Revolution (Beatles song)

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
  (Redirected from Revolution (The Beatles))
Jump to: navigation, search
"Revolution (song)" redirects here. For songs of the same name, see Revolution (disambiguation)#Songs.
"Revolution"
Single by The Beatles
A-side "Hey Jude"
Released 26 August 1968
Format 45 rpm
Recorded 9–13 July 1968
Genre Hard rock[1]
Length 3:21
Label Apple
Writer(s) Lennon–McCartney
Producer(s) George Martin
The Beatles singles chronology
"Lady Madonna" / "The Inner Light"
(1968)
"Hey Jude" / "Revolution"
(1968)
"Get Back" / "Don't Let Me Down"
(1969)
Music sample
"Revolution 1"
Song by the Beatles from the album The Beatles
Released 22 November 1968
Recorded 30 May – 21 June 1968
Genre Rock, blues rock
Length 4:17
Label Apple
Writer Lennon–McCartney
Producer George Martin
The Beatles track listing
Music sample

"Revolution" is a song by the Beatles, written by John Lennon and credited to Lennon–McCartney. Two versions of the song were recorded in 1968: a hard rock version, released as the B-side of the "Hey Jude" single, and a slower, bluesier version (titled "Revolution 1") for the album The Beatles (aka the "White Album"). Though the single version was released first, it was recorded several weeks after "Revolution 1" as a re-make specifically intended for release as a single. A third connected piece, written by Lennon, is the experimental track "Revolution 9", which evolved from an unused, spoken-word portion of "Revolution 1", and which also appears on the White Album.

Inspired by political protests in early 1968, Lennon's lyrics expressed doubt in regards to some of the tactics. When the single version was released in August, the political left viewed it as betraying their cause. The release of the album version in November indicated Lennon's uncertainty about destructive change, with the phrase "count me out" recorded differently as "count me out, in". In 1987, the song became the first Beatles recording to be licensed for a television commercial, which prompted a lawsuit from the surviving members of the group.

Background and composition[edit]

In early 1968, media coverage in the aftermath of the Tet Offensive spurred increased protests in opposition to the Vietnam War, especially among university students.[2] The protests were most prevalent in the US, but on 17 March several thousand demonstrators marched to the American embassy in London's Grosvenor Square and violently clashed with police.[3] Major protests concerning other political issues made international news, such as the March 1968 protests in Poland against their communist government, and the campus uprisings of May 1968 in France.[4]

By and large, the Beatles had avoided publicly expressing their political views, with "Taxman" being their only overtly political track thus far. During his time in Rishikesh, Lennon decided to write a song about the recent wave of social upheaval. He recalled, "I thought it was about time we spoke about it [revolution], the same as I thought it was about time we stopped not answering about the Vietnamese war. I had been thinking about it up in the hills in India."[5]

Despite Lennon's antiwar feelings, he had yet to become anti-establishment, and expressed in "Revolution" that he wanted "to see the plan" from those advocating toppling the system.[6] The repeated phrase "it's gonna be alright" in "Revolution" came directly from Lennon's Transcendental Meditation experiences in India, conveying the idea that God would take care of the human race no matter what happened politically.[7] Another influence on Lennon was his burgeoning relationship with avant-garde artist Yoko Ono; Ono attended the recording sessions, and participated in the unused portion of "Revolution 1" which evolved into "Revolution 9".

Around the fourth week of May 1968, the Beatles met at Kinfauns (George Harrison's home in Esher) to demonstrate their compositions to each other in preparation for recording their next studio album. A bootleg recording from that informal session shows that "Revolution" had two of its three verses intact.[6] The line referencing Mao Zedong was added to the lyrics in the studio. During filming of a promotional clip later that year, Lennon told the director that it was the most important lyric of the song.[8] Lennon had changed his mind by 1972, saying "I should have never put that in about Chairman Mao".[9]

Recording[edit]

Revolution 1[edit]

The Beatles began their studio sessions for the new album on 30 May, starting with "Revolution 1" (simply titled "Revolution" for the first few sessions). The first day concentrated on recording the basic rhythm track. Take 18 lasted 10:17, much longer than the earlier takes, and it was this take that was chosen for additional overdubs recorded over the next two sessions.[10]

During overdubs which brought the recording to take 20, Lennon took the unusual step of performing his lead vocal while lying on the floor. He also altered one line into the ambiguous "you can count me out, in".[11] He later explained that he included both because he was undecided in his sentiments.[12] The appended "in" did not appear on the lyric sheet included with the original album.[13]

