|Founding location||Russia, former Soviet Union|
|Territory||Active in many parts of Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union throughout Russia (mostly Moscow), United States (mostly Brighton Beach), Canada, Spain, Portugal, France, Hungary and more.|
|Criminal activities||Money laundering, racketeering, extortion, arms trafficking, cybercrime, human trafficking, prostitution, drug trafficking, arson, fraud, larceny, murder|
The Russian Mafia (Russian: русская мафия; russkaya mafiya) or Bratva, is a term used to refer to the collective of various organized crime elements originating in the former Soviet Union. Although not a singular criminal organization, most of the individual groups share similar goals and organizational structures that define them as part of the loose overall association.
Organized crime in Russia began in its imperial period of Tsars, but it was not until the Soviet era that vory v zakone ("thieves-in-law") emerged as leaders of prison groups in gulags (Soviet prison labor camps), and their honor code became more defined. After World War II, the death of Joseph Stalin, and the fall of the Soviet Union, more gangs emerged in a flourishing black market, exploiting the unstable governments of the former Republics, and at its highest point, even controlling as much as two-thirds of the Russian economy. Louis Freeh, former director of the FBI, had once said the Russian mafia posed the greatest threat to U.S. national security in the mid-1990s.
In modern times, there are as many as 6,000 different groups, with more than 200 of them having a global reach. Criminals of these various groups are either former prison members[clarification needed], corrupt Communist officials and business leaders, people with ethnic ties, or people from the same region with shared criminal experiences and leaders[clarification needed]. However, the existence of such groups has been debatable[clarification needed]. In December 2009, Timur Lakhonin, the head of the Russian National Central Bureau of Interpol, stated, "Certainly, there is crime involving our former compatriots abroad, but there is no data suggesting that an organized structure of criminal groups comprising former Russians exists abroad", while in August 2010, Alain Bauer, a French criminologist, said that it "is one of the best structured criminal organizations in Europe, with a quasi-military operation."
- 1 History
- 2 Structure and composition
- 3 Notable individual groups
- 4 Popular culture
- 5 See also
- 6 References
- 7 External links
The Russian mafia can be traced back to Russia's imperial period, which began in the 1700s, in the form of banditry and thievery. Most of the population were peasants in poverty at the time, and criminals who stole from government entities and divided profits among the people earned Robin Hood-like status, being viewed as protectors of the poor and becoming folk heroes. In time, the Vorovskoy Mir (Thieves' World) emerged as these criminals grouped and started their own code of conduct that was based on strict loyalty with one another and opposition against the government. When the Bolshevik Revolution came around in 1917, the Thieves' World was alive and active. Vladimir Lenin attempted to wipe them out after being robbed by a gang of highwaymen who also did a rape attempt, but failed[clarification needed], but the criminals survived onto Joseph Stalin's reign.
1917–1991: Soviet era
During Stalin's reign as ruler, millions of criminals were sent to gulags (Soviet labor camps), where powerful criminals worked their way up to become vory v zakone ("thieves-in-law"). These criminal elite often conveyed their status through complicated tattoos, an act that is still used today by Russian mobsters.
After Hitler's invasion of the Soviet Union during World War II, Stalin was desperate for more men to fight for the nation, offering prisoners freedom if they joined the army. Many flocked to help out in the war, but this act betrayed codes of the Thieves' World that one must not ally with the government. When the war was over, however, Stalin sent them back to prison. Those who refused to fight in the war referred to the traitors as suka ("bitch"), and the latter landed at the bottom of the "hierarchy". Outcast, the suki separated from the others and formed their own groups and power bases by collaborating with prison officials, eventually gaining the luxury of comfortable positions. Bitterness between the groups erupted into a series of Bitch Wars from 1945 to 1953 with many killed every day. The prison officials encouraged the violence, seeing it as a way to rid the prisons of criminals.
After the death of Stalin, around eight million inmates were released from gulags. Those that survived the imprisonment and Bitch Wars became a new breed of criminal, no longer bound to the laws of the old Thieves' World. They adopted an "every-man-for-himself" attitude that meant cooperating with the government if necessary. As corruption spread throughout the Soviet government, the criminal underworld began to flourish. This corruption was common during the Brezhnev era, and the nomenklatura (the power elite of the country, usually corrupt officials) ran the country along with criminal bosses. In the 1970s, small illegal businesses sprang up throughout the country, with the government ignoring them, and the black market thrived. Then, in the 1980s, Mikhail Gorbachev loosened up restrictions on private businesses, allowing them to grow legally, but by then, the Soviet Union was already beginning to collapse.
