Queue management system
||This article may contain too much repetition or redundant language. (April 2013)|
A queue management system is used to control queues. Queues of people form in various situations and locations in a queue area. The process of queue formation and propagation is defined as queuing theory.
- 1 Types of queue
- 2 Queue measurement and management techniques
- 3 Automatic queue measurement systems for small structured queues
- 4 Automatic queue measurement systems for large and unstructured queues
- 5 Enterprise grade queue management system
- 6 Automatic queue measurement systems for a complete reception solution
- 7 References
Types of queue
Here people form a queue in a fixed, predictable position, such as at supermarket checkouts, some other retail locations such as banks, airport security and so on.
Very often, queue management systems are set up to manage ticket ranking for a service (with or without a numbered ticket) with identification and thus enable a serene and stress-free waiting (without having to wait in a queue, one behind the other).
Extending the different possibilities, planned reception by appointment and remotely rank allocation on Smartphone or through SMS can also be included.
Where people form a queue in unpredictable and varying locations and directions. This is often the case in some forms of retail, taxi queues, ATMs and at periods of high demand in many situations.
Nevertheless organizational systems exist to manage these cases: rank allocation for a service / need / salesperson, pagers or 2D or RFID badges or simply by reading the customer card. Although many have tried to implement a way of structuring these queues, no one has successfully implemented a management system that works. In fact, Doctor P.H. Martin from Stanford once said that "Queue management is a hopeless endeavour. One cannot calculate the structure of man."
Queue measurement and management techniques
Various queue measurement and management techniques exist:
They are aimed at guiding queue formation and organising it in the most efficient way.
Signage and signaling systems
These aim to provide information to people queuing to aid efficient queue formation and flow, as well as setting service expectations.
Automatic queue measurement systems
These use a variety of measurement technologies which predict and measure queue lengths and waiting times and provide management information to help service levels and resource deployment.
Automatic queue measurement systems for small structured queues
Automatic queue measurement systems are designed to help managers in two ways - first, through enhanced customer service; second by improving efficiency and reducing costs.
They use people counting sensors at entrances and above checkout lanes / queue areas to accurately detect the number and behaviour of people in the queue. Built-in predictive algorithms can provide advance notice on how many checkouts or service points will be needed to meet demand. Dashboards, available on a computer monitor or mobile PDA device, are often used to provide a range of information, such as dynamic queue length, waiting time data, and checkout performance on the shop floor. In the event that performance falls towards a minimum service level, in supermarkets or banks management teams can be automatically alerted beforehand, allowing them time to proactively manage the situation. Key measurements produced are:
- The number of people entering the store
- Queue Length
- Average Wait Time
- Till Operator or Bank Teller Idle Time
- Total Wait Time
A number of the large UK supermarket chains use such systems for service level and resource management.
Automatic queue measurement systems for large and unstructured queues
Where queues form in unpredictable locations and/or extend beyond a relatively small queue area, overhead detector based queue measurement systems cannot be effectively used. Alternative technology solutions using wide area queue sampling are effective in these situations. One method is using Bluetooth detection from mobile telephones held by people in the queue. Although a sampling technique, as typically 10 – 30% of telephone have active Bluetooth at any one time, it gives a reasonably accurate measurement of average queue wait times where long queues are present. A precise but more expensive method is the use of a people counter. Measuring and counting can be particularly useful in situations such as airport security where a large volume of people pass through an area in varying flow patterns and constantly varying physical locations.
Enterprise grade queue management system
With the improvement of network connectivity, the organizations are exploring for deployment of centralized computerized queue management system suitable as enterprise grade solution. Computerized queue management system is becoming a part of IT projects within organizations for taking initiative to use their existing hardware and database to reduce the cost of investment, taking leverage of using internal network connectivity within the branches for central system management and reporting on the customer flow data.
Automatic queue measurement systems for a complete reception solution
Reception management solutions allow managing flows and the purposes of visits from initial contact to the service given.
