The Players (New York City)
|Location||16 Gramercy Park, Manhattan, New York City, New York|
|Architect||Stanford White (1888 renovations)|
|NRHP Reference #||66000549|
|Added to NRHP||October 15, 1966|
|Designated NHL||December 29, 1962 |
|Designated NYCL||March 15, 1966|
The Players, or the Players Club, is a social club founded in New York City by the noted 19th-century Shakespearean actor Edwin Booth, who purchased an 1847 mansion located at 16 Gramercy Park. During his lifetime, he reserved an upper floor for his home, turning the rest of the building over to the Clubhouse. Its interior and part of its exterior was designed by architect Stanford White. It was named a National Historic Landmark in 1962.
In 1989, women were invited to become fully participating members.
The Players still maintains its entryway gaslights, which are among the few remaining examples in New York City.
On April 14, 1865, Edwin's younger brother John Wilkes, a popular actor, assassinated President Abraham Lincoln, after which the life of his family changed. In 1888 Edwin Booth purchased the former residence of Valentine G. Hall in Gramercy Square and, perhaps inspired by London's Garrick Club, established a social club which would bring actors into contact with men of different professions such as industrialists, writers and other creative artists.
The building Booth had purchased was completely redesigned, furnished, equipped and decorated with Booth's personal possessions. When ready, a series of meetings was held, and a small group of founding fathers turned the Clubhouse over to newly invited members in a grand ceremony on December 31, 1888.
In the title papers, it is stated that Edwin Booth should retain a furnished apartment for his own use where he could be left undisturbed as he wished. Booth made his home at The Players, where he died June 7, 1893, at the age of 59.
Members of the Players included the local pillars of society of the day, prominent bankers, lawyers and businessmen, as well as those identified with other arts - writers, journalists, sculptors, architects and painters.
Presidents of the club have included Joseph Jefferson, who succeeded Booth as president after his death, John Drew Jr, Walter Hampden, Howard Lindsay, Dennis King, Alfred Drake, Roland Winters, Jose Ferrer, Robert Lansing, John Bartholomew Tucker pro temp, Michael Allinson and Lynn Redgrave. President Timothy Hutton resigned on June 5, 2008, due to work keeping him on the West Coast. New York producer and longtime member Herb Blodgett took his place, and in June 2010, it was announced that theatrical manager Johnnie Planco would replace him.
Some past and present notable members include: Samuel Clemens (Mark Twain), George M. Cohan, William Astor Chanler, Stanford White, Nikola Tesla, John Barrymore, Eugene O'Neill, James Cagney, Gregory Peck, Alfred Lunt, Robert M. McBride, Walter Cronkite, Alexander Woollcott, Kevin Spacey, Judy Collins, Rue McClanahan, George S. Kaufman, Angela Lansbury, Sidney Poitier, Tony Bennett, Tony Roberts, Carol Burnett, Liza Minnelli, Dick Cavett, Billy Connolly, Vartan Gregorian, Hal Holbrook, George Innes, Eli Wallach, Robert Vaughn, Ben Gazzara, Christopher Plummer, Budd Schulberg, Ethan Hawke, Jimmy Fallon, Marian Seldes, Peter O'Toole, Rosemary Harris, Roger Moore, Russell Miller, and Sidney Zion.
The longtime syndicated columnist Earl Wilson said in 1964: "Long ago a New Yorker asked the difference between the Lambs, Friars, and Players, since the membership was, at the time, predominantly from Broadway. ... [A] wit believed to have been George S. Kaufman [drew the distinction:] The Players are gentlemen trying to be actors, the Lambs are actors trying to be gentlemen, and the Friars are neither trying to be both."
Beginning in the 1970s, widows of club members were afforded limited privileges to the club, but in September 1987, the club voted to allow women to be full members for the first time. One benefit to the club of doing so was that once women were admitted, the Players could then rent out its facilities for outside functions, which it had not been allowed to do before under New York City law.
The Players serves as a social club but is also a repository of American and British theatre history, memorabilia, and theatrical artifacts. Today, it still holds "Pipe Nights" honoring theatrical notables, and maintains a kitchen and wine cellar and a billiard table in its usually busy Grill room. In the Dining Room, filled with portraits of theatre and film notables and rare playbills from the 19th and 20th centuries, a small stage has been built where members and people of the theatre can be honored; staged readings can take place and new works tried out.
The Players also gives the prestigious "Edwin Booth Life Achievement Award" to actors who have had a long, important body of theatre and film work. Past recipients include Helen Hayes, Jose Ferrer, Garson Kanin, Christopher Plummer, Jason Robards, Jack Lemmon, and Marian Seldes. In June 2007, Angela Lansbury was the recipient, and Edward Albee received it on September 30, 2007.
The Players Club is open Monday through Friday from 10 a.m. to 12 midnight.
The club was the subject of an investigation by the New York State Attorney General's Office beginning in 1996 regarding its financial dealings with the Hampden-Booth Theater Library, which occupies about a third of the club's building, and the John Drew Fund, a charity which has its offices in the building. The allegations were that the club may have overcharged the library for building upkeep, and kept more than its appropriate share of the sale of a collection of books in 1984, using the money to help pay for a major renovation to the building. The club also borrowed money from the John Drew Fund to pay for the renovation, a loan which, at the time the investigation was reported in 2000, had not yet been paid back. The boards of the club, the library, and the fund have overlapping members, a circumstance which may have contributed to the financial irregularities. The dispute between the library and the club was settled, with neither owing the other any money; the settlement also satisfied part of the state's investigation. One of the terms of the settlement was that the club would sell its John Singer Sargent portrait of Edwin Booth to raise money.
