Palace of Justice siege

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Palace of Justice siege
Part of Colombian armed conflict
Date 6 November 1985
Location Bogotá,  Colombia
Result creation of the AFEUR unit
35 M19 members dead
11 Supreme Court Justices dead
48 Colombian Soldiers dead
Destruction of the Palace of Justice Building
Belligerents
Army of Colombia 19th of April Movement (M19)
Casualties and losses
120 killed on both sides

The Palace of Justice siege (Toma del Palacio de Justicia in Spanish) was a 1985 attack against the Supreme Court of Colombia, in which members of the M-19 guerrilla group took over the Palace of Justice in Bogotá, Colombia, and held the Supreme Court hostage, intending to hold a trial against President Belisario Betancur. Hours later, after a military raid, the incident left almost half of the 25 Supreme Court Justices dead.[1][2]

The siege[edit]

Day one: 6 November[edit]

On 6 November 1985, at 11:35 a.m., three vehicles holding 35 guerrillas (25 men and 10 women) stormed the Colombian Palace of Justice, entering through the basement.[3][4][5][6] Meanwhile, another group of guerrillas disguised as civilians took over the first floor and the main entrance.[4] The rebels killed security guards Eulogio Blanco and Gerardo Díaz Arbeláez as well as building manager Jorge Tadeo Mayo Castro.[7]

Jorge Medina -a witness located in the basement at the start of the siege- said that "suddenly, the guerrillas entered the basement in a truck. They opened fire with their machine guns against everyone who was there".[8] The official report judged that the guerrilla planned the takeover operation to be 'bloody takeover'.[9] According to these official sources[10] the guerrilla "set out to shoot indiscriminately and detonate building-shaking bombs while chanting M19-praising battle cries."

The M-19 lost one guerrilla and a nurse during the initial raid to the building.[9] After the guerrillas took care of the security personnel guarding the building, they went on to install armed posts at strategic places, like the stairs and the fourth floor.[9] A group of guerrillas, led by Commander Luis Otero got to the 4th floor and kidnapped the President of the Supreme Court, Chief Justice Alfonso Reyes Echandía.[9]

In the meantime many hostages took refuge in empty offices on the first floor, where they hid until around 2 pm.[9]

The assailants took 300 people hostage, including the 24 justices and 20 other judges. Once in the building the first hostage the Guerrilla group was asking for was Supreme Court Justice and President of the Constitutional Court then called Sala Constitucional, Manuel Gaona Cruz,[11] who was in charge of delivering the opinion of the Court in regard to the constitutionality of the Extradition Treaty between Colombia and the United States.

About three hours after the initial seizure, army troops rescued about 200 hostages[12] from the lower three floors of the courthouse; the surviving gunmen and remaining hostages occupied the upper two floors.

A recording was delivered to a radio station soon after the seizure, saying that the M-19 group had taken over the building "in the name of peace and social justice".[citation needed] From the Supreme Court, the M-19 members demanded via telephone that President Belisario Betancur come to the Palace of Justice in order to stand trial and negotiate. The president refused and ordered an emergency cabinet session.

Day two: 7 November[edit]

The M-19 rebels freed Arciniegas.[4]

The assault[edit]

The operation to retake the building was led by General Jesús Armando Arias Cabrales, commander of the Thirteenth Army Brigade in Bogotá; he appointed Colonel Alfonso Plazas, commander of an armored cavalry battalion, to personally oversee the operation.[citation needed] The retaking of the building began that day and ended on 7 November, when Army troops stormed the Palace of Justice, after having occupied some of the lower floors during the first day of the siege. After surrounding the building with EE-9 Cascavel armored cars and soldiers with automatic weapons, they stormed the building sometime after 2 pm. The EE-9s knocked down the building's massive doorway, and even made some direct hits against the structure's external walls.

