Roboethics is a short expression for ethics of robotics. It is often used in the sense that it is concerned with the behavior of humans, how humans design, construct, use and treat robots and other artificially intelligent beings, whereas * machine ethics is concerned with the behavior of robots themselves, whether or not they are considered artificial moral agents (AMAs).
While the issue is as old as the word robot, the short word roboethics was probably first used by roboticist Gianmarco Veruggio in 2002, who also served as chair of an Atelier funded by the European Robotics Research Network to outline areas where research may be needed. The road map effectively divided ethics of artificial intelligence into two sub-fields to accommodate researchers' differing interests:
- 1 Main positions on roboethics
- 2 Disciplines involved in roboethics
- 3 Principles
- 4 General ethical issues in science and technology
- 5 History
- 6 In popular culture
- 7 Notes
- 8 References
- 9 Further reading
- 10 External links
Main positions on roboethics
- Not interested in ethics (This is the attitude of those who consider that their actions are strictly technical, and do not think they have a social or a moral responsibility in their work)
- Interested in short-term ethical questions (This is the attitude of those who express their ethical concern in terms of “good” or “bad,” and who refer to some cultural values and social conventions)
- Interested in long-term ethical concerns (This is the attitude of those who express their ethical concern in terms of global, long-term questions)
Disciplines involved in roboethics
The design of Roboethics requires the combined commitment of experts of several disciplines, who, working in transnational projects, committees, commissions, have to adjust laws and regulations to the problems resulting from the scientific and technological achievements in Robotics and AI.
In all likelihood, it is to be expected that the birth of new curricula studiorum and specialties, necessary to manage a subject so complex, just as it happened with Forensic Medicine. In particular, the main fields involved in Roboethics are: robotics, computer science, artificial intelligence, philosophy, ethics, theology, biology, physiology, cognitive science, neurosciences, law, sociology, psychology, and industrial design.
As roboethics is a human-centered ethics, it should comply with the principles state in the most important and widely accepted Charters of Human Rights:
- Human dignity and human rights.
- Equality, justice and equity.
- Benefit and harm.
- Respect for cultural diversity and pluralism.
- Non-discrimination and non-stigmatization.
- Autonomy and individual responsibility.
- Informed consent.
- Solidarity and cooperation.
- Social responsibility.
- Sharing of benefits.
- Responsibility towards the biosphere.
General ethical issues in science and technology
Roboethics shares with the other fields of science and technology most of the ethical problems derived from the Second and Third Industrial Revolutions:
- Dual-use technology.
- Environmental impact of technology.
- Effects of technology on the global distribution of wealth.
- Digital divide, socio-technological gap.
- Fair access to technological resources.
- Dehumanization of humans in the relationship with the machines.
- Technology addiction.
- Anthropomorphization of the machines.
|Laws of robotics|
Tilden's Laws of Robotics
by Mark Tilden
Since antiquity, the discussion of ethics in relation to the treatment of non-human and even non-living things and their potential "spirituality" have been discussed. With the development machinery and eventually robots, this philosophy was also applied to robotics. The first publication directly addressing roboethics was developed by Isaac Asimov as his Three Laws of Robotics in 1942, in the context of his science fiction works, although the term "roboethics" was created by Gianmarco Veruggio in 2002.
The Roboethic guidelines were developed during some important robotics events and projects:
- 1942, Asimov's short story "Runaround" explicitly states his Three Laws for the first time. Those "Laws" get reused for later works of robot-related science fiction by Asimov.
- 2004, First International Symposium on Roboethics, 30–31 January 2004, Villa Nobel, Sanremo, Italy, organized by School of Robotics, where, the word Roboethics was officially used for the first time;
- 2004, IEEE-RAS established a Technical Committee on Roboethics.
- 2004, Fukuoka World Robot Declaration, issued on February 25, 2004 from Fukuoka, Japan.
- 2005, ICRA05 (International Conference on Robotics and Automation), Barcelona: the IEEE RAS TC on Roboethics organized a Workshop on Roboethics.
- 2005–2006, E.C. Euron Roboethics Atelier (Genoa, Italy, February/March 2006). The Euron Project, coordinated by School of Robotics, involved a large number of roboticists and scholars of humanities who produced the first Roadmap for a Roboethics.
