominantly female, which contrasts the marginalized presence of women in mainstream hip hop and R&B.[17] Jason Anderson of CBC News calls neo soul a "sinuous, sly yet unabashedly earnest" alternative and "kind of haven for listeners turned off by the hedonism of mainstream hip-hop and club jams."[8] Neo soul artists are often associated with alternative lifestyles and fashions, including organic food, incense, and knit caps.[18]

According to music writer Peter Shapiro, the term itself refers to a musical style that obtains its influence from older R&B styles, and bohemian musicians seeking a soul revival, while setting themselves apart from the more contemporary sounds of their mainstream R&B counterparts.[1] In a 1998 article on neo soul, Time journalist Christopher John Farley wrote that neo soul artists such as Lauryn Hill, D'Angelo, and Maxwell "share a willingness to challenge musical orthodoxy".[13] Miles Marshall Lewis comments that 1990s neo soul "owed its raison d'être to '70s soul superstars like Marvin Gaye and Stevie Wonder", adding that "in concert, Erykah Badu and D'Angelo regularly covered Chaka Khan, the Ohio Players, and Al Green, to make the lineage crystal clear."[19] In citing Tony! Toni! Tone! as progenitors of the genre, Tony Green of Vibe views that the group pioneered the "digital-analog hybrid sound" of neo soul and "dramatically refreshed the digitalized wasteland that was R&B in the late '80s".[20] Neo soul artists during the 1990s were heavily inspired by the eclectic sound and mellow instrumentation of Gil Scott-Heron's and Brian Jackson's collaborative work in the 1970s.[21] All About Jazz has cited Jackson as "one of the early architects" of the sound and his early work with Scott-Heron as "an inspirational and musical Rosetta stone for the neo-soul movement".[22]

History[edit]

1980s–early 1990s: Origins[edit]

Neo soul's origins lie in the 1980s and early 1990s, with the work of musical acts such as Prince, Tony! Toni! Toné!, Terrence Trent D'Arby, Joi,[23] and Mint Condition, whose music deviated from the conventions of most contemporary R&B at the time.[2][4][13][20] Tony! Toni! Toné!-member Raphael Saadiq later embarked on a solo career and produced various works of other neo soul artists.[24] Influential to neo soul, UK act Sade achieved success in the 1980s with music that featured a sophisti-pop style, incorporating elements of soul, pop, smooth jazz, and quiet storm.[25][26] The band was part of a new wave of British R&B-oriented artists during the late-1980s and early 1990s that also included Soul II Soul, Caron Wheeler, The Brand New Heavies, Jamiroquai, and Lisa Stansfield.[27] Allmusic's Alex Henderson writes that, "Many of the British artists who emerged during that period had a neo-soul outlook and were able to blend influences from different eras".[27] Other British progenitors of the neo soul movement at the time included Young Disciples and Omar Lye-Fook,[28] the latter of whom has been cited as "the father of British neo-soul" and an influence on many later neo soul artists.[29]

American artists during the early 1990s included Zhané, Groove Theory, Joi, Tony Rich, and Me'Shell NdegéOcello.[11][30][31][32] Christopher John Farley writes that, "before there was a name for it, Prince had been carrying a torch for neo soul for decades, refusing to make R&B that played by the rules or fit into comfortable formats. In the mid-'90s, he was suddenly joined by a host of other soul artists who also wanted to break boundaries".[33]

Mid–late 1990s: Mainstream breakthrough[edit]

Although she disputes the term, Erykah Badu has been dubbed "the first lady of neo soul" and "the queen of neo-soul".[34][35][36][37]

The success of Tony! Toni! Toné!'s 1993 album Sons of Soul has been viewed as a precursor to the soul music revival in the mid-1990s.[38][39] In a 1997 article for the Los Angeles Times, music journalist Cheo Hodari Coker cited the album as having "largely sparked the soul music revival that has opened the door for a new generation of singers who build on the tradition of Marvin Gaye and Stevie Wonder".[38] Allmusic editor Leo Stanley wrote that by the release of Tony! Toni! Toné!'s follow-up album House of Music in 1996, "their influence was beginning to be apparent, as younger soul singer/songwriters like Tony Rich and Maxwell began reaching the R&B charts. Like Tony! Toni! Toné!, Rich and Maxwell relied on traditional soul and R&B values of songwriting and live performances, discarding the synth-heavy productions of the late '80s and early '90s".[39] Malcolm Venable of Vibe cites the early work of hip hop group The Roots, who used live instrumentation, as a precursor to neo soul's commercial breakthrough in the mid-1990s.[40]