The official version of the attack holds that, in an effort to complete one of the 2 objectives they had assaulted the palace for, the M-19 guerrillas burnt different criminal records containing proof and warrants against many members of the group. It is also believed, but argued whether they also burnt records against Pablo Escobar, one of the nation's biggest drug traffickers at the time.[citation needed] However, "no one knows with absolutely certainty what happened. The results of the tests carried out later by ballistics experts and investigators demonstrated the most likely cause to have been the recoil effect of the army's rockets. Tests proved that if fired by a soldier standing twenty feet of wood-lined walls of the library that housed Colombian legal archives, the intense heat generated by the rocket's rear blast could have ignited the wooden paneling. In any event, in a shelved area stacked high with old papers, files, books, and newspapers, the quantity of explosives used by the military virtually guaranteed a conflagration." [13] In total, over 6000 different documents were burned. The fire lasted about 2 days, even with efforts from firemen to try and smother the flames. An investigated theory to the "disappearance" of the missing entities in the siege is that they were charred in the fire, and were not able to be identified in any way, and without having been found, these entities are regarded as missing in action. This theory is still being studied in the different trials of the case.[14]

More than 100 people died during the final assault on the Palace. Those killed consisted of hostages, soldiers, and guerrillas, including their leader Andrés Almarales and four other senior commanders of M-19. After the raid, another Supreme Court justice died in a hospital after suffering a heart attack.

Aftermath[edit]

The siege of the Palace of Justice and the subsequent raid was one of the deadliest attacks in Colombia in its war with leftist rebels. The M-19 group was still a potent force after the raid, but was severely hampered by the deaths of five of its leaders. In March 1990, it signed a peace treaty with the government.

After the siege, firemen rushed to the site of the assault and smothered the few flames left in the palace. Other rescue groups assisted with removing debris and rubble left after the siege.

President Betancur went on national TV on the night of the 7th, saying he took full responsibility for the "terrible nightmare." He offered condolences to the families of those who died — civilians and rebels alike — and said he would continue to look for a peaceful solution with the rebels. Exactly a week later, on 14 November, he would offer condolences for another tragedy: the eruption of the Nevado del Ruiz volcano, which killed 25,000 people in the Armero tragedy. "We have had one national tragedy after another", he said.

This siege led to the creation of the AFEUR unit within the Colombian Army to manage this kind of situation. Colombia's Armed Forces did not have antiterrorist units specifically trained for urban operations before the siege, and some partially blamed the final outcome on the relative inexperience of the personnel assigned to the task.

Dead magistrates[edit]

The twelve magistrates killed were:[15]

  1. Manuel Gaona Cruz
  2. Alfonso Reyes Echandía
  3. Fabio Calderón Botero
  4. Dario Velásquez Gaviria
  5. Eduardo Gnecco Correa
  6. Carlos Medellín Forero
  7. Ricardo Medina Moyano
  8. Alfonso Patiño Rosselli
  9. Horacio Montoya Gil
  10. Pedro Elías Serrano Abadía
  11. Fanny González Franco
  12. Dante Luis Fiorillo Porras

Alleged Mafia links[edit]

The U.S. and Colombian governments shortly after the siege asserted that drug lords masterminded the operation in order to get rid of various criminal files lost during the event. The Special Commission of Inquiry, established by the Betancur government after intense public pressure,[16] released a June 1986 report which concluded that this was not the case.[17]

Author Ana Carrigan, who quoted the June 1986 report in her book on the siege and originally dismissed any such links between the M-19 and the drug mafia, told Cromos magazine in late 2005 that she now believes that the mafia may have financially supported the M-19.[18]

On the same day of the siege, the Supreme Court's docket apparently called for the beginning of pending deliberations on the constitutionality of the Colombia-United States extradition treaty. The M-19 was publicly opposed to extradition on nationalist grounds. Several of the magistrates had been previously threatened by drug lords in order to prevent any possibility of a positive decision on the treaty. One year after the siege, the treaty was declared unconstitutional.[19][20]

Former Assistant of the Colombia Attorney General, National Deputy Comptroller, Author and destacated Professor Jose Mauricio Gaona es:Manuel Gaona Cruz, along with the Former Secreatry of Justice and Colombian British Ambassador Carlos Medellín Becerra, the sons of two of the murdered Supreme Court magistrates, Manuel Gaona Cruz and Carlos Medellín, have permanently pushed for further and broader lines of investigations related not only to the presumed links between the M-19 and the Medellín Cartel drug lords, but also to the any other possible links between the investigations performed by the Justices against members of the Armed Forces. Congressman Gustavo Petro, a former M-19 guerrilla, has denied these accusations and dismissed them as based upon the inconsistent testimonies of drug lords. Petro says that the surviving members of the M-19 do admit to their share of responsibility for the tragic events of the siege, on behalf of the entire organization, but deny any links to the drug trade.[21]

Impunity[edit]

Later investigations and commentators have considered both the M-19 and the military as responsible for the deaths of the justices and civilians inside the building. Some have blamed President Belisario Betancur for not taking the necessary actions or for failing to negotiate, and others have commented on the possibility of a sort of de facto "24-hour coup", during which the military was in control of the situation.

