Sad Cypress

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Sad Cypress
Sad Cypress First Edition Cover 1940.jpg
Dust-jacket illustration of the first UK edition
Author Agatha Christie
Cover artist Barlow
Country United Kingdom
Language English
Genre Crime novel
Publisher Collins Crime Club
Publication date
March 1940
Media type Print (hardback & paperback)
Pages 256 pp (first edition)
ISBN N/A
Preceded by And Then There Were None
Followed by One, Two, Buckle My Shoe

Sad Cypress is a work of detective fiction by Agatha Christie and first published in the UK by the Collins Crime Club in March 1940[1] and in the US by Dodd, Mead and Company later in the same year.[2][3] The UK edition retailed at eight shillings and threepence (8/3)[1] – the first price rise for a UK Christie edition since her 1921 debut – and the US edition retailed at $2.00.[3]

The novel is notable for being the first courtroom drama in the Poirot series.

Explanation of the novel's title[edit]

The title comes from a song from Act II, Scene IV of Shakespeare's Twelfth Night which is printed as an epigraph to the novel.

Come away, come away, death,
And in sad cypress let me be laid;
Fly away, fly away breath;
I am slain by a fair cruel maid.
My shroud of white, stuck all with yew,
O, prepare it!
My part of death, no one so true
Did share it.

Plot summary[edit]

The novel is written in three parts: in the first place an account, largely from the perspective of the subsequent defendant, Elinor Carlisle, of the death of her aunt, Laura Welman, and the subsequent death of the victim, Mary Gerrard; secondly an account of Poirot's investigation; and, thirdly, a sequence in court, again mainly from Elinor's dazed perspective.

In the first part, distant cousins Elinor Carlisle and Roddy Welman are happily engaged to be married when they receive an anonymous letter claiming that someone is "sucking up" to their wealthy aunt, Laura Welman, from whom Elinor and Roddy expect to inherit a sizeable fortune. Elinor immediately suspects Mary Gerrard, the lodgekeeper's daughter, to whom their aunt has taken a considerable liking. They go down to visit their aunt: partly to see her and partly to protect their interests.

Mrs. Welman is helpless after a stroke and speaks of a desire to die, most notably to Peter Lord, her physician. After a second stroke, she asks Elinor to ask the family solicitor to prepare a will under which it is clear that Mary is to be a beneficiary. Roddy has fallen in love with Mary, provoking Elinor's jealousy. Mrs. Welman dies intestate during the night and her estate goes to Elinor outright as her only known surviving blood relative.

Subsequently, Elinor releases Roddy from the engagement and makes moves to settle money on him (which he refuses) and Seven thousand pounds on Mary (which Mary accepts). At an impromptu tea party thrown by Elinor for Mary and Nurse Hopkins, Mary dies of poison supposedly in a fish-paste sandwich. Elinor (who has been behaving suspiciously in the eyes of some) is put on trial. Worse, when the body of her aunt is exhumed it is discovered that both women died of morphine poisoning. Elinor had easy access to morphine from a bottle that apparently went missing from Nurse Hopkins's bag.

In the second part of the novel, Poirot is persuaded to investigate the case by Peter Lord, who is in love with Elinor and wants her to be acquitted at all costs. Poirot's investigation focuses on a small number of elements. Was the poison in the sandwiches, which everyone ate, or something else, such as the tea that was prepared by Nurse Hopkins and drunk by Mary and the nurse, but not by Elinor? What is the secret of Mary Gerrard's birth, which everyone seems keen to conceal? Is there any significance in the scratch of a thorn on Nurse Hopkins's wrist? Is Peter Lord right to draw Poirot's attention to evidence that someone watching through the window might have poisoned the sandwich, thinking that it would be eaten by Elinor? In the third part of the novel, the case appears to go badly for Elinor, until her Defence unveils three theories that might exonerate her. The first (that Mary committed suicide) is difficult for anyone really to believe, and the second (Peter Lord's theory of the killer outside the window) is unconvincing. But the third theory is Poirot's.

