Parallel programming model
A parallel programming model is a concept that enables the expression of parallel programs which can be compiled and executed. The value of a programming model is usually judged on its generality: how well a range of different problems can be expressed and how well they execute on a range of different architectures. The implementation of a programming model can take several forms such as libraries invoked from traditional sequential languages, language extensions, or complete new execution models.
Consensus on a particular programming model is important as it enables software expressed within it to be transportable between different architectures. The von Neumann model has facilitated this with sequential architectures as it provides an efficient bridge between hardware and software, meaning that high-level languages can be efficiently compiled to it and it can be efficiently implemented in hardware.
Main classifications and paradigms
Classifications of parallel programming models can be divided broadly into two areas: process interaction and problem decomposition.
Process interaction relates to the mechanisms by which parallel processes are able to communicate with each other. The most common forms of interaction are shared memory and message passing, but it can also be implicit.
In a shared memory model, parallel tasks share a global address space which they read and write to asynchronously. This requires protection mechanisms such as locks, semaphores and monitors to control concurrent access. Shared memory can be emulated on distributed-memory systems but non-uniform memory access (NUMA) times can come in to play.
In a message passing model, parallel tasks exchange data through passing messages to one another. These communications can be asynchronous or synchronous. The Communicating Sequential Processes (CSP) formalisation of message-passing employed communication channels to 'connect' processes, and led to a number of important languages such as Joyce, occam and Erlang.
In an implicit model, no process interaction is visible to the programmer, instead the compiler and/or runtime is responsible for performing it. This is most common with domain-specific languages where the concurrency within a problem can be more prescribed.
Any parallel program is composed of simultaneously executing processes, problem decomposition relates to the way in which these processes are formulated. This classification may also be referred to as algorithmic skeletons or parallel programming paradigms.
A task-parallel model focuses on processes, or threads of execution. These processes will often be behaviourally distinct, which emphasises the need for communication. Task parallelism is a natural way to express message-passing communication. It is usually classified as MIMD/MPMD or MISD.
A data-parallel model focuses on performing operations on a data set which is usually regularly structured in an array. A set of tasks will operate on this data, but independently on separate partitions. In a shared memory system, the data will be accessible to all, but in a distributed-memory system it will divided between memories and worked on locally. Data parallelism is usually classified as SIMD/SPMD.
Example parallel programming models
- Algorithmic Skeletons
- Distributed Objects
- Remote Method Invocation
- Parallel Random Access Machine
- Stream processing
- Bulk synchronous parallelism
- List of concurrent and parallel programming languages
- Bridging model
- Automatic parallelization
- Degree of parallelism
- Partitioned global address space
- Leslie G. Valiant, A bridging model for parallel computation, Commun. ACM, volume 33, issue 8, August, 1990, pages 103--111
- H. Shan and J. Pal Singh. A comparison of MPI, SHMEM, and Cache-Coherent Shared Address Space Programming Models on a Tightly-Coupled Multiprocessor. International Journal of Parallel Programming, 29(3), 2001.
- H. Shan and J. Pal Singh. Comparison of Three Programming Models for Adaptive Applications on the Origin 2000. Journal of Parallel and Distributed Computing, 62:241–266, 2002.
- About structured parallel programming: Davide Pasetto and Marco Vanneschi. Machine independent Analytical models for cost evaluation of template--based programs, University of Pisa, 1996
- J. Darlinton, M. Ghanem, H. W. To (1993), "Structured Parallel Programming", In Programming Models for Massively Parallel Computers. IEEE Computer Society Press. 1993
- Developing Parallel Programs — A Discussion of Popular Models (Oracle White Paper September 2010)
- Designing and Building Parallel Programs (Section 1.3, 'A Parallel Programming Model')
- Introduction to Parallel Computing (Section 'Parallel Programming Models')