Pakistan–United States relations

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Pakistan-United States relations
Map indicating locations of Pakistan and United States

Pakistan

United States
Circular diagram showing 96% of U.S. funding to Pakistan in military efforts and 1% in development efforts.

United States–Pakistan relations refers to the international, historical, and cultural bilateral relationship between the Islamic Republic of Pakistan and the United States of America. Roughly two months after independence and Great Britain's departure from the subcontinent, the United States established relations with Pakistan on 20 October 1947.

The United States was amongst the first nations along with Iran and few others, to establish relations with Pakistan in the late 1940s. Since then, relations have been centered on the United States' extensive economic, scientific, and military assistance to Pakistan.[1] Allying with the U.S. during the Cold war against the USSR, Pakistan was an integral in CENTO and SEATO— both alliances opposed the Soviet Union and Communism. Relations were soured in the 1970s with the left-oriented PPP led government which came in power in 1971. However, the closely coordinated military cooperation deepened in the 1980s against Soviet expansion in Central Asia. After the disintegration of USSR, and Pakistan's subsequent return to democracy, the relations once again became cold with the U.S. imposing an economic embargo against Pakistan during most of the 1990s. The alliance between Pakistan and the United States mostly normalized in the 2000s, and became very cordial and friendly, especially under the governments of Shaukat Aziz, who served as Prime minister of Pakistan from 2004 to 2007 and under the governments of Pervez Musharraf who was President of Pakistan from 2001 to 2008 and Asif Ali Zardari who served as President of Pakistan from 2008 to 2013.

Since 2011, mutual and intensive criticisms and allegations based on their strategies in the War on Terror have hindered relations. Furthermore, as a result of the Lahore incident and the black operation in the country which killed the al-Qaeda leader Osama bin Laden, followed by the Salala incident, relations between the two countries have become increasingly strained in recent years. Currently, Pakistan is designated as a Major non-NATO ally of the United States, which is the second-largest supplier of military equipment to Pakistan after China, and largest economic aid contributor as well.[2][3][4] A 2014 Politico article named Pakistan as America's most "awkward" ally.[5] The rise of Anti-Americanism in Pakistan and Anti-Pakistan sentiment in the United States has also marred relations. According to a 2014 BBC World Service Poll, 16% of Pakistanis view U.S. influence positively, with 61% expressing a negative view, while 5% of Americans view Pakistan's influence positively, with 85% expressing a negative view, the most negative perception of Pakistan in the world. [6]

Relations with Superpower during Cold war[edit]

Main article: Cold war

Democratic governments (1947-1958)[edit]

Prime minister Liaquat Ali Khan meeting President Truman (during the 1950s when Pakistani Prime minister made a good will tour in the U.S.).[7]

After Pakistan's independence by the partitioning of the British Indian Empire, Pakistan was founded while struggling with problems involving the national economy, national security, and Soviet influence on Afghanistan and Iran, forced Pakistan's first prime minister Liaquat Ali Khan to cement a pro-Western and pro-American policy.[8] In 1949, the Soviet Union directed a farewell message to Prime minister Ali Khan, followed by the U.S. invitation in 1950. The proposal was under consideration when Pakistan's geostrategists, military policy makers, logisiticians and foreign service officers raised great questions whether or not the Soviet Union could provide the military, technical, and economic aid that the country needed so urgently.[9] One key common denominator was at the home front, when the Communist party had gained the considerable support in East Pakistan and the Socialist party in West Pakistan, in which the Muslim League had failed to take active measures against socialists in the West and communists in the East.[8] Prime Minister Ali Khan made a tireless effort to establish relations with the Soviet Union, repeatedly asking Joseph Stalin for military aid, but all attempts were rebuffed by the Soviets.[9] According to the PIIA, the religious background of Pakistan and the atheist background of the Soviet Union had created a major divergence after Pakistan noted subservience which was forced upon the allies of the Soviet Union.[8]

After a long debate, Prime Minister Ali Khan decided to pay his first visit to the United States, while holding the Soviet invitation which was met with great hostility from the Soviet Union, and the harsh criticism by Pakistani socialists and communists of Ali Khan and his government. The President of the United States Harry Truman and the U.S. itself were well aware of strategic importance of Pakistan, but did not have any concrete plans[dubious ].[10] The U.S. continued its civilian aid to the country through the United States Ambassador to Pakistan, Paul Allin. It was not until 1950 when the military aid was begun with new ambassador Avra M. Warren taking office.[10]

U.S Vice President Alben W. Barkley explains the 1948 version of the Vice President's seal to Prime Minister Ali Khan of Pakistan and his wife

In 1950-53, Pakistan's state delegation paid visit to the U.S., initially seeking military aid rather than civilian.[10] Prime Minister Liaqat Ali Khan, Huseyn Suhravardie, Army commander Ayub Khan, Foreign Minister Sir Zafrullah Khan, Foreign Secretary Ikram-ullah Khan, Finance Minister Ghulam Muhammad, Defense Secretary Sikander Mirza, and special envoy Mir Laiq Ali made U.S visits with the main intention of getting military aid. Controversially, there was neither an organized, coordinated, nor institutional effort nor any attempt made to study the U.S. decision-making process to achieve the goal.[10]

The U.S. government officials were smart enough to understand and to very quickly grasp the mediocre leadership of Pakistan.[10] The U.S. government would use the country to achieve regional and strategic goals and interests. When the true nature of U.S. ambition exposed to Prime minister Ali Khan, the prime minister deliberately attempted to warm relations with the Soviet Union and the Soviet bloc, while warning the U.S. that "[Pakistan] has annexed half of Kashmir without [A]merican support.... And would be able to take the other half too".[11] Ali Khan's sudden shift and aggressive mood was a "bombshell" for President Truman's presidency and for U.S. foreign policy.[11] In 1950, President Truman requested Prime minister Ali Khan to provide a military base to the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) to keep an eye on Soviet Union, which Ali Khan hesitated and later refused, prompting the U.S. to began planning the assassination of Ali Khan to remove him from the country's politics once and for all.[11] However, there are no official evidence[citation needed] to support, marking the big question on Ali Khan's assassination.[11] The Indian government followed a different, non-aligned policy stance, which leaned closer towards the Soviet Union than towards the United States of America. Pakistan was seeking strong alliances to counter its neighbor, India. At this time, India was neutral and went on to be a part of Non Aligned Movement.

In 1972, Zulfi Bhutto gifted a carved ivory set of chess to the United States President Gerald Ford.

In 1953, the United States assessed Pakistan as "a volunteer army of 3,000,000... It is not neutral but an anti-communist... As a possible ally for US, Pakistan displays a tempting picture of power — potential and actual." The Pakistan Armed Forces were extremely well-disciplined, professional, well trained armed forces whose morale and bravery are unquestionable.[10] According to Hamid Hussain, Pakistan has became comical in 1955-56[clarification needed], and the Secretary of State John Foster Dulles while arguing for wheat aid to Pakistan in 1953, told the sub-committee on Agriculture and Forestry during hearings that, "the [p]eople of Pakistan had a splendid military tradition and that in Karachi he had been met by a guard of honour which was the "finest" he had ever seen".[10] Apparently, Dulles did not tell the agriculture department what on earth the wheat aid has to do with the military. After the signing of first mutual defence treaty in May 1954, large-scale interaction between U.S. and Pakistani military started, with hundreds of officers began to sent to U.S. on routine and regular basis, getting trained shoulder-to-shoulders with U.S. military.[10] A U.S. Military Assistance Advisory Group (MAAG) was established in Army Headquarters in Rawalpindi, although the MAAG was divided into groups depending on their role.[10] According to Colonel Jordan of CIA, the officers of Pakistan Armed Forces were not only trained in military ethics but also to groom them for non-military activities such as leadership, management, economics.[10] The U.S. had no interests to enhance relations with the political leadership, but was rather hostile towards the civilians.[10] In 1956, President Dwight Eisenhower kindly requested Prime minister Suhravardie to lease a military base, Peshawar Air Station (PAS), to make preparations for spy operations and to coordinate secret signal intelligence flights to gain intelligence on Soviet Union's intercontinental ballistic missiles.[10] The request was granted and the U.S. opened the station with building an airstrip, command and control station and air force base near by.[10] This base was kept in secret, the highest Pakistani government officials, including the military personnel, could not enter, and in 1959, U.S. denied the request of Zulfikar Ali Bhutto when he tried to visit the facility.[10]

The U.S. interest in Pakistan grew after realizing the importance of Pakistan Armed Forces, which was seen as potential partners against communism, not the political leadership. That is why, when Prime minister Huseyn Suhravardie made frequent trips to U.S., the importance was not given to him but his Army commander Ayub Khan.[10] Furthermore, relations gradually went down with people-elected president Iskander Mirza, leading to the military coup against him in 1958. After successfully leading the military coup d'état in 1958, Ayub Khan quickly visited the U.S., stressing that armed forces are the strongest element.[10]

Ayub Khan and U.S. were convinced that the left wing intellectuals would come to power which would not only destabilize Pakistan[how?] but would affect U.S. strategic interest.[10] To United States, the military alliance with Ayub Khan was to ensure a provide safeguard to U.S. interests in Southwest Asia and Middle East and not against India. The secret Establishment too saw the relationship as a short cut to modernization of its armed forces but failed to comprehend long-term strategic interest of Pakistan.[10]

Military dictatorship (1960–1969)[edit]

Motorcade in Arrival Ceremonies for Ayub Khan
President Lyndon B. Johnson meets with President Ayub Khan in Karachi, Pakistan