A torn pharmaceutical label that the Prosecution supposed to have held morphine hydrochloride, the poison, had in fact held apomorphine hydrochloride, an emetic. This was revealed because on an ampoule, the M in Morphine would be capital; Poirot finds a lowercase M – thus it isn't morphine. The capitalised prefix "Apo" had been carefully torn off. Nurse Hopkins had injected herself with an emetic, apomorphine, to vomit the poison that she had ingested in the tea, which explains her quick departure from the table as soon as the tea was consumed that fateful day and Elinor's briefly noticing Hopkins's odd colouring while the nurse was standing over the kitchen sink. Hopkins' claim to have scratched herself on a thorn is disproved when it is revealed that the rose tree in question is a thornless variety: Zephirine Drouhin.

The motive was simple – money. Mary Gerrard was not the daughter of Eliza and Bob Gerrard. Instead – as Poirot has discerned in the course of the investigation – she was the illegitimate daughter of Laura Welman and Sir Lewis Rycroft, which made her the heiress to Mrs. Welman's estate as she was actually a closer relative than Elinor. When Nurse Hopkins encouraged Mary Gerrard to write a will, Mary was prompted to name as beneficiary the woman whom she supposed to be her aunt, Mary Riley (Eliza Gerrard's sister), in New Zealand. Mary Riley's married name is Mary Draper. Mary Draper is none other than Nurse Hopkins as two witnesses of the defence (Amelia Sedley and Edward Marshall, both from New Zealand), confirm in court. Nurse Hopkins is recalled to the witness stand but has left the courtroom in a hurry.

Poirot ends the novel by rebuking Peter Lord for his clumsy efforts to implicate the hypothetical killer outside the window. He has planted evidence and led Poirot to it in a desperate bid to free Elinor. Lord's momentary embarrassment is presumably alleviated by Poirot's assurance that it is to him, and not to her former love Roddy, that Elinor is now likely to become married.

Characters in Sad Cypress[edit]

The Victims:

  • Mrs. Laura Welman, a widow
  • Mary Gerrard, her protégée

Suspects:

  • Elinor Carlisle, Mrs. Welman's niece
  • Roddy Welman, Mrs. Welman's nephew by marriage
  • Dr. Peter Lord, Mrs. Welman's doctor
  • Nurse Jessie Hopkins, the District Nurse
  • Nurse Eileen O'Brien, Mrs. Welman's nurse
  • Mr Seddon, Mrs. Welman's solicitor
  • Mrs Bishop, Mrs. Welman's housekeeper
  • Horlick, the gardener
  • Bob Gerrard, the lodge keeper and Mary's ostensible father
  • Ted Bigland, a farmer's son

Characters in the courtroom:

  • The Judge
  • Sir Edwin Bulmer, Counsel for the Defence
  • Sir Samuel Attenbury, Counsel for the Prosecution
  • Dr. Alan Garcia, expert witness for the Prosecution
  • Inspector Brill, the investigating officer
  • Mr. Abbott, a grocer
  • Alfred James Wargrave, a rose-grower
  • James Arthur Littledale, a chemist
  • Amelia Mary Sedley, a witness from New Zealand
  • Edward John Marshall, a witness from New Zealand

Literary significance and reception[edit]

Maurice Percy Ashley in The Times Literary Supplement gave a positive review to the book in the issue of 9 March 1940: "In recent years the detective story-reading public has been so profusely drenched with thrills, 'wisecracks' and perverted psychology that one sometimes wonders whether there is still room for the old-fashioned straight-forward problem in detection. There are, however, a few first-class exponents of this art with us – though now that Miss Sayers has, for the moment at any rate, turned moralist and others have entered the easier field of thriller writing there seem to be increasingly few. Mrs. Christie in particular remains true to the old faith; and it is pleasant to be able to record that her hand has not lost its cunning". The reviewer regretted that Poirot had lost some of his 'foibles' and Hastings no longer featured in the plots but he ended on a high note: "Like all Mrs Christie's work, it is economically written, the clues are placed before the reader with impeccable fairness, the red herrings are deftly laid and the solution will cause many readers to kick themselves. Some occasional readers of detective stories are wont to criticize Mrs Christie on the ground that her stories are insufficiently embroidered, that she includes, for instance, no epigrams over the college port. But is it not time to state that in the realm of detective fiction proper, where problems are fairly posed and fairly solved, there is no one to touch her?"[4]

