Restoring the Lost Constitution

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Restoring the Lost Constitution: The Presumption of Liberty
2004 Book Cover
2004 Cover
Author Randy Barnett
Country United States
Language English
Subject U.S. Constitution
Genre Non-fiction
Publisher Princeton University Press
Publication date
2003
Published in English
15 December 2003
Media type Print (Hardback & Paperback)
Pages 394 pp (first edition)
ISBN 0-691-11585-0
OCLC 52334894
342.73/029 21
LC Class KF4541 .B313 2004

Restoring the Lost Constitution: The Presumption of Liberty is a 2003 book about the United States Constitution written by Randy Barnett, a professor of law at the Georgetown University Law Center. In the book, Barnett outlines his theory of constitutional legitimacy, interpretation and construction. He argues for an interpretation of the Constitution based on its "original meaning" (as distinct from the founders' original intent).[1] Restoring the Lost Constitution was awarded the 2005 Lysander Spooner Award for Advancing the Literature of Liberty by Laissez Faire Books.[2]

Summary[edit]

Restoring the Lost Constitution is broken into four parts, each addressing an aspect of the U.S. Constitution.

  1. Constitutional Legitimacy – describes the most common arguments for constitutional legitimacy, and argues against them in practical terms. Barnett suggests that in practice it is impossible for any constitution to derive its legitimacy from consent, but it must rather derive legitimacy through "necessity" and "propriety".
  2. Constitutional Method
  3. Constitutional Limits
  4. Constitutional Powers

Reception[edit]

The Journal of Libertarian Studies reviewed the book, stating that "though well-intentioned, the book is fatally flawed".[3] The Future of Freedom Foundation praised Restoring the Lost Constitution, comparing it to "a great symphony on which the composer labored for years, poring over passages again and again to get them just right."[4] The Atlas Society also reviewed the book, writing "Despite its occasional lack of focus, Restoring the Lost Constitution is a succinct and accurate distillation of libertarian constitutional theory—and it convincingly shows that this phrase is largely redundant."[5] Steven G. Calabresi of the Michigan Law Review Association praised the work, citing that it "replaces Richard Epstein's Takings as the leading tome about constitutional law written from a libertarian perspective.[6] The American Political Science Association reviewed the book, saying that it was "a welcome addition to a never-ending debate".[7]

Ronald Kahn of the Law and Politics Book Review wrote that the book was "terrific in demonstrating the natural rights background to our Constitution and demonstrating that all rights cannot be listed in the Constitution", but that "Barnett’s fundamental problem is that he allows for “constitutional construction” when originalism cannot tell us which meanings to adopt, but he does not seem to allow for social construction of law, or changing social meanings".[8] In Ethics Matthew Simpson criticized Restoring the Lost Constitution, stating that while Barnett "argues persuasively that an unprincipled judiciary poses a great threat to constitutionalism in America ... his own principle for reading the Constitution, the presumption of liberty, is implausible and deeply flawed".[9]

References[edit]

  1. ^ Peñalver, Eduardo M. Restoring the Right Constitution? Yale Law Journal. Vol. 116, No. 4, Jan., 2007, p. 732-766
  2. ^ "Restoring the Lost Constitution: The Presumption of Liberty Randy E. Barnett". Princeton University Press. Princeton University. Retrieved 17 December 2010. 
  3. ^ Huebert, J.H., Journal of Libertarian Studies, VOLUME 19, NO. 2 (SPRING 2005): 103–09.
  4. ^ Book Review: Restoring the Lost Constitution Future of Freedom Foundation
  5. ^ The Normality of Freedom The Atlas Society
  6. ^ Calabresi, Steven G. The Originalist and Normative Case against Judicial Activism: A Reply to Professor Randy Barnett. The Michigan Law Review Association. Vol. 103, No. 6, May, 2005, p. 1081 - 1092
  7. ^ Evan Charney. Perspectives on Politics. American Political Science Association. Vol. 2, No. 3, Sep., 2004 p. 564-566
  8. ^ RESTORING THE LOST CONSTITUTION: THE PRESUMPTION OF LIBERTY Law and Politics Book Review
  9. ^ Simpson, Matthew. Ethics, The University of Chicago Press. Vol. 116, No. 1, October 2005

External links[edit]