Pakistan joined the US-led military alliances SEATO and CENTO. In 1954 the United States signed a Mutual Defense Assistance Agreement with Pakistan. Under Ayub Khan, Pakistan enjoyed a strong and close relationship with the United States. Pakistan had aligned itself with the United States during the Cold War, as opposed to the Soviet Union. Khan's government also provided a secret military base to United States. The 1960s era was perhaps most enjoyable and fond relationships enjoyed both by the United States and Pakistan. This 1960s era, Pakistan and her people were the most pro-American nation where the U.S. image was more positive than any other nation at that time. In 1961, Khan paid a state visit to the United States, accompanied by his daughter Begum Nasir Akhtar Aurangzeb. Highlights of the trip included a state dinner at Mount Vernon, a visit to the Islamic Center of Washington, and a ticker tape parade in New York City.[12]

In 1954, Ayub Khan famously told Brigadier-General Henry A. Byroade and the United States that "I didn’t come here to look at barracks. Our army can be your army if you want us. But let’s make a decision".[10] In 1960, Ayub Khan gave approval to U.S. to fly a spy mission to Soviet Union, knowing the aftermath of the mission, Ayub Khan was fully aware of the operation.[10] On May 1960, the U-2 incident took place, its pilot Gary Powers was captured.[10] The CIA notified Ayub Khan of the incident when he was in London for a state visit, he shrugged his shoulders and said that he had expected this would happen at some point.[10] According the General Khalid Mahmud Arif, this incident "severely compromised Pakistan security" and brought the Soviet ire on Pakistan.[10] "Pakistan felt deceived because the US had kept her in the dark about such clandestine spy operations launched from Pakistan’s territory", quoted by General Arif.[10]

The United States military aide was only concentrated in West-Pakistan, and the economical benefits enjoyed by West Pakistan, not the East.[10] The Anti-Americanism and democracy tendency was great and was stronger in East-Pakistan, the East-Pakistan parliament signed a statement, denouncing the military pact and aide with United States.[10] The United States refrained to provide the military training of the East Pakistan Army and the East Pakistan Rifles, troops stationed at Kashmir province did not receive any training but was managed by Pakistan itself.[10]

President Ayub Khan and Jaqueline Kennedy with Sardar, a Seal brown horse gifted by Khan to Jackie Kennedy, 1962.

The economical aide to Pakistan was increased by the United States through the consortium companies.[13] Booming economy had brought Pakistan a prestige and the success of capitalism system in an underdeveloped country was widely appreciated.[13] But this was short lived, when Ayub Khan launched the Operation Gibraltar against India, leading India to declare full-scale war with West-Pakistan.[13]

Many civil bureaucrats, notably Sartaj Aziz noted that the war with India was an ill-considered decision and its aftermath that was uncontrollable by Ayub Khan.[13] The economy and foreign policy requirements are not fully consistent, in fact they were rapidly falling out of line after the operations were launched.[13] The United States placed embargo on Pakistan, both military and economical, that led the collapse of Pakistan's economy.[13]

The war with India came with an economic cost for Pakistan, which lost the half a billion dollars it had coming from the Consortium for Pakistan through the United States.[13] Ayub Khan could not suffer the aftermath and fall from the presidency after surrendering the presidential power of Army Commander General Yahya Khan in 1969.[13] Escalating the further crises, the country was floundered, losing East-Pakistan after India was again attacked by Pakistan six years later, with the economy in great jeopardy without United States' assistance.[13]

Military dictatorship (1969–1971)[edit]

Pakistan was perceived in the United States as an integral bulwark against Communism in the Cold War. The United States cautiously supported Pakistan during the 1971 war although congress kept an arms embargo in place.[14]

Pakistan's role in U.S.-China relations[edit]

In 1971, Pakistan helped the United States to make preparations for the President Richard Nixon for his historical visit to the Peoples' Republic of China (PRC). President Nixon and Henry Kissinger used Pakistan's relationship with China to start secret contacts with China, which resulted in Henry Kissinger’s secret visit to China in July 1971 while visiting Pakistan.

Role in Indo-Pakistani war of 1971[edit]

President of Pakistan Yahya Khan with United States President Richard Nixon, 1970.

Nixon relayed messages to Yahya, urging him to restrain Pakistani forces.[15] His objective was to prevent a war and safeguard Pakistan's interests, though he feared an Indian invasion of West Pakistan that would lead to Indian domination of the sub-continent and strengthen the position of the Soviet Union.[16] Similarly, Yahya Khan feared that an independent Bangladesh could lead to the disintegration of Pakistan. Indian military support for Bengali guerillas led to war between India and Pakistan.[17]

The United States was secretly encouraging the shipment of military equipment from Iran, Turkey, and Jordan to Pakistan, reimbursing those countries[18] despite Congressional objections.[19] The U.S. used the threat of an aid cut-off to force Pakistan to back down, while its continued military aid to Islamabad prevented India from launching incursions deeper into the country. Near the end of the war and fearing Pakistan's defeat by the joint forces of Mukti Bahini and Indian forces, Nixon ordered the USS Enterprise into the Indian Ocean, although it was never used for actual combat fearing Russian response.[20] Pakistan also felt the US arms embargo affected Pakistan more than it affected India.[21]

The United States deployed the Task Force-74 of the United States Seventh Fleet, when it became apparent that Pakistan was losing the war. At the height of Vietnam war, the Enterprise led the Task Force-74 and was seen as a Show of force by the United States in support of the beleaguered West Pakistan Armed Forces.[21] The Task Force-74 was forced to withdraw when the Soviet Union dispatched a large fleet to support India, as well as nuclear submarines armed with nuclear missiles.[20]

Declassified CIA intelligence documents stated that "India intended to dismember Pakistan and destroy its armed forces, a possible loss of U.S. ally in the Cold war that United States cannot afford to lose. Nixon termed India as "Soviet stooge" before ordering the Enterprise to lead the Task Force-74.[22] In an assessment completed by U.S., India, with full-backing of Soviet Union, can tackle [Pakistan] without anybody doing anything.[22] Nixon sent a strong message to Soviet Union urging Russians to stop India from dismembering and disintegrating the State of Pakistan from existence, in Nixons' words: "In the strongest possible...(...)... terms to restrain India with which … (Soviets) have great influence and for whose actions you must share responsibility... (...)...".[22]

Democratic government (1971-1977)[edit]

Zulfikar Ali Bhutto raising a toast at a state dinner during his 1975 trip to the US.

As a result of the 1970s election, Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, a charismatic democratic socialist, became President (1971-1974) and later Prime minister in 1974. This period is seen as a "quiet cold war" with the Pakistan who was administer under democratic socialists led by Zulfikar Ali Bhutto. His socialist ideas favored the communist ideas but never actually allied with communism. Under Bhutto, Pakistan would focused on Movement of Non-Aligned Countries, building closer ties with Soviet bloc and the Soviet Union. Meanwhile, Bhutto tried to maintain a balance with the United States, but such attempts were rebuffed by United States. Bhutto opposed the ultra-leftism concepts but was a strong proponent of left-wing politics, which the U.S. had opposed in Pakistan from the very start.[23]

Although, Richard Nixon enjoyed firmly strong relations with Bhutto and was a close friend of Bhutto, the graph of relation significantly went down under the Presidency of Jimmy Carter.[24] Carter, an anti-socialist, tightened the embargo placed on Pakistan and placed a pressure through the United States Ambassador to Pakistan, Brigadier-General Henry Byroade.[24] The socialist orientation, and Bhutto's proposed left-wing theories, had badly upset the United States, further clinging the bell tolls in the United States as fearing Pakistan's loss as an ally in the Cold war.[24] The leftists and Bhutto's policy towards Soviet Union was seen sympathetic and had built a bridge for Soviet Union to have gain access in Pakistan's warm water ports, that something both United States and Soviet Union had lacked.[24]

During the course of 1976 presidential election, Carter was elected as U.S. President, and his very inaugural speech Carter announced the determination to seek the ban of nuclear weapons.[24] With Carter's election, Bhutto lost all links to United States administration he had through President Nixon.[24] Bhutto had to faced the embargo and pressure from the American President who was totally against the political objectives which Bhutto had set forth for his upcoming future plans. Carter indirectly announced his opposition to Bhutto, his ambition and the elections.[24] Responding to President Carter, Bhutto launched a more actively aggressive and serious diplomatic offensive on the United States and the Western world over the nuclear issues.[25] Bhutto's demagogic act on nuclear issues put the United States, particularly Carter who found it extremely difficult to counter Bhutto, on Defensive position at the United Nations.[25] While India and Soviet Union were pushed aside when Bhutto attacked Indian nuclear programme as labeling latter's program based on the nuclear proliferation.[25] Writing to the world and Western leaders, Bhutto made it clear and maintained to the United States:

Pakistan was exposed to a kind of "nuclear threat and blackmail" unparalleled elsewhere..... (...)... If the world's community failed to provide political insurance to Pakistan and other countries against the nuclear blackmail, these countries would be constraint to launch atomic bomb programs of their own!... [A]ssurances provided by the United Nations were not "Enough!"...

—Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, statement written in "Eating Grass"source[25]

Although, Carter placed an embargo on Pakistan, Bhutto under the technical guidance and diplomatic though Foreign minister Aziz Ahmed, succeeded to bought sensitive equipments, common metal materials, and electronic components, marked as "common items", hide the true nature of the intentions, greatly enhance the atomic bomb project, though a complete failure for Carter's embargo.[24] Bhutto tried to resolve the issue, but Carter intentionally sabotage the talks. In a thesis written by historian Abdul Ghafoor Buhgari, Carter keenly sabotaged Bhutto credibility, but did not wanted favored his execution as Carter made a call to General Zia-ul-Haq to stop the act.[24] Therefore senior leadership of Pakistan Peoples Party reached out to different country's ambassadors and high commissioners but did not meet with the U.S. ambassador, as the leadership knew the "noble" part played by Carter and his administration.[24] When Carter administration discovered Bhutto's act, the programme was reached to a well advanced level, and furthermore, had disastrous effect on SALT I Treaty which was soon collapse, a failure of President Carter to stop the atomic proliferation and arm race between Soviet Union and United States heightened.[24]

Bhutto meeting with Nixon in 1972.

