Question Time (TV series)

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Question Time
BBC Question Time.png
Genre Politics
Presented by Robin Day
(1979-1989)
Peter Sissons
(1989-1993)
David Dimbleby
(1994-present)
Country of origin United Kingdom
Original language(s) English
No. of episodes 1212 (as of 10 April 2014) (List of episodes)
Production
Running time 60 minutes
Production company(s) Mentorn
Broadcast
Original channel BBC One
Picture format 576i (16:9 SDTV)
1080i (HDTV)
Original run 25 September 1979 (1979-09-25) – present
Chronology
Related shows Any Questions?
The Big Questions
Question Time Extra
Young Voters Question Time
Schools Question Time
BBC Free Speech
External links
Website
The former Question Time set at Oxford

Question Time is a topical debate BBC television programme in the United Kingdom, based on Any Questions?. The show typically features politicians from at least the three major political parties as well as other public figures who answer pre-selected questions put to them by a carefully selected audience. The independent production company Mentorn has made the programme for the BBC since 1998.[1] Question Time is presented by David Dimbleby.

It is usually recorded about two hours prior to transmission, but has been broadcast live.

Until 2010 BBC One Northern Ireland replaced Question Time with the more local debate show Let's Talk at least once a month hosted by Mark Carruthers but this show has been axed and brought under the Spotlight brand and is now shown once a month on Tuesday night with Noel Thompson. Nowadays BBC One NI have their own political show called the view broadcast live from 10.35pm to 11.05pm with Mark Carruthers and Question Time follows it. Question Time is only broadcast at the usual time in Northern Ireland if the programme is coming from Northern Ireland, as in September 2012 when it was broadcast from Derry and in May 2013 when the programme was from Belfast.

Origins[edit]

Question Time began on Tuesday 25 September 1979, as a television version of the BBC Radio 4 programme Any Questions? Originally intended to have only a short run, the programme became very popular and was duly extended. The guests on the very first show were Edna O'Brien, Teddy Taylor, Michael Foot and Derek Worlock, Archbishop of Liverpool. From 21 February 1980 the series moved to its current Thursday-night slot and became fully networked within BBC, with Scotland and Northern Ireland broadcasting the series from this point onwards.

Chairmen[edit]

Veteran newsman Sir Robin Day was the programme's first chairman, presenting it for nearly 10 years until June 1989. His famous catchphrase when he had introduced the panel was: "There they are, and here we go." There were several guest hosts during Day's tenure, the most frequent being Sue Lawley.

After Day retired, Peter Sissons took over and continued until 1993. Since 1994, David Dimbleby has been the programme's presenter. Any Questions? is still broadcast and is chaired by Dimbleby's brother Jonathan Dimbleby.

Editors[edit]

Charlie Courtauld was editor from 1998 to 2000, leaving to join the Independent on Sunday as its comment editor.[2][3]

Nick Pisani was appointed in 2000, resigning abruptly in May 2005 after news was leaked that he had been offered a job as David Cameron's head of TV presentation.[3]

Ed Havard was made acting editor in May 2005 after Nick Pisani left. During his time in charge the BBC offered a seat on the panel to Nick Griffin in 2009. He left when the programme's production base moved to Glasgow.[3]

Gill Penlington, the ITV News political producer, was made interim editor in May 2008, when the BBC gave Ed Havard a year-long sabbatical.[3]

Nicolai Gentchev, a former output editor of BBC Radio 4's Today Programme, has been the editor of Question Time since March 2011.[4]

Format[edit]

Question Time began with a panel of four guests, usually one member from each of the three major parties (Conservatives, Labour and Liberal Democrats) and another public figure, for example non-governmental organisation directors, newspaper columnists, or religious leaders. In 1999, the panel was enlarged to five, with another non-partisan member or leading member of a fourth political party joining the panel.

The chairman sits in the middle and chairs the debate, deciding who can speak on the panel and bringing audience members into the discussion. Questions are submitted by the audience before the programme goes on air. The programme makers select some to put to the panel, who never know the questions before recording begins. During the programme, the presenter calls on the relevant members of the audience to put their question to the panel and gives each member an opportunity to answer the question and respond to each other's points. Every audience member is asked to bring a question and those chosen are informed immediately prior to filming.