"Revolution 1" has a blues style, performed at a relaxed tempo. The basic time signature is 12/8 (or 4/4 with a swing feel), but the song has several extra half-length bars during the verses.[14] There is also an extra beat at the end of the last chorus, the result of an accidental bad edit during the mixing process that was left uncorrected at Lennon's request.[15]

Take 20[edit]

Low-quality monitor mixes of the full-length version of Revolution appeared on various bootlegs, such as From Kinfauns to Chaos, throughout the 90s.[16] Then in 2009, a high-quality version labeled "Revolution Take 20" appeared on the bootleg CD Revolution: Take...Your Knickers Off![17][18] The release triggered great media fanfare and activity among fans. This version, RM1 (Remix in Mono #1) of Take 20, runs 10 minutes 46 seconds (at the correct speed) and was created at the end of the 4 June session, with a copy taken away by Lennon.[19] It was an attempt by Lennon to augment the full-length version of "Revolution" in a way that satisfied him before he chose to split the piece between the edited "Revolution 1" and the musique concrete "Revolution 9".

The bootlegged recording starts with engineer Geoff Emerick announcing the remix as "RM1 of Take..." and then momentarily forgetting the take number, which Lennon jokingly finishes with "Take your knickers off and let's go," hence the name of the bootleg CD.[20] The first half of the recording is almost identical to the released track "Revolution 1". It lacks the electric guitar and horn overdubs of the final version, but features two tape loops in the key of A (same as the song) that are faded in and out at various points.[19] After the final chorus, the song launches into an extended coda a la "Hey Jude". (The album version only features about 40 seconds of this coda.) Beyond the point where the album version fades out, the basic instrumental backing keeps repeating while the vocals and overdubs become increasingly chaotic: Paul McCartney and George Harrison repeatedly sing "dada, mama" in a childlike register; John Lennon's histrionic vocals are randomly distorted in speed (a little of this can be heard in the fade of "Revolution 1"); and radio tuning noises à la "I Am the Walrus" appear.[21] Several elements of this coda appear in the officially released "Revolution 9". Throughout the body of that song, Lennon's histrionic vocal track periodically appears (albeit minus the speed distortion), as do the tape loops.

After the band track ends, the song moves into avant-garde territory, with Yoko Ono reciting some prose over an unknown, vaguely operatic recording (possibly captured live from the radio). Yoko's piece begins with the words, "Maybe, it's not that..." with Yoko trailing off at the end; John (or George) jokingly replies, "It is 'that'!" As the piece continues, John quietly mumbles "Gonna be alright" a few times. Then follows a brief piano riff, some comments from John and Yoko on how well the track has preceded, and final appearances of the tape loops.[19] Most of this coda was lifted for the end of "Revolution 9", with a little more piano at the beginning (which monitor mixes reveal was present in earlier mixes of "Revolution"[22]) and minus Lennon's (or Harrison's) joking reply.

Splitting of Revolution 1 and Revolution 9[edit]

Further information: Revolution 9

Lennon soon decided to divide the existing ten-minute recording into two parts: a more conventional Beatles track and an avant-garde sound collage.[23] Within days after take 20, work began on "Revolution 9" using the last six minutes of the take as a starting point. Numerous sound effects, tape loops, and overdubs were recorded and compiled over several sessions almost exclusively by Lennon and Ono, although Harrison provided assistance for additional spoken overdubs.[24] With more than 40 sources used for "Revolution 9", only small portions of the take 20 coda are heard in the final mix; most prominent from take 20 are Lennon's multiple screams of "right" and "alright", and about a minute near the end featuring Ono's lines up to "you become naked".[25]

On 21 June, the first part of take 20 received several overdubs and became officially titled "Revolution 1". The overdubs included a lead guitar line by Harrison and a brass section of two trumpets and four trombones. Final stereo mixing was completed 25 June.[26] The final mix included the hurried announcement of "take two" by engineer Geoff Emerick at the beginning of the song.[15]

Revolution (single version)[edit]

Lennon wanted "Revolution 1" to be the next Beatles single, but McCartney was reluctant to invite controversy, and argued along with Harrison that the track was too slow for a single.[27] Lennon persisted, and rehearsals for a faster and louder re-make began on 9 July; recording started the following day.[28]

The song begins with "a startling machine-gun fuzz guitar riff", with Lennon's and Harrison's guitars prominent throughout the track.[29] The distinctive distorted guitar sound was achieved by direct injection of the guitar signal into the mixing console.[30] Emerick further explained that he routed the signal through two microphone preamplifiers in series while he kept the amount of overload just below the point of overheating the console.[31] McCartney overdubbed the opening scream, and Lennon double-tracked some of the words "so roughly that its careless spontaneity becomes a point in itself".[32]