Also during the 1970s and 1980s, the United States expanded its immigration policies, allowing Soviet Jews and criminals to enter the country, with most settling in a southern Brooklyn area known as Brighton Beach (sometimes nicknamed as "Little Odessa"). Here is where Russian organized crime began in the US. The earliest known case of Russian crime in the area was in the mid-1970s by the "Potato Bag Gang," a group of con artists disguised as merchants that told customers that they were selling antique gold rubles for cheap, but in fact, gave them bags of potatoes when bought in thousands. By 1983, the head of Russian organized crime in Brighton Beach was Evsei Agron.
Pauol Mirzoyan, Small Time Leader, He was a prime target among other mobsters, including rival Boris Goldberg and his organization, and in May 1985, Agron was assassinated. Boris "Biba" Nayfeld, his bodyguard, moved on to employ under Marat Balagula, who was believed to have succeeded Agron's authority. In the following year, Balagula fled the country after he was convicted in a fraud scheme of Merrill Lynch customers, and was found in Frankfurt, West Germany in 1989, where he was extradited back to the US and sentenced to eight years in prison.
Balagula would later be convicted on a separate $360,000 credit card fraud in 1992. Nayfield took Balagula's place, partnering with the "Polish Al Capone", Ricardo Fanchiniin, in an import-export business and setting up a heroin business. In 1990, his former friend, Monya Elson, back from a six-year prison sentence in Israel, returned to America and set up a rival heroin business, culminating in a Mafia turf war.
1992–2000: Growth and internationalization
When the USSR collapsed and a free market economy emerged, organized criminal groups began to take over Russia's economy, with many ex-KGB soldiers and veterans of the Afghan war offering their skills to the crime bosses. Gangster summit meetings had taken place in hotels and restaurants shortly before the Soviet's dissolution, so that top vory v zakone could agree on who would rule what, and set plans on how to take over the post-Communist state. It was agreed upon that Vyacheslav "Yaponchik" Ivankov would be sent to Brighton Beach in 1992, allegedly because he was killing too many people in Russia and also to take control of Russian organized crime in North America. Within a year, he built an international operation that included, but was not limited to, narcotics, money laundering, and prostitution and made ties with the American Mafia and Colombian drug cartels, eventually extending to Miami, Los Angeles, and Boston. Those who went against him were usually killed.
Prior to Ivankov's arrival, Balagula's downfall left an empty void for America's next vory v zakone. Monya Elson, leader of Monya's Brigada (a gang that similarly operated from Russia to Los Angeles to New York), was in a feud with Boris Nayfeld, with bodies dropping on both sides. Ivankov's arrival virtually ended the feud, although Elson would later challenge his power as well, and a number of attempts were made to end the former's life. Nayfield and Elson would eventually be arrested in January 1994 (released in 1998) and in Italy in 1995, respectively.
Ivankov's reign, too, ended in June 1995 when a $3.5 million extortion attempt from two Russian businessmen, Alexander Volkov and Vladimir Voloshin, ended in an FBI arrest that resulted in a ten-year maximum security prison sentence. Before his arrest and besides his operations in America, Ivankov regularly flew around Europe and Asia to maintain ties with his fellow mobsters (like members of the Solntsevskaya Bratva), as well as reinforce ties with others. This did not stop other people from denying him growing power. In one instance, Ivankov attempted to buy out Georgian boss Valeri "Globus" Glugech's drug importation business. When the latter refused the offer, he and his top associates were shot dead. A summit held in May 1994 in Vienna rewarded him with what was left of Glugech's business. Two months later, Ivankov got into another altercation with drug kingpin and head of the Orekhovskaya gang, Segei "Sylvester" Timofeyev, ending with the latter murdered a month later.
Back in Eastern Europe in May 1995, crime boss Semion Mogilevich held a different summit meeting of Russian mafia bosses in his U Holubu restaurant in Anděl, a neighborhood of Prague. The excuse to bring them together was that it was a birthday party for Victor Averin, the second-in-command of the Solntsevskaya Bratva. However, Major Tomas Machacek of the Czech police got wind of an anonymous tip-off that claimed that the Solntsevskaya were planning to assassinate Mogilevich at the location (it was rumored that Mogilevich and Solntsevskaya leader Sergei Mikhailov had a dispute over $5 million), and the police successfully raided the meeting. 200 guests were arrested, but no charges were put against them; only key Russian mafia members were banned from the country, most of whom moved to Hungary.
