Pierre Brossolette

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Pierre Brossolette
Born (1903-06-25)25 June 1903
Paris XVI, France
Died 22 March 1944(1944-03-22) (aged 40)
Paris V, France
Resting place
Père Lachaise Cemetery's Columbarium
Other names Pedro, Brumaire, Bourgat, Bernier, Baron, Boutet, Briant
Education Agrégé in History
Alma mater École Normale Supérieure
Occupation Journalist and politician
Title Commandant (Major)
Spouse(s) Gilberte Brossolette
Children Anne Brossolette-Branco, Claude Pierre-Brossolette
Awards
Website
www.pierrebrossolette.com

Pierre Brossolette (25 June 1903 – 22 March 1944) was a French journalist, left-wing politician, a top leader, and a major hero of the French Resistance.

Biography[edit]

Education and journalism[edit]

Pierre Brossolette was born in Paris, France to a family deeply involved in the fights for laic schools in early 20th century France. His father was Léon Brossolette, General Inspector for Primary Education, and was the nephew of Francisque Vial, Director of Secondary Education, responsible for making secondary education free in France.

Pierre ranked first at the entrance examination to the prestigious École Normale Supérieure, and throughout his education held the title of "cacique" which was internally attributed to the most brilliant student, ahead of intellectuals such as philosopher Vladimir Jankélévitch and two years before Jean-Paul Sartre and Raymond Aron. In 1925 he graduated second to Georges Bidault after a small scandal on the dissertation themes for the final examination. His passion for history had led him to choose this "agrégation" instead of the more usual and prestigious philosophy one. During this time he married Gilberte Bruel and had two children, Anne and Claude.

Instead of pursuing an academic career like most normaliens, he longed for action and decided to enter journalism and politics. He joined the Section française de l'Internationale ouvrière (SFIO), the main socialist party, in 1929, adhered to the LDH and LICA league and entered freemasonry. He worked as a journalist for Notre Temps, L'Europe Nouvelle, the party newspaper Le Populaire and the state-owned Radio PTT but was fired when he violently opposed the Munich Agreement on air in 1939. In his newspaper columns, Brossolette had evolved from a resolute pacifist and europeanist, after Aristide Briand's ideals, to a denunciator of both fascism and communism.

Resistance[edit]

When World War II broke out, he joined the army as a lieutenant of the 5e RI regiment and, before the fall of France, reached the rank of captain receiving two citations for the French War Cross for having retreated his battalion in an orderly way. After the Armistice, when the Vichy regime forbade him to teach, Brossolette and his wife took over a bookstore specialized in Russian literature at rue de la Pompe near Lycée Janson-de-Sailly (where he had actually attended high school). The bookstore became an intelligence hub of Parisian resistance where documents, such as Renault factory plans used for its bombing, were exchanged unnoticed, thanks to the extensive library available underground.

He was a popular voice on the radio before the war and his chronicles on Hitler's rise led to being blacklisted early in the 1930s by the Nazis. It did not take long before he was approached by his friend Agnès Humbert and introduced to Jean Cassou and the Groupe du musée de l'Homme, the very first resistance network. He just had time to produce the last issue of the newsletter Résistance before narrowly escaping its dismantlement.

Bookstore at Rue de la Pompe

By then assuming a pivotal role in the ZO (Zone Occupée) Resistance, Brossolette coordinated contacts between groups such as Libération-Nord from Christian Pineau, Organisation Civile et Militaire (OCM) and Comité d'Action Socialiste (CAS). He finally obtained a liaison with London and General Charles de Gaulle when he was hired by conservative Gilbert Renault a.k.a. Colonel Rémy as press and propaganda manager of Confrérie Notre-Dame (CND), by then the most important network in northern France.

In April 1942, Brossolette met De Gaulle in London as representative of the ZO Resistance and was hired to work on bringing political credibility to De Gaulle to back his recognition as the only Free French Forces leader by the Allies in his feud against Henri Giraud in Algiers. At the same time, he was promoted to major (commandant) and awarded Compagnon de la Libération.

Brossolette created the civilian arm of the BCRAM intelligence service, which became the Bureau Central de Renseignements et d’Action (BCRA), in liaison with the RF section of the British side, Special Operations Executive (SOE). Strong ties of camaraderie were forged between Brossolette (codenamed Brumaire, a.k.a Commandant Bourgat), BCRA's chief André Dewavrin (codenamed Arquebuse, a.k.a. Colonel Passy) and SOE's Forest Frederick Edward Yeo-Thomas (codenamed Shelley, a.k.a. The White Rabbit).