"Revolution" was performed in a higher key, B major, compared to the A major of "Revolution 1", although the distortion changes the key slightly, leaving the song halfway between B flat and B. The "shoo-bee-do-wah" backing vocals were omitted in the re-make, and an instrumental break was added. "Revolution" was given a climactic end, as opposed to the fade out of "Revolution 1".[33] For this version, Lennon unequivocally sang "count me out". An electric piano overdub by Nicky Hopkins was added 11 July, with final overdubs on 13 July and mono mixing on 15 July.[34]

Release and reception[edit]

"Revolution" was released as the B-side of the "Hey Jude" single in late August 1968. The song reached number 12 in the US and was certified gold. and reached number 1 in New Zealand.[35] The "Hey Jude"/"Revolution" single was listed as a double-sided number 1 in Australia. "Revolution 1" was released on The Beatles in late November 1968. It was the first track on the fourth side, four spots ahead of the companion piece "Revolution 9".

"Revolution" later appeared on the 1970 US compilation album Hey Jude, the first time the song appeared in stereo. Lennon disliked the stereo mix, saying in a 1974 interview that the mono mix of "Revolution" was a "heavy record" but "then they made it into a piece of ice cream!"[36] The song was released on other compilations, including 1967–1970 and Past Masters. It was remixed for the 2006 soundtrack album Love, appearing in full length on the DVD-Audio version and as a shortened edit on other versions.

Music journalist Greil Marcus noted that the political critics had overlooked the music; he wrote that while "there is sterility and repression in the lyrics", the "freedom and movement in the music ... dodges the message and comes out in front."[13] Among later music critics, Dave Marsh included "Revolution" in his 1989 book covering the 1001 greatest singles, describing it as a "gem" with a "ferocious fuzztone rock and roll attack" and a "snarling" Lennon vocal.[37] Writing for Allmusic, Richie Unterberger called "Revolution" one of The Beatles' "greatest, most furious rockers" with "challenging, fiery lyrics" where the listener's "heart immediately starts pounding before Lennon goes into the first verse".[29]

Political reception[edit]

"Count me out if it's for violence. Don't expect me on the barricades unless it's with flowers"

—Statement made by Lennon in 1980 about how "Revolution" still stood as an expression of his politics.[38]

Politically, the release of "Revolution" prompted immediate responses from the New Left and counterculture press: Ramparts branded it a "betrayal", and the New Left Review said the song was "a lamentable petty bourgeois cry of fear".[39] The far left contrasted "Revolution" with a song by The Rolling Stones that was inspired by similar events and released around the same time: "Street Fighting Man" was perceived to be more supportive of their cause.[3] Others on the left praised The Beatles for rejecting radicalism and advocating "pacifist idealism".[40] The song's seeming scepticism about revolution caused Lennon to become the target of a few various minority Trotskyist, Leninist and in particular Maoist groups.[41]

The far right remained suspicious of the Beatles, saying they were moderate subversives who were "warning the Maoists not to 'blow' the revolution by pushing too hard".[7] As further evidence of The Beatles' supposed "pro-Soviet" sentiments, the John Birch Society magazine cited another song on the White Album, "Back in the U.S.S.R.".[42] Anti-communist and far-right groups also picked on the track "Piggies", which was about social class and corporate greed.[43][44]

Promotional clips[edit]

Filming for promotional clips of "Hey Jude" and "Revolution" took place on 4 September 1968 under the direction of Michael Lindsay-Hogg. Two finished clips of "Revolution" were produced, with only lighting differences and other minor variations.[45] The Beatles sang the vocals live over the pre-recorded instrumental track from the single version. Their vocals included elements from "Revolution 1": McCartney and Harrison sang the "shoo-bee-doo-wah" backing vocals, and Lennon sang "count me out, in". Lennon also substituted "we'd all love" for "we all want" in the opening verse. Later it was correctly pointed out that a track of Lennon's voice is in fact playing in the background during the performance and can be heard quite noticeably at the end of the song when he fails to shout out his last and most explosive 'All right.' Instead, the shout is heard from the soundtrack after he has already stopped singing and backed away from the microphone.

While the "Hey Jude" clip debuted on David Frost's ITV television programme, the "Revolution" clip was first broadcast on the BBC1 programme Top of the Pops on 19 September 1968. The first US screening of "Revolution" was on the 13 October 1968 broadcast of The Smothers Brothers Comedy Hour.[45]

Personnel[edit]

Revolution
Revolution 1
Personnel per Ian MacDonald[46]

Use in Nike advertisement[edit]

"If it's allowed to happen, every Beatles song ever recorded is going to be advertising women's underwear and sausages. We've got to put a stop to it in order to set a precedent. Otherwise it's going to be a free-for-all. It's one thing when you're dead, but we're still around! They don't have any respect for the fact that we wrote and recorded those songs, and it was our lives."

