Portal talk:Featured portals
|This is the talk page for discussing improvements to the Featured portals page.|
|Archives: 1, 2|
A proposal to add topical links to all of the contents pages has been made. As part of that proposal, the navigation bar at the top of these contents pages would look like this.
All who read this invitation, please respond to the proposal, Portal talk:Contents#Adding topical links to contents pages navigational headers and footers, as you see fit. Regards, RichardF (talk) 15:30, 30 January 2011 (UTC)
Possible RfC regarding articles to be selected for inclusion in FPs
I was wondering whether it might not be a bad idea to maybe file an RfC for broad community discussion regarding what types of articles we might like to see among those included in portals. Currently, the "default" seems to be to include primarily GA and better quality articles, and I obviously can see including those articles which have been declared among the best we have. The occasional problem with that, perhaps, is that these articles will often, to an extent, be among the less significant articles relating to the specific topic of the portal, and, in some really broad cases, like maybe Portal:Religion for instance, the specific article might be of such comparative lack of importance to the topic of the portal that one might have to read through several levels of subarticles before actually encountering even the first mention of the topic of that article, which might make them, to a degree, comparatively "trivial" to the stated topic of the portal.
Having said that, as I think many of us know, some of the most significant articles directly relating to the stated subject area of a portal are in rather poor shape, if they even actually exist at this point. Maybe one way to go might be to arrange some form of "alternating" choice of quality or significance, but I do personally think that it is almost certainly in the best interests of the portals to see if there is any way to try to bring more attention to some of the most significant articles related to those topics, and maybe find a way to, effectively, increase the "usability" of the portals, particularly for those who may not be as familiar with the topics as others. John Carter (talk) 20:35, 16 December 2012 (UTC)
- That's a good suggestion, in theory. In practice, as you said, many topics do not have high-quality high-importance articles. For those topics which do have good important articles, it's certainly a good idea, though. YPNYPN 04:08, 17 December 2012 (UTC)
- The featured portal criteria say "Because portals promote the best of Wikipedia's content, a featured portal is selective in what it displays. It showcases only high-quality content that is preferably already featured." Wikipedia:Portal guidelines (not part of the criteria) say that the selected articles should be "of high quality, either a featured article, a good article or one which deals with its subject substantially or comprehensively". So the preference is for FAs/FLs/GAs, but it's not a rigid rule. I can see the difficulties here, though - whilst for overarching topics such as "religion", it will likely to be difficult to get sufficient "core" articles to GA/FA standard, it dilutes the standard of promoting the best of Wikipedia's content if featured portals in such areas are allowed to show poor-quality content. I think the acceptability of sub-GA articles in a featured portal candidate is likely to depend on the context i.e. the number of such articles and what percentage of the articles in the portal they form, and the importance/significance of the articles to the portal as opposed to possible alternatives. But don't let me stop you having an RFC - the more attention that portals and featured portals get, the better - and this page is only on a few watchlists at the moment, I suspect. BencherliteTalk 20:27, 18 December 2012 (UTC)
Request for comment at Portal talk:Judaism
An editor has filed a request for comment regarding Portal:Judaism at Portal talk:Judaism#Request for Comment. Any input from knowledgable editors here would be more than welcome. John Carter (talk) 19:15, 19 December 2012 (UTC)
Today's featured portal
An RfC on including featured portals on the Main Page.
Please see Wikipedia:VPR#Today.27s_featured_portal.