According to Ana Carrigan's 1993 book The Palace of Justice: A Colombian Tragedy, Supreme Court Chief Justice Alfonso Reyes was apparently burned alive during the assault, as someone incinerated his body after pouring gasoline over it. The book also asserts that, after the siege was over, some twenty-eight bodies were dumped into a mass grave and apparently soaked with acid, in order to make identification difficult. Carrigan argued that the bodies of the victims of the Nevado del Ruiz volcano eruption, which buried the city of Armero and killed more than 20,000 people, were dumped into the same mass grave, making any further forensic investigations impractical.[22][23]

Despite numerous investigations and lawsuits to date, impunity prevailed for most of the subsequent decades. Ana Carrigan asserted in her 1993 book that "Colombia has moved on... Colombia has forgotten the Palace of Justice siege", in much the same way that, in her opinion, Colombians have also forgotten or adopted a position of denial towards other tragic events such as the 1928 Santa Marta Massacre. No definite responsibility has been fixed on the government or on the surviving members of the M-19 movement who were pardoned after they demobilized.

Eduardo Umaña, the first attorney representing some of the families of the people killed during the siege, was assassinated in 1998 and several members of those families had to flee to Europe because of death threats against them.[24]

The missing[edit]

The eleven missing [1]
Photos of the missing
Name Occupation
Bernardo Beltrán Fernández Cafeteria waiter[25]
Héctor Jaime Beltrán Fuentes Cafeteria waiter[25]
Ana Rosa Castilblanco* Assistant chef[26]
David Celis Cafeteria Chef[25]
Norma Constanza Esguerra Sold homemade
pastries
in cafeteria[26][27]
Cristina Guarín Cortés Teller in cafeteria
Gloria Stella
Lizarazo Figueroa
Cafeteria employee
Luz Mary Portela León Cafeteria dishwasher[26]
Carlos Augusto Vera Rodríguez Cafeteria manager[25]
Gloria Anzola de Lanao Niece of
Aydee Anzola,
state official
Irma Franco Pineda Law student,
M-19 member

It is suspected that at least 11 people disappeared during the events of the siege, most of them cafeteria workers, and their fate is unknown. It has been speculated that their remains may be among a number of unidentified and charred bodies, one of which was identified through DNA testing done by the National University of Colombia, leaving the fates of the other 10 still in question. [2]

According to Ana Carrington, one of the disappeared was a law student and M-19 guerrilla, Irma Franco. Carrington says Franco was seen by several hostages. She also states that the guerrilla left with several hostages and was never seen again.[28] The Special Commission of Inquiry confirmed Franco's disappearance, and the judges requested that the investigation of her case be thoroughly pursued.[29]

One week after the siege, M-19 released a communique to the press claiming that six leaders, including Franco, and "seven other fighters" had all been "disappeared and murdered" by the army. From the tapes of the military and police inter-communications it is known that army intelligence arrested at least seventeen people in the course of the two-day siege. None of the M-19 leaders, with the exception of Andrés Almarales, were ever identified in the city morgue.[30]

Some of their relatives and some human rights organizations have claimed that they could have been taken alive by the military and then killed outside or inside the building, possibly after being interrogated and tortured.[citation needed]

Recent developments[edit]

The new Palace of Justice building.

The events surrounding the Palace of Justice siege received renewed media coverage in Colombia during the 20th anniversary of the tragedy. Among other outlets, the country's main daily El Tiempo, the weekly El Espectador, and the Cromos magazine published several articles, interviews and opinion pieces on the matter, including stories about the survivors, as well as the plight of the victims' relatives and those of the missing. [3][4]

2005–2006 Truth Commission[edit]

The Supreme Court created a Truth Commission in order to investigate the siege. The Commission officially began its work on November 3, 2005 and according to one of its members, Judge Jorge Aníbal Gómez.[31]

2006–2007 Judicial processes[edit]

On 22 August 2006, Attorney General Mario Iguarán announced that former Colonel Edilberto Sánchez, former B-2 intelligence chief of the Army's Thirteenth Brigade, would be summoned for questioning and investigated for the crimes of kidnapping and forced disappearance. Public prosecutors are to reopen the case after examining video tape recordings and identifying cafeteria manager Carlos Augusto Rodríguez being taken outside of the Palace of Justice alive by a soldier, together with other former M-19 hostages.[32]