In 1974, with India carried out the test of nuclear weapons near the Pakistan's eastern border, codename Smiling Buddha, Bhutto sought United States to impose economic sanctions in India.[23] Though it was unsuccessful approach, in a meeting of Pakistan's Ambassador to United States with Secretary of State Henry Kissinger, Kissingers told Pakistan’s ambassador to Washington that the test is “a fait accompli and that Pakistan would have to learn to live with it,” although he was aware this is a “little rough” on the Pakistanis.[23] In the 1970s, the ties were further severed with Bhutto as Bhutto had continued to administer the research on weapons, and in 1976, in a meeting with Bhutto and Kissinger, Kissinger had told Bhutto, "that if you [Bhutto] do not cancel, modify or postpone the Reprocessing Plant Agreement, we will make a horrible example from you".[26] The meeting was ended by Bhutto as he had replied: "For my country’s sake, for the sake of people of Pakistan, I did not succumb to that black-mailing and threats". After the meeting, Bhutto intensified his nationalization and industrialization policies, as well as aggressively taking steps to spur scientific research on atomic weapons and the atomic bomb project. Bhutto authorized the construction of Chagai weapon-testing laboratories, whilst United States opposed the action and predicted that it will lead to a massive and destructive war between India and Pakistan in the future. The atomic bomb project became fully mature in 1978; and a first cold test was conducted in 1983 (see Kirana-I).

Bhutto called upon Organization of Islamic Conference in order to bring Muslim world together but after months, the pro-United States Muslim nations and United States itself took the promised step and Bhutto was declared as the corrupted one, and, as a result, Bhutto was hanged in 1979.[26]

Military dictatorship (1977–1988)[edit]

In 1979, a group of Pakistani students burned the American embassy in Islamabad to the ground killing two Americans as a reaction to Grand Mosque Seizure, citing the U.S. involvement. The claim was a lie started by Iran.

Crile and Charlie Wilson meeting with ISI officers, c. 1980s.

After the removal and death of Bhutto, the Pakistan's ties with United States were better and improved. Nn December 24, 1979, the Soviet 40th Army crossed borders, rolling into Afghanistan, President Carter issued his doctrine (see Carter Doctrine). The silent features offers the creation of the Rapid Deployment Force (RDF), increasing the deployment of United States Naval Forces Central Command (NAVCENT), a collective security framework in the region and a commitment to the defence of Pakistan by transfer of significant amount of weapons and Monetarism.

Following the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan, ISI and CIA ran multi-billion dollar worth Operation Cyclone to thwart the communist regime as well as defeating Soviets in Afghanistan. Throughout the military regime of General Zia-ul-Haq, the ties and relations were promoted at its maximum point, and United States had given billion dollars of economical and military aid to Pakistan. The Soviet invasion of Afghanistan in December 1979 highlighted the common interest of Pakistan and the United States in opposing the Soviet Union. In 1981, Pakistan and the United States agreed on a $3.2 billion military and economic assistance program aimed at helping Pakistan deal with the heightened threat to security in the region and its economic development needs. With US assistance, in the largest covert operation in history, Pakistan armed and supplied anti-Soviet fighters in Afghanistan.

In the 1980s, Pakistan agreed to pay $658 million for 28 F-16 fighter jets from the United States; however the US congress froze the deal, citing objections to Pakistan's nuclear ambitions. Under the terms of the American cancellation, the US kept both the money and the planes, leading to angry claims of theft by Pakistanis.[27]

Initially, Carter offered Pakistan $325 million in aid over three years; Zia rejected this as "peanuts."[28] Carter also signed the finding in 1980 that allowed less than $50 million a year to go to the Mujahideen. All attempts were rebuffed, Zia shrewdly played his cards knowing that Carter was on his way out and he may get a better deal from the incoming Reagan. After Ronald Reagan came to office, defeating Carter for the US Presidency in 1980, all this changed, due to President Reagan's new priorities and the unlikely and remarkably effective effort by Congressman Charles Wilson (D-TX), aided by Joanne Herring, and CIA Afghan Desk Chief Gust Avrakotos to increase the funding for Operation Cyclone. Aid to the Afghan resistance, and to Pakistan, increased substantially, finally reaching $1 billion. The United States, faced with a rival superpower looking as if it were to create another Communist bloc, now engaged Zia to fight a US-aided war by proxy in Afghanistan against the Soviets.

The Reagan administration and Reagan himself supported Pakistan's military regime, American officials visited the country on a routine basis.[10] The U.S. political influence in Pakistan effectively curbed down the liberals, socialists, communists, and democracy-advocates in the country in 1983, instead advising Zia to hold the non-partisans elections in 1985.[10] General Akhtar Abdur Rahman of ISI and William Casey of CIA worked together in harmony, and in an atmosphere of mutual trust. The ISI officer Mohammad Yusuf stated "“It was a great blow to the Jehad when Casey died", calling Casey "shaheed", a former CIA director is actually a martyr of Islam[clarification needed].[10] The U.S. intelligence community also helped Zia to expand the idea of Establishment, in the national politics of Pakistan, approving the sell of F-16 Fighting Falcon, nuclear technology, naval warships, intelligence training and efforts.[10]

Relations after the Cold war: 1988-1999[edit]

Democratic governments (1988–1998)[edit]

After the restoration of democracy after the disastrous and mysterious death of Zia and U.S. Ambassador in an aviation crash, relations deteriorated quickly with upcoming prime ministers Benazir Bhutto and Nawaz Sharif. The United States took tough stand on Pakistan's nuclear development, passing the Pressler amendment, while significantly improving the relations with India. Both Benazir and Nawaz Sharif also asked the United States to take steps to stop the Indian nuclear programme, feeling that United States was not doing enough to address what Pakistan saw as an existential threat. Pakistan found itself in a state of extremely high insecurity as tensions mounted with India and Afghanistan’s infighting continued. Pakistan’s alliance with the U.S. was strained due to factors such as its support for the Taliban and public distancing of the Pakistani government from the U.S.

Rift in relations[edit]

In 1992 US Ambassador Nicholas Platt advised Pakistan's leaders that if Pakistan continued to support terrorists in India or Indian-administered territory, "the Secretary of State may find himself required by law to place Pakistan on the state sponsors of terrorism list."[29] When the US decided to respond to the 1998 United States embassy bombings in Africa by firing missiles at an al-Qaeda camp in Taliban-controlled Afghanistan, five Pakistani ISI agents present at the camp were killed.[29]

Economic embargo[edit]

Benazir Bhutto paying state visit to the U.S., 1989.

In 1989, Benazir Bhutto made a quick visit in the U.S. asking U.S. to stop financing the Afghan mujahideen to President George H. W. Bush, which she marked "America's Frankenstein".[30] This was followed by Nawaz Sharif who visited the U.S. in 1990, but U.S. gave cold shoulder to Pakistan, asking Pakistan to stop developing the nuclear deterrence. In 1990, Prime minister Nawaz Sharif travels to U.S. to solve the nuclear crises after the U.S. had tightened its economic embargo on Pakistan, prompting Sharif and then-Treasure Minister Sartaj Aziz to held talks on Washington.[31] It was widely reported in Pakistan that the U.S. Assistant Secretary of State Teresita Schaffer had told the Foreign Minister Shahabzada Yaqub Khan to halt the uranium enrichment programme.[31] In December 1990, France's Commissariat à l'énergie atomique agreed to provide a commercial 900MW power plant, but plans did not materialize as France wanted Pakistan to provide entire financial funds for the plant. Furthermore, the U.S. Ambassador Robert Oakley further influenced on the project, showing growing concerns of the U.S. on the agreement.[31] While talking to U.S. media, Nawaz Sharif declared that: "Pakistan possessed no [atomic] bomb... Pakistan would be happy to sign the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty (NPT) but it must be provided "first" to India to do the same".[31] After the France's project cancel, Nawaz Sharif successfully held talks with the China to build the largest commercial nuclear plant, CHASNUPP-I in Chasma city in Pakistan.[31]

In 1995, Prime minister Benazir Bhutto made final visit to U.S. urging President Bill Clinton to amend the Pressler Amendment and emphasized United States to launch a campaign against the extremism, with Pakistan allying with the United States.[32] Prime minister Benazir Bhutto was succeeded to pass the Brown Amendment, but the embargo on arms remain active. At the United States trip, Prime minister Benazir Bhutto faced a heated criticism and opposition on nuclear weapons program, Benazir Bhutto responded fiercely and sharply criticized U.S.'s nonproliferation policy and demanded that the United States honour its contractual obligation.[32] Although Benazir was able to convince U.S. business community to invest in Pakistan, but was unable to revert the economic embargo which kept investment away from the country.[32]

Nawaz Sharif meeting with William Cohen, Secretary of State, 1998.