One person that wasn't there, though, was Mogilevich himself. He claimed that "[b]y the time I arrived at U Holubu, everything was already in full swing, so I went into a neighboring hotel and sat in the bar there until about five or six in the morning." Mikhailov would later be arrested in Switzerland in October 1996 on numerous charges, including that he was the head of a powerful Russian mafia group, but was exonerated and released two years later after evidence was not enough to prove much.
The worldwide extent of Russian organized crime wasn't realized until Ludwig "Tarzan" Fainberg was arrested in January 1997, primarily because of global arms dealing. In 1990, Fainberg moved from Brighton Beach to Miami and opened up a strip club called Porky's, which soon became a popular hangout for underworld criminals. Fainberg himself gained a reputation as an ambassador among international crime groups, becoming especially close to Juan Almeida, a Colombian cocaine dealer. Planning to expand his cocaine business, Fainberg acted as an intermediary between Almeida and the corrupt Russian military. He helped him get six Russian military helicopters in 1993, and in the following year, helped arrange to buy a submarine for cocaine smuggling. Unfortunately for the two of them, federal agents had been keeping a close eye on Fainberg for months. Alexander Yasevich, an associate of the Russian military contact and an undercover DEA agent, was sent to verify the illegal dealing, and in 1997, Fainberg was finally arrested in Miami. Facing the possibility of life imprisonment, the latter agreed for his testimony against Almeida in exchange for a shorter sentence, which ended up being 33 months.
As the 21st century dawned, the Russian mafia remained alive and well. New Mafia bosses sprung up, while imprisoned ones were released. Among the released were Pachovich Sloat[who?], Marat Balagula and Vyacheslav Ivankov, all three in 2004. The latter was extradited to Russia, but was jailed once more for his alleged murders of two Turks in a Moscow restaurant in 1992; he was cleared of all charges and released in 2005. Four years later, he was assassinated by a shot in the stomach from a sniper. Meanwhile, Monya Elson, along with Leonid Roytman, were arrested in March 2006 for an unsuccessful murder plot against two Kiev-based businessmen.
In 2009, FBI agents in Moscow targeted[clarification needed] two suspected Mafia leaders and two other corrupt businessmen. One of the leaders is Yevgeny Dvoskin, a criminal who had been in prison with Ivankov in 1995 and was deported in 2001 for breaking immigration regulations; the other is Konstantin "Gizya" Ginzburg, who is reportedly the current "big boss" of Russian organized crime in America after it was suspected that Ivankov handed over his control to him.
In 2009, Maxim Sheaib was a prominent name that surfaced in the crime world. Underground organizations know him as the Prince. Sheaib is also known as the negotiator between different counterparts in criminal organizations, allowing him the nickname of the Diplomat. He had a wide presence in Thailand during and after Viktor Bout arrest. It is reported that Sheaib arranged meetings and negotiations between Bout counterparts and other organizations while residing in Malaysia. He was last reported to be seen in 2012, in Singapore and Malaysia, meeting with previous members of the Sa Lah Kau gang and the Triad. Sheaib origins are not clear due to his strong ties with different ethnic groups as well as many relationships in different regions. Sheaib has strong presence in Eastern Europe, the Middle East, and Asia. He was reportedly noted during Viktor Bout arrest and had links to the meeting between Aslan Usoyan and Tariel Oniani. Some facts state that Sheaib was present in Eastern Europe right before the death of Vyacheslav Ivankov as well as Aslan Usoyan. The same speculation was revealed that Maxim Sheaib was in Eastern Europe prior to both of their deaths.
In the same year, Semion Mogilevich was placed on the FBI Ten Most Wanted Fugitives list for his involvement in a complex multi-million dollar scheme that defrauded investors in the stock of his company YBM Magnex International, swindling them out of $150 million. He was indicted in 2003 and arrested in 2008 in Russia on account of tax fraud charges, but because the US does not have an extradition treaty with Russia, he was released on bail. Monya Elson stated that "[h]e's the most powerful mobster in the world" in 1998.
