Q Public License

This article is about the license. For the library system in New York, see Queens Public Library.

Q Public License

Author	Trolltech
Version	1.0
Publisher	Trolltech AS
Published	1999-2000
DFSG compatible	No
FSF approved	Yes, according to the FSF
OSI approved	Yes
GPL compatible	No
Copyleft	No

The Q Public License (QPL) is a non-copyleft license, created by Trolltech for its free edition of the Qt. It was used until Qt 3.0, as Trolltech toolkit version 4.0 was released under GPL version 2. It fails the Debian Free Software Guidelines, used by several Linux distributions, though it qualifies for the Free Software Foundation's Free Software Definition; however, it is not compatible with the FSF's GNU General Public License, meaning that you cannot legally distribute products derived from both GPL'ed and QPL'ed code.

Opposition to the license

The Free Software Foundation and authors of the GPL sum up their objections to the QPL:

This is a non-copyleft free software license which is incompatible with the GNU GPL. It also causes major practical inconvenience, because modified sources can only be distributed as patches.

We recommend that you avoid using the QPL for anything that you write, and use QPL-covered software packages only when absolutely necessary. However, this avoidance no longer applies to Qt itself, since Qt is now also released under the GNU GPL.

Since the QPL is incompatible with the GNU GPL, you cannot take a GPL-covered program and QPL-covered program and link them together, no matter how.

However, if you have written a program that uses QPL-covered library (called FOO), and you want to release your program under the GNU GPL, you can easily do that. You can resolve the conflict for your program by adding a notice like this to it:

As a special exception, you have permission to link this program

with the FOO library and distribute executables, as long as you

follow the requirements of the GNU GPL in regard to all of the

software in the executable aside from FOO.

You can do this, legally, if you are the copyright holder for the program. Add it in the source files, after the notice that says the program is covered by the GNU GPL.

It also allowed Qt to change the license in later editions of its software, something often also provided in the GPL, and it was also frowned upon that non-free use or development of derivatives was still not allowed. Only the personal edition of Qt was covered by the QPL; the commercial edition, which is functionally equal, is under a pay-per-use license and could not be freely distributed. As KDE, a desktop environment for Linux based on Qt, grew in popularity, the free software community urged Trolltech to put Qt under a license (the QPL) that would assure that it would remain free software forever and could be used and developed by commercial third-parties. Eventually, under pressure, Trolltech dual-licensed Qt for use under the terms of the GPL or the QPL.

All legal disputes about the license are settled in Oslo, Norway, but it has never been legally contested.

The Debian project rejects software covered by solely QPL (and not dual licensed with something else like the GPL) because of:

• a choice of venue clause
• forced distribution to a third party
• forced blanket license to the original developer

Adoption of the license

Other projects that have adopted the Q Public License, sometimes with a change in the choice of jurisdiction clause, include:

• The OCaml compiler and related tools from Projet Cristal at INRIA
• LibreSource is a versatile collaborative platform provided by artenum and dedicated to collaborative software development
• Jpgraph is a graph generation tool written in PHP that dynamically produces charts and graphs as image files for presentation on websites.
• Hercules, a software implementation of the System/370, ESA/390, and z/Architecture mainframe computer architectures.
• CGAL

See also

• Open source license

External links

• The Q Public License, version 1.0