In 1998, Prime minister Nawaz Sharif ordered to conduct first nuclear tests after Benazir Bhutto called for the tests (see Chagai-I and Chagai-II), in response to Indian nuclear tests (see Pokhran-II). Nawaz Sharif's ordering the nuclear tests was met with great hostility and ire in the United States after President Clinton placing the economic embargo on Pakistan. The relations were also refrained and strained after Nawaz Sharif became involved with Kargil war with India, while India's relations with Israel and U.S greatly enhanced. Soon after the tests, Benazir Bhutto publicly announced her believe that her father was "sent to the gallows at the instance of the superpower for pursuing the nuclear capability,[33] though she did not disclose the name of the power.[34] In 1999, Benazir leaked the information that Nawaz Sharif would be deposed that there is (nothing) that Americans[35] want to support Nawaz Sharif or the democracy in Pakistan.[35] After the military coup was commenced against Nawaz Sharif, the President Clinton criticized the coup demanding the restoration of democracy but did not favor the mass demonstration against the military regime as the coup, at that time, was popular. In conclusion, both Nawaz Sharif and Benazir Bhutto refused to make compromises with respect to the country's nuclear deterrence, instead building infrastructure despite U.S. objections.[33]

Cold war legacies and trade sanctions[edit]

CENTO and SEATO[edit]

Pakistan was a leading member of the Central Treaty Organization (CENTO) and the Southeast Asia Treaty Organization (SEATO) from its adoption in 1954-55 and allied itself with the United States during the most of the Cold war. In 1971-72, Pakistan ended its alliance with the United States after the East-Pakistan war in which East Pakistan successfully seceded with the aid of India. The promise of economic aid from the United States was instrumental in creating these agreements. At the time the pact was adopted, Pakistan's relationship with the United States was the friendliest in Asia.[citation needed]

During the Indo-Pakistani War of 1965, the United States refused to provide any military support to as against its pledged. This generated a widespread anti-American feelings and emotions in Pakistan that the United States was no longer a reliable ally. According to C. Christine Fair, the U.S. cut off arms supplies because Pakistan "started the war with India by using regular military personnel disguised as mujahideen." According to Fair, in 1971 "the Pakistanis were angry at the U.S. again, for not bailing them out from another war they started against India."[29]

Trade embargo[edit]

In April 1979, the United States suspended most economic assistance to Pakistan over concerns about Pakistan's atomic bomb project under the Foreign Assistance Act.[36]

Military science programmes[edit]

Pakistan and atomic weapons[edit]

In 1955, after Prime minister Huseyn Suhrawardy established nuclear power to ease of the electricity crises, with U.S. offering grant of US$350,000 to acquire a commercial nuclear power plant.[37] Following this year, the PAEC signed an agreement with counterpart United States Atomic Energy Commission where the research on nuclear power and training was started initially by the United States. During the 1960s, the U.S. opens doors to Pakistan's scientists and engineers to conduct research on leading institutions of the U.S., notably ANL, ORNL, and LLNL. In 1965, Abdus Salam went to U.S. succeeding the U.S. government to establish a national institute of nuclear research (see PINSTECH and a research reactor Parr-I).[37] The Pinstech was designed by leading American architect Edward Durrell Stone whereby American nuclear engineer Peter Karter designed the reactor, with the reactor supplied by the American Machine and Foundry as its contractors.[37] Later in years, U.S. helped Pakistan to negotiate to acquire first commercial nuclear power plant, Kanupp-I, from GE Canada in 1965.[37] All this nuclear infrastructure was established by the U.S. during the successive years of the 1960s, as part of the Congressional Atoms for Peace programme.[37]

The leadership of both nations meeting in a high-level state dinner in Islamabad, 2006.

This was changed after Zulfikar Ali Bhutto and democratic socialists under him decided to build nuclear weapons for the sake of their national security and survival.[37] In 1974, U.S. imposed embargo and restriction on Pakistan to limit its nuclear weapons programme.[37] In the 1980s, the American concerns of Pakistan’s role in nuclear proliferation eventually turned out to be true after the exposure of nuclear programs of Iran, North Korea, Saudi Arabia and Libya.[37] Although the atomic program was effectively peaceful and devoted for economical usage, the nuclear policy change in the 1970s and till the present, with Pakistan maintaining its program as part of the strategic deterrence.[37]

In the 1980s, the plan to recognise national security concerns and accepting Pakistan' assurances that it did not intend to construct a nuclear weapon, Congress waived restrictions (Symington Amendment) on military assistance to Pakistan. In October 1980, a high level delegation and CMLA General Zia-ul-Haq travels to U.S., first meeting with former president Richard Nixon.[38] Although, the meeting was to discuss the Soviet integration of Afghanistan, Nixon made it clear he is in favor of Pakistan gaining nuclear weapons capability, while correcting that he is not in a race for the presidential elections.[38] The following year, Agha Shahi made it clear to Alexander Haig that Pakistan "won't make a compromise" on its nuclear weapons program, but assured the U.S. that the country had adopted the policy of deliberate ambiguity, refraining itself to conduct nuclear tests to avoid or create divergence in the relations.[38]

In March 1986, the two countries agreed on a second multi-year (FY 1988–93) $4-billion economic development and security assistance program. On October 1, 1990, however, the United States suspended all military assistance and new economic aid to Pakistan under the Pressler Amendment, which required that the President certify annually that Pakistan "does not possess a nuclear explosive device."

India's decision to conduct nuclear tests in May 1998 and Pakistan's response set back US relations in the region, which had seen renewed US interest during the second Clinton Administration. A presidential visit scheduled for the first quarter of 1998 was postponed and, under the Glenn Amendment, sanctions restricted the provision of credits, military sales, economic assistance, and loans to the government.

Nonproliferation and security[edit]

Since 1998, the governments of both countries have started an intensive dialogues on nuclear nonproliferation and security issues. First meeting took place in 1998 between Foreign Secretary Shamshad Ahmad and Deputy Secretary of State Strobe Talbott to discuss the issues focusing on CTBT signature and ratification, FMCT negotiations, export controls, and a nuclear restraint regime.[39] The October 1999 overthrow of the democratically elected Sharif government triggered an additional layer of sanctions under Section 508 of the Foreign Appropriations Act which include restrictions on foreign military financing and economic assistance. US Government assistance to Pakistan was limited mainly to refugee and counter-narcotics assistance.".[40] At the height of the nuclear proliferation case in 2004, President George Bush delivering a policy statement at the National Defense University, President Bush proposed to reform the IAEA to combat the nuclear proliferation and quoted: "No state, under investigation for proliferation violations, should be allowed to serve on the IAEA Board of Governors—or on the new special committee. And any state currently on the Board that comes under investigation should be suspended from the Board."[41]

The Bush's proposal was seen as targeted against Pakistan, which is an influential member of IAEA since the 1960s and serves on the Board of Governors; it did not receive attention from other world governments. In 2009, Pakistan has repeatedly blocked the Conference on Disarmament (CD) from implementing its agreed program of work, despite severe pressure from the major nuclear powers to end its defiance of 64 other countries in blocking international ban on the production of new nuclear bomb-making material, as well as discussions on full nuclear disarmament, the arms race in outer space, and security assurances for non-nuclear states.[42] The Chairman Joint Chiefs General Tariq Majid justified Pakistan's action and outline the fact that atomic deterrence against a possible aggression was a compulsion, and not a choice for Pakistan.[43] He further justified that "a proposed fissile material cutoff treaty would target Pakistan specifically.[44]

On December 10, 2012, the Assistant Secretary for Arms Control, Verification, and Compliance Rose Gottemoeller and Additional Secretary for United Nations and Economic Coordination Aizaz Ahmad Chaudhry co-chaired the Pakistan-U.S. Security, Strategic Stability, and Nonproliferation (SSS&NP) Working Group in Islamabad.[45] Gottemoeller traveled to Pakistan after former Indian Foreign Secretary Shyam Saran wrote in an article that, "Pakistan had moved its nuclear doctrine from minimum deterrence to second strike capability and expanded its arsenal to include tactical weapons that can be delivered by short-range missiles like the Hatf-IX.[45] The meeting ended with an agreement on continuing dialogue on a range of issues related to the bilateral relationship, including international efforts to enhance nuclear security and peaceful applications of nuclear energy.[46]

Space programme[edit]

In the 1990s, U.S. and the Missile Technology Control Regime put restrictions on Pakistan's space programme in amid fear that the country's alleged covert development of missile programmes. The U.S. began cooperation with Pakistan in peaceful space technology in the 1960s after establishing the Sonmiani Terminal in 1961, constructing an airfield and launch pad. In 1962, the Space Research Commission launched the first solid-fuel rocket, Rehbar-I, built with close interaction with the U.S. NASA. Launching of the rocket made Pakistan the first South Asian country and tenth country in the world to carrying out the launch of the rocket. During the 1962 and 1972, approximately 200 rockets were fired from the Sonmiani, but this cooperation waned after 1972.

During the 1990s and early 2000s, U.S. tightened its embargo and constriction on Pakistan's space development, and in 1998, putting restrictions and sanctions on premier astronautics research department, DESTO, although the sanctions were uplifted in 2001 by the Bush Administration.

Relations since 2001[edit]

Pervez Musharraf with President Bush.

After the September 11 attacks in 2001 in the United States, Pakistan became a key ally in the war on terror with the United States. In 2001, US President George W. Bush pressured the government into joining the US war on terror. Pervez Musharraf acknowledges the payments received for captured terrorists in his book:

We've captured 689 and handed over 369 to the United States. We've earned bounties totaling millions of dollars

—Former President of Pakistan Pervez Musharraf

In 2003, the US officially forgave US$1 billion in Pakistani debt in a ceremony in Pakistan in turn for Pakistan joining the US 'war on terror'. "Today's signing represents a promise kept and another milestone in our expanding partnership," US Ambassador Nancy Powell said in a statement, "The forgiveness of $1 billion in bilateral debt is just one piece of a multifaceted, multibillion dollar assistance package." The new relationship between the United States and Pakistan is not just about September 11,' Powell said. "It is about the rebirth of a long-term partnership between our two countries." However Pakistan support of the U.S. and its war has angered many Pakistanis that do not support it.

