The Stampede won the Southeast Division of the PDL Southern Conference in their first season, which enabled them to one of four host cities for the 2012 USL-PDL playoffs (round of 16 and round of 8). Their record was 11 Wins, 3 Losses and 2 Ties. The Stampede was defeated by the Austin Aztex 3-2 in the Conference Semifinals. 
Through winning their division, the Stampede qualified for the 2013 US Open Cup. They defeated Red Force FC 4-2 in the first round on May 14th, then lost to Orlando City 2-1 on May 21st. 
They again won the PDL Southeast Division title in 2013 with a 11 Win, 3 Loss record with no Ties. The Stampede lost to the Laredo Heat 2-0 in the Conference Semifinals.