Usually, filming takes place on the evening of broadcast, to ensure issues are as up-to-date as possible.

For a brief period in the mid-1990s, the programme used voting keypads to take a poll of the audience, who were stated to have been selected to provide a balanced sample compared with the nation as a whole.

During general election campaigns, the programme has taken a different format, with the party leaders appearing as single guests and fielding questions from the audience.

In 2007 the BBC commissioned a new programme called The Big Questions, which has a similar format to Question Time but focuses on ethical and religious issues. It is broadcast on BBC One on Sunday mornings between 10am and 11am. Both programmes are produced by Mentorn Media.[5]

Interactivity[edit]

SMS contributions[edit]

Viewers of the show can submit comments to the show via SMS and until October 2012 a selection of those comments were posted on Ceefax. Comments were edited and put to air by a team of four journalists based at Television Centre in London. The system displayed one message at a time, and usually showed several tens of messages throughout each hour-long episode. The system's popularity sprang from its mix of serious and light-hearted comments.[citation needed]

On average, around 3,500 texts are received during each hour-long programme, although 12,000 texts were once recorded in one frantic programme in 2004. Quantity of texts is generally related to the composition of the panel.[citation needed]

Twitter[edit]

On 24 September 2009, the show launched its Twitter presence and the show's presenter has regularly announced its presence on Twitter since late 2009. Using the Twitter ID "@bbcquestiontime"[6] it tweeted using the #bbcqt hashtag. By early 2010, this had become one of the UK's most active "Twitter backchannels" to a TV show. @bbcquestiontime claimed 10,000 tweets had been sent around the show on 7 October 2010. The show had over 40,000 followers on Twitter by October 2010 and this exceeded 50,000 on the evening of 3 February 2011.

On 9 June 2011, Question Time became one of the most-tweeted about shows of the week in the UK, with 5,000 tweets during the programme, with tweeting continuing through to the next day.[7] In addition to the more sober analysis of the discussion, Question Time also has a parallel Twitter backchannel based on the spoof account Dimblebot - purportedly a robot version of Dimbleby - where the entire premise of the programme is claimed to be a demonstration of Dimbleby's ability to defeat the panel. It became clear during the riot special that David Dimbleby knows of the existence of Dimblebot and the associated Dimbledance[8][9] It now has 230,000 followers.

Location[edit]

When chaired by Sir Robin Day, Question Time was almost always made in London, at the Greenwood Theatre on the south side of London Bridge. After his departure the BBC decided to try to widen the programme's appeal by moving it around the country. Currently the programme is presented from a different location each week, usually in the UK, with a local studio audience each time. The make-up of the panel is usually altered to reflect part of the country where it is filmed. When in Scotland, for example, the programme may invite a Scottish National Party MP or MSP onto the panel.

Some editions of the programme have been made in locations outside the UK, such as Australia in November 1999, before the republic referendum. In October 2004 a US election special was made in Miami, Florida, with an American studio audience and guests including Michael Moore on the panel. On 10 March 2005, another overseas edition of the programme was shown from Shanghai, China, and a programme from Paris, France, was broadcast on 26 May 2005, three days before the French referendum on the EU Constitution. On 7 July 2005, an edition was broadcast from Johannesburg in South Africa, coinciding with the G8 summit in Gleneagles. It just so happened that this edition was broadcast on the same day as the suicide bombings on the London Underground and the London bus in Tavistock Square, therefore diverting the original topic of this QT special somewhat.

In time for the G8 conference in Moscow, there was a special programme from the city on 30 March 2006.[10] Another US election special was held in Washington D.C. on 30 October 2008.[11][12]

Production[edit]

The show is recorded at different venues throughout the UK. Although, as part of plans to relocate BBC production around the UK, the main office of the programme will move to BBC Scotland in Glasgow, the itinerant nature of the programme will continue.[13]

Episodes[edit]

Famous editions[edit]

In early 1981, David Steel declared his support in principle for "a marriage" between the Liberal Party and any party which might be formed by the Gang of Four; David Owen, who was also on the programme, said he could see advantages in an "electoral alliance" between them. This prefigured the period 1983–1987 when Owen and Steel were Leaders of the SDP/Liberal Alliance and tension grew over whether their deal was a prelude to a merger of the parties or merely a temporary electoral pact.