In October 2005, Condoleezza Rice made a statement where she promised that the United States will support the country's earthquake relief efforts and help it rebuild" after the Kashmir Earthquake.[47]

Alliance with United States[edit]

Prior to the September 11 attacks in 2001, Pakistan and Saudi Arabia were key supporters of the Taliban in Afghanistan, as part of their "strategic depth" objective vis-a-vis India, Iran, and Russia.[citation needed]

After 9/11, Pakistan, led by General Pervez Musharraf, reversed course as they were under pressure from the United States and joined the "War on Terror" as a U.S. ally. Having failed to convince the Taliban to hand over bin Laden and other members of Al Qaeda, Pakistan provided the U.S. a number of military airports and bases for its attack on Afghanistan, along with other logistical support.[citation needed] Since 2001, Pakistan has arrested over five hundred Al-Qaeda members and handed them over to the United States; senior U.S. officers have been lavish in their praise of Pakistani efforts in public while expressing their concern that not enough was being done in private. However, General Musharraf was strongly supported by the Bush administration.[citation needed]

Pakistan Prime minister Shaukat Aziz shakes hands with President George Walker Bush.

In return for their support, Pakistan had sanctions lifted and has received about $10 billion in U.S. aid since 2001, primarily military. In June 2004, President George W. Bush designated Pakistan as a major non-NATO ally,[48] making it eligible, among other things, to purchase advanced American military technology.

Pakistan has lost thousands of lives since joining the U.S. war on terror in the form of both soldiers and civilians, and was going through a critical period, however many areas of Pakistan are becoming terror free.[neutrality is disputed] Suicide bombs were commonplace in Pakistan, whereas they were unheard of prior to 9/11.[citation needed] The Taliban have been resurgent in recent years in both Afghanistan and Pakistan. Hundreds of thousands of refugees have been created internally in Pakistan, as they have been forced to flee their homes as a result of fighting between Pakistani forces and the Taliban in the regions bordering Afghanistan and further in Swat.[citation needed] In addition, the economy is in an extremely fragile position.[citation needed][weasel words]

A key campaign argument of US President Barack Obama was that the US had made the mistake of "putting all our eggs in one basket" in the form of General Musharraf.[citation needed] Musharraf was eventually forced out of office under the threat of impeachment, after years of political protests by lawyers, civilians and other political parties in Pakistan. With Obama coming into office, the U.S. is expected to triple non-military aid to Pakistan to $1.5 billion per year over 10 years, and to tie military aid to progress in the fight against militants. The purpose of the aid is to help strengthen the relatively new democratic government led by President Zardari and to help strengthen civil institutions and the general economy in Pakistan, and to put in place an aid program that is broader in scope than just supporting Pakistan's military.

Aid from the United States since 9/11[edit]

Pakistan is a major non-NATO ally as part of the War on Terrorism, and a leading recipient of U.S. aid.[49]

Trust deficits issues[edit]

In 2008, NSA Director Mike McConnell confronted ISI Director Ahmad Shuja Pasha, claiming that the ISI was tipping off jihadists so that they could escape in advance of American attacks against them.[29]

On 11 June 2008, the Gora Prai airstrike, on the Afghan-Pakistani border, killed 10 members of the paramilitary Frontier Corps. The Pakistani military condemned the airstrike as an act of aggression, souring the relations between the two countries.[50] However after the drone attacks in June, President Bush had said 'Pakistan is strong ally '.[51] Western officials have claimed nearly 70%( roughly $3.4 billion) of the aid given to the Pakistani military has been misspent in 2002–2007. However U.S-Pakistani relationship has been a transactional based and US military aid to Pakistan has been shrouded in secrecy for several years until recently.[52][53][54][55][56] Furthermore a significant proportion of US economic aid for Pakistan has ended up back in the US as funds are channeled through large US contractors. US Representative Gary Ackerman also said a large sum of US economic aid has not left the US as it spent on consulting fees and overhead cost.[57][58]

In the November 2008 Mumbai Attacks, the United States informed Pakistan that it expected full cooperation in the hunt for the plotters of the attacks.

Border engagement and skirmishes[edit]

The United States and Pakistan have experienced several military confrontations on the Durand Line. These skirmishes took place between American forces deployed in Afghanistan, and Pakistani troops guarding the border. On November 26, 2011, 24 Pakistani soldiers were killed in an aerial attack on Pakistani positions near the border. The attack further damaged US-Pakistani relations with many in Pakistan calling for a more hardline stance against the United States.[59]

Afghan war factor in Pakistan–United States relations[edit]

Present US-Pakistan relations are a case study on the difficulties of diplomacy and policy making in a multipolar world. Pakistan has important geopolitical significance for both India and China, making unilateral action almost impossible for the US. At the same time, Pakistan remains a key player in American efforts in Afghanistan. The two countries are trying to build a strategic partnership, but there remains a significant trust deficit, which continues to hinder successful cooperation in combating common threats.

Despite recent setbacks, both Pakistan and the United States continue to seek a productive relationship to defeat terrorist organizations.[60] It has been alleged that the ISI pays journalists to write articles hostile to the United States.[29]

2009: U.S. military and economic aid[edit]

Secretary State Hillary Clinton attending meeting with Former Pakistan Prime Minister Raza Gillani during an October 2009 visit to Islamabad.

On 14 September 2009, former President of Pakistan, Pervez Musharraf, admitted that American foreign aid to Pakistan had been diverted from its original purpose of fighting the Taliban to preparing for war against neighboring India.[61] The United States government has responded by stating that it will take these allegations seriously.[62] However Pervez Musharraf also said, '"Wherever there is a threat to Pakistan, we will use it [the equipment] there. If the threat comes from al-Qaeda or Taliban, it will be used there. If the threat comes from India, we will most surely use it there."[61]

In late 2009, Hillary Clinton made a speech in Pakistan about the war against the militants and said "...we commend the Pakistani military for their courageous fight, and we commit to stand shoulder to shoulder with the Pakistani people in your fight for peace and security."[63]

In October 2009, the US Congress approved $7.5 billion of non-military aid to Pakistan over the next five years via the Kerry-Lugar Bill. In February 2010, US President Barack Obama sought to increase funds to Pakistan to "promote economic and political stability in strategically important regions where the United States has special security interests".[49] Obama also sought $3.1 billion aid for Pakistan to defeat Al Qaeda for 2010.[64]

On December 1, 2009, President Barack Obama in a speech on a policy about Pakistan said "In the past, we too often defined our relationship with Pakistan narrowly. Those days are over.... The Pakistani people must know America will remain a strong supporter of Pakistan’s security and prosperity long after the guns have fallen silent, so that the great potential of its people can be unleashed."[65] President Obama also said, "In the past, we too often defined our relationship with Pakistan narrowly, those days are over. Moving forward, we are committed to a partnership with Pakistan that is built on a foundation of mutual interests, mutual respect and mutual trust" and that the two countries "share a common enemy' in combating Islamic extremism."[66]

In the aftermath of a thwarted bombing attempt on a 2009 Northwest Airlines flight, the U.S. Transportation Security Administration (TSA) issued a new set of screening guidelines that includes pat-downs for passengers from countries of interest, which includes Pakistan.[67] In a sign of widening fissures between the two allies, on January 21, Pakistan declined a request by the United States to launch new offensives on militants in 2010.[68] Pakistan say it "can't launch any new offensives against militants for six months to a year because it wants to 'stabilize' previous gains made. However, the US praises Pakistan's military effort against the militants.[69] Furthermore Pakistan president, in meeting with the U.S. delegation, had said Pakistan "had suffered a... loss of over 35 billion dollars during the last eight years as a result of the fight against militancy." But the President also called for "greater Pak-U.S. cooperation".

2010: Coalition partnership issues[edit]

In February 2010, Anne W. Patterson (U.S. Ambassador to Pakistan) said that the United States is committed to partnership with Pakistan and further said “Making this commitment to Pakistan while the U.S. is still recovering from the effects of the global recession reflects the strength of our vision. Yet we have made this commitment, because we see the success of Pakistan, its economy, its civil society and its democratic institutions as important for ourselves, for this region and for the world.”[65]

Between 2002–2010, Pakistan received approximately $18 billion[70] in military and economic aid from the United States. In February 2010, the Obama administration requested an additional $3 billion in aid, for a total of $20.7 billion.[71]

In mid-February 2010, after the capture of the second most powerful Taliban, Abdul Ghani Baradar in Pakistan by Pakistani forces, the White House hailed the operation. Furthermore, White House Press Secretary Robert Gibbs said that this is a "big success for our mutual efforts(Pakistan and United States)in the region" and praised Pakistan for the capture, saying it was a sign of increased cooperation with the US in the terror fight.[72]

In March, Richard Holbrooke, then US special envoy to Pakistan, said that US-Pakistani relations have seen "significant improvement" under Obama. He also said, "No government on earth has received more high-level attention" than Pakistan[73][74]

2011: American accusations and attacks in Pakistan[edit]

U.S President Obama and Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif.

As early as 2005, the Western criticism against Pakistan grew and many European and American political correspondents criticized Pakistan at the public level.[75] The London-based The Economist in fact observed: "As an American ally, Pakistan has became an embarrassment for United States."[75] In January 2011, the Raymond Allen Davis incident occurred in which Raymond Davis, an alleged private security contractor, shot dead two Pakistani locals after they attempted to rob him. The action sparked protests in Pakistan and threatened relations between the United States and Pakistan, including aid flows.[76] Pakistan prosecuted him despite US demands for him to be freed because he enjoys diplomatic immunity.[76] Ultimately he was freed after the United States made payments to the families of the slain Pakistanis, but the incident was emblematic of the volatile nature of American-Pakistani relations. In spite of this rocky relationship, the United States remains committed to assisting Pakistan's new democratic government in the areas of development, stability, and security.[77]

The CIA had long suspected Osama Bin Laden of hiding in Pakistan.[78][79] India and US have also accused Pakistan of giving safe-haven to the Taliban.[80] However, Pakistan has repeatedly denied these accusations.