Around the world, Russian mafia groups have popped up as dominating particular areas: Alec Simchuk and his group ripped-off and robbed unsuspecting tourists and businessmen in South Florida, leading to Rick Brodsky of the FBI to say that "Eurasian organised crime is our no. 1 priority"; Russian organized crime has a small hold in the city of Atlanta where members are distinguished by a spade with a 3 under it tattooed on their body. Russian organized crime was reported to have a stronger grip in the French Riviera region and Spain in 2010; and Russia was branded as a virtual "mafia state" according to the WikiLeaks cables. The Jewish branch of the Russian mafia[clarification needed] has created tremendous problems for the Israeli government. There has been a large increase in criminal activity in Israel due to the large influx of Russian-Jews. The Israeli police and intelligence services have focused their resources on the Palestinians and have not paid adequate attention to this growing problem. The Russian Jewish mafia has cooperated with Israeli mafiosi[who?].
Structure and composition
||This section possibly contains original research. (August 2013)|
|This article needs additional citations for verification. (October 2013)|
|"They're not carefully structured Cosa Nostra–type families... They're loose structures of networks, but they draw on people from a number of different areas."|
|— James Finckenauer, author of Russian Mafia In America|
Note that all these positions are not always official titles, but rather are understood names for roles that the individual performs.
- Pakhan - is the Boss or Krestnii Otets "Godfather" and controls everything. The Pakhan controls four criminal cells in the working unit through an intermediary called a "Brigadier."
- Two Spies - watch over the action of the brigadiers to ensure loyalty and none become too powerful. Sovietnik (Support Group) and Obshchak (Security Group)
- Sovietnik - ("Councilor"), is the advisor and most close trusted individuals to the Pakhan, similar to the Consigliere in Italian-American Mafia crime families and Sicilian Mafia clans.
- Obshchak - the bookmaker, collects all money from Brigadiers and bribes the government.
- Brigadier – or Avtorityet ("Authority"), is like a captain in charge of a small group of men, similar to Caporegime in Italian-American Mafia crime families and Sicilian Mafia clans. He gives out jobs to Boyeviks ("warriors") and pays tribute to Pakhan. He runs a crew which is called a Brigade (Bratva). A Brigade is made up of 5-6 Boyeviks and Shestyorkas. There are four Brigadiers running criminal activity in the Russian Bratva.
- Boyevik - literally "warrior" works for a Brigadier having a special criminal activity to run, similar to soldiers in Italian-American Mafia crime families and Sicilian Mafia clans. A Boyevik is in charge of finding new guys and paying tribute up to his Brigadier. Boyevik is also the main strike force of a brigade (bratva).
- Kryshas - literally "roofs", "covers". Those are an extremely violent "enforcers" as well as cunning individuals. Such enforcer is often employed to protect a business from other criminal organizations.
- Torpedo – "Contract killer" 
- Byki - bodyguards (literally: bulls)
- Shestyorka - is an "associate" to the organization also called the "sixth", similar to associates in Italian-American Mafia crime families and Sicilian Mafia clans. Is an errand boy for the organization and is the lowest rank in the Russian Mafia. The sixthes are assigned to some Avtorityets for support. They also provide an intelligence for the upcoming "dielo" or on a certain target. They usually stay out of the main actions, although there might be exceptions, depending on circumstances. During a "dielo" Shestyorkas perform security functions standing on the look out (Shookher - literally: danger). Shestyorkas are usually young males up to 24 years of age (approximately) and are Vory in training, so to speak. It is a temporary position and an individual either making it into the Vor-world or being cast aside. As they are earning their respect and trust in Bratva they may be performing roles of the regular Boyeviks or Byki depending on the necessities and patronage of their Brigadier or Avtorityet. Etymology of 'shestyorka' word comes from the lowest rank of 36 playing card deck - sixes.
In the Russian Mafia to become a "Vor" (plural: Vory) (a Thief) is an honorary title meaning to become a made man. The honor of becoming a Vor is only given when the recruit show’s considerable leadership skills, personal ability, intellect and charisma. Pakhan or another high-ranking member of an organization can decided if the recruit will receive such title. When you become a member amongst the Vor-world you have accept the code Vor v Zakone or Thief inside the Law (compare to outlaws).