—George Harrison in November 1987[47]

In 1987, "Revolution" became the first Beatles recording to be licensed for use in a television commercial.[48] Nike paid $500,000 for the right to use the song for one year, split between recording owner Capitol-EMI and song publisher ATV Music Publishing (owned by Michael Jackson). Commercials using the song started airing in March 1987.[47]

The three surviving Beatles, through their record company Apple, filed a lawsuit in July 1987 objecting to Nike's use of the song. The suit was aimed at Nike, its advertising agency Wieden+Kennedy,[49] and Capitol-EMI Records.[50] Capitol-EMI said the lawsuit was groundless because they had licensed the use of "Revolution" with the "active support and encouragement of Yoko Ono Lennon, a shareholder and director of Apple".[47] Ono had expressed approval when the commercial was released, saying the commercial "is making John's music accessible to a new generation".[50]

The "Revolution" lawsuit and others involving the Beatles and EMI were settled out of court in November 1989, with the terms kept secret.[51] The financial website TheStreet.com included the Nike "Revolution" advertisement campaign in its list of the 100 key business events of the 20th century, as it helped "commodify dissent".[52]

Cover versions[edit]

Thompson Twins version[edit]

"Revolution"
Single by Thompson Twins
from the album Here's to Future Days
B-side The Fourth Sunday
Released 29 November 1985
Format 7" vinyl, 12" vinyl
Recorded 1984-1985
Genre Pop Rock
Length 5:20
Label Arista Records
Producer(s) Nile Rodgers & Tom Bailey
Thompson Twins singles chronology
"King for a Day"
(1985)
"Revolution"
(1985)
"Nothing In Common"
(1986)
Arista TWINS 1210
Arista TWINS 2210

Thompson Twins covered "Revolution" on the 1985 album Here's to Future Days, from which it was released as the fourth and final single. The single peaked at #56 in the UK, spending five weeks on the chart.[53] A promotional music video was made to the single version of the song. The B-side, "The Fourth Sunday", was exclusive to this single.

Thompson Twins also performed the song with Madonna and Nile Rodgers at Live Aid

Formats[edit]

7" UK vinyl single (1985) Arista TWINS 10

Side A

  1. "Revolution" - 3:23

Side B

  1. "The Fourth Sunday" - 4:18
12" UK vinyl single (1985) Arista TWINS 1210

Side One

  1. "Revolution" (Extended Mix) - 6:25

Side Two

  1. "The Fourth Sunday" - 4:18
12" UK vinyl single (1985) Arista TWINS 2210

Side One

  1. "Revolution" (Remix) - 6:00

Side Two

  1. "The Fourth Sunday" - 4:18

Chart performance[edit]

Chart (1985) Peak
position
UK Singles Chart[53] 56
New Zealand Singles Chart [54] 43

Official versions[edit]

Version Length Mixed/Remixed by Comment
Album version 4:04 James Farber Found on the album Here's To Future Days, and on a select few of their greatest hits compilations.
7" single version 3:23 Tom Bailey & Brian Tench Only found on the UK 7" vinyl single. Never has been released on CD.
Extended mix 6:25 Tom Bailey & Brian Tench Found on the UK 12" vinyl single (Arista TWINS 1210), the 12" vinyl single for "Nothing In Common", and the CD Thompson Twins - '12 Inch Collection' (2004 BMG Japan).
Remix 6:00 John Morales & Sergio Munzibai Found on the UK 12" vinyl single (Arista TWINS 2210), and on the double CD reissue of Here's To Future Days (2008 Edsel Records).

Personnel[edit]

  • Tom Bailey - vocals, piano, Fairlight, synthesizers, guitar, contrabass, Fairlight and drum programming
  • Alannah Currie - lyrics, marimba, backing vocals, acoustic drums, percussion, tuned percussion
  • Joe Leeway - backing vocals, congas, percussion
  • Steve Stevens - additional guitar
  • Produced by Nile Rodgers and Tom Bailey
  • Mixed by James Farber
  • Mixed at Skyline Studio, NYC
  • Photography - Rebecca Blake
  • Artwork/Design - Andie Airfix, Satori
  • Art Direction - Alannah

Stone Temple Pilots version[edit]