The attack on the US embassy and the NATO headquarters in Kabul was blamed on the Haqqani Network, which US Admiral Mike Mullen called "a veritable arm of Pakistan's Inter-Services Intelligence Agency."[81][82] Pakistan reacted by recalling its finance minister who was on a visit to the U.N.[83] Pakistan also tried to strengthen the relationship with China and Saudi Arabia to counter the U.S.[84] The Chinese government advised Pakistan against any commitments that could jeopardize China's relationships with US and India.[85] The United States reissued a call urging Pakistan to act against the Haqqani Network or else the US would be forced to take on the threat unilaterally.[86] Islamic groups in Pakistan, issued a fatwa proclaiming Jihad against the US.[87] This was followed by Pakistan threatening the US with retaliation, if the US went ahead with unilateral action against the Haqqani network.[88]

In May 2011, Pakistani journalist Saleem Shahzad was killed and in September, The New Yorker reported that the order to kill Shahzad came from an officer on General Kayani's staff. In July Admiral Mullen alleged that Shahzad's killing had been "sanctioned by the government" of Pakistan,[89] but the ISI denied any involvement in the Shahzad murder.

Collapse of alliance and death of Osama bin Laden[edit]

Diagram of Osama bin Laden's hideout, showing the high concrete walls that surround the compound

Osama bin Laden, then head of the militant group al-Qaeda, was killed in Pakistan on May 2, 2011, shortly after 1 a.m. local time[90][91] by a United States special forces military unit. The operation, codenamed Operation Neptune Spear, was ordered by United States President Barack Obama and carried out in a US Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) operation by a team of United States Navy SEALs from the United States Naval Special Warfare Development Group (also known as DEVGRU or informally by its former name, SEAL Team Six) of the Joint Special Operations Command, with support from CIA operatives on the ground.[92][93]

According to Obama administration officials, US officials did not share information about the raid with the government of Pakistan until it was over.[94][95] Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Michael Mullen called Pakistan's army chief Ashfaq Parvez Kayani at about 3 a.m. local time to inform him of the Abbottabad Operation.[96]

According to the Pakistani foreign ministry, the operation was conducted entirely by US forces.[97] Pakistan Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) officials said they were also present at what they called a joint operation;[98] President Asif Ali Zardari flatly denied this.[99] Pakistan's foreign secretary Salman Bashir later confirmed that Pakistani military had scrambled F-16s after they became aware of the attack but that they reached the compound after American helicopters had left.[100]

2012–13: American sentiment against Pakistan[edit]

American Chairman of Joint Chiefs Peter Pace is saluting to Pakistan's inter-services in Islamabad.

Numerous allegations were made that the government of Pakistan had shielded bin Laden.[98][101][102] Critics cited the very close proximity of bin Laden's heavily fortified compound to the Pakistan Military Academy, that the US chose not to notify Pakistani authorities before the operation and the double standards of Pakistan regarding the perpetrators of the 2008 Mumbai attacks.[102][103][104] US government files, leaked by Wikileaks, disclosed that American diplomats had been told that Pakistani security services were tipping off bin Laden every time US forces approached. Pakistan's Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI), also helped smuggle al-Qaeda militants into Afghanistan to fight NATO troops.

According to the leaked files, in December 2009, the government of Tajikistan had also told US officials that many in Pakistan were aware of bin Laden's whereabouts. [105]

CIA chief Leon Panetta said the CIA had ruled out involving Pakistan in the operation, because it feared that "any effort to work with the Pakistanis could jeopardize the mission. They might alert the targets."[106] However, Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton stated that "cooperation with Pakistan helped lead us to bin Laden and the compound in which he was hiding."[107] Obama echoed her sentiments.[108] John O. Brennan, Obama's chief counterterrorism advisor, said that it was inconceivable that bin Laden did not have support from within Pakistan. He further stated, "People have been referring to this as hiding in plain sight. We are looking at how he was able to hide out there for so long." [109]

In 2012, Shakil Afridi, a doctor who had been cooperating with the United States in searching for Al Qaeda and bin Laden was convicted of treason by Pakistan, and sentenced to 33 years in prison.[110] The United States Congress voted to cut 33 million dollars in aid to Pakistan; 1 million dollars for every year that Shakil Afridi was sentenced to prison.[111]

Meetings between Pakistani and U.S leaders[edit]

===Visits By Leaders of Pakistan===[112]

Visitor Date Description
Prime Minister Liaquat Ali Khan May 3–5, 1950 Official visit. Afterwards visited New York City, Chicago, San Francisco, Los Angeles, Houston, New Orleans (Louisiana), Schenectady (New York), and Boston (Massachusetts). Departed U.S. May 30.
Governor General Malik Ghulam Muhammad November 8–13, 1953 Met with President Eisenhower after obtaining medical treatment in Boston.
P.M Muhammad Ali Bogra October 14–21, 1954 Official guest.
Huseyn Shaheed Suhrawardy July 10–13, 1957 Official visit. Afterwards visited Colorado Springs (Colorado), the Grand Canyon (Arizona), Los Angeles, San Francisco, Salt Lake City (Utah), Omaha (Nebraska), Detroit (Michigan), and New York City. Departed U.S. July 27.
Field Marshal Ayub Khan July 11–14, 1961 State visit. Addressed U.S. Congress July 12. Afterwards visited New York City, Gettysburg (Pennsylvania), San Antonio, Austin, and the LBJ Ranch (Texas). Departed U.S. July 18.
Field Marshal Ayub Khan September 24, 1962 Informal meeting at Newport (Rhode Island). Afterwards visited Washington and New York City. Departed U.S. September 27.
Field Marshal Ayub Khan December 14–16, 1965 State visit. Arrived in U.S. December 12; visited New York City.
General Yahya Khan October 24–25, 1970 Attended White House dinner on 25th Anniversary of the U.N; met privately with Richard Nixon on October 25.
Zulfikar Ali Bhutto September 18–20, 1973 Official visit. In U.S. September 17–24; visited Williamsburg, San Francisco, and New York City.
Zulfikar Ali Bhutto February 4–7, 1975 Official visit. Afterwards visited New York City. Departed U.S. February 8.
Muhammad Zia-ul-Haq October 3, 1980 Private visit while attending U.N. General Assembly session.
Muhammad Zia-ul-Haq December 6–9, 1982 State visit; visited New York City, Houston, Sacramento, and San Francisco. Departed U.S. December 14.
Muhammad Zia-ul-Haq October 23, 1985 Met with President Reagan in New York City at reception and luncheon at the U.N.
Muhammad Khan Junejo July 15–18, 1986 Official Visit; visited Orlando (Fla.) and New York City. Departed U.S. July 22.
Benazir Bhutto June 5–7, 1989 Official Visit; visited Boston and New York City. Departed U.S. June 10.
Farooq Leghari May 23–27, 1994 Arrived in U.S. May 21; departed June 1. Also visited Rochester, NY. Met with President Bill Clinton during a private visit. Later visited New York City.
Benazir Bhutto April 9–11, 1995 Official working visit. Arrived in the U.S. April 5; also visited New York City and Los Angeles. Departed the U.S. April 14.
Nawaz Sharif September 22, 1997 Met with President Bill Clinton at the UN General Assembly in New York City.
Nawaz Sharif September 21, 1998 Met with President Clinton at the U.N. General Assembly in New York City.
Nawaz Sharif December 1, 1998 Official working visit.
Nawaz Sharif July 4–5, 1999 Discussed the Kashmir conflict with President Bill Clinton during a private visit.
President Pervez Musharraf November 10, 2001 Met with George W. Bush at the UN General Assembly in New York City.
President Pervez Musharraf February 12–14, 2002 Official Working Visit.
President Pervez Musharraf September 12, 2002 Met with President Bush at the UN General Assembly in New York City.
President Pervez Musharraf June 23–27, 2003 Working visit. Met with President Bush in Washington, DC and Camp David. Arrived in Boston June 20; later visited Los Angeles.
President Pervez Musharraf September 24, 2003 Met with President Bush at the UN General Assembly in New York City.
Prime Minister Zafarullah Khan Jamali September 30-October 4, 2003 Working visit, meet U.S President
President Pervez Musharraf September 21–22, 2004 Met with President Bush at the UN General Assembly in New York City.
President Pervez Musharraf December 3–4, 2004 Working visit.
Prime Minister Shaukat Aziz January 22–24, 2006 Working visit. Arrived in the U.S. January 19; also visited New York City and Boston.
Pervez Musharraf September 20–22, 2006 Working visit.
Pervez Musharraf September 27, 2006 Also met with Afghan President Hamid Karzai on September 27.
Yousaf Raza Gillani July 27–30, 2008 Working visit.
Asif Ali Zardari September 23, 2008 Met with President Bush at the UN General Assembly in New York City.
Asif Ali Zardari September 24–25, 2009 Attended a meeting of the Friends of Democratic Pakistan in New York City
Yousaf Raza Gillani April 11–13, 2010 Attended the Nuclear Security Summit.
Asif Ali Zardari January 14, 2011 attended Richard Holbrooke Memorial Service.
Asif Ali Zardari May 21, 2012 Met with President Obama at the NATO Summit Meeting in Chicago, IL.
Nawaz Sharif October 20–23, 2013 Met with President Barack Obama at the Oval office.