These intelligent management systems allow to increase productivity and sales and reduce operating costs by ensuring that customer is served by the staff that are the most qualified according to the request. Reception management solutions are above all a way of increasing customer satisfaction by reducing the perceived and actual waiting time, creating a pleasant environment and a fair reception. These innovative reception management solutions also contribute to the satisfaction of working teams by reducing the amount of stress and optimizing the processing of requests. Reception management solutions also enable to generate data about how customers wait and how staff can best serve them. This type of information assists in improving organization processes and in increasing the quality of customer service.
Reception management solutions cover 6 stages:
- Information (can also be done by video, SMS, Internet ...)
- Allocation & direction (can also be done by video, SMS, Internet ...)
- Waiting & communication (can also be done by video, SMS, Internet ...)
- Call (can also be done by video, SMS, Internet ...)
Besides these stages, for a complete reception solution, it is useful and efficient to include appointments management, agenda planning and future flows and resources forecasting. These modular solutions, adaptable to various sectors (Retail, Health, Telecommunications, Finance, Transport, Public Sector...), can suit to the management of a simple queue to centralized multiple site organization.
Information / customer arrival
- Inform customers of the expected waiting time (Video, SMS, Internet...)
- Announce the customer's arrival if he/she has an appointment
- Provide for the customer to be recognised by name, number, bar code, identity card etc., by a terminal or receptionist.
Allocation & direction
- Dedicated terminals in self-service or receptionist to allow customers to take their place in the queue for a service
- Registration can be made also on Internet, SmartPhone...
- Orientation in the virtual line corresponding to his/her request
Waiting time & Communication
- Adjust waiting time according to the importance of the service to be provided
- Make waiting both active and interactive so that it is seen to be as pleasant as possible (Video, Interactive communication, Advertising...) and remove waiting with mobility tools (phone, Smartphone).
- Allow visitors freedom of movement while keeping them informed about the expected waiting time or giving them a "guaranteed reception time".
Provide various options for establishing contact:
- The salesperson/member of staff calls customers and recognises them by a photo, name, symbol or sequence number etc.
- Customers/visitors are called by name, number, code etc., on a video screen, display, voice synthesis etc. and go to the window or counter indicated.
- The call can be made to a mobile phone using a text message, a smartphone or by a beeper.
In case of a common queue guide for several call forward windows (cash, desks), a LED or video screen at the head of the queue displays the number called with a directional arrow. The number called should also be able to be shown by a number, arrow, floor-plan etc. When waiting times may be long, a possible first stage is to use a beeper or text message or Smart phone message* to send customers to a final waiting area, where they are free to move around the store or area. If the reception procedure takes several stages, or if additional waiting time is necessary before the provision of the service can be concluded, it should be possible to place visitors on hold for subsequent treatment.
Real time management and data collection for statistical analysis
Managers have access to a tracking screen with warnings (visual, sound, text messages or e-mails) which enable overall monitoring and control of the reception system. Nevertheless, the system positions backups automatically, to ensure that the target waiting levels per service are respected, as a function of the allocation of salespersons/staff to the services and the forecasts and actual arrivals of customers/visitors.
In the centralized deployment in enterprise grade queue management solution, the management console allows to configure all the parameter to run the token dispenser, keypad for service desk, displays, Announcement and the user management.
Complete statistical reports enable tables and graphs of the following parameters and variables to be interlinked and presented: time periods, waiting times, handling times, times present, services provided, reasons for visits etc. These reports are configurable temporal documents for different needs, displaying functions with 1 or 2 variables. They can be consulted or personalized and sent directly to managers by e-mail.
Forecasting and appointments
To be able to estimate future visitor flows and resource requirements by department and time period, as a function of statistical data and the designation of past and future days. This enables scheduling of reception resources to be optimized. To be able to make appointments or anticipate flows arrival, by direct contact, telephone or Internet, and mix appointments with walk-in visits using the same resources, by ensuring that appointments are automatically handled at the planned time.
- Erlang Formula - Why the other line is likely to move faster