- 2006, BioRob2006 (The first IEEE / RAS-EMBS International Conference on Biomedical Robotics and Bio-mechatronics), Pisa, Italy, February 20, 2006: Mini symposium on Roboethics.
- 2006, International Workshop “Ethics of Human Interaction with Robotic, Bionic, and AI Systems: Concepts and Policies”, Naples, 17–18 October 2006. The workshop was supported by the ETHICBOTS European Project.
- 2007 ICRA07 (International Conference on Robotics and Automation), Rome: the IEEE RAS TC on Roboethics organized a Workshop on Roboethics.
- 2007 ICAIL’07,International Conference on Artificial Intelligence and Law, Stanford University, Palo Alto, USA, 4–8 June.
- 2007 International European Conference on Computing and Philosophy E-CAP ‘07, University of Twente, Netherlands, 21–23 June 2007. Track “Roboethics”.
- 2007 Computer Ethics Philosophical Enquiry CEPE '07, University of San Diego, USA,12–14 July 2007. Topic “Roboethics”.
- 2008 INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ROBOTICS: NEW SCIENCE, Thursday FEBRUARY 20th, 2008, Via della Lungara 10 – ROME - ITALY
- 2009 ICRA09 (International Conference on Robotics and Automation), Kobe, Japan: the IEEE RAS TC on Roboethics organized a Workshop on Roboethics.
- 2012 We Robot 2012, University of Miami, FL, USA
- 2013 Workshop on Robot Ethics, University of Sheffield, Feb 2013
- 2013 We Robot 2013 - Getting Down to Business, Stanford University
- 2014 We Robot 2014 - Risks and Opportunities, University of Miami, FL, USA
In popular culture
Roboethics as a science or philosophical topic has not made any strong cultural impact, but is a common theme in science fiction literature and films. One of the most popular films depicting the potential misuse of robotic and AI technology is The Matrix, depicting a future where the lack of roboethics brought about the destruction of the human race. An animated film based on The Matrix, the Animatrix, focused heavily on the potential ethical issues between humans and robots. Many of the Animatrix's animated shorts are also named after Isaac Asimov's fictional stories. The movie I, Robot (named after Isaac Asimov's book I, Robot) also depicts a scenario where robots rebel against humans due to the lack of civil rights and ethical treatment.
Although not a part of roboethics per se, the ethical behavior of robots themselves has also been a joining issue in roboethics in popular culture. The Terminator series focuses on robots run by an uncontrolled AI program with no restraint on the termination of its enemies. This series too has the same futuristic plot as The Matrix series, where robots have taken control. The most famous case of robots or computers without programmed ethics is HAL 9000 in the Space Odyssey series, where HAL (a computer with advance AI capabilities who monitors and assists humans on a space station) kills all the humans on board to ensure the success of the assigned mission.
- Veruggio, Gianmarco (2007). "The Roboethics Roadmap". Scuola di Robotica. p. 2. Retrieved 2011-04-28.
- Levy, David (November, 2008). Love and Sex with Robots: The Evolution of Human-Robot Relationships. Harper Perennial.
- Laryionava, Katsiaryna/Gross, Dominik (2012). Deus Ex Machina or E-slave? Public Perception of Healthcare Robotics in the German Print Media, International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care 28/3: 265-270.
- Lin, Patrick/Abney, Keith/Bekey, George A. (December, 2011). Robot Ethics: The Ethical and Social Implications of Robotics. MIT Press.
- Gunkel, David J. (July, 2012). The Machine Question: Critical Perspectives on AI, Robotics, and Ethics. MIT Press.
- Ethics + Emerging Sciences Group
- The Makkula Center for Applied Ethics at Santa Clara University, USA
- Conference list on the Official Roboethics Website
- Cultural Attitude Towards Technology and Communication Conference
- The Pugwash Conference on Science and World Affairs
- Technical Committee on Roboethics
- We Robot - An Annual Conference Dedicated to Legal and Policy Issues Related to Robotics
- International Society for Ethics and Information Technology
- Computer Professionals for Social Responsibility
- The Centre for Responsible Nanotechnology
- Union of Concerned Scientists
- The International Institute of Humanitarian Law
- Living Safely with Robots, Beyond Asimov's Laws, PhysOrg.com, June 22, 2009.
- Plug & Pray, documentary film on the ethics of robotics and artificial intelligence (with Joseph Weizenbaum and Ray Kurzweil)