Peter Goldsmith, Baron Goldsmith
|The Right Honourable
The Lord Goldsmith
|Attorney General for England and Wales
Attorney General for Northern Ireland
8 June 2001 – 27 June 2007
|Prime Minister||Tony Blair|
|Preceded by||Gareth Williams|
|Succeeded by||Patricia Scotland|
5 January 1950 |
Liverpool, United Kingdom
|Alma mater||Gonville and Caius College, Cambridge
University College London
Peter Henry Goldsmith, Baron Goldsmith, PC, QC (born 5 January 1950), is a former Attorney General for England and Wales and Northern Ireland. On 22 June 2007, Goldsmith announced his resignation which took effect on 27 June 2007, the same day that prime minister, Tony Blair, stepped down. Goldsmith was the longest serving Labour Attorney General. He currently works for US law firm Debevoise & Plimpton as head of its European litigation practice.
Goldsmith was born in Liverpool and is of Jewish descent, he was educated at Quarry Bank School (now Calderstones School) before reading law at Gonville and Caius College, Cambridge and University College London. He was called to the Bar at Gray's Inn in 1972, practising from Fountain Court Chambers in London. He became a Queen's Counsel in 1987 and a Deputy High Court Judge in 1994 and he was elected the youngest ever Chairman of the Bar of England and Wales in 1995. He was created a Labour Life Peer in 1999, as Baron Goldsmith, of Allerton in the County of Merseyside. He was appointed Her Majesty's Attorney General in June 2001. One of his first acts was to discuss breaches of the injunction against publishing the whereabouts of the offenders in the James Bulger murder case. He became a Privy Counsellor in 2002.
Goldsmith has also held a number of posts in international legal organisations, including Council Member of the International Bar Association (IBA) and of the Union Internationale des Avocats. From 1998 until his appointment as Attorney General he was co-Chairman of the IBA’s Human Rights Institute. Between 1997 and 2000 he was Chairman of the Financial Reporting Review Panel, a non-departmental public body responsible for enforcing financial reporting standards. In 1997 he was elected to membership of the American Law Institute and made a member of the Paris Bar.
In 1996 he founded the Bar Pro Bono Unit of which he was Chairman until 2000 and remains President. He was the Prime Minister's Personal Representative to the Convention for the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union.
In 2006, Goldsmith gave a speech at the Royal United Services Institute, calling for the closure of the US detention camp at Guantanamo Bay. Goldsmith called it a "symbol of injustice", and said that it did not respect the rights of liberty or freedom.
In 2007, Goldsmith was accused of attempting to cover up the BAE-Saudi corruption case by ordering the Serious Fraud Office to call off its ongoing investigation into the matter, arguing that it might "compromise national security."
Invasion of Iraq controversy
The Government turned down repeated calls to break with tradition and have the advice made public. Goldsmith's original memo to the Prime Minister written on 30 January 2003 opined that UN Resolution 1441 did not sanction the use of force and that a further resolution would be required before military action. A subsequent memo written on 7 March 2003, was eventually leaked to the press, which led to its official publication on 28 April 2005. In the memo, Lord Goldsmith discussed whether the use of force in Iraq could legally be justified by Iraq's 'material breach', as established in UN Security Council Resolution 1441, of its ceasefire obligations as imposed by Security Council Resolution 687 at the end of the First Gulf War. Goldsmith concluded that 'a reasonable case can be made that resolution 1441 is capable in principle of reviving the authorisation [of the use of force] in Resolution 678 without a further resolution.' However, Goldsmith did concede that 'a court might well conclude that operative paragraphs 4 and 12 do require a further Council decision in order to revive the authorisation.' In this Memo he also concluded "the argument that resolution 1441 alone has revived the authorisation to use force in resolution 678 will only be sustainable if there are strong factual grounds for concluding that Iraq has failed to take the final opportunity. In other words, we would need to be able to demonstrate hard evidence of non-compliance and non-cooperation."
In his final advice to the Government, written on 17 March 2003, Goldsmith stated that the use of force in Iraq was lawful. This advice stated Goldsmith's preferred view in more unequivocal terms than his earlier memo, without reference to the doubts expressed therein. This has led to allegations that Goldsmith succumbed to political pressure to find legal justification for the use of force against Iraq. Shortly after the leak Goldsmith released a statement in response to such allegations, saying that the two documents were consistent, pointing to the difference in the nature of the two documents and to the firm assurances he claims to have had received between 7 and 17 March that Iraq was indeed in breach of its obligations under Security Council resolutions.