During the 1983 election campaign, Conservative Foreign Secretary Francis Pym was asked by an A-level student named Andy Davis about the implications of the Conservatives winning the election with a landslide victory. He began by casting doubt on the likelihood of this happening and then observed "I think landslides on the whole don't produce successful governments". This remark was regarded by many[citation needed] as a gaffe and Margaret Thatcher was reported to have been angry at Pym. After the election (won by the Conservatives on a landslide) she sacked him as Foreign Secretary.

In a 1984 edition, Alan Clark, a junior government Minister at the time, was openly critical of a government decision to buy a foreign-made missile system, prompting guest host Sue Lawley to ask the audience, "Is there anyone here who wishes to defend the government on this, because its Minister doesn't?"

The programme broadcast on 13 September 2001, which was devoted to the political implications of the 11 September 2001 attacks, featured many contributions from members of the audience who were anti-American, expressing the view that "the United States had it coming". The BBC received more than 2,000 complaints and later apologised to viewers for causing offence, stating that the edition should not have been broadcast live, but rather should have been recorded and edited.[14]

In 2002, the editor of Private Eye, Ian Hislop, made an open attack on Jeffrey Archer, who had been imprisoned for perjury, when his wife Mary Archer was a fellow panellist. She was noticeably angry that the issue had been raised and criticised Hislop after the recording had finished.

In March 2007, an Iraq Special was broadcast, featuring Tony Benn, Benazir Bhutto, Des Browne, Liam Fox, Charles Kennedy and, via video link from Washington D.C., John R. Bolton. The episode is particularly memorable for the clashes between Benn and Bolton.

On 11 October 2007, former editor of The Sun newspaper Kelvin MacKenzie appeared on the programme in Cheltenham and launched an attack on Scotland. During a debate about tax, MacKenzie claimed that "Scotland believes not in entrepreneurialism like London and the south east... Scots enjoy spending it (money) but they don't enjoy creating it, which is the opposite to down south." The comments came as part of an attack on Prime Minister Gordon Brown who MacKenzie said could not be trusted to manage the British economy because he was "a Scot" and a "socialist", and insisting that this was relevant to the debate. Fellow panellist Chuka Umunna from the think tank Compass called his comments "absolutely disgraceful", and booing and jeering were heard from the Cheltenham studio audience. The BBC received 350 complaints and MacKenzie's comments drew widespread criticism in both Scotland and England. On 3 July 2008, it was reported that the BBC Trust's editorial complaints unit had cleared the programme of any wrongdoing. Question Time then proceeded to broadcast the following question from Nick Hartley as part of the programme on the same evening: "After the media coverage of [Andy] Murray's rise and fall, are we now to infer that the English resent the Scots more than the Scots resent the English?" MacKenzie reappeared on the programme in Cardiff on 17 May 2012.

The 12 November 2009 edition was the first time in more than 15 years that David Dimbleby did not host the show, having been taken to hospital as a precaution after being briefly knocked out by a rearing bullock at his farm in Sussex. The show was instead hosted by John Humphrys.[15]

After he was elected to the European Parliament, Nick Griffin the leader of the British National Party was invited onto Question Time for the first time, to appear on 22 October 2009. The decision led to controversy and political debate. Hundreds of people protested outside BBC Television Centre as the edition was filmed; six people were arrested after 25 protesters forced their way into the main reception.[16][17] The edition attracted eight million viewers,[18] and also drew a large number of complaints as a result of its content. Griffin himself said that he would make a formal complaint to the BBC for the way he believed he was treated by the show's other guests and the audience, who he described as a "lynch mob."[18]

An edition aired on 19 May 2011 was recorded at Wormwood Scrubs Prison in London. The episode was the first to feature prisoners as part of the audience, while panellists included Justice Secretary Ken Clarke who attempted to defend controversial remarks he had made earlier in the week about rape sentencing.[19]

A special edition of the programme was aired on 11 August 2011 following the outbreak of rioting which had occurred during the previous weekend and earlier that week.[20] Question Time had been off air for its annual summer break at the time and the edition was a scheduled at short notice due to the nationwide riots.

