A game of quiz bowl being played at the University of Delaware
|Playing time||~30 minutes (can vary widely)|
|Random chance||Negligibly little|
Quiz bowl (also known as quizbowl, scholars' bowl, and academic bowl) is a game of questions and answers on topics such as history, literature, and science. It is commonly played by college or high school students, and sometimes middle and elementary school. Participants benefit from exposure to a broad range of school and cultural subjects, memorization and study skills, and an improved ability to cooperate and work in teams.
The game is typically played with a lockout buzzer system between two teams, most commonly consisting of four or five players each. A moderator reads questions to the teams, whose players endeavor to buzz in first with the correct answer, scoring points for their team.
At the collegiate level, academic quiz bowl competitions enjoyed broad exposure in the United States media via College Bowl, which started on radio in 1953 and aired on national television from 1959 to 1970. In 1977, the format was revived on college campuses by College Bowl Company Inc. (CBCI), which operated until 2008. In September 1990, the Academic Competition Federation (ACF) was incorporated as the first major alternative to College Bowl on university campuses. In 1996, National Academic Quiz Tournaments (NAQT) was founded. Today, most major college-level competitions are run by either ACF or NAQT, with varying formats and governing rules.
In recent years, many former quiz bowl players have gone on to become successful game show contestants. Several of the top dollar winners in the history of Jeopardy! include former players such as Ken Jennings, David Madden, and Brad Rutter.
There are several different formats of quiz bowl, but they generally share the following rules for playing.
Two teams of up to four or five players each sit at a set of handheld buzzers while a moderator reads a set of questions. Anyone who buzzes in locks out everyone else from doing so. There are two basic types of questions asked: tossups and bonuses. Tossups are questions that any individual player can attempt to answer. At any point during the reading of one, a player may buzz in and attempt to answer. If the answer given is incorrect, then no other member of that team may attempt to answer, with only players from the other team being able to buzz in. Bonuses are a series of related questions awarded to teams who answer a tossup correctly. Unlike tossups, teams are allowed to confer on bonuses. Some tournaments allow missed bonus parts to be answered by the team that did not originally control the bonus. Occasionally, a lightning round is included in a game, during which one team attempts to answer multiple questions as fast as possible under a given time limit.
If a tossup is successfully answered, the correctly answering team is given an opportunity to answer a bonus question. The bonus question is usually given in multiple parts, with each part being worth a stated number of points. Team members are generally permitted to confer with each other on these questions. Usually, only the team that answered the tossup question correctly can answer the bonus questions, though some formats allow the opposing team to answer certain parts of the bonus not correctly answered by the team in control of the bonus, a feature known as a "bounceback". In some formats, a team controlling the bonus may choose to decline to answer a bonus part, "passing" it and denying their opponent a chance to answer. In others, often those whose game length is determined by time elapsed, the non-controlling team is given opportunities to answer both incorrect answers and passes, leaving that team to decide whether to expend additional time in an effort to answer the question.
Some regional or local tournaments may dispose of bonus questions altogether. Instead, matches consist of two rounds usually similar in the number of questions but differing in the difficulty and, accordingly, in the number of points awarded for correct answers. In most such formats, questions in the second round are worth twice as much as are questions in the first round.
Overtime occurs only if there is a tie at the end of regulation play. Overtime structures vary from format to format and may include extra toss-ups until the tie is broken or one team establishes a lead of a given size, entire toss-up or toss-up-and-bonus sets until one team leads at the end of a set, a multiple-toss-up playoff, or a fixed time period (usually one to three minutes).
Tossups are questions that players may interrupt and answer at any time, unlike Trivial Pursuit and Jeopardy!. Tossups are so named because each team has an equal opportunity to buzz in, answer the question, and earn points. There are two main types of tossups: pyramidal tossups and buzzer-beaters.
Pyramidal or pyramid-style tossup questions include multiple clues, generally written so that each question starts with more difficult clues and moves toward easier clues. This type of toss-up is the standard style written in college and high school tournaments. Pyramidal-style questions are designed to give the player with the most knowledge of the subject being asked about the best opportunity to answer first. Criticisms of pyramidal tossups include longer running times for matches and the difficulty in writing them.
Buzzer-beater, fast-buzz, or quick-recall questions are short with a single, relatively simple clue. This type of question is written specifically to test quick recall skills of players, and does not discriminate the different levels of knowledge that the players possess. They have virtually disappeared at the college or high school levels.
