|Some or all of this article's listed sources may not be reliable. (August 2011)|
A puppy mill, sometimes known as a puppy farm, is a commercial dog breeding facility that is operated with an emphasis upon profits above animal welfare and is often in substandard conditions regarding the well-being of dogs in their care. Similar types of operations exist for other animals most commonly kept as pets or used as feed for other animals. The term can be applied to operations involving other animals commercially bred for profit, e.g. "kitty mills." There are an estimated 4,000 puppy mills in the U.S. that produce more than half a million puppies a year. Commercial kennels may be licensed by the United States Department of Agriculture and state and local jurisdictions which may inspect the kennels routinely.
Although no standardized legal definition for "puppy mill" exists, a definition was established in Avenson v. Zegart in 1984 as "a dog breeding operation in which the health of the dogs is disregarded in order to maintain a low overhead and maximize profits." The ASPCA uses a similar definition: "a large-scale commercial dog breeding operation where profit is given priority over the well-being of the dogs."
Differences in breeding conditions
The Kennel Club and the American Kennel Club state that responsible breeders raise their animals with the intent to produce healthy dogs, and to ensure that all animals are provided responsible homes and socialization.
In puppy mills, females are sometimes bred every time they are in heat to increase profits, resulting in gradually decreasing sizes of litters. As puppies, mill dogs are also often weaned from their mothers well before the eight to ten weeks recommended. Bark Rescue in Belleview, IL also explains, “Puppies are taken from their mother when they are 5 to 6 weeks old and sold to brokers who pack them in crates for resale to pet stores all over the country.” Only half of the puppies survive during this exhausting travel only to make it to the pet shop until they are sold.[dubious ] Dogs in puppy mills are often bred indiscriminately. While the puppies produced may come with pedigrees, the pedigree itself is neither an indication of quality nor authenticity. Nearly 90% of puppies in pet stores were born in puppy mills  PAWS, an organization dedicated to helping improve the welfare of animals gives potential dog owners a list of "red flags" to look out for that could indicate that a puppy is from a puppy mill. These red flags include:
- Designer dogs are being bred or puppies are being sold at less than 6 weeks old (before a puppy should be taken away from its mother)
- Breeders are unwilling to show the environment in which the puppy was born or the parents of the puppy
- Breeders who don't ask many questions about the potential owners or show a disinterest in where the puppy will be living
- An unwillingness to take back the puppy for any reason
Treatment at puppy mills
Puppy mills usually house dogs in overcrowded and unsanitary conditions, without adequate veterinary care, food, water and socialization. Puppy mill dogs do not receive adequate attention, exercise or basic grooming. To minimize waste cleanup, dogs are often kept in cages with wire flooring that injures their paws and legs. It is not unusual for cages to be stacked up in columns. Breeder dogs at mills might spend their entire lives outdoors, exposed to the elements, or kept inside indoor cages all their lives. Often, after the breeder dog has reached the age of 4 years, it is no longer needed and killed. Sometimes the puppy mill owners will have a contact person who collaborates with rescues. The rescue will receive a phone call with the number of breeder dogs and types. The rescue then can save the breeder dogs from death. Once adopted, it can take a year or more for the dog to relax and allow human touch.
In a 2005 investigation conducted on pet shops and puppy mills in California, 44% of the locations visited had sick and neglected animals, 32% of the animals were confined in unhealthy, cramped, or crowded conditions and 25% of the animals did not have adequate food or water.
Due to the frequently poor breeding conditions in puppy mills, puppies bred there often suffer from health and/or social problems. Puppies raised in a cramped environment shared by many other dogs become poorly socialized to other dogs and to humans. Dogs are then transported over long distances in poor conditions, sometimes resulting in animal stress and death. As the surviving mill dogs grow older, they are more prone to developing respiratory ailments and pneumonia, as well as hereditary defects such as hip dysplasia. In addition, mill dogs are more prone to have problems with their temperament. Puppies from mills are usually sold as purebred dogs in an attempt to attract the higher prices associated with purebreds. However, due to the indiscriminate breeding practices of puppy mills, the dog may not actually be a purebred puppy. The vast majority of puppy mill animals are sold to pet stores by "dealers". Some puppies are sold by dealers masquerading as authentic breeders.
According to Canis Major V. publications, puppy mills originated in the post-World War II era. Midwestern farmers looking for an alternative crop reacted to a growing demand for puppies, resulting in the development of the first commercial puppy business. As the business grew, both small and large retail outlets began to sell puppies through pet departments. At around the same time, the first pet store chains were born.