"Revolution"
Single by Stone Temple Pilots
Released November 2001 (2001-11)
Format CD single
Recorded 6 October 2001
Genre Hard rock
Length 3:21
Label Atlantic Records
Writer(s) Lennon–McCartney
Stone Temple Pilots singles chronology
"Days of the Week"
(2001)
"Revolution"
(2001)
"All in the Suit That You Wear
(2003)

In October 2001, Stone Temple Pilots performed "Revolution" live during Come Together: A Night for John Lennon's Words and Music, a television special in tribute to Lennon that raised funds for victims of the September 11 attacks on the World Trade Center. After their performance received significant radio airplay, the group recorded a studio version, which was released as a single in November 2001.[55] The song reached number 30 on the US Mainstream Rock Tracks chart.[56]

Other covers[edit]

References[edit]

Footnotes
  1. ^ McKeen 1989, pp. 90-100.
  2. ^ MacDonald 1994, p. 226.
  3. ^ a b Burley 2008.
  4. ^ Dülffer 2008.
  5. ^ The Beatles 2000, p. 298.
  6. ^ a b Everett 1999, p. 173.
  7. ^ a b MacDonald 1994, p. 227.
  8. ^ Bextor, Barrow & Newby 2004, p. 74.
  9. ^ Spignesi & Lewis 2004, p. 40.
  10. ^ Lewisohn 1988, pp. 135–136.
  11. ^ Lewisohn 1988, p. 136.
  12. ^ Wenner 2000, pp. 110–111.
  13. ^ a b Wiener 1991, p. 61.
  14. ^ Everett 1999, p. 174.
  15. ^ a b Emerick & Massey 2006, p. 243.
  16. ^ "From Kinfauns to Chaos". FabFour.de. 
  17. ^ Kreps 2009.
  18. ^ Winn 2009, pp. 171–173.
  19. ^ a b c McKinney 2009.
  20. ^ Winn 2009, p. 173.
  21. ^ Lewisohn 1988, p. 135.
  22. ^ From Kinfauns to Chaos (Media notes). Beatles. Vigotone. 1999. VT-184. 
  23. ^ Winn 2009, p. 180.
  24. ^ Lewisohn 1988, pp. 136–138.
  25. ^ Everett 1999, pp. 174–175.
  26. ^ Lewisohn 1988, pp. 138–139.
  27. ^ MacDonald 1994, p. 229.
  28. ^ Lewisohn 2000, pp. 288–289.
  29. ^ a b Unterberger.
  30. ^ Everett 1999, p. 178.
  31. ^ Emerick & Massey 2006, p. 253.
  32. ^ MacDonald 1994, p. 238.
  33. ^ Pollack 1997.
  34. ^ Lewisohn 2000, p. 289.
  35. ^ Allmusic.
  36. ^ Unterberger 2006, p. 167.
  37. ^ Marsh 1989, p. 424.
  38. ^ Turner 2009, p. 101.
  39. ^ Wiener 1991, p. 60.
  40. ^ Wiener 1991, p. 62.
  41. ^ Turner 2009, p. 100.
  42. ^ Wiener 1991, p. 63.
  43. ^ Turner 2009, p. 86.
  44. ^ Turner 2009, p. 68.
  45. ^ a b Lewisohn 2000, pp. 296–297.
  46. ^ MacDonald 1994, pp. 223, 237.
  47. ^ a b c Doyle 2009.
  48. ^ A cover version of "Help!" had been used two years earlier in a Lincoln–Mercury commercial.
  49. ^ The ad was conceived by copywriter Janet Champ and art directors Susan Hoffman and Kristi Myers, directed by Peter Kagan and Paula Greif and edited by Larry Bridges (Communication Arts, vol. 29, no. 5, p. 112).
  50. ^ a b Pareles 1987.
  51. ^ Kozinn 1989.
  52. ^ TheStreet.com 1999.
  53. ^ a b "Thompson Twins - Revolution". ChartArchive.org. Retrieved 24 Sep 2012. 
  54. ^ "New Zealand Charts". charts.org.nz. Retrieved 24 Sep 2012. 
  55. ^ Wiederhorn 2001.
  56. ^ Billboard 2001.
  57. ^ Sampsel, Kurt (December 2001). "Reviews". Fufkin.com. Retrieved 13 October 2010. 
  58. ^ Remz, Jeffrey B. "Rascal Flatts jump starts "Revolution"". Country Standard Time. Retrieved 13 October 2010. 
  59. ^ "Beatles Cover Versions". beatlescoverversions.com. Retrieved 13 October 2010. 
  60. ^ "Big Time Movie Soundtrack - EP". Retrieved 5 July 2013. 
Bibliography

External links[edit]