In most American formats, correct tossup answers earn the team 10 points. Some formats award extra points, usually for a total of 15 or 20 points, if a question is answered prior to a certain clue-providing keyword in the question (an action informally known in these formats as "powering") or penalize teams for answering the question incorrectly after interrupting it with a five-point penalty (an action informally known as "negging." There is usually no penalty for when a player from the team receiving an uncontested opportunity to answer a tossup also buzzes in with a wrong answer before the question is complete.
Bonus questions may or may not be related to corresponding tossups. Bonus questions with multiple parts are often seen in a patterned format, in which the individual parts of a bonus question are often related by some common thread. This common thread is often revealed in the opening part of the bonus question, called the "lead-in". A team is usually rewarded with 10 points upon correctly answering a bonus part.
Some less-used types of bonus questions include list bonuses, which require players to give their answers from a requested list, and "30-20-10" bonuses, which give three or some other number of discrete clues in order of decreasing difficulty, with more points being awarded for giving an answer on an earlier clue. The 30-20-10 bonus was officially banned from ACF in 2008 and NAQT in 2009.
For tournament purposes, a format covers rules of play, question structure, and question content. For questions, this includes topics, difficulty, and writing style. Rules of play include player eligibility, scoring of questions, acceptable answers, and procedures for protesting a question.
In particular, ACF, CBCI, HCASC, NAQT, and UC each have distinctive formats, while certain college tournaments and programs have developed their own distinctive formats. However, the basic ACF format is more or less standard for non-NAQT or pre-2010 PACE tournaments in the US.
The ACF format has a rigorous emphasis on academics. There is no limit on graduate student participation. Toss-ups are typically written in pyramidal style, with more difficult clues coming first. ACF is untimed; questions are generally much longer than CBCI questions. Games are usually played to a total of 20 tossups read.
The now-defunct CBCI or College Bowl format emphasizes comparatively short questions on academics, current events, pop culture, and general knowledge. The limits on participation are 6 years total in CBCI tournaments and only one graduate student per team. Questions tend to be structured so that most of the players know the answers to tossups read in their entirety. It is played in eight-minute halves, to a usual total of 22–24 tossups read, though there's no actual limit and 30-toss-up games, though quite rare, have occurred. Game play is relatively quick as a result. The Honda Campus All Star Challenge and University Challenge use a similar format.
NAQT format balances the diversity of subjects found in CB packets with the academic rigor of the ACF format. The limits on participation are complex but in general, as long as a player is earning a degree, they can play. Game play is markedly different from ACF or CB formats. Timeouts and player substitution during timeouts are allowed. The NAQT also uses power marks in tossups (15 points instead of 10 earned for a tossup answered before a certain point). Game length can vary a little, but a standard length for NAQT is nine-minute halves and a total of 26 tossups. National and regional tournaments follow these formats very closely, while invitationals often modify these formats for their own use. NAQT also writes questions and helps organize tournaments at the high school level.
The National Academic Championship is played in four-quarter format, with gameplay broken up into several phases with differing styles of gameplay in each phase. Individual formats vary but may include worksheets, lightning rounds, and tossups, with or without accompanying bonuses.
Other competitions evolved from these formats include competitions testing knowledge in the Bible, Latin, modern foreign languages, and hundreds of other specialties. Many medical schools use quiz bowl-style competitions as part of their "grand rounds" specialty training for students and interns. In the 1990s, "Deaf College Bowl" for university teams with hearing-impaired students emerged. Tournaments designated as "trash" tournaments focus on pop culture and sports trivia.
In addition, other variants on the above quiz bowl formats are used at the high school level, including such formats as those of the Ohio Academic Competition (OAC), Partnership for Academic Competition Excellence (PACE), and the Panasonic Academic Challenge (PAC or simply "Panasonic").
Quiz bowl is generally played at tournaments, though high schools will also commonly play single matches against local schools or schools within an athletic conference. Many schools hold intramural tournaments where any team formed from students on that campus can play. On occasion, such tournaments may be open to graduate students and/or campus staff. Invitational tournaments involve teams from various schools and are generally run by the quiz bowl team from the host school. Invitations are sometimes sent to individual programs, though most tournaments give out open invitations for any school to accept. Major variants of invitational tournaments include national, regional, novice, and open tournaments. Such tournaments often have qualification requirements, sometimes including purchase of intramural tournament packets, or participation in regional tournaments (or other tournaments). They have unique rules above their associated formats, usually concerning eligibility and number of teams per school.
Novice tournaments are restricted to collegiate players in their first or second year of playing. Freshmen and sophomores are the intended target of such tournaments, though upperclassmen or grad students who meet the criteria are sometimes allowed to play. These tournaments aim to support player development by providing experience against other teams of similar skills, and to give newer players a chance to compete without being dominated by long-time veterans.
