He was the producer of Black Sabbath's first three albums, Budgie's first two albums, Judas Priest's first album, Rocka Rolla, and Wild Turkey's debut album Battle Hymn. Bain dominated the production of Priest's first album and made decisions that the band did not agree with. Bain chose to leave fan favourites such as "Tyrant", "Genocide", and "The Ripper," off the album. As well, he cut the song "Caviar and Meths" from a 10-minute song down to a 2-minute instrumental.
He also produced the Judas Priest album Hero, Hero (an album not authorised by the band, who in their split with Gull Records had had to concede the original recordings of their first albums to Gull, although they retained the rights to the songs), which contained remixed versions of the tracks on Rocka Rolla. Both of these Judas Priest albums received a lot of negative reviews.
He subsequently went on to produce Barclay James Harvest, producing their first two albums for Polydor, Everyone Is Everybody Else and Barclay James Harvest Live. Although he reportedly did not get on with the band, the albums are highly regarded.
In the Last Supper DVD, Black Sabbath bassist Geezer Butler describes Bain positively and claims that he let them record their album live which was and still is an uncommon method of recording, when other producers had refused. This is also how he is said[by whom?] to have produced the other albums mentioned above.