Music writers have credited the breakthroughs of D'Angelo's Brown Sugar (1995), Erykah Badu's Baduizm (1997), Maxwell's Urban Hang Suite (1996), and Lauryn Hill's The Miseducation of Lauryn Hill (1998) with shaping and raising the neo soul movement to commercial visibility into the late 1990s.[1][11][16][41][42][43] According to Farley, D'Angelo's album "gives a nod to the past, [...] mints his own sound, with golden humming keyboards and sensual vocals and unhurried melodies [...] His songs were polished without being slick and smart without being pretentious", while Badu "brought an iconoclastic spirit to soul music, with her towering Afrocentric headwraps, incense candles, and quirky lyrics".[33] Baduizm sold nearly three million copies and won Badu two Grammy Awards.[37] Hill's debut featured her singing and rapping, with deeply personal lyrics,[33] and was one of neo soul's primary successes,[11] achieving massive sales, critical acclaim, and five Grammy Awards.[44] Subsequently, other female neo soul artists broke through with their debut albums, including Macy Gray, Angie Stone, and Jill Scott.[16][24] The 1997 film Love Jones capitalized on neo soul's success at the time with its soundtrack album, which impacted the Billboard charts and featured artists such as Hill, Maxwell, The Brand New Heavies, Me'Shell NdegéOcello, Groove Theory, and Dionne Farris.[45][46]

According to music journalist Greg Kot, musical collective Soulquarians, consisting of such artists as D'Angelo, The Roots, Erykah Badu, Bilal, Mos Def, Common, James Poyser, and Q-Tip, contributed significantly to the neo soul movement during the late 1990s to the early 2000s with its members' "organic soul, natural R&B, boho-rap".[47] The collective developed through the production work of The Roots' drummer and producer Questlove.[40] Following a minor decline in its hype, neo soul's mainstream popularity increased in the late 1990s with the successes of Hill, Maxwell, Eric Benét, Raphael Saadiq, and Les Nubians.[11] It impacted more mainstream-oriented R&B radio, while influencing contemporary R&B acts, such as R. Kelly and Aaliyah,[33] to incorporate some of its textural and lyrical elements.[11] In his song "When a Woman's Fed Up" (1998), R&B recording artist R. Kelly incorporated a more soul-based sound and referenced Erykah Badu's 1997 song "Tyrone" in the lyrics.[11]

2000s: Apex and mainstream decline[edit]

With the success of albums by Lauryn Hill, Erykah Badu, and Maxwell, D'Angelo's second album Voodoo served as a further alternative to excesses of late 1990s R&B and hip hop, as neo soul reached its apex in 2000.[48] A production of the Soulquarians,[47] it was an exemplary creative milestone of neo soul.[8][49] Ben Ratliff of The New York Times called the album "the succes d'estime that proves the force of this new music: it is a largely unslick, stubbornly idiosyncratic and genuinely great album that has already produced two hit singles".[5] By the time of her second album Mama's Gun (2000), Erykah Badu had been dubbed by writers as "the queen of neo-soul".[37] She has said of the honorific title, "I hated that because what if I don’t do that anymore? What if I change? Then that puts me in a penitentiary."[37] Subsequently, other neo soul artists attained success in the early 2000s, including Bilal, Musiq Soulchild, India.Arie, and Alicia Keys, who broke through to broader popularity with her debut album Songs in A Minor (2001).[2][16][50] Hip hop artists such as The Roots and Common, associated with the Soulquarians,[47] released albums that incorporated neo soul, Phrenology (2002) and Electric Circus (2003).[24]

However, the decade later featured a decline in output by neo soul artists,[7][51] with many of them failing to make a commercial impact after previous successes or not releasing a follow-up album.[45] Erykah Badu's commercial viability decreased as each of her releases following her debut Baduizm departed further from that album's music.[8] Lauryn Hill followed-up her 1998 debut, considered the best-selling neo soul album, with the 2002 live album MTV Unplugged No. 2.0, a combative, confessional work in which she expresses her misgivings about fame.[8] Melena Ryzik of The New York Times wrote in a retrospect of that "era of left-of-center black singer-songwriters", stating "many of them struggled to keep their creative momentum, conflicted about their early mainstream success."[37] Producer and Soulquarians member Questlove elaborated on the artists' regression from the mainstream, saying "I think most of us went through our psychosomatic, quasi-self-saboteur stage. Once we got that first taste of success, I think just the pressure of reacting got to all of us. Some of us released some of the craziest records of our career."[37] Other artists such as D'Angelo and Lauryn Hill went on indefinite hiatus from the music scene.[8][37] Music writer Tyler Lewis of PopMatters attributed the decline to "the downside of [the] rejection of the term ['neo soul']", writing that:

Raheem DeVaughn performs socially-conscious and love-themed songs, and has been compared to Donny Hathaway and Marvin Gaye.[52][53]

The Boston Globe's Renée Graham wrote of the artists' ambivalence towards the term in a 2003 article on neo soul's standing, "Despite its critical success, if neo-soul had an initial failing, it was the media-created label itself – a term that the artists, whom it was meant to represent, generally rejected".[45] In a 2003 interview, music publicist John Constanza said that "The neo-soul movement is still there, but it's been underground, and it's trying to get the attention of the mainstream again".[45] Mark Edward Nero of About.com stated, "In general, neo-soul has remained almost exclusive to R&B outlets such as urban radio and Black Entertainment Television [...] the majority of neo-soul artists have yet to crossover to mainstream American music listeners, partially because the music's sound generally focuses on artist expression, rather than popular appeal".[54]

During the mid-2000s, emerging artists such as Heather Headley, Anthony David, J Davey, Eric Roberson, and Ledisi signed to independent soul labels and received exposure through independent retailers, neo soul-oriented web sites, college and public radio stations, city club venues, cable networks such as Music Choice and BET J, and publishing deals as writers and producers for major label-recording artists.[55] Erykah Badu and Maxwell returned from their respective hiatuses and released well-received albums, her New Amerykah albums and his 2009 album BLACKsummers'night, and they subsequently toured together.[8][56][57] VH1 Soul's series Soulstage, which began in 2007, showcased new music by artists such as Badu, Jill Scott, India.Arie, Q-Tip, and Raphael Saadiq.[58][59]

2010s: Late period[edit]