===Visits By Presidents of the United States===[113]

Visitor Date Description
Dwight D. Eisenhower December 7–9, 1959 Informal visit to Karachi; met with Field Marshall Ayub Khan.
Lyndon B. Johnson December 23, 1967 visit to Karachi; met with Field Marshall Ayub Khan.
Richard Nixon August 1–2, 1969 State visit; met with President Yahya Khan
Bill Clinton March 25, 2000 Met with General Musharraf; delivered radio address.
George W. Bush March 3–4, 2006 Met with President Musharraf, red carpet welcome at Islamabad

Military aid from the United States[edit]

Pakistan is a major non-NATO ally as part of the War on Terrorism and provides key intelligence and logistical support for the United States. A leading recipient of US military assistance, Pakistan expects to receive approximately $20 billion since 2001 a combination of reimbursement to Pakistan and training programs for the Pakistan counter terrorism units. However, in the aftermath of the Osama Bin Laden raid, Pakistan Army cancelled a $500 million training program and sent all 135 trainers home. The United States showed displeasure at this act and withheld a further $300 million in assistance.[114]

Some politicians in Pakistan argue the war on terror has cost the Pakistani economy $70 billion and U.S. aid costs the country more in the long term, leading to accusations that the US is making Pakistan a client state.[115]

On 31 May 2012, Senator Rand Paul (R-Kentucky) called for the United States to suspend all aid to Pakistan and grant citizenship to a doctor who was jailed for helping hunt down Osama bin Laden.[116]

Cultural influence[edit]

According to the Washington Post, American culture has heavily penetrated Pakistan. In the past decade, the introduction of US cinema, US fashion and US Cuisine have proliferated Pakistan. In particular, the introduction of American apple pies, US-style diners similar to the Sonic Drive-In on Pakistani motorways, Hot dog stands on the streets of major cities, Fast food restaurants serving Chicago-style pizza as well as New York-style pizza with the option of US style home deliveries.

The proliferation of American culture in Pakistan stands in stark contrast to the growing resentment most Pakistanis feel toward the United States. As a result, US companies have heavily invested in Pakistan. Hardee's have opened restaurants in the country and its first American-style sports bar. McDonald's has heavily invested in the country and has been credited with introducing the concept of home deliveries. Those businesses join existing burger joints and other American fast-food restaurants such as Pizza Hut, KFC, Fatburger and Domino's Pizza. Taco Bell and Burger King are also said to be looking at opening branches in Pakistan.[117]

See also[edit]