Although most Russian criminal groups vary in their structure[clarification needed], there have been attempts[who?] at trying to figure out a model in how they work. One such model, which could be possibly out-dated structure, as it is based on the old style of Soviet criminal enterprises, works out like the following:
- Elite group – led by a Pakhan who is involved in management, organization and ideology. This is the highest group controls both support group and security group.
- Security group – is led by one of his spies. His job is to make sure the organization keeps running and also keeps the peace between the organizations and other criminal groups and also paying off the right people. This group works with the Elite group and is equal in power with the Support groups. Is in charge of security and in intelligence.
- Support group- is led by one of his spies. His job is to watch over the working unit collecting the money while supervising their criminal activities. This group works with the elite group and is equal in power with the Security group. They plan a specific crime for a specialized group or choose who carries out the operation.
- Working Unit – There are four Brigadiers running a criminal activity in the working unit. Each Brigade is controlled by a Brigadier. This is the lowest group working with only the Support group. The group is involved in burglars, thieves, prostitution, extortion, street gangs and other crimes.
Strongest ethnic criminal groups
||This article or section appears to contradict itself. (August 2013)|
Russian criminal gangs are rarely formed along ethnic lines. Within the post-Soviet criminal world there exist a multitude of strong ethnic criminal gangs who often cooperate with each other regardless of ethnic origin. The strongest, most well-represented groups are the following:
Russian criminal groups
Chechen criminal groups
Armenian criminal groups
Organized criminal groups consisting of Armenians have long been active in the Eastern European underworld. Gangs with ties to the Armenian organized crime kingpins also exist abroad, such as the Armenian Power in Los Angeles.
Georgian criminal groups
Organized crime operating out of Georgia is regarded to be one of the strongest in the former Soviet Union. Georgian criminals are mainly based out of the ethnic Georgian Kutaisi region, the Svaneti and Mingrelian community and the Georgia-based Yazidi community (such as Aslan Usoyan). Georgian criminal groups are active throughout the former Soviet Union and Western Europe.
Azerbaijani criminal groups
Gangs consisting of Azerbaijanis have long been a major force in the Russian criminal world. Azeri groups control a large portion of the illegal drug market, as well as being involved in weapon trafficking and kidnapping.
Notable individual groups
- Groups based in and around the City of Moscow:
- The Brothers' Circle: Headed by Temuri Mirzoyev, this multi-ethnic transnational group is "composed of leaders and senior members of several Eurasian criminal groups largely based in countries of the former Soviet Union but operating in Europe, the Middle East, Africa, and Latin America." In 2011, US President Barack Obama and his administration named it one of four transnational organized crime groups that posed the greatest threat to US national security, and sanctioned certain key members and froze their assets. A year later, he extended the national emergency against them for another year.
- The Odessa Mafia: The most prominent and dominant Russian criminal group operating in the US; its headquarter is in Brighton Beach.
- Lyuberetskaja Bratva (russ.: Люберецкая Братва) or Ljubery (russ.: Люберы): One of the largest criminal groups in late 80-s early-mid 90-s in the USSR. Based in (and originating from) Lyubertsy district of Moscow.
- The Dolgoprudninskaya gang: Russia's second largest criminal group. Originally from the City of Dolgoprudny.
- The Izmaylovskaya gang: One of Russia's oldest modern gangs, it was started in the mid- to late-1980s by Oleg Ivanov; it has around 200–500 members in Moscow alone, and is named after the Izmaylovo District.
- The Orekhovskaya Gang: Founded by Segei "Sylvester" Timofeyev, this group reached its height in Moscow in the 1990s. When Timofeyev died, Sergei Butorin took his place. However, he was sentenced to jail for life in 2011.
- The Slonovskaya gang one of the strongest criminal groups in CIS (90-s). Based in Ryazan. Сaused a stir long-term war with other criminal groups of the city ('Ajrapetovskaya', 'Kochetkovskie', etc.)
- The Grekov gang: Named after Grecoff Bradlik, this group has been known to dominate Saint Petersburg and has sects in Canada,Montreal; the man most associated with them is Vladimir Kumarin.
- The Semion Mogilevich organization: Based in Budapest, Hungary and headed by the crime boss of the same name, this group numbered approximately 250 members as of 1996. Its business is often tied with that of the Solntsevskaya Bratva and the Vyacheslav Ivankov Organization. Aleksey Anatolyevich Lugovcov is the second-in-command, and Vitaly Borisovich Savalovsky is the "underboss" to Mogilevich.