The more popular neo soul artists in recent years have included John Legend, Anthony Hamilton, Jill Scott, Maxwell, Chrisette Michele, Leela James, and Raheem DeVaughn.[24][54] DeVaughn has described himself as an "R&B Hippy Neo-Soul Rock Star", viewing it as a reference to his eclectic musical style.[52] In its 2010 issue on critical moments in popular music, Spin cited D'Angelo's Voodoo and its success as a turning point for neo soul: "D'Angelo's pastiche of funk, carnal ache, and high-minded, Afrocentric rhetoric stands as neo-soul's crowning achievement. So unsurpassable that it'd be eight years before we'd hear from Erykah Badu and Maxwell again, while Hill and D'Angelo remain missing. But Alicia Keys, John Legend, and Cee-Lo picked up D's mantle and ran with it".[51] Evan Rytlewski of The A.V. Club discerns "a line of revelatory, late-period neo-soul albums" with the releases of Maxwell's BLACKsummers'night (2009), Badu's New Amerykah Part Two (Return of the Ankh) (2010), Bilal's Airtight's Revenge (2010), and Frank Ocean's Channel Orange (2012).[60]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ a b c d e f Shapiro, Peter; Al Spicer (2006). The Rough Guide to Soul and R&B. Rough Guides. ISBN 1-84353-264-6. 
  2. ^ a b c d e f g Ehrlich, Dimitri. "Young Soul Rebels". Vibe: 72. February 2002.
  3. ^ a b Kot, Greg. "Dusting of Old King Soul". Chicago Tribune: 1. July 21, 1996.
  4. ^ a b c d e f g h Mitchell, Gail. "Soul Resurrection: What's So New About Neo-Soul?". Billboard: 30, 36. June 1, 2002.
  5. ^ a b c Ratliff, Ben. Out of a Rut and Into a New Groove. The New York Times. Retrieved on May 9, 2010.
  6. ^ Neal, Mark Anthony. "Songs in the Key of Black Life: A Rhythm and Blues Nation". Routledge: 117–118. 2003.
  7. ^ a b c Lewis, Tyler (September 28, 2010). Review: Airtight's Revenge. PopMatters. Retrieved on September 28, 2010.
  8. ^ a b c d e f g Anderson, Jason (July 17, 2009). "Soul on Fire". CBC News. Canadian Broadcasting Centre. Retrieved November 2, 2011. 
  9. ^ Haithcoat, Rebecca (October 29, 2010). Live Review: Bilal at the Echoplex – Los Angeles Music – West Coast Sound. LA Weekly. Retrieved on March 6, 2011.
  10. ^ Amorosi, A.D. (November 30, 2010). "Bilal impresses at World Cafe Live". The Philadelphia Inquirer (Philadelphia). Archived from the original on July 17, 2012. Retrieved March 6, 2011. 
  11. ^ a b c d e f g Ross, Sean. "After a False Start, The Neo-Soul Genre Picks Up Steam on the Mainstream Track". Billboard: May 8, 1999.
  12. ^ Burch, Audra D.S. (June 3, 2001). "Neo-Soul: Past Future Perfect". Richmond Times. p. H.2. 
  13. ^ a b c d Farley, Christopher John. Music: Neo-Soul on a Roll. Time. Retrieved on May 9, 2010.
  14. ^ Kennedy, Gerrick D. (November 11, 2012). "Miguel helps lead the charge for an edgier kind of R&B artist". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved November 10, 2012. 
  15. ^ Danielsen, Anne (2010). Musical Rhythm in the Age of Digital Reproduction. Ashgate Publishing. p. 19. ISBN 1-4094-0340-8. 
  16. ^ a b c d Genre: Neo Soul. Allmusic. Retrieved on April 26, 2010.
  17. ^ Rabaka, Reiland (2011). Hip Hop Inheritance: From the Harlem Renaissance to the Hip Hop Feminist Movement. Lexington Books. p. 174. ISBN 0-7391-6481-3. 
  18. ^ "Anthony David – India.Arie's Singer-Songwriter Friend Has His Own Testimony". Vibe (Vibe/Spin Ventures) 14: 100. 2006. 
  19. ^ Lewis, Miles Marshall. "R. Kelly, 'Write Me Back' (RCA)". Spin (New York: Spin Media). Retrieved July 17, 2012. 
  20. ^ a b Green, Tony. "Props: Tony! Toni! Tone!". Vibe: 168. May 2003.
  21. ^ Bordowitz, Hank. "Gil Scott-Heron". American Visions: June 1, 1998.
  22. ^ Columnist. Biography: Brian Jackson. All About Jazz. Retrieved on July 17, 2008.
  23. ^ Mock, Brentin. The Joyful Noise of Janelle Monae. The Atlantic. Retrieved on May 18, 2010.
  24. ^ a b c d Staff (June 26, 2008). Alternatives : The Neo-Soul Family Tree. AllHipHop. Retrieved on March 5, 2011.
  25. ^ Genre: Sophisti-pop. Allmusic. Retrieved on May 9, 2010.
  26. ^ Kot, Greg. Review: Soldier of Love. Chicago Tribune. Retrieved on May 9, 2010.
  27. ^ a b Henderson, Alex (August 1, 2003). British Soul. Allmusic. Retrieved on March 6, 2011.