Pierre Brossolette (1st left) and Passy (3rd) awarded Compagnon

The three friends were sent on a mission to France and united, under the CCZN (Comité de Coordination de Zone Nord), the various ZO Resistance groups which had been thoroughly divided by political views, including the communist-led Front National (mission Arquebuse-Brumaire), and were thus instrumental in the merging with the ZL (Zone Libre) Resistance similarly united by Jean Moulin under the MUR. This led to the creation of the Conseil National de la Résistance (CNR) by Moulin through the addition of the political parties and unions, and ultimately to De Gaulle's unequivocal recognition as Free France's political representative to the Allies.

During this time, Pierre Brossolette resumed his radio chronicles on BBC with high-profile speeches to the "army of shadows", replacing Maurice Schumann as anchor (38 times). In a speech at the Albert Hall on June 18, 1943, he famously praised the soutiers de la gloire (or "stokers of glory") in a reference to the fallen anonymous soldiers and resistants. Brossolette also resumed his newspaper work through a series of articles on France's situation, including one in La Marseillaise considered by many to be the doctrinal founding of the Gaullisme de guerre movement.

Politics[edit]

In addition to journalism, Pierre Brossolette was also a politician. He was a protégé of Léon Blum and was considered an up-and-coming star of the SFIO party, running elections on his Troyes (Champagne) base. He assumed cabinet functions during the Popular Front government and as a political pundit on official Radio-PTT he was considered the de facto foreign policy spokesman of the socialist government. Already calling for deep rejuvenation of the political class before the war, he attributed French defeat in 1940 to the corrupt political system of the Third Republic.

As he politically structured the Parisian resistance, Brossolette succeeded in convincing the network leaders to create a temporary Resistance Party under De Gaulle's leadership after the war, focused on promoting ambitious social transformations while avoiding the predictable enmity and chaos of post-Liberation times. This political and social plan, including nationalisations and price controls, inspired the March 1944 Conseil national de la Résistance program and was implemented after war.

Brossolette's criticism of the old parliamentarian system, together with the role of communist networks inside the CNR, became the main point of disagreement with his southern counterpart Jean Moulin. His desire to disband all the old parties through a complete reshuffle of ideological lines logically brought him into conflict with the party leaders. As a result, he was excluded from the newly reconstituted SFIO party by Daniel Mayer and Gaston Defferre a few days before being arrested,[1] although the decision to remove him from the party was never enforced and was actually forgotten.

Despite this, most of his ideas were implemented in 1958 when De Gaulle created the Fifth Republic and established a presidentialist system based around his RPF party. However, De Gaulle was pushed in the short term to decide in favour of Jean Moulin's proposal as he still struggled to show the Allies (Americans in particular) that he was not a dictator. Brossolette's ideas of a Resistance party raised many opponents' fears of a "bonapartian" drift, especially among fellow socialists in London among which Pierre Cot and Raymond Aron. This seemed to be confirmed to his detractor's eyes when Brossolette succeeded a bold blow against the Vichy regime by exfiltrating from France Charles Vallin, deputy leader of conservative PSF (Parti Social Français) that had surged as the main French party with over 30% at pre-war elections, but deemed proto-fascist by the left. Hence the French Fourth Republic eventually reverted to the Third Republic's pre-war parliamentarist system.

During his last missions, Brossolette worked on creating a new party that could be the major force of the left. He was inspired by the British Labour party, utilizing a non-Marxist or, at least, reformist approach (thus effectively challenging the French Socialist Party). For that, he spent his last days writing an ambitious critique of Marx's political philosophy as a by-product of 18th century rationalism that would provide the theoretical framework for this party. Unfortunately, at the time of his arrest the manuscripts were thrown overboard at sea over Brittany shores.[2]

Arrest[edit]

Brossolette returned to Paris for a third mission to reorganize the Parisian Resistance which was in disarray after successive Gestapo raids, in special by CND's dismantlement. By then, his role and importance was already well known to the SS Intelligence Services after Jean Moulin's death and despite De Gaulle's clear reluctance to appoint him as substitute CNR chief. He escaped arrest many times and was summoned to return to Britain by late 1943 to introduce the newly appointed CNR chief, Émile Bollaert, to De Gaulle. The bad winter weather cancelled many Lysander exfiltration attempts (conducted only under moonlight) or Lysanders would be shot down as in a December attempt near Laon, so in February 1944, they decided to return by boat from Brittany. But the vessel, hit by a storm, shipwrecked at Pointe du Raz. They managed to reach the coast and to be hidden by local Resistance, but were betrayed by a local woman at a checkpoint.