- The Uralmash gang of Yekaterinburg.
- The Mkhedrioni was a paramilitary group involved in organised crime led by a Thief in law Jaba Ioseliani in 1990s Georgia.
- Armenian Power, or AP-13, is a California based crime syndicate tied to Russian and Armenian organised crime.
- The city of Kazan was known for its gang culture, which later progressed into more organised, mafia-esque groups. This was known as the Kazan phenomenon.
- The 1994 film Little Odessa, the Russian mafia of New York is the subject.
- The 1998 film Rounders prominently features members of the Russian mafia.
- In the Grand Theft Auto IV video game, the main protagonist is allied with and later rivals against a Russian mafia gang. The Russian mafia also appears in Grand Theft Auto 2. Also in Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas one of the missions involves Big Smoke taking CJ down to a Hotel in Los Santos where they meet up with a group of Russian Mobsters.
- The 2007 film Eastern Promises, the Russian mafia in London is the subject.
- The 1997 film Jungle 2 Jungle features a Russian mafia in New York City run by Alexei Jovanovic (David Ogden Stiers).
- The final episodes of the Law & Order Season 9 (1998–99) center around the Russian mafia in Manhattan and their attempts to sabotage prosecution.
- In the film Training Day, Denzel Washington's character is trying to pay a ransom of money for his life after he assaulted a member of the Russian mafia in Las Vegas.
- In The Sopranos, there were many references and interactions with the Russian Mafia
- The Japanese manga and anime series "Black Lagoon" prominently features the Russian Mafia
- The 2012 TV series Arrow's main character often turns to his contacts in the Bratva to locate drug dealers and information on assassins, etc.
- List of journalists killed in Russia
- Corruption in Russia
- Criminal tattoos
- Mafia state
- Russian Bratva Structure
- Russian oligarchs
- Thief in law
- Goble, Paul (March 2, 2010). "'Russian Mafia' Abroad Now 300,000 Strong, Journal Says". The Moscow Times. Retrieved July 18, 2012.
- http://web.wm.edu/so/monitor/issues/07-1/4-hatcher.htm The Russian Mafia and its Impact on the Russian Economy
- "The rise and rise of the Russian mafia". BBC News. November 21, 1998. Retrieved July 16, 2012.
- Mallory, Stephen L. Understanding Organized Crime. Jones and Bartlett Publishers, 2007, p. 73-87.
- "Russian mafia abroad is a myth – head of Russian Interpol bureau". Interfax.com.ua. December 23, 2009. Retrieved July 16, 2012.
- "Russian mafia taking over French Riviera". The Telegraph. August 31, 2010. Retrieved July 16, 2012.
- Molly Thompson (Writer/Producer) (2001). Russian Mafia: Organized Crime (TV). United States: The History Channel.
- "Russian Mafia's Worldwide Grip". CBS News. February 11, 2009. Retrieved July 18, 2012.
- Ralph Blumenthal, Celestine Bohlen (June 4, 1989). "Soviet Emigre Mob Outgrows Brooklyn, and Fear Spreads". New York Times. Retrieved July 20, 2012.
- Gordon, Mark. "Ideas Shoot Bullets: How the RICO Act Became a Potent Weapon in the War Against Organized Crime". Retrieved July 20, 2012.
- Raab, Selwyn (August 23, 1994). "Influx of Russian Gangsters Troubles F.B.I. in Brooklyn". Retrieved July 20, 2012.
- Summers, Chris (February 19, 2009). "Time catches up with global gangster". Retrieved July 20, 2012.
- Jerry Capeci, Gene Mustain (April 22, 1997). "2 Dance Bullet Ballet". New York Daily News. Retrieved July 20, 2012.
- "IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT COURT OF DELAWARE". May 31, 2005. Retrieved July 18, 2012.
- Smillie, Ian, Lansana Gberie, Ralph Hazleton The Heart of the Matter: Sierra Leone, Diamonds and Human Security. Diane Pub, 2000, p. 44-45.
- Claffey, Mike (August 24, 1996). "RUSSIAN IN MOB RAP". New York Daily News. Retrieved July 18, 2012.
- Friedman, Robert I. Red Mafiya: How the Russian Mob Has Invaded America. Warner Books, 2000.