  28. ^ Werner, Craig Hansen (2006). A Change is Gonna Come: Music, Race & the Soul of America. University of Michigan Press. pp. 327–328. ISBN 0-472-03147-3. 
  29. ^ Cordor, Cyril (2005). Biography: Omar. Allmusic. Retrieved on March 6, 2011.
  30. ^ Valdés, Mimi (September 2003). "The Sound of Music". Vibe: 200–208.
  31. ^ Cinquemani, Sal (July 3, 2001). Me'Shell NdegéOcello: Plantation Lullabies | Music Review. Slant Magazine. Retrieved on March 5, 2011.
  32. ^ Aaron, Peter (October 2010). Goddess of Groove: Meshell Ndegeocello – Roll the Music :: Roll Magazine: Creative Living in the Hudson Valley. Roll Publishing. Retrieved on March 5, 2011.
  33. ^ a b c d Farley, Christopher John (2001). Aaliyah: More Than a Woman. Simon and Schuster. pp. 54–58. ISBN 0-7434-5566-5. 
  34. ^ Jansen, Steve (May 28, 2009). First Lady of Neo-Soul – Page 1. Phoenix New Times. Retrieved on March 6, 2011.
  35. ^ Kinnon, Joy Bennett (July 1997). "Home Brew: Erykah Badu". Ebony: 36–37.
  36. ^ McIver, Joel (2002). Erykah Badu: The First Lady of Neo-Soul. Sanctuary. ISBN 1-86074-385-4. 
  37. ^ a b c d e f g Ryzik, Melena (March 2, 2008). "The Mind of a One-Woman Multitude". The New York Times. The New York Times Company. Retrieved October 27, 2011. 
  38. ^ a b Coker, Cheo Hodari (January 12, 1997). Time to Jam—or Jam? – Los Angeles Times. Los Angeles Times. Retrieved on June 25, 2011.
  39. ^ a b Stanely, Leo (August 1, 2003). House of Music – Tony! Toni! Toné! | AllMusic: Review. Allmusic. Retrieved on June 24, 2011.
  40. ^ a b Venable, Malcolm (October 2002). "Mo' Money, Mo' Problems". Vibe (VIBE/SPIN Ventures) 10 (10): 124–128. Retrieved November 13, 2011. 
  41. ^ Huey, Steve. Maxwell: Biography. Allmusic. Retrieved on March 30, 2009.
  42. ^ Nelson, Trevor. Radio 1 Listeners Top 50 Albums of 1993–2003. TrevorNelson. Retrieved on March 30, 2009.
  43. ^ Harvilla, Rob. Maxwell Returns. So Do the Giant Panties. The Village Voice. Retrieved on March 31, 2009.
  44. ^ Raftery, Brian (November 1, 2001). Biography: Lauryn Hill. Allmusic. Retrieved on March 5, 2011.
  45. ^ a b c d Graham, Renée (November 14, 2003). Boston.com / A&E / Music / Soul searching. The Boston Globe. Retrieved on March 6, 2011.
  46. ^ Promis, Jose F. (August 1, 2003). Love Jones [Original Soundtrack] – Original Soundtrack. Allmusic. Retrieved on March 6, 2011.
  47. ^ a b c Kot, Greg. "A Fresh Collective Soul?". Chicago Tribune: 1. March 19, 2000.
  48. ^ Dombal, Ryan (December 12, 2012). "D'Angelo: Voodoo". Pitchfork Media. Retrieved December 12, 2012. 
  49. ^ Neo-Soul's Familiar Face; With 'Voodoo,' D'Angelo Aims to Reclaim His Place in a Movement He Got Rolling. The Washington Post. Retrieved on March 6, 2011.
  50. ^ Seymour, Craig (February 2002). "The Re-Energizers". Vibe: 68–73.
  51. ^ a b Staff (May 2010). "The 100 Moments That Rocked Our World: 78) Voodoo Scares Off the Neo-Soul Competition". Spin: 98.
  52. ^ a b Dinsmore, Jason (March 20, 2010). "Raheem DeVaughn: R&B Hippy Neo-Soul Rockstar". BE Entertained Magazine. Retrieved October 27, 2011. 
  53. ^ Smith, Jessie Carney (2010). Encyclopedia of African American Popular Culture, Volume 1. ABC-CLIO. p. 1120. ISBN 0-313-35796-X. 
  54. ^ a b Nero, Mark Edward. Neo-Soul: What Is Neo-Soul?. About.com. Retrieved on March 5, 2011.
  55. ^ Mitchell, Gail (July 1, 2006). "The Next Soul Survivors". Billboard: 27–29.
  56. ^ Almeida, Chase (May 10, 2010). "Maxwell Tabs Erykah Badu to Support Select Summer Tour Dates". ConcertTour.org. Retrieved November 2, 2011. 
  57. ^ O'Toole, Kit (April 26, 2011). "Reevaluating Nineties Music: Trivial or Noteworthy?". Seattle Post-Intelligencer. Hearst Communications. Retrieved November 2, 2011. 
  58. ^ "VH1 Soul is More Soulful Than Ever in Its Third Installment of 'SoulStage: Erykah Badu presented by Infiniti' Premiering Tuesday, February 26 at 9PM*". New York: PRNewswire. February 21, 2008. Retrieved September 17, 2012. 
  59. ^ Williams, Brennan (February 17, 2009). "India Arie: Brings International Appeal to VH1's 'Soulstage'". BVNewswire. Retrieved September 17, 2012. 
  60. ^ Rytlewski, Evan (July 24, 2012). "Frank Ocean: Channel Orange". The A.V. Club (Chicago: The Onion). Retrieved July 24, 2012. 

Further reading[edit]

External links[edit]