Potboiler
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Potboiler or pot-boiler is a term used to describe a poor quality novel, play, opera, or film, or other creative work that was created quickly to make money to pay for the creator's daily expenses (thus the imagery of "boil the pot"[1], which means "to provide one's livelihood"[2]). Authors who create potboiler novels or screenplays are sometimes called hack writers. Novels deemed to be potboilers may also be called pulp fiction or "page-turners", and potboiler films may be called "popcorn movies" or, in film industry slang, "tentpoles" (large-budget films typically based on well-known characters or prior works, which, due to their immense popularity, support the studio economically, like tent poles hold up a tent).
Contents |
[edit] Etymology and usage
[edit] High culture
"In the more elevated arenas of artistry such a motive...was considered deeply demeaning."[3] If a serious playwright or novelist's creation is called a potboiler, this has a negative connotation that suggests that it is a mediocre or inferior-quality work. An early usage of the term that has this sense is in Putnam’s Monthly Magazine of New York, dated 1854: “He has not carelessly dashed off his picture, with the remark that ‘it will do for a pot-boiler’”.[3] Similarly, Jane Scovell's Living in the Shadows states that "...the play was a mixed blessing. Through it O'Neill latched on to a perennial source of income, but the promise of his youth was essentially squandered on a potboiler."
In an early-1980s Time review of a book by Andrew Greeley, the author called his novel Thy Brother's Wife a "...putrid, puerile, prurient, pulpy potboiler." [4] In the late 1990s, American author and newspaper reporter Stephen Kinzer referred to potboilers in this derogatory sense: "If reading and travel are two of life's most rewarding experiences, to combine them is heavenly. I don't mean sitting on a beach reading the latest potboiler, a fine form of relaxation but not exactly mind-expanding."[5]
A definition of potboiler fiction from the 2000s captures the sense that it is an inferior grade of writing; in a Publishers Weekly article, author David Schow called potboilers fiction that "... stacks bricks of plot into a nice, neat line."[6]
[edit] Popular culture
However, for more popular genres, such as action thriller films or detective novels, the term "potboiler" does not have such negative connotations. Indeed, a review praising a thriller film or detective novel may effusively call the work an excellent "potboiler". In a 2007 review of the 1972 Sam Peckinpah film The Getaway, starring Steve McQueen, the review calls it "... a '70s outlaws-on-the-run potboiler; a poor man's Bonnie and Clyde. That doesn't make it a bad film; it's actually a good potboiler. But it does stand out in both the McQueen and Peckinpah canons as a primarily commercial, and not artistic, venture. It's neither artist's finest moment, but there's certainly no reason for them to be embarrassed by the film."[7]
One well-known potboiler is A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens.[8] Television host Mike Wallace used the term while interviewing writer Rod Serling about his upcoming show, The Twilight Zone. At that time, science fiction writing was widely considered amateurish and juvenile, and Wallace questioned whether or not Serling was moving away from "serious" writing. However, Serling's series became an influential part of television.[9] Many current popular novels are indiscernably potboilers. However their use of interesting titles enables publishers to attempt to sell them as if they were more original, more creative works. This is expectable, given how many themes and ideas are constantly being re-used, and quite successfully.
[edit] See also
[edit] Sources and notes
- ^ wordnet.princeton.edu/perl/webwn
- ^ The American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language, Fourth Edition copyright ©2000 by Houghton Mifflin Company. Updated in 2003. Published by Houghton Mifflin Company
- ^ a b http://www.worldwidewords.org/qa/qa-pot1.htm "Potboiler" at World Wide Words
- ^ The Luck of Andrew Greeley Monday, Jul. 12, 1982 By MAYO MOHS Article ToolsPrintEmailReprints THY BROTHER'S WIFE by Andrew M. Greeley; Warner; 350 pages; $14.95
- ^ "Traveling Companions," [2]New York Times, April 19, 1998
- ^ From Splatterpunk to Bullets. Publishers Weekly Talks with David Schow by Stefan Dziemianowicz. Publishers Weekly, 10/6/2003
- ^ 403 Forbidden
- ^ Mendelssohn Club of Philadelphia - Program Notes
- ^ Sander, Gordon F.:Serling: The Rise And Twilight of Television's Last Angry Man. New York: Penguin Books, 1992.