A labor dispute in 2008 came about after the club fired 16 union workers in a cost-cutting measure, replacing them with a catering company which used non-union workers. This led to several weeks of picketing of the club by the union, before an arbitrator ruled that the club had breached its agreement with the union, and the workers had to be reinstated with back pay. The club went to court, seeking to overturn the arbitrator's decision, but eventually was fined $100,000. One member was quoted as saying "The [club] is being horribly mismanaged. Nobody knows what they are doing, and the board is a rubber stamp." 
In June 2012, the club's leadership came under criticism from some of its members following allegations of financial mismanagement. The misconduct included selling one of its two paintings by John Singer Sargent for $2.5 million to pay for an estimated $650,000 in repairs to the building's facade; awarding the construction work to the brother of one of its vice presidents; and allowing its rooms to be used by favored parties for free or nominal rates. It was reported that while about 1000 members are needed to keep the club running, the club's rolls following a recent membership drive amounted to only 625. In response, the club has been forced to cut services, assess the members a $450 fee, and borrow $2 million from a member.
In March 2013, it was reported by the New York Times that as of the end of the fiscal year in April 2011, the Club had $448,853 in losses, and it was claimed they owed Con Edison $30,000, although the club Executive Director, John Martello, denied that. In addition, club employees were suing, claiming that their salaries had been paid late and that they were not given money from the year-end tip fund that they were due. At a club meeting, at which Martello narrowly survived a vote to oust him, the club's audit committee reported that the club had been in arrears in it workers' compensation insurance premium payments for 5 months, which lead to a fine of $30,000. The club had also lost its access to Gramercy Park because it has not paid the $7,500 annual assessment. Although the meeting was closed to outsiders, the Times based its report on an audio recording of the meeting it had obtained. Martello was removed as executive director less than three weeks later, on April 4.  Shortly afterward, three members of the club's executive committee resigned and members circulated a petition that called upon the club's president and two vice presidents to step down as well. 
On June 19, 2013, Johnnie Planco was re-elected as President. Planco informed members at that time that the club was about $4 million in debt, and raised the possibility that their clubhouse may have to be sold; some estimates put the value of the property at more than $14 million. In addition, it has been reported that according to the New York City Department of Finance a lien has been placed against the club due to $250,000 in back taxes owed, in addition to other debts. The tax debt has been sold to a third party.
Options under consideration to ameliorate the club's financial problems include, it has been reported, renting the club's rooms for parties and meetings, providing the building to be used as an interior location for film shoots, and selling naming rights to the rooms. Creative partnerships with Actors' Equity the Screen Actors Guild and the Directors Guild are also being pursued. In October 2013, the effort to restore the deteriorating facade of the club's historic building was initiated, with the formation of a not-for-profit 501c3 organization, "The Players, 16 Gramercy Park South Preservation Fund, Inc."
- "National Register Information System". National Register of Historic Places. National Park Service. 2010-07-09.
- Greenwood, Richard (May 30, 1975). "National Register of Historic Places Inventory-Nomination: The Players" (pdf). National Park Service.
- "The Players". National Historic Landmark summary listing. National Park Service. 2007-09-11.
- "National Register of Historic Places Inventory-Nomination: The Players—Accompanying photos" (pdf). National Park Service. 1975.
- Brentano's, Old Buildings of New York City. New York: The Trow Press, 1907, "The Players", pp. 90–91
- The Players "Brief Chronicles", issue dated July 2010
- Wilson, Earl (1964). Earl Wilson’s New York. New York: Simon & Schuster. pp. 49–50.
- Neuffer, Elizabeth. "Players Club Votes for Admission of Women" New York Times (September 29, 1987)
- "About Us" on the Players Club website
- O'Grady, Jim. Neighborhood Report: Gramercy Park: Attorney General Investigating The Venerable Players Club" New York Times (November 12, 2000)
- "Players Club-Library Spat Resolved...Sort of" Billboard
- Grey, Geoffrey. "The Union Rat Descends Upon Gramercy Park" New York (January 31, 2008)
- Reinholz, Mary. "Union Rat Invades Gramercy Park, Emerges Victorious" New York (February 11, 2008)
- Barron, James. "Union Workers Protest Firing by Players Club" New York Times (February 2, 2008)
- Zimmer, Amy. "Gramercy Park's Players Club Crumbling Under $2M Debt" DNAinfo.com New York (April 26, 2012)
- Leland, John. "At Century-Old Club, Money Woes Sour the Mood" New York Times (June 20, 2012)
- Leland, John. "Players Club Stages a Real-Life Drama" New York Times (March 15, 2013)
- Holland, Heather. "Players Club Fined $30K for Failing to Insure Workers, Members Say" DNAinfo.com New York (March 12, 2013)
- Leland, John. "Players Club Removes Director Amid Turmoil" New York Times (April 5, 2013)
- Zimmer, Amy. "Curtains For Three Board Members at Legendary Players Club" DNAinfo.com New York (April 22, 2013)
- Zimmer, Amy. "Doomsday Scenario Would Sell Debt-Ridden Players Club's Gramercy Park Home" DNAinfoNewYork (June 24, 2013)
|Wikimedia Commons has media related to The Players (New York City).|