Poet as legislator
Plato's opposition to poets in his ideal Republic was predicated on the contemporary existence of Homeric expounders who claimed that "a man ought to regulate the tenour of his whole life by this poet's directions". Plato only allowed the already censured poet to guide the young, to be an acknowledged legislator at the price of total external control.
Renaissance and Augustan views
Building the view of the fifteenth century Florentine Neoplatonists on the poet as seer, however, Sir Philip Sidney developed a more powerful concept of the poet as overtopping the philosopher, historian and lawyer to stand out as "the monarch...of all sciences.
Such a viewpoint was more or less institutionalised in Augustan literature, Johnson's Rasselas maintaining for example that the poet "must write as the interpreter of nature and the legislator of mankind" - a fully public, even patriotic role moreover
By contrast the Romantic view of the poet as unackowledged legislator emerges at the turm of the century in the writing of William Godwin, with his anarchic view of the poet as "the legislator of generations and the moral instructor of the world".
It received its most memorable formulation however in Shelley's 1820 A Defence of Poetry. Shelley maintained that, through their powers of imaginative understanding, poets (in the widest sense) were able to identify and formulate emerging socio-cultural trends; and were as a result "the hierophants of an unapprehended inspiration...the unacknowledged legislators of the world".
The grand claims of the Romantics began to give way in the twentieth century to a more ironic stance - Yeats speaking for his calling in general when he wrote "We have no gift to set a statesman right".
- C. Prendergast ed., Cultural Materialism (1995) p. 222
- Richard Holmes, Dr Johnson and Mr Savage (1994) p. 51
- D. Griffin, Patriotism and Poetry in Eighteenth-Century Britain (2005) p. 70
- J. L. Davies/D. J. Vaughan trans., The Republic of Plato (1908) p. 352
- E. B. Castle, Ancient Education and Today (1969) p. 91
- M. H. Abrams, The Mirror and the Lamp (1971) p. 16
- M. H. Abrams, The Mirror and the Lamp (1971) p. 272
- J. A van Dorsten ed, Sidney: A Defence of Poetry (1984) p. 39
- Samuel Johnson, Rasselas (1905) p. 42
- D. Griffin, Patriotism and Poetry in Eighteenth-Century Britain (2005) p. 71-2
- Quoted in J. A. Carlson, England's First Family of Writers (2007) p. 267
- I. Ousby ed., The Cambridge Guide to Literature in English (1995) p. 245
- Quoted in M. H. Abrams, The Mirror and the Lamp (1971) p. 332
- S. Chatterji, Memories of a Lost War (2001) p. 70
- W. B. Yeats, The Poems (1984) p. 155
- Tools of the Sacred