Some tournaments are restricted to undergraduate collegiate players (excluding graduate students). Variants on this format permit teams to have a certain total number of years of experience (e.g. four freshman or sophomores, three juniors, but only two seniors).
Open tournaments do not place any restrictions on who may play. They are intended for competitors who want to play on teams drawn from multiple schools, who hold degrees disqualifying them from collegiate-level-only play, who are not currently enrolled in a qualifying collegiate academic program, and/or who are for other reasons ineligible for tournaments open only to collegiate-level participants.
During tournaments, teams gather to engage each other in several rounds of games. A tournament winner is determined using some criteria such win-loss record. There are several classes of tournaments, which may use one of several formats.
Collegiate national tournaments
At the college level, there exist several academic tournaments run by organizations not affiliated with a given school. These generally have regional competitions followed by a national championship. These organizations include:
- National Academic Quiz Tournaments (NAQT)
- Academic Competition Federation (ACF)
- Honda Campus All-Star Challenge (HCASC) for Historically Black Colleges and Universities, sponsored by the USA subsidiary of Honda Motor Company. This program is administered by the College Bowl Company, Inc. (CBCI) in cooperation with the Association of College Unions International (ACUI) and the National Association for Equal Opportunity in Education (NAFEO).
Defunct tournaments include:
- College Bowl - traces its history to 1953, but was suspended after the 2007-08 season by the College Bowl Company, Inc. (CBCI).
High-school national tournaments
A number of organizations conduct national competitions for high-school students in the United States. These include:
- High School National Championship Tournament (HSNCT) is sponsored by National Academic Quiz Tournaments since 1999. The tournament has been held in a number of different cities throughout its existence.
- National Scholastics Championship (NSC) has been held since 1998, and is organized by the Partnership for Academic Competition Excellence (PACE). The competition has been held at various sites in the South, Mid-Atlantic and Midwest.
- National Academic Championship (NAC) has been held since 1983, and is sponsored by Questions Unlimited. The tournament is played at three sites throughout the nation every year. Players of NASAT, HSNCT, and NSC tournament often overlap; however, many[who?] of those players frown upon the NAC.[opinion]
- The National All-Star Academic Tournament (NASAT) is a national tournament hosted by High School Academic Pyramidal Questions (HSAPQ). NASAT is played by all-star teams from each state in an ACF format tournament.
Defunct tournaments include:
- American Scholastics Competition Network (ASCN) hosted a national tournament from 1987 through 2005 in the Chicago area.
- The National Tournament of Academic Excellence (formerly known as the Panasonic Academic Challenge) occurred annually from 1988, traditionally at Walt Disney World in Orlando, Florida, to 2009. It was sponsored in part by the county and state school boards of the State of Florida, with Panasonic holding title-sponsor status from 1992 to 2008. The program lost funding between the 2008-2009 and 2009-2010 academic years and has been defunct since the conclusion of the 2009 tournament.
Eligibility rules depend on the game. For the college game, in official College Bowl, NAQT or other events, there are strict eligibility rules, while other tournaments differ on whether senior or only junior undergraduate, graduate, and even non-students can play. In general, players of lower academic standing than specified can compete; there is a debate about how much more experienced players should be involved (analogous to the hypothetical question of whether NBA players should be able to play college games, or even high school games). First and second year undergraduates can always play. Junior and senior undergraduates are typically excluded from novice tournaments. Graduate students are excluded from undergraduate-only tournaments. The general intent is to ensure a degree of fairness, by preventing teams from having too many players who have too much experience who can swamp the entire field. College Bowl in particular allows only one graduate student per team.
Non-students are excluded from college tournaments; however, there are some tournaments open to everyone. These tournaments include open tournaments and the occasional intramural tournament.
No form of quiz bowl at the college level is broadcast regularly in the United States on a national basis. The "College Quiz Bowl" was broadcast on NBC radio from 1953 to 1955; General Electric College Bowl was televised on CBS and later NBC from 1959 to 1970, College Bowl returned to CBS radio 1979-82, and HCASC was broadcast on BET until 1995. The Texaco Star National Academic Championship premiered July 1, 1989 on the Discovery Channel . and was hosted by Chip Beall until 1993. In 1994, it was syndicated as the Star Challenge and hosted by Mark Wahlberg. University Challenge is licensed from CBCI by Granada TV Ltd. and broadcast in the United Kingdom.
There are several local broadcasts of college and high school level quiz bowl.