Through indifference or ignorance, many puppies were left unsocialized or exposed in existing chicken coops or rabbit hutches. In addition, veterinary care for these puppies was often overlooked because of an inability to pay. As a result, organizations such as the Humane Society of the United States began to investigate breeding kennels, leading to the passage of the Animal Welfare Act of August 24, 1966.
According to the Humane Society of the United States, there are an estimated 10,000 licensed and unlicensed puppy mills in the United States, in total selling more than 2,000,000 puppies annually.
Missouri has been labeled the "Puppy Mill Capital of the U.S." by animal welfare and consumer protection groups. A study by the Better Business Bureau concluded that the southwest corner of Missouri is the hub of the nation's puppy mill industry, and termed it the "national hot spot of the puppy industry."
The term "puppy mill" has been widely used by animal rights groups in protests against breeders who have substandard breeding conditions. Critics in the breeder community claim that emotional rhetoric, sensationalism, and pictures of dirty kennels are used to justify additional legislation or additional restrictive licensing that travels well beyond the initial goal of removing dogs from truly deplorable conditions, or that attempts to legislate puppy mills would put them out of business. They argue the laws, which often require extra paperwork and inspections, would be more of a nuisance than help in shutting down puppy mills, and cite existing lemon laws for puppies as sufficient protection for both dogs and prospective buyers.
On May 29, 2008, MSNBC aired a report about puppy mills, in which talk show host Oprah Winfrey revealed an industry fraught with problems and apparent cruelty. The broadcast showed puppy mills with small cages, with chicken wire floors, stacked in rows from floor to ceiling, and stated that many dogs spend their entire lives within these tiny cages. Many of these dogs are sold on the internet or by pet retailers to buyers who are unaware of the dogs' background. The report claimed that customers who object to this treatment of puppies unknowingly allow the industry to thrive.[clarification needed] It also pointed out that many of the puppy mill bred dogs suffer long-term health problems.
United States of America
In recent years, state legislatures have passed new laws aimed at eliminating the worst abuses at puppy mills. New laws include limits on the number of breeding females, requirements that facilities be licensed and inspected, and requirements that dogs be given proper veterinary care. Louisiana, Pennsylvania and Virginia passed puppy mill laws in 2008, and 10 states passed laws in 2009 to crack down on abusive puppy mills. In 2010, Missouri voters passed Proposition B, the "Puppy Mill Cruelty Prevention Act", which establishes minimum standards of humane care and limits breeders to 50 intact dogs.
However, voters experienced push-back from the industry in the state of Missouri. Dog breeders and other farmers, worried about costly animal welfare measures spreading to their farms, pressured the state to repeal the law. In April 2011 Proposition B was repealed.
A compromise, dubbed the Missouri Solution, was signed by Missouri Governor Jay Nixon.
It retained some of the provisions of Proposition B, and made available some state funding for inspections. Humane Society of Missouri President Kathy Warnick reacted favorably, seeing a step in the right direction for animal welfare.
Detractors, which include the President and CEO of the Humane Society of the United States, point to the "shameful" overturn of the voter's will to weaken Proposition B.
“Lawmakers should never have substituted their judgment for the people of Missouri and gutted core provisions of Prop B,” said Wayne Pacelle, president and CEO of the Humane Society of the United States. “The so-called compromise was not about protecting animals, it was about placating agri-business.”.
Below is a set of lists describing some of the key differences between Proposition B and the so-called Missouri Solution.
Proposition B (approved by Missouri voters in November, 2010) Wire flooring for cages eliminated by November 2011; Maximum allowable breeding females per business = 50; Cage height = taller than any dog standing erect; Maximum number of times a female may be bred within 18 months time = 2; Larger enclosures by November 2011.
the “Missouri Solution” (compromise law signed by Missouri Gov. Jay Nixon, April 2011, after repealing Proposition B) No wire flooring for new enclosures in 2016, existing wire flooring permitted to remain indefinitely; No limit on number of breeding females; No restriction on cage height; No restrictions on how often females are impregnated; Larger enclosures in 2016.
Sydney Lord Mayor Clover Moore has responded to the problem of puppy mills in Australia by proposing the Animals Regulation of Sale Bill. It would ban the sale of dogs through pet shops, the internet or newspapers. The aim is to crack down on impulse purchases and shut down unregistered backyard breeders. These breeders should no longer easily profit from the sale of the dogs and the number of unwanted and abandoned animals could drop.
Opposition to the bill comes from the Australian Veterinary Association and the Pet Industry Association. They say that the bill makes no difference to shelter admissions or euthanasia rates.