Former Col. Sánchez was then detained. In May 2007, former Col. Sánchez has been questioned by prosecutors about his possible role in the disappearance of Irma Franco and at least two cafeteria workers, who would have left the Palace alive. Sánchez rejected the charges and proclaimed his innocence. He accepted that he could have received the order to cover the exit of some hostages from the Palace of Justice.[33]

2008 Virginia Vallejo's testimony[edit]

On 11 July 2008, Virginia Vallejo, the television anchorwoman who was romantically involved with Pablo Escobar from 1983 to 1987 and the author of "Amando a Pablo, odiando a Escobar" (Loving Pablo, Hating Escobar), was asked to testify in the reopened case of the Palace of Justice siege, in order to confirm the events described in "That Palace in Flames" and pages 230 to 266 of her memoir. In the Colombian Consulate in Miami, where she was granted political asylum on June 3, 2010, she described the drug lord's relationship with the Sandinista Junta and the M-19 and a meeting of Escobar and the rebel group commander, Ivan Marino Ospina in which she had been present, two weeks before the latter was killed by the Army on 29 August 1985. She said that, in mid-1986, Escobar had told her that he had paid the rebels one million dollars in cash and another in arms and explosives to steal his files from the Palace of Justice before the Supreme Court could begin their study to decide on the extradition of the leading members of the cocaine cartels to the United States of America. During the testimonial, that lasted five hours, Vallejo also described sixteen photographs of bodies that had been anonymously sent to her in 1986. According to her, Escobar identified them as the employees of the Palace cafeteria and two rebel women who had been detained by the Army after the siege, tortured and disappeared, on orders of Colonel Edilberto Sánchez, the director of B-2, Military Intelligence. In October 2008, excerpts of Virginia Vallejo's testimonial, given under gag order, appeared in the Colombian newspaper El Tiempo. On radio stations, Vallejo accused the Colombian General's Attorney's Office of filtering it to the media and of adulterating the contents to favor the military and former presidential candidate Alberto Santofimio.[34][35][36]

2010 Sentence against Colonel Plazas[edit]

In 2010, retired Colonel Alfonso Plazas Vega was punished with 30 years of jail time for his role in forced disappearances after the siege.[37]

The President of Colombia, Álvaro Uribe, reacted by declaring that he was "sad and hurt" by the decision. He announced his intention of seeking changes to the way military are judged in Colombia and asked for jail time for those he called the "instigators" of the massacre.[38] Uribe also had a meeting with the military command to find ways to protect them from "judiciary decisions that interfere with their work".[39]

Nevertheless, Colombia's General Attorney has declared that crimes against humanity took place during the siege, which has allowed for the continued processing of another colonel and one general involved in the incident.[24] María Stella Jara, the judge that handed the sentence to Colonel Plazas left the country after receiving multiple death threats to her and her son. She and her family had to live under heavy surveillance for the duration of the trial[40]

References[edit]