Bollaert and Brossolette were not identified and were kept imprisoned in Rennes for weeks. Yeo-Thomas, when informed of Brossolette's capture, decided to be immediately parachuted onto the continent and organize his escape. But they were recognized before the planned action and taken to the Intelligence Services (Sicherheitsdienst) headquarters on Avenue Foch by senior SD officer Ernst Misselwitz in person on March 19. It was recently confirmed that he was identified by a semi-coded report to London from CNR's Claude Bouchinet-Serreules and Jacques Bingen written by the services of Daniel Cordier intercepted at the Pyrenees, tragically self-fulfilling the severe criticism of Brossolette and Yeo-Thomas about the lack of prudence inside the Parisian Délégation générale. Yeo-Thomas himself would be captured as he prepared a bold escape from Rennes prison wearing German uniforms with the help of Brigitte Friang. Both Yeo-Thomas and Friang were captured before planned action as many Parisians networks were dismantled following the so-called "Rue de la Pompe Affair" (after the location of the Delegation générale) and Pierre Manuel's avows. (Seaman, 1997)

Death[edit]

Brossolette was tortured at the Gestapo HQ, enduring severe beatings and waterboardings over a two and a half day period. On March 22, while he was left alone and recovered some consciousness, he threw himself through the window of the garret room of the HQ's sixth floor. Since he had not swallowed his cyanide capsule when captured in Rennes, he was afraid of implicating others and probably chose to silence himself. There was a widespread belief among resistants that it was difficult, if not impossible, not to speak under torture.

He died later in the evening at La Pitié-Salpêtrière hospital and, on March 24, was cremated at Père-Lachaise without being identified. His ashes are kept at the Père Lachaise cemetery's columbarium and attributed to urn 3913 though the latter is labeled "unknown". It was believed for long that urn 3920 kept the ashes of another resistant, François Delimal and that actually their ashes could have been exchanged, but it is proved now that this urn is unattributed and moreover that François Delimal's ashes are normally kept since the early 70's at Passy's cemetery. Brossolette's reportedly last words were enigmatic: "all will be fine Tuesday".

Posterity[edit]

Brossolette Aeolian Memorial at Narbonne-Plage. Wind pipes played the four chords of Beethoven's 5th Symphony as per BBC's Radio Londres opening [3]

From after the war until the late 1950s, Brossolette was considered the main leader of the French Resistance, though many were claimed heroes by their political family (such as Honoré d'Estienne d'Orves by royalists and Gabriel Péri by communists). Brossolette's fame was helped by his media notoriety before the war on Radio-PTT and on wartime BBC emissions, his networking role that made his name or codename known and remembered over almost every Resistance member in northern France and by flattering early accounts of BCRA's chief Passy in his memoirs although he had also created, through his independent position and sarcastic wit, many enemies among party leaders, Gaullists, communists and even socialists that survived him. (Roussel, 2011; Seaman, 1997)

De Gaulle himself thought otherwise and as he started writing his memoirs on 1954 and later assumed power, he attributed the main leading role to his by-then relatively unknown representative Jean Moulin rather than field leaders as De Gaulle emphasized the top-down unification work that objectively allowed him to be recognized by the Allies. This was formalized in 1964 by the transfer of Moulin's ashes to the Panthéon, and backed by an emotional speech by André Malraux. (Piketty, 1998)

With time, Brossolette was relegated to a second place and became the hero of his party SFIO while Moulin came to symbolize the myth of the French Resistance unity while the country struggled with the Algerian war and as De Gaulle tried to avoid civil war calling for union while noticing the growing popular clout of the Resistance legend on the postwar imagination. (Douzou, 2005)

Later, Brossolette's memory suffered another blow when the 1981-elected socialist president François Mitterrand chose to honour Moulin at a Panthéon investiture ceremony instead of rehabilitating Brossolette's role. This further enhanced his relegation - even inside the socialist political family, as evidenced by the modest celebrations of his birth centenary in 2003 and the SFIO/PS centenary.[4] At the time, a senior party official Harlem Désir (currently secretary-general of the PS) anecdotally told that the most important figure of the party's century was Jean Moulin - who actually never was a party member and deemed instead close to the Radical Party.