Appearing on Question Time on 5 July 2012, former Sex Pistols and Public Image Ltd frontman John Lydon questioned the notion of a parliamentary inquiry into the banking industry, saying "How on earth is Parliament going to discuss this really when both sides, left and right, are connected to this? This doesn't just go back to Brown, this is part of the ongoing problem. Mr Diamond comes from Wall Street...hello. Both parties love this idea. They are fiddling with rates. They are affecting the world and everything we used to count on as being dependable and accurate is being discussed by these argumentative chaps. If I nick a motor I'm going to be up before the judge, the rozzers. Hello, same thing."[21]

The BBC issued an apology after a floor plan for the 23 May 2013 edition recorded in Belfast described the Northern Ireland Education Minister John O'Dowd as being from Sinn Féin/IRA. The phrase is a pejorative term used by members of the unionist community, but Sinn Féin maintains it and the IRA are separate organisations. The note, attached to a camera, was not seen on screen, but spotted by an audience member who photographed it and posted the image on Twitter.[22][23]

13 June 2013: Kenneth Gibson MSP placed a Scottish parliamentary motion on 14 June 2013, and it was supported by 24 of his fellow MSPs. If the motion is discussed on the Parliament floor, it could lead to a vote on an official rebuke for the BBC from Holyrood. Mr Gibson’s motion criticises the BBC for inviting Respect’s George Galloway and Ukip’s Nigel Farage to participate despite their lack of Scottish representation. Gibson also calls for the BBC to “try to reflect political reality north of the border” in what he describes as the corporation’s “occasional forays into Scotland”. The motion concludes: “ (The parliament) calls on the BBC to reflect on its choice of Question Time guests and their relevance to Scotland, given that the only time any Scottish issues are debated on the programme is, it considers, when it is recorded in Scotland.” Also as part of the show, an audience of 16- and 17-year-olds was featured, with a panel of Farage, Galloway, SNP Westminster leader Angus Roberston, Scottish Conservative leader Ruth Davidson, Scottish Labour deputy leader Anas Sarwar, and Scotsman columnist Lesley Riddoch.

On 12 December 2013, a special edition aired from Johannesburg in South Africa, debating the legacy of Nelson Mandela.[24]

Audience figures[edit]

Audience figures for Question Time are usually around 2.7 million.

On 14 May 2009, Question Time discussed the MPs' expenses row, with audience members heckling guest panellists Menzies Campbell and Margaret Beckett, the Labour MP, who was booed by the audience for insisting that her expenses were her privilege. The TV audience reached 3.8 million.[25][26]

3.4 million people watched in 2003 for the declaration of the war on Iraq.

The highest audience figures to date, however, were recorded when Nick Griffin of the BNP appeared in an episode on 22 October 2009; the audience reaching 7.9 million viewers.

Similar programmes[edit]

  • BBC Northern Ireland has Let's Talk, though this is broadcast monthly (replacing Question Time for that week) and has greater audience interaction
  • BBC World produces an Indian version of the programme for such viewers
  • Pakistan has developed its own version of Question Time
  • The Irish broadcaster RTÉ produced a similar show, Questions and Answers, which ran from 1986 to 2009, and was replaced by The Frontline, which is of a similar format[27]
  • In March 2010, Dermot O'Leary hosted a spinoff edition of the show, which was broadcast on BBC Three. It was called First Time Voters' Question Time, and the show was aimed at first time voters. This version of the programme was later commissioned on a permanent, monthly basis on BBC Three, to now be hosted by Richard Bacon, and re-titled Young Voters' Question Time. He was replaced by Jake Humphrey then by Rick Edwards and the show was renamed Freespeach which goes out every month.[28]
  • In 2008, the Australian Broadcasting Corporation launched a similar, Australian version of the programme, called Q&A. Airing live weekly, it has become a critical success, achieving extremely positive ratings for the ABC in Australia, with a wide audience from a range of demographics not all of which are normally noted for their interest in the Australian political scene.
  • In 2011 Azerbaijan launched its own version of the programme. Open Talk Azerbaijani: Açıq söhbət is a weekly debate ANS TV television programme in Azerbaijan, based on Question Time. The show features political leaders as well as other public figures. Open Talk is presented by Sevinj Osmanqizi.

