Rokotov–Faibishenko case

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

The Rokotov–Faibishenko case, tried in the Soviet Union in 1961, helped demonstrate that despite the Khrushchev Thaw, Stalinist tendencies were still present in the Soviet judicial system. It also marked the start of a three-year campaign against large-scale economic crimes, accompanied by show trials.

Ever since the 6th World Festival of Youth and Students, held in Moscow in 1957, dealing in foreign currency had begun to take place on a fairly large scale despite being illegal. Soviets (generally of a young age) would buy foreign currency from tourists and other visitors, selling it for a profit.

In 1961, the authorities broke one such speculation ring, composed of nine people, which had acquired around 20 million rubles in a year. During the search, they found 344,000 rubles, 1,524 gold coins, about $19,000, almost £500, 3,345 new and 133,000 old French francs1, 1,500 German marks, 8,500 Belgian francs, other currency, icons and other contraband. It was the KGB that conducted the investigation because contact with foreigners was involved.

Those arrested were Ian Timofeyevich Rokotov, I. I. Lagun, the married couple Nadya Edlis and Sergei Popov (a pianist), the brothers Yash and Shalv Papismedov, their nephew Ilya (the three of whom bought gold from Edlis and sold it in Georgia), Vladislav "Vladik" Petrovich Faibishenko, and Mubashirya Rizvanova.

Rokotov and Faibishenko had a history of making profit, which was not only illegal in the USSR but also looked down upon as immoral, as it went against the country's guiding Leninist ideology. Roikotov had traded in stamps, books and camera equipment in school and moved up to foreign clothing before entering the currency business. Faibishenko had bought and sold foreign stockings and chewing gum during the 1957 youth festival.

Rokotov (at least) was held in Lefortovo prison prior to the trial.

The case was tried in Moscow City Court beginning on May 31, 1961. The trial lasted thirteen days and was well-attended. On June 15, Rokotov, Faibishenko and Edlis were sentenced to fifteen years' imprisonment and confiscation of all property. Lagun, the Papismedov brothers, and Rizvanova received eight-year sentences and had their illegally obtained property confiscated. Ilya Papismedov was sent to prison for six years.2 The sentence was met approvingly by the audience, and the state treasury received an infusion of over twelve kilograms of gold coins, a large amount of foreign and Soviet currency, and other materials.

At this point the influence of General Secretary Nikita Khrushchev began to be felt, and with it the accompanying politicisation of the case. During the trial the KGB had arranged an exhibit featuring the group's holdings: a mountain of valuables, Czarist gold coins, a mound of foreign banknotes, packets of Soviet money and bank deposit books. Khrushchev was invited and supposedly remarked, "They need to be shot for this". Although this was taken for yet another of his angry outbursts, he was serious this time.

Those defendants who had received 15-year sentences were given them illegally, as the maximum penalty was eight years (under Article 88 of the Criminal Code of the RSFSR). Still, the procurator general of the USSR condemned the "leniency of the punishment" assigned to Rokotov and Faibishenko. Then on July 1 the Presidium of the USSR Supreme Soviet issued an edict providing the death penalty for violators of the laws regarding foreign currency operations. Another edict was issued secretly, applying this norm retroactively to the two men. Aleksei Adzhubei, Khrushchev's son-in-law and editor-in-chief of Izvestia, saw this as clearly illegal and tried to intercede on their behalf, but the General Secretary had made up his mind.

On July 18 and 19 the case was retried by a panel of three judges at the Russian Republic Supreme Court. The trial was shown on television. The court established that Rokotov had bought and sold 12 million rubles' worth of currency and gold coins, while Faibishenko had bought and resold 1 million rubles' worth of currency. Izvestia noted that they had "led a parasitic type of life and enriched themselves through the benefits created by the working people". Accordingly, on July 21, pursuant to Article 25 of the Law on State Crimes, they were sentenced to death by shooting with confiscation of all their valuables and property. The sentence was heard "with approval" by those present.

Soon after, both men were shot. They were twenty-two years old. Thousands of Soviet citizens sent letters endorsing the penalty, though a few condemned it, in part because retroactive punishment was banned by Article 6 of the RSFSR Criminal Code.

Khrushchev had spoken of a "return to Leninist norms of socialist legality" after years of abuse of the legal system by Joseph Stalin. This case made clear, however, that the rights of Soviet citizens did not extend to capitalist activities such as profiteering and speculation.

Notes[edit]

^1 The franc was revalued in 1960.
^2 The Izvestia report of June 16 does not mention Popov.

References[edit]

  • Feofanov, Yuri and Barry, Donald D. (1996). Politics and Justice in Russia: Major Trials of the Post-Stalin Era, pp. 22–31. M. E. Sharpe, Inc. ISBN 1-56324-344-X.
  • Schwartz, Charles A. (1981). "Economic Crime in the USSR: A Comparison of the Khrushchev and Brezhnev Eras". The International and Comparative Law Quarterly 30 (2): 281–296. doi:10.1093/iclqaj/30.2.281.