Since then, he has been fairly better remembered than heroes such as Bingen, Jean Cavaillès or Berty Albrecht [5] or important leaders such as Henri Frenay, but overall eclipsed by Moulin's popularity. More recently in 2013, a support committee presided by historian Mona Ozouf was set up in order to bid for the transfer of Pierre Brossolette's ashes to the Panthéon, backed by an internet petition at the committee's site.

Homages[edit]

In France today Brossolette's name is better known than the man himself or his life achievements, thanks to the great number of streets - nearly 500 out of which 127 in Greater Paris, schools and public facilities bearing it (see below). His widow Gilberte was prominent in relaying his political ideas. In the 1950s, she was the first woman to enter – and, as vice-president, occasionally preside over – the French Senate.

In Paris, a small street in the Quartier Latin between Rue Érasme and Rue Calvin, near École Normale Supérieure, was christened Rue Pierre-Brossolette in 1944 as among the very few celebrating a 20th-century person, together with Pierre and Marie Curie.[6] A notable exception is Lyon, probably illustrating the rivalries between the two Zones as conversely no street in Paris had been christened after Jean Moulin until 1965.

Buildings in Paris such as the former bookstore and nearby Lycée Janson de Sailly's court at Rue de la Pompe, the residence at Rue de Grenelle, his birthplace at rue Michel-Ange, the Maison de Radio France and the Ministry of the Interior's court at Rue des Saussaies all feature commemorative plaques and his name is mentioned on a floor plaque at the Panthéon. Brossolette's ashes are currently kept at the columbarium of Père Lachaise Cemetery (urns 3902 or 3913).

In Narbonne plage, a unique aeolian memorial attests to his popularity in the early postwar years and marks the place of his exfiltration by felucca Seadog.[7] In Saint-Saëns, a stele commemorates the first Lysander exfiltration to London [8] and nearby Plogoff another marks the failed Brittany exfiltration attempt.

Brossolette was also featured in the first series of postage stamps of Resistance heroes by French PTT in 1957. The Saint-Cyr Military Academy ROTC Class of 2004 was christened after Brossolette, and a class song was created for the occasion.[9] The masonic Grande Loge de France named its cultural circle after Condorcet-Brossolette.

Military honours[edit]

Croix de guerre 1939-45 Compagnon of the Order of  Liberation Médaille de la Résistance Croix de guerre 1939-45 with palm Légion d'honneur

Operations & Missions[edit]

  • April 27, 1942 - Saint-Saëns (near Rouen) - 1st exfiltration
  • June 3, 1942 - Chalon-sur-Saône - blind dropping (single)
  • Operation Leda - Sept. 5th, 1942 - Narbonne - 2nd exfiltration - felucca Seadog
  • Operation Atala - Jan. 26th, 1943 - Le Grand-Malleray (near Bourges) - dropping (single)
  • Mission Arquebuse-Brumaire - Jan-April 1943
  • Operation Liberté/Juliette - April 15, 1943 - 3rd exfiltration - Lysander (w/ André Dewavrin and Yeo-Thomas)
  • Trip to Algiers - Aug 13 - Sept. 3rd, 1943
  • Operation Bomb - Sept. 18th, 1943 - Angoulême - Lysander (w/ Yeo-Thomas)
  • Mission Marie-Claire - Sept-Feb 1944
  • Operation Sten - Dec. 10th, 1944 - near Laon - cancelled (Lysander shot down)

Famous quote[edit]

"For the French. the war will be over when they will be able to read Le Canard enchaîné and see this wonderful movie [ Gone with the Wind ]"—to Jean-Pierre Melville in front of Ritz Theater in London, adapted in the same location to Luc Jardie, interpreted by Paul Meurisse in the movie Army of Shadows produced in 1969.[10]