In 1996, Britain passed the Breeding and Sale of Dogs Act which requires annual veterinary inspections for anyone breeding five or more litters in one year. Breeding females are restricted to one litter per year and four per lifetime.
Breeders who choose to be members of the UK Kennel Club are required to register purebred puppies for sale with that organization and must certify the conditions under which the puppies were raised. Breeders who sell puppies by misrepresenting these standards may be liable to prosecution under the Sale of Goods Act 1979.
- Farr Introduces Bill to Regulate Puppy Farms
- ASPCA (2007). "Fight Animal Cruelty: Puppy Mills". Retrieved 2007-12-13.
- Swartz, Tracy (2007-11-19). "Buy or adopt? Where you get your pet is a big decision—and a big controversy". Chicago Tribune RedEye Edition.
- ASPCA (2007). "ASPCA: Fight Animal Cruelty: Cruelty Glossary". Retrieved 2012-10-07.
- Questions and Answers on Animal Care’s Regulation of Commercial Animal Dealers
- Avenson v. Zegart, 577 F. Supp. 958, 960 (United States District Court, D. Minnesota, Sixth Division January 17, 1984) (“A "puppy mill" is a dog breeding operation in which the health of the dogs is disregarded in order to maintain a low overhead and maximize profits.”).
- "Laws That Protect Dogs in Puppy Mills". ASPCA. Retrieved October 7, 2012.
- American Kennel Club (2007). "Step Two - Breed to Improve". Retrieved 2007-12-13.
- Westminster Kennel Club (2007). "Buy Dogs from a Breeder". Retrieved 2007-12-13.
- City of Boston (2007). "Are you ready to adopt a pet?". Retrieved 2007-12-13.
- ASPCA (2007). "Puppy Mills: Responsible Breeding". Retrieved 2007-12-14.
- "Barktopia". Barkrescue.net. Retrieved 2012-08-13.
- The Kennel Club (UK) (2006-05-16). "Where NOT to buy a puppy or a dog". Retrieved 2007-12-14.
- Smith, Kimberly K. (2009). "A Pluralist-Expressivist Critique of the Pet Trade". Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics.
- Canis Major Publications (2007). "Just what is a puppy mill?". Retrieved 2007-12-14.
- United State Department of Agriculture (2003-08-21). "Animal Welfare Act". Retrieved 2007-12-26.
- Humane Society of the United States (2012-08-30). "FAQs". Retrieved 2012-10-07.
- Hamilton, Anita (2005-12-04). "Curbing the Puppy Trade: Dog lovers are divided over new efforts to ensure that all breeders treat their pooches humanely". Time. Retrieved 2012-10-07.
- "New Pa. Law Putting Puppy Mills out of Business". AP. 2010-06-11. Retrieved October 7, 2012.
- "Critics: Pa. failing to enforce puppy mill law". Associated Press. April 24, 2012. Retrieved October 7, 2012.
- "Is Pennsylvania regaining reputation for puppy mills?". 2012-10-04. Retrieved October 7, 2012.
- "HSUS Undercover Investigation Exposes the Suffering Behind New York Pet Stores". Humane Society of the United States. November 9, 2012. Retrieved October 7, 2012.
- Teuscher, Robert H. (March, 2010). "The Puppy Mill Industry In Missouri". Better Business Bureau. Retrieved October 7, 2012.
- "Puppy Factories / Animal Liberation Victoria". Alv.org.au. Retrieved 2012-08-13.
- Animal Welfare Information Center - United States Department of Agriculture - Agricultural Research Service - National Agricultural Library (2003-08-21). "Animal Welfare Act and Regulations". Retrieved 2008-01-03.
- The Humane Society of the United States (2010-03-09). "Iowa Gov. Culver Signs Bill to Combat Puppy Mills". Retrieved 2009-03-18.
- Pamela M. Prah, stateline.org (2011-05-25). "Missouri's puppy mill politics: dog breeders outmaneuver animal-rights movement". The Seattle Times.
- Joel Currier St. Louis Post Dispatch (2011-06-14). "State Officials Outline New Dog Breeding Law".
- KPLR.11.com (2011-06-15). "Humane Society President Calls Prop B Overturn, "Shameful"".
- About the Bill | Lead The Way | Support the Animals (Regulation of Sale) Bill | Animal Welfare | Against Puppy Farms[dead link]
- Clover Moore | Lead The Way | Support the Animals (Regulation of Sale) Bill | Animal Welfare | Against Puppy Farms[dead link]
- 'Puppy mills' under fire for cruelty[dead link]
- Death Row Pets[dead link]
- "Puppy Mill Victory in UK". Spring 2000. Retrieved 2009-07-12.
- Litter registration form