There is no relationship between quiz bowl and Jeopardy! or any of the other TV trivia game shows, other than that many of the contestants may be the same. NAQT maintains a list of current and former quiz bowl players at any level who have appeared on TV game shows.
Televised quiz bowl
Quiz bowl shows have been on television for many years in some areas, featuring both college and high school competitions.
- Academic games
- Certamen – A Latin version of the Quiz bowl
- Gettu betur – A long-lasting Icelandic high school tournament
- Ken Jennings
- Knowledge bowl
- National History Bee and Bowl
- National Ocean Sciences Bowl
- Reach for the Top – A long lasting Canadian high school tournament, broadcast on some provincial levels and at the national level
- Quick Recall
- Schools' Challenge – a UK high school tournament
- Science Bowl – a national high school and middle school tournament focused on science
- SmartAsk – a defunct Canadian high school tournament, began as a spin off of Reach for the Top
- University Challenge
- Parke, Dr. Beverly N. (2002) Discovering Programs for Talent Development. Corwin Press, P 119. ISBN 978-0-7619-4613-7
- Weber, Bruce (April 4, 1999). "Total Recall". The New York Times. Retrieved September 9, 2009.
- "Hot Fun in the Summertime... on TV, That Is". Game Show News Net. June 24, 2008. Retrieved September 15, 2009.
- Jennings 2006, p. 259.
- Kahn, Joseph P. (February 17, 2009). "Keeping their eyes on the bowl". The Boston Globe. Retrieved September 9, 2009.
- Jennings, Ken (2006). Brainiac: Adventures in the Curious, Competitive, Compulsive World of Trivia Buffs. Villard. ISBN 978-1-4000-6445-8., p.29-48
- "College Quiz Bowl basics". The Boston Globe. February 17, 2009. Retrieved September 9, 2009.
- Jones, Tamara (October 5, 2004). "A: Quiz Bowl. Q: What Do Top Game Show Players Prize?". The Washington Post. Retrieved September 9, 2009.
- "Quiz competition decided". SMU Daily Campus. February 4, 2005. Retrieved September 10, 2009.
- IHSA Scholastic Bowl Terms and Conditions. Bloomington, IL: Illinois High School Association (IHSA). 2008. p. 5. "For non-computational toss-ups, the preferred style is multi-clue, starting with a more challenging clue and ending with a clue that most teams should reasonably be expected to answer correctly ... Toss-ups should begin in a way that uniquely identifies the answer so that an expert in the subject could answer early without having to guess what the question is asking for."
- Vinokurov, Jerry (September 2009). "How to Write Questions". In Greenthal, Jonah. Scholastic Visions (Evanston, IL: Illinois High School Scholastic Bowl Coaches Association) 15 (1): 16–19. Retrieved September 24, 2009.[dead link]
- Gauthier, Greg (September 2009). "What's a Good Quizbowl Question?". Scholastic Visions (Evanston, IL: Illinois High School Scholastic Bowl Coaches Association) 15 (1): 20–21. Retrieved September 24, 2009.[dead link]
- IHSA Scholastic Bowl Terms and Conditions. Bloomington, IL: Illinois High School Association (IHSA). 2008. p. 5. "Buzzer-beater questions that virtually any team can be expected to answer after hearing only a few words are discouraged."
- Riley, David (September 2000). "Beta Tournaments Debut". Scholastic Visions (Evanston, IL: Illinois Scholastic Bowl Coaches Association (IHSSBCA)) 6 (1): 11. Retrieved September 15, 2009. "... similar to the format used at the NAA’s National Academic Championship tournaments. Each match will be divided into four quarters, as follows: 1) Ten relatively easy, “buzzer-beater” toss-up questions."[dead link]
- "Official NAQT Rules". National Academic Quiz Tournaments, LLC. Retrieved March 13, 2012.
- "ACF Packet Submission Guidelines".
- "Message board post by NAQT vice-president of communications Jeff Hoppes announcing the change".
- "University of Chicago Quiz Bowl Team Beats Harvard to Win the First Annual National Academic Quiz Tournament". University of Chicago News Office. January 28, 1997. Retrieved September 15, 2009.
- "College Bowl Campus Program Suspended". College Bowl. Archived from the original on March 9, 2009.
- "Episode List: Texaco Star National Academic Championship". TV Tango. Retrieved March 13, 2012.
- "Overview: Texaco Star National Academic Championship". TV Tango. Retrieved December 18, 2012.
- Jennings, Ken (2006). Brainiac: Adventures in the Curious, Competitive, Compulsive World of Trivia Buffs, Villard