"Mon Général, (...) There are times when someone must have the courage to say out loud what others whisper behind your back with weeping faces. There are subjects on which you do not tolerate any contradiction, let alone any debate. Moreover, these subjects are generally those in which your position is most emotional, i.e. precisely those on which you would have great interest in being tested against other people's reactions (...) Among your entourage, the not-so-good only go after your approval; the worst make a policy of coaxing you; the best soon cease to readily offer themselves to discussion. You end up reaching the situation, restful amid your daily worries, where you no longer meet anything but flattering assentment. But you know as well as me where this path has led others than you in history, and where it risks to lead yourself " - letter to General de Gaulle, 1942

Notes[edit]

  1. ^ (French) "Témoignage de Gaston Defferre". Retrieved 2008-09-02. 
  2. ^ (French) "Pierre Brossolette". Retrieved 208-01-19.  Check date values in: |accessdate= (help)
  3. ^ The then-deserted beach was a popular spot for embarkment to London via Gibraltar. The pipes have been muted after neighbourhood protests as it developed, postwar, into a popular balneary area.
  4. ^ (French) "Centenaire du Parti socialiste - Pierre Brossolette". Centenaire du Parti socialiste - Pierre Brossolette. 
  5. ^ (French) "Autour de Jean Moulin : Histoire et Mémoire". Retrieved 2008-01-17. 
  6. ^ (French) "Noms de martyrs donnés au rues de Paris (Video - 1944 - source INA)". Retrieved 2009-09-25. 
  7. ^ "Seawolf & Seadog". Retrieved 2009-09-26. 
  8. ^ (French) "Inauguration d'une stèle à la memoire de Pierre Brossolette à Saint Saëns (Video - 1975 - source INA)". Retrieved 2009-09-25. 
  9. ^ (French) "Chant de promotion - IVe Bataillon - Saint-Cyr - Promotion Pierre Brossolette - 2003/2004". Retrieved 2009-09-25. 
  10. ^ "Melville on Army of Shadows". Retrieved 2009-09-25. 

References[edit]

  • René Ozouf, Pierre Brossolette, héros de la résistance, librairie Gedalge, 1946.
  • Colonel Passy, Souvenirs - Tome 1 : 2e bureau, Londres (1940-1941), Raoul Solar, 1947 - Tome 2 : 10, Duke Street, Londres (le B.C.R.A), Raoul Solar, 1951 - Tome 3 : Missions secrètes en France (novembre 1942-juin 1943), Plon, 1951; republished Mémoires du chef des services secrets de la France libre, Odile Jacob, 2000
  • Bruce Marshall, The White Rabbit, Evans Bros., 1952 ; Greenwood Press, 1987; Cassel Military Paperbacks, 2000.
  • Agnès Humbert, Notre guerre: souvenirs de résistance, éd. Émile Paul, 1946; republished éd. Tallandier, 2004; Memoirs of Occupied France (tr. Barbara Mellor), London, Bloomsbury Publishing PLC, 2008
  • Charles de Gaulle, Mémoires de guerre, éd. Plon, Paris, 1954 ; republished éd.Pocket, 1999, 2007
  • Gilberte Brossolette, Il s'appelait Pierre Brossolette, éd. Albin Michel, 1976
  • Guy Perrier, Pierre Brossolette, le visionnaire de la Résistance, éd. Hachette littératures, 1997
  • Mark Seaman, Bravest of the Brave, Isis LP Books, 1997
  • Guillaume Piketty, Pierre Brossolette, un héros de la Résistance, éd. Odile Jacob, 1998
  • Pierre Brossolette, Résistance (1927-1943), éd. Odile Jacob, 1998 (assembled by Guillaume Piketty)
  • Guillaume Piketty, Daniel Cordier, Alain Finkielkraut, Pierre Brossolette ou le destin d'un héros, éd. du Tricorne, 2000
  • Julian Jacson - France - The dark years, 1940-1944, Oxford University Press, 2001
  • Guillaume Piketty, Pierre Brossolette, le rude parcours d'une mémoire, Les Chemins de la Mémoire, n° 128, mai 2003
  • Laurent Douzou, La résistance française, une histoire périlleuse. éd. du Seuil, 2005
  • Éric Roussel, Pierre Brossolette, éd. Fayard, 2011
  • Sébastien Albertelli, Les Services secrets du général de Gaulle, le BCRA 1940-1944, Perrin, 2009

External links[edit]

See also[edit]