External links[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ "U.S.-Pakistan relations: An unhappy alliance". Los Angeles Times. May 7, 2011. 
  2. ^ "U.S-Pakistan Military Cooperation". Council on Foreign Relations. Retrieved June 26, 2008. 
  3. ^ Provost, Claire (July 15, 2011). "Sixty years of US aid to Pakistan: Get the data". The Guardian (London). Retrieved October 22, 2011. 
  4. ^ "U.S.-PAKISTAN RELATIONS". state.gov. 
  5. ^ "America's 25 Most Awkward Allies". Politico Magazine. March 2014. Retrieved 28 February 2014. 
  6. ^ "2014 BBC World Service poll". 
  7. ^ Warden, Philip (May 4, 1950). "Liaquat Ali Arrives For Goodwill Tour". Chicago Daily Tribune. 
  8. ^ a b c Kazmi, Muhammad Raza (2003). Liaquat Ali Khan: his life and work. United Kingdom: Oxford University Press, 2003. p. 354. ISBN 978-0-19-579788-6. 
  9. ^ a b Ardeshir Cowasjee (13 March 2011). "A recap of Soviet-Pakistan relations". Dawn Newspaper, Pakistan Institute of International Affairs (1950). Retrieved 26 February 2012. 
  10. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z aa ab ac ad ae af ag Hamid Hussain. "Tale of a love affair that never was: United States-Pakistan Defence Relations". Hamid Hussain , Defence Journal of Pakistan. Hamid Hussain , Defence Journal of Pakistan. Retrieved 12 February 2012. 
  11. ^ a b c d Gauhar, Altaf. "Declassified Papers Shed Light on US Role in Liaquat’s Murder". Altaf Gauhar. Retrieved 31 January 2012. 
  12. ^ "America Welcomes President Ayub". Gordon Wilkison Collection. Texas Archive of the Moving Image. July 1961. Retrieved 28 July 2011. 
  13. ^ a b c d e f g h i Aziz, Sartaj (2009). Between Dreams and Realities: Some Milestones in Pakistan’s History. Karachi, Pakistan: Oxford University Press. p. 408. ISBN 978-0-19-547718-4. 
  14. ^ Mosleh Uddin. "Personal Prejudice Makes Foreign Policy". Asiaticsociety.org.bd. Retrieved 2011-03-28. 
  15. ^ Black, Conrad (2007), p. 751.
  16. ^ "The Kissinger Tilt". Time. January 17, 1972. Retrieved September 30, 2008. 
  17. ^ "World: Pakistan: The Ravaging of Golden Bengal". TIME. 1971-08-02. Retrieved 2011-03-28. 
  18. ^ Black, Conrad (2007), p. 756.
  19. ^ Gandhi, Sajit (December 16, 2002). "The Tilt: The U.S. and the South Asian Crisis of 1971". National Security Archive Electronic Briefing Book No. 79. National Security Archive. Retrieved January 15, 2009. 
  20. ^ a b Garthoff R.L, B.M, R.L B.M (1994). Detente and Confrontation: American-Soviet Relations from Nixon to Reagan. Transaction Publishers. pp. 297–312. ISBN 0-8157-3042-X. 
  21. ^ a b Blechman, B.M.; Kaplan, S.S. (1978). Force Without War: U.S. Armed Forces as a Political Instrument. Brookings Institution Press. ISBN 0-8157-0985-4 .
  22. ^ a b c U.S. Government. "Nixon/Kissinger Saw India as "Soviet Stooge" in 1971 South Asia Crisis". CIA Documentation Center (1971). U.S. Government, 1971 archives. Retrieved 2 March 2012. 
  23. ^ a b c "Zulfikar Ali Bhutto". historycommons.com. Retrieved 2011. 
  24. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k Bhurgari, Abdul Ghafoor. "The Falcon of Pakistan". Abdul Ghafoor Bugari. Abdul Ghafoor Bugari and Sani Penhwar, Member of Parliament. Retrieved 26 January 2012. 
  25. ^ a b c d Khan, Feroz Hassan (November 22, 2012). "The Route to Nuclear Ambition" (google book). Eating grass : the making of the Pakistani bomb. Stanford, California: Stanford University Press. pp. 119–120. ISBN 978-0804776011. Retrieved 9 January 2013. 
  26. ^ a b "Zulfikar Bhutto had blamed US for his ‘horrible’ fate". Zee News. April 8, 2011. Retrieved 2011. 
  27. ^ Benjamin, Daniel & Steven Simon. "The Age of Sacred Terror", 2002
  28. ^ The Bear Trap, Brig. Muhammad Yousuf
  29. ^ a b c d e Jeffrey Goldberg and Marc Ambinder, The Ally From Hell The Atlantic December 2011
  30. ^ "The Road to September 11". Evan Thomas. Newsweek. 1 October 2001.
  31. ^ a b c d e NTI. "Nuclear policy of Nawaz Sharif". NTI. NTI Publications on 1990. Retrieved 2 December 2011. 
  32. ^ a b c Our Staff Correspondent. "Pakistan against forces of extremism: PM". DAWNWIRESERIVCE, APRIL 1995. DAWNWIRESERIVCE, APRIL 1995. Retrieved 18 November 2011. 
  33. ^ a b Malick, Nasir Malick (May 10, 1998). "Benazir vows to fight on people's side". DawnWireService (DWS). Retrieved 17 November 2011. 
  34. ^ Panhwar, Member of Sindh Provincial Assembly., Sani (April 5, 1979). "CIA Sent Bhutto to the Gallows". The New York Time (article published in 1979) and Sani H. Panhwar, member of Sindh Provincial Assembly and Party representative of Pakistan People's Party. Retrieved August 23, 2011. ""I [Ramsey Clark] do not believe in conspiracy theories in general, but the similarities in the staging of riots in Chile (where the CIA allegedly helped overthrow President Salvadore Allande) and in Pakistan are just too close, Bhutto was removed from power in Pakistan by force on July 5, after the usual party on the 4th at the U.S. Embassy in Islamabad, with U.S. approval, if not more, by General Zia-ul-Haq. Bhutto was falsely accused and brutalized for months during proceedings that corrupted the Judiciary of Pakistan before being murdered, then hanged. As Americans, we must ask ourselves this: Is it possible that a rational military leader under the circumstances in Pakistan could have overthrown a constitutional government, without at least the tacit approval of the United States?"." 
  35. ^ a b Shaheen Sehbai (25 September 1999). "Benazir says Nawaz to go by December". DawnWire Service. Retrieved 19 November 2011. 
  36. ^ "Background note: Pakistan". US Department of State. 
  37. ^ a b c d e f g h i Munawar, Harris (14 July 2011). "What has America done for Pakistan?". Dawn Newspapers. Retrieved 15 February 2012. 
  38. ^ a b c History Commons. "History: U.S. recognition of secret nuclear power, Pakistan". History commons. Retrieved 15 February 2012. 
  39. ^ Staff (August 29, 1998). "Pakistan may sign CTBT if curbs lifted". Dawn Archives, 1998. Retrieved 12 December 2012. 
  40. ^ "All our rulers have carried a begging bowl to US" The News International, Wednesday, October 23, 2013
  41. ^ "President Announces New Measures to Counter the Threat of WMD"\, address by President George W. Bush at the National Defense University, 11 February 2004.
  42. ^ Pakistan feels heat from nuclear powers over talks block, Agence France-Presse, August 21, 2009.
  43. ^ Khan, Iftikhar A. "World must accept Pakistan as nuclear power: Gen Majid". Dawn Archives, 2010. Retrieved 3 December 2012. 
  44. ^ Officials reports (June 18, 2010). "Pakistan a Responsible Nuclear Power, Official Asserts". NPT News Directorate. Retrieved 3 December 2012. 
  45. ^ a b "Pak, US officials hold talks on ’non-proliferation challenges". The Week. Monday, December 10, 2012 21:38 hrs IST. Retrieved 12 December 2012.  Check date values in: |date= (help)
  46. ^ MoFA. "Joint Statement: Pakistan and United States discuss Security, Strategic Stability, and Nonproliferation issues". Government of Pakistan. Ministry of Foreign Affairs. Retrieved 12 December 2012. 
  47. ^ "CNN.com – Rice: U.S. will support Pakistan – Oct 12, 2005". CNN. Retrieved May 20, 2010. 
  48. ^ "US and Pakistan, Not Allies But Enemies". Theworldreporter.com. 2010-10-02. 
  49. ^ a b "Obama seeks boost in Pakistan aid". Reuters. February 1, 2010. 
  50. ^ Riaz Khan (2008-06-11). "Pakistan blames U.S. coalition for troops' death". Google News. Associated Press. Retrieved 2008-06-11. [dead link]
  51. ^ Feller, Ben (July 28, 2008). "Bush hails Pakistan as strong ally". Fox News. 
  52. ^ "/ Asia-Pacific / Pakistan - US boosts strategic ties with Pakistan". Ft.com. 2010-03-24. Retrieved 2011-03-17. 
  53. ^ Walsh, Declan (February 27, 2008). "Up to 70% of US aid to Pakistan 'misspent'". The Guardian (London). Retrieved May 20, 2010. 
  54. ^ Rohde, David; Gall, Carlotta; Schmitt, Eric; Sanger, David E. (December 24, 2007). "U.S. Officials See Waste in Billions Sent to Pakistan". The New York Times. Retrieved May 20, 2010. 
  55. ^ Peters, Justin (2007-12-24). "Foreign Aid Betrayed". Slate. 
  56. ^ Rohde, David; Carlotta Gall, Eric Schmitt and David E. Sanger (2007-12-24). "U.S. Officials See Waste in Billions Sent to Pakistan". The New York Times. 
  57. ^ "U.S. to channel more aid via Pakistan government". Reuters. April 14, 2010. 
  58. ^ Upadhyay, Brajesh (May 16, 2008). "U.S. aid 'failing to reach target'". BBC News. Retrieved May 20, 2010. 
  59. ^ http://www.dawn.com/2011/11/27/thousands-protest-at-us-consulate-against-attack.html
  60. ^ http://www.state.gov/r/pa/prs/dpb/2011/07/169177.htm#PAKISTAN
  61. ^ a b "Musharraf admits U.S. aid diverted". BBC News. September 14, 2009. Retrieved May 20, 2010. 
  62. ^ CJ: Mineguruji (2009-11-21). "US unaware of any diversion of military aid to Pak". Merinews.com. Retrieved 2011-03-17. 
  63. ^ "Pakistan mourns bomb victims - Central & South Asia". Al Jazeera English. 2009-10-29. Retrieved 2011-03-17. 
  64. ^ "Obama seeks $3.1 billion aid for Pakistan to defeat Al Qaeda". Sify.com. 2010-02-02. Retrieved 2011-03-17. 
  65. ^ a b "Associated Press Of Pakistan ( Pakistan's Premier NEWS Agency ) - United States committed to partnership with Pakistan: Anne Patterson". App.com.pk. Retrieved 2011-03-17. 
  66. ^ Obama pledges strengthened partnership with Pakistan (Extra)
  67. ^ Dawn.com
  68. ^ "Pakistan snubs U.S. over militants". BBC News. January 21, 2010. Retrieved May 20, 2010. 
  69. ^ "U.S. praises Pakistani military efforts". UPI.com. 2009-11-18. Retrieved 2011-03-17. 
  70. ^ [1][dead link]
  71. ^ "Pakistan got $18bn aid from U.S. since 2001". The Times Of India. February 23, 2010. 
  72. ^ Holland, Steve (February 17, 2010). "White House hails capture of Taliban leader". Reuters. 
  73. ^ "U.S. sees improved relations with Pakistan - CNN.com". CNN. March 15, 2010. Retrieved May 20, 2010. 
  74. ^ (AFP) – Mar 17, 2010 (2010-03-17). "AFP: U.S., Pakistan to host talks on economy, security next week". Google.com. Retrieved 2011-03-17. 
  75. ^ a b "Ties between U.S. and Pakistan suspended". 
  76. ^ "The United States Embassy" (in English (U.S.)). Retrieved 2008-12-21. 
  77. ^ CIA chief says bin Laden in Pakistan, The Boston Globe, 2009-06-11 (link broken)
  78. ^ Font size Print E-mail Share 39 Comments (2009-06-11). "CIA says Bin Laden is in Pakistan, CBS News/AP, 2009-06-11". Cbsnews.com. Retrieved 2011-03-17. 
  79. ^ "Pakistan and Taliban, Brothers or Rivals?". Theworldreporter.com. 2010-09-14. 
  80. ^ "Pakistan 'backed Haqqani attack on Kabul' - Mike Mullen". BBC News. 2011-09-22. 
  81. ^ U.S. blames Pakistan agency in Kabul attack
  82. ^ Pakistani PM calls back FM over U.S. charge
  83. ^ Pakistan hosts top Chinese security official and war games with Saudi as ties with US plunge
  84. ^ Pakistan wants more fire, but China has commitment issues
  85. ^ US sharpens warning to Pakistan
  86. ^ Fatwa for Jihad against America
  87. ^ Pak will retaliate to any US misadventure: Report
  88. ^ Dexter Filkins, The Journalist and the Spies The New Yorker September 19, 2011
  89. ^ Greg Miller (May 5, 2011). "CIA spied on bin Laden from safe house". The Washington Post. Retrieved May 6, 2011. 
  90. ^ Cooper, Helene (May 1, 2011). "Obama Announces Killing of Osama bin Laden". The New York Times. Retrieved May 1, 2011. 
  91. ^ Philip Sherwell (May 7, 2011). "Osama bin Laden killed: Behind the scenes of the deadly raid". The Daily Telegraph (London). Retrieved May 9, 2011. 
  92. ^ Dilanian, Ken (May 2, 2011). "CIA led U.S. special forces mission against Osama bin Laden". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved May 14, 2011. 
  93. ^ "Osama Bin Laden, al-Qaeda leader, dead – Barack Obama". BBC News. May 2, 2011. Retrieved May 2, 2011. 
  94. ^ "Osama bin Laden killed in Pakistan, says Obama". Dawn. May 2, 2011. Retrieved May 2, 2011. 
  95. ^ Perlez, Jane (May 5, 2011). "Pakistani Army Chief Warns U.S. on Another Raid". The New York Times. Retrieved May 5, 2011. 
  96. ^ "Bin Laden operation conducted by U.S. forces: Pakistan". Dawn. May 2, 2011. Retrieved May 2, 2011. 
  97. ^ a b Rodriguez, Alex (May 2, 2011). "Suspicions grow over whether Pakistan aided Osama bin Laden". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved May 2, 2011. 
  98. ^ Zardari, Asif Ali (May 3, 2011). "Pakistan did its part". The Washington Post. Retrieved May 3, 2011. 
  99. ^ Wright, Tom (May 5, 2011). "Pakistan Rejects U.S. Criticism". The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved May 5, 2011. 
  100. ^ Solomon, Jay; Laura Meckler; Tom Wright; Zahid Hussain (May 2, 2011). "Pakistan's bin Laden Connection Is Probed". The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved May 3, 2011. 
  101. ^ a b "Did Pakistan Army shelter Osama?". The Indian Express. May 2, 2011. Retrieved May 2, 2011. 
  102. ^ "Obama kept Pakistan in dark about Osama attack". News One. Retrieved May 13, 2011. 
  103. ^ "Did Pakistan know of U.S. raid to kill Osama?". Mid Day. May 2, 2011. 
  104. ^ Ross, Tim (May 2, 2011). "WikiLeaks: Osama bin Laden 'protected' by Pakistani security". The Daily Telegraph (UK). Retrieved May 2, 2011. 
  105. ^ Calabresi, Massimo (May 3, 2011). "CIA Chief Breaks Silence: Pakistan Would Have Jeopardized bin Laden Raid, 'Impressive' Intel Captured". TIME. Retrieved May 3, 2011. 
  106. ^ "Clinton: Pakistan helped lead U.S. to bin Laden". Forbes. Associated Press. May 2, 2011. Retrieved May 2, 2011. 
  107. ^ Walsh, Nick Paton (May 2, 2011). "Official: Pakistan had but didn't probe data that helped make raid". Islamabad, Pakistan: CNN. Retrieved May 2, 2011. 
  108. ^ MacAskill, Ewen; Walsh, Declan (May 2, 2011). "Osama bin Laden: Dead, but how did he hide so long?". The Guardian (London). Retrieved May 2, 2011. 
  109. ^ Leiby, Richard; Finn, Peter (May 24, 2012). "Pakistani doctor who helped CIA hunt for bin Laden sentenced to prison for treason". Washington Post. Retrieved May 24, 2012. 
  110. ^ http://tribune.com.pk/story/383739/us-senate-proposes-cut-in-aid-for-pakistan-over-shakil-afridi-verdict/
  111. ^ Visits By Foreign Leaders of Pakistan
  112. ^ PRESIDENTS TRAVELS TO PAKISTAN
  113. ^ "U.S. withholds $800 million in aid to Pakistan: White House". Reuters. July 10, 2011. 
  114. ^ http://www.supportimrankhan.org/news/Default.aspx?242
  115. ^ US senator proposes suspending all Pakistan aid, The News International, 31 May 2012
  116. ^ Brulliard, Nicolas (July 26, 2011). "American fast food on the menu in Pakistan". The Washington Post.