The controversy was heightened by the resignation of Elizabeth Wilmshurst, deputy legal adviser at the Foreign and Commonwealth Office, on 20 March 2003. A full version of her letter of resignation became public in March 2005. In this, Wilmshurst stated that the reason for her resignation was that she did not agree with the official opinion that the use of force in Iraq was legal. She also accused Goldsmith of changing his view on the matter. In the course of her testimony to the Iraq Inquiry commission, Wilmshurst, even though she understood that "Goldsmith was put into an impossible position", she expressed her disapproval of the way Goldsmith set about in formulating his eventual opinion, stating she thought that "the process that was followed in this case was lamentable," adding that she believes "there should have been a greater transparency within [the British] government about the "evolving legal advice." On the efforts of the Attorney General to determine the nature of the alleged Iraqi breaches, she expressed her disapproval of Goldsmith relying, in part, for his legal opinion, "on private conversations he had with British and US negotiators on what the French [negotiators] had said," while "of course, he hadn't asked the French themselves."
In November 2008, the former Lord Chief Justice and Senior Law Lord Lord Bingham of Cornhill stated that Goldsmith's advice contained "no hard evidence" that Iraq had defied UN resolutions "in a manner justifying resort to force" and that the invasion was "a serious violation of international law and of the rule of law."
Goldsmith has been appointed head of European Litigation at the London office of US law firm Debevoise & Plimpton.
He is the first retiring Attorney General ever to join a law firm. In August 2008, Goldsmith qualified as a solicitor of the Supreme Court of England and Wales in order to become a full equity partner of the firm (and so share in the firm's profits and acquire an ownership share in the firm). He is reported - by The Guardian newspaper on 27 September 2007 - to be remunerated at the rate of £1 million a year in his new position. The same report said that he would have expected to earn more than that if he had resumed practice at the English Bar.
Upon leaving office, former Attorneys General usually return to practise at the Bar, often at the chambers which they left upon appointment as Attorney. Unlike the position with retired Lords Chancellor, there is no prohibition on an Attorney General returning to practise at the Bar.
As a former Minister and holder of public office, Goldsmith has had to accept a number of restrictions on his freedom to practise for two years after leaving office. The restrictions are imposed by the prime minister on the advice of the Advisory Committee on Business Appointments, a branch of the Cabinet Office (www.acoba.gov.uk).
Goldsmith's restrictions prevent him, for 12 months after leaving office, from being personally involved in lobbying Government Ministers or officials. For two years after leaving office, he is required to stand aside from dealing with any matter about which he had confidential or privileged information acquired while he was Attorney General.
- "Debevoise coup with Lord Goldsmith hire". Legal Week. 27 September 2007. Retrieved 28 September 2007.
- The London Gazette: . 5 August 1999.
-  Report of Lord Goldsmith's Visit to Kenyan charities]
- "UK calls for Guantanamo closure". BBC. 10 May 2006. Retrieved 23 June 2007.
- Mail on Sunday (18 February 2007). "Another law chief admits affair with barrister". Retrieved 23 June 2007.
- The Independent (9 June 2007). "Goldsmith denies cover-up over BAE's alleged Saudi fund". London. Retrieved 2007-06-23.
- The Guardian (11 June 2007). "New pressure on Goldsmith after cabinet inquiry call". London. Retrieved 23 June 2007.
- "A Very British Deceit", Philippe Sands QC, NYRB, 30 September 2010
- BBC News (7 March 2003). "Iraq resolution 1441 advice - original memo" (pdf). Retrieved 23 June 2007.
- The Guardian (17 March 2003). "A case for war - Lord Goldsmith's published advice on the legal basis for the use of force against Iraq". London. Retrieved 23 June 2007.
- The Observer (29 February 2004). "Army chiefs feared Iraq war illegal just days before start". The Guardian (London). Retrieved 23 June 2007.
- BBC News (24 March 2005). "Wilmshurst resignation letter". Retrieved 2007-06-23.
- BBC Newnight report of Elizabeth Wilmshurst's testimony to the Iraq Inquiry, 26 January 2010
- BBC News (18 November 2008). "Iraq war 'violated rule of law'". Retrieved 2008-11-18.
- "Goldsmith admits to changing view over Iraq advice". BBC. 27 January 2010. Retrieved 29 January 2010.
- Debevoise & Plimpton Lawyer Profiles
- "Board of Directors". Westfield Group. Retrieved 11 May 2009.
- The Legal Secretariat to the Law Officers: Attorney General — a biography
- Written answer on Iraq advice — from BBC News
- Announcement of Lord Goldsmith's introduction at the House of Lords
- "The Legal Advice to Wage War on Iraq was not just 'sexed-up', it was concocted" by C. Stephen Frost, from GlobalResearch.ca, November 28, 2008
The Lord Williams of Mostyn
|Attorney General for England and Wales
The Baroness Scotland of Asthal
|Attorney General for Northern Ireland