  1. ^ Livingstone, Grace (2004). Inside Colombia: Drugs, Democracy, and War. Rutgers University Press. p. 55. ISBN 0-8135-3443-7. 
  2. ^ Pearce, Jenny (1 May 1990). Colombia:Inside the Labyrinth. Latin America Bureau. p. 181. ISBN 0-906156-44-0. 
  3. ^ Acosta, Mauricio (director) (2011). El Palacio de Justicia [The Palace of Justice] (Television production) (in Spanish). History Channel. Event occurs at 01:32-01:39. Retrieved March 15, 2013. 
  4. ^ a b c http://www.palaciodejusticia.org/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=30:la-toma-del-palacio-minuto-a-minuto&catid=21
  5. ^ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ObMuKzY1Xqk
  6. ^ http://dialnet.unirioja.es/servlet/articulo?codigo=3744850
  7. ^ Consejo Superior de la Judicatura. (2005). Libro Blanco. 20 años del Holocausto del Palacio de Justicia. Bogotá: Legis. p. 93.
  8. ^ Consejo Superior de la Judicatura. (2005). Libro Blanco. 20 años del Holocausto del Palacio de Justicia. Bogotá: Legis. p. 101.
  9. ^ a b c d e Consejo Superior de la Judicatura. (2005). Libro Blanco. 20 años del Holocausto del Palacio de Justicia. Bogotá: Legis. p. 102.
  10. ^ Consejo Superior de la Judicatura. (2005). Libro Blanco. 20 años del Holocausto del Palacio de Justicia. Bogotá: Legis. pp. 102-103.
  11. ^ Official Report. Commission of Truth. Colombia Supreme Court Justice / Preliminary Report November 2005. See also, Ambito Juridico Law Review Journal. Legis, 6 de Noviembre de 2005.
  12. ^ Adriana Echeverry; Ana María Hanssen (2005). Holocausto en el silencio (in Spanish). Editorial Planeta. p. 156. 
  13. ^ Carrigan, Ana.(1963)."The Palace of Justice: A Colombian Tragedy", p.160. New York: Four Walls Eight Windows.
  14. ^ Palace Of Justice Siege
  15. ^ Rama Judicial
  16. ^ Carrigan, Ana (1993). The Palace of Justice: A Colombian Tragedy. Four Walls Eight Windows. p. 268. ISBN 0-941423-82-4. 
  17. ^ Carrigan, p. 279
  18. ^ "Un Grito por el Palacio" (in Spanish). Cromos. 25 November 2005. Retrieved 2006-04-03. [dead link]
  19. ^ "Palacio de Justicia, 20 años de dolor". El País. 7 November 2005. Retrieved 2006-04-03. [dead link]
  20. ^ "Diez fallos que hicieron historia". El Espectador. 9 October 2005. Archived from the original on 2005-12-10. Retrieved 2006-04-03. 
  21. ^ "M-19 cambió drogas por armas". El País (in Spanish). 6 October 2005. Retrieved 2006-04-03. [dead link]
  22. ^ Carrigan, p. 263-264, 266, 281
  23. ^ McClintick, David (28 November 1993). "Lost in the Ashes". The Washington Post. pp. X5. 
  24. ^ a b http://www.elpais.com.co/elpais/judicial/noticias/dos-caras-condena-‘historica’
  25. ^ a b c d Carrigan, p. 272
  26. ^ a b c Carrigan, p. 275
  27. ^ Carrigan, p. 265
  28. ^ Carrigan, pp. 269–270
  29. ^ Carrigan, p. 280
  30. ^ Carrigan, pp. 270–271
  31. ^ "Comisión de la Verdad citará al ex presidente Belisario Betancur por toma del Palacio de Justicia". El Tiempo. 10 November 2005. 
  32. ^ "Por video y testimonios reabren caso del Palacio" (in Spanish). El Tiempo. 23 August 2006. 
  33. ^ "En bóveda del B-2 apareció la billetera de magistrado muerto en el Palacio de Justicia" (in Spanish). El Tiempo. 14 May 2007. Retrieved 2007-05-25. [dead link]
  34. ^ Amante de Pablo Escobar afirma que éste pagó por asalto a Palacio de Justicia en 1985
  35. ^ Virginia Vallejo habla sobre el narcotráfico de los 80's en Colombia
  36. ^ Ex presentadora Virginia Vallejo critica que Tribunal haya absuelto a Alberto Santofimio
  37. ^ http://latindispatch.com/2010/06/10/colombian-colonel-alfonso-plazas-vega-sentenced-to-30-years-for-forced-disappearances/
  38. ^ http://colombiareports.com/colombia-news/news/10184-uribe-questions-plazas-vegas-sentence.html
  39. ^ http://colombiareports.com/colombia-news/news/10195-uribe-meets-with-military-over-plazas-vegas-sentence.html
  40. ^ http://www.infosurhoy.com/cocoon/saii/xhtml/es/newsbriefs/saii/newsbriefs/2010/06/24/newsbrief-06

(1) http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052970203413304577088584132407556.html

Further reading[edit]

Books[edit]

Government/NGO reports[edit]

News[edit]

  • Jimenez, Michael F. (5 September 1994). "Dead Beat: A Colombian Journalist's Life Inside the Cocaine Wars.". The Nation 259 (7). p. 246. 
  • Kirby, Peadar (26 February 1994). "Palace where justice was put to death". The Irish Times. p. 8. 
  • McClintick, David (28 November 1993). "Lost in the Ashes". The Washington Post. pp. X5. 
  • Weiner, Lauren (26 December 1993). "Buffoonish Armageddon at the 'Palace of Justice'". The Washington Times. pp. B8. 
  • Impunity Still Surrounds Palace of Justice Tragedy, Inter Press Service