- "Czech police arrest internationally wanted mafia boss". Prague Daily Monitor. March 8, 2011. Retrieved July 18, 2012.
- Glenny, Misha McMafia: A Journey Through the Global Criminal Underworld. House of Anansi Press, 2008.
- "TRANSCRIPT - PANORAMA "THE BILLION DOLLAR DON"". BBC. Retrieved July 18, 2012.
- Bohlen, Celestine (January 10, 1999). "The World; To Sicilians, Russia Has No Mafia. It's Too Wild.". The New York Times. Retrieved July 18, 2012.
- Paddock, Richard C. (December 13, 1998). "Russian Calls Swiss Verdict a Win for Fellow Businessmen". The Los Angeles Times. Retrieved July 18, 2012.
- "Russian mobster to be released". September 24, 2004. Retrieved July 20, 2012.
- "Top Russian mobster Ivankov dies". The Sidney Morning Herald. October 10, 2009. Retrieved July 20, 2012.
- "TWO RUSSIAN ORGANIZED CRIME FIGURES CHARGED IN PLOT TO MURDER BUSINESSMEN". United States Attorney's Office. March 24, 2006. Retrieved July 20, 2012.
- "FBI agents in Moscow on trail of Russian mafia bosses". EN.RIAN.ru. April 23, 2009. Retrieved July 20, 2012.
- Thai Border Arrests, The Journal, 2009
- "In a River Raid, a Glimpse of Russia’s Criminal Elite". The New York Times. July 30, 2008. Retrieved 2013-10-29.
- Name (required). "Another Go Round the ‘Brothers’ Circle’ | In Moscow's Shadows". Inmoscowsshadows.wordpress.com. Retrieved 2013-10-29.
- "Top Ten Fugitives: Global Con Artist and Ruthless Criminal". FBI. October 21, 2009. Retrieved July 18, 2012.
- Meserve, Jeanne (October 21, 2009). "FBI: Mobster more powerful than Gotti". CNN. Retrieved July 18, 2012.
- Friedman, Robert I. (May 26, 1998). "The Most Dangerous Mobster in the World". The Village Voice. Retrieved July 20, 2012.
- "Miami becomes 'Little Moscow': FBI says Russian mob eclipses Italian Mafia in South Florida". Daily Mail. June 1, 2011. Retrieved July 20, 2012.
- "Wikileaks: Russia branded 'mafia state' in cables". BBC News. December 2, 2010. Retrieved July 20, 2012.
- Russian Organized Crime: Organization and Structure 1993
- Lindsay Haselton The Emergence of the Russian Mafia YETT Young Experts Think Tank
- James O. Finckenauer and Elin Waring. Challenging the Russian Mafia Mystique. National Institute of Justice Journal. April 2001. 
- Stephen L. Mallory. Understanding Organized Crime. 2007. (pg.76-78)
- Bleifuss, Joel (September 7, 2007). "Business as Usual: The Rise of the Russian Mafia". FocusFeatures.com. Retrieved July 18, 2012.
- Bleifuss, Joel (April 1, 1998). "So who are the Russian mafia ?". BBC News. Retrieved July 18, 2012.
- "Treasury Designates Brothers' Circle Members". US Department of Treasury. June 6, 2012. Retrieved July 19, 2012.
- "Obama Calls "Brothers' Circle" a National Security Threat...But Who Are They?". Hetq.am. March 14, 2012. Retrieved July 18, 2012.
- Sinelnikov, Mikhail (July 11, 2011). "Russian mafia most powerful in the world?". Pravda.ru. Retrieved July 18, 2012.
- "War on International Criminals Continues". BBC News. July 20, 2012. Retrieved July 21, 2012.
- "Russian Organized Crime". fas.org. Retrieved July 18, 2012.
- "The Russian Mafia – Part Three". UnreportedCases.com. March 11, 2011. Retrieved July 18, 2012.
- "Leader of Orekhovskaya gang sentenced to life in jail". ITAR-TASS. June 9, 2011. Retrieved July 18, 2012.
- "Russian crime gang leader gets life in jail". Kyiv Post. September 7, 2011. Retrieved July 18, 2012.
- "Semion Mogilevich Organization: Eurasian Organized Crime". FBI. August 1996. Retrieved July 21, 2012.
- In Moscow's Shadows (Russian crime and security blog)
- Russian Organized Workforce Network outside of Russia: "Pomogaem.NET"