Paide Linnameeskond made its debut in the Meistriliiga in 2009, only avoiding relegation via play-offs against Warrior. A 1-1 draw in the second match was enough after a 1-0 victory in the first match. In 2010, Paide finished 8th in de league, avoiding relegation play-offs only by one point. The 2011 season was much more successful, finishing 6th in the league, their highest position yet.
Reserve team, Paide Linnameeskond II, currently plays in II Liiga, fourth tier of Estonian football league system. Reserve teams in Estonia play in the same league system as the senior team, rather than in a reserve team league. They must play at least one level below their main side.