Schools edition[edit]

Several schools editions have been broadcast: On 20 June 2005, with a panel of Tony Benn, Justine Greening, Lembit Opik, June Sarpong and Otis Ferry.[29] On 6 July 2006, with a twenty-year-old student joining David Miliband, Richard Madelely, Lord Coe and Julia Goldsworthy.[29] On 5 July 2007, an 18-year-old student joined a panel of Ed Miliband, Sayeeda Warsi, Davina McCall and Douglas Murray.[29] On 9 July 2009, one of the panellists was an eighteen-year-old student. Other panellists were Andy Burnham, Jeremy Hunt, Sarah Teather and Shami Chakrabarti.[30]

References[edit]

  1. ^ "Press Office - Mentorn wins back Question Time contract". BBC. 25 September 1979. Retrieved 25 November 2010. 
  2. ^ "LinkedIn". Retrieved 8 April 2013. 
  3. ^ a b c d Collins, Nick (11 March 2011). "Question Time's previous editors". Daily Telegraph (London). 
  4. ^ Plunkett, John (10 March 2011). "Nicolai Gentchev named Question Time editor". The Guardian (London). 
  5. ^ "MentornMedia". Mentorn.tv. Retrieved 25 November 2010. 
  6. ^ BBC Question Time on Twitter
  7. ^ http://www.tvgenius.net/socialtvstats/
  8. ^ "Ten Of The Best UK Twitter Feeds", Huffington Tech, 5 September 2011.
  9. ^ Jack Seale, "DIMBLEBOT helps Question Time special draw 3.5m viewers", Radio Times, 12 August 2011.
  10. ^ "BBC stages political debate in Moscow". BBC News. 30 March 2006. Retrieved 22 May 2010. 
  11. ^ US election special BBC News, 27 October 2008
  12. ^ Future programme venues BBC News, 3 August 2010
  13. ^ BBC2's "Newsnight Review to get revamp", The Guardian, 24 March 2009.
  14. ^ BBC chief apologises for terror debate, BBC News, 15 September 2001
  15. ^ "David Dimbleby injured by bullock". BBC News. Archived from the original on 12 November 2009. Retrieved 12 November 2009. 
  16. ^ "BNP on Question Time", The Guardian, 22 October 2009.
  17. ^ "Angry scenes face Griffin at BBC". BBC News. 22 October 2009. Retrieved 22 May 2010. 
  18. ^ a b "Griffin complaint over BBC 'mob'". BBC News. 23 October 2009. Retrieved 23 October 2009. 
  19. ^ Dowell, Ben (20 May 2011). "Ken Clarke detains 3 million on Question Time". The Guardian (Guardian Media Group). Retrieved 21 May 2011. 
  20. ^ Dowell, Ben (12 August 2011). "Question Time riots special draws 3.6m viewers". The Guardian (Guardian Media Group). Retrieved 16 August 2011. 
  21. ^ Cockerell, Jennifer (6 July 2012). "Anarchy at the BBC as former Sex Pistol Johnny Lydon appears on Question Tim". Irish Independent via Press Association (Independent News & Media). Retrieved 6 July 2012. 
  22. ^ "BBC apologises over Question Time Sinn Féin 'IRA' label". BBC News (BBC). 24 May 2013. Retrieved 24 May 2013. 
  23. ^ "BBC 'very sorry' after John O'Dowd labelled 'SF/IRA!' on Question Time". Belfast Telegraph (Independent News and Media). 24 May 2013. Retrieved 24 May 2013. 
  24. ^ http://www.bbc.co.uk/mediacentre/latestnews/2013/question-time-south-africa.html
  25. ^ "Millions see Beckett heckled", The Sun, 16 May 2009
  26. ^ "MPs' expenses: Question Time boos for Margaret Becket as she insists, 'I won't pay it back'", Daily Mail, 15 May 2009
  27. ^ "Recession leaves its mark on RTÉ schedule". Irish Times. 14 August 2009. Retrieved 12 September 2009. 
  28. ^ Young Voters' Question Time becomes permanent fixture on BBC Three BBC Press Office, 21 September 2010
  29. ^ a b c Classic Question Times
  30. ^ Question Time, Schools Edition, BBC One, 9 July 2009.

Other sources[edit]

External links[edit]