In The New York Times Book Review of 15 September 1940, Kay Irvin concluded, "The cast of characters is small, the drama is built up with all this author's sure, economical skill. Sad Cypress is not the best of the Christie achievements, but it is better than the average thriller on every count."[5]

In reviewing several crime novels in The Observer's issue of 10 March 1940, Maurice Richardson began, "An outstanding crime week. Not only is Agatha Christie shining balefully on her throne, but the courtiers have made an unusually neat artistic arrangement of corpses up and down the steps." Concentrating on Sad Cypress specifically, Richardson concluded, "Characterisation brilliantly intense as ever. In fact, Agatha Christie has done it again, which is all you need to know."[6]

The Scotsman's review in its issue of 11 March 1940 concluded, "Sad Cypress is slighter and rather less ingenious than Mrs Christie's stories usually are, and the concluding explanation is unduly prolonged. But it is only with reference to Mrs Christie's own high level that it seems inferior. By ordinary standards of detective fiction it is a fascinating and skilfully related tale."[7]

E.R. Punshon in The Guardian's issue of 2 April 1940 concluded, "The story is told with all and even more of Mrs. Christie's accustomed skill and economy of effect, but it is a pity that the plot turns upon a legal point familiar to all and yet so misconceived that many readers will feel the tale is deprived of plausibility."[8]

Robert Barnard: "A variation on the usual triangle theme and the only time Christie uses the lovely-woman-in-the-dock-accused-of-murder ploy. Elegiac, more emotionally involving than is usual in Christie, but the ingenuity and superb clueing put it among the very best of the classic titles. Her knowledge of poison is well to the fore, but the amateur will also benefit from a knowledge of horticulture and a skill in close reading."[9]

References to other works[edit]

Peter Lord says that he has been recommended to consult Poirot by Dr. John Stillingfleet on the basis of Poirot's brilliant performance in the case related in the short story, The Dream, which had been printed two years earlier in issue 566 of The Strand (magazine) and later printed in book form in The Adventure of the Christmas Pudding in 1960 in the UK and in The Regatta Mystery in the US in 1939. The character of Stillingfleet later reappears in Third Girl (1966).

Film, TV or theatrical adaptations[edit]

BBC Radio 4 Adaptation[edit]

The novel was adapted as a five-part serial for BBC Radio 4 in 1992. John Moffatt reprised his role of Poirot. The serial was broadcast weekly from Thursday, 14 May to Thursday, 11 June at 10.00am to 10.30pm. All five episodes were recorded in the week of 16 to 20 March 1992.

Adaptor: Michael Bakewell
Producer: Enyd Williams

Cast:
Eric Allan
Jonathan Adams
Barbara Atkinson as Mrs. Welman
Margot Boyd as Mrs. Bishop
John Church
Susannah Corbett as Mary Gerrard
Alan Cullen as the Judge
Keith Drinkel
Emma Fielding as Elinor Carlisle
Eamonn Fleming as Ted Bigland
Pauline Letts as Nurse Hopkins
Peter Penry-Jones
David McAlister as Dr. Lord
John Moffatt as Hercule Poirot
Joanna Myers as Nurse O'Brien, and as the singer of the title song
Gordon Reid
Charles Simpson as Roddy Welman
John Webb as Mr.Gerrard

Agatha Christie's Poirot[edit]

The book was adapted by London Weekend Television as a one hundred-minute drama and transmitted on ITV in the UK on Friday 26 December 2003 as a special episode in their series Agatha Christie's Poirot. The adaptation was quite faithful to the novel, though some minor changes were made, such as time (1937, around the time of George Gershwin's death) and setting (the adaptation took place in the Welman household, whereas the original mystery took place largely in criminal court during Elinor Carlisle's trial). At the end in the movie nurse Hopkins tries to kill Poirot, putting a poison in the tea, but Poirot (who already knows that the nurse is the killer) only pretends to drink it, but instead pour out the tea in a vase.

Adaptor: David Pirie
Director: David Moore

Cast:
David Suchet as Hercule Poirot
Elisabeth Dermot-Walsh as Elinor Carlisle
Rupert Penry-Jones as Roddy Winter
Kelly Reilly as Mary Gerrard
Paul McGann as Dr. Peter Lord
Phyllis Logan as Nurse Hopkins
Marion O'Dwyer as Nurse O'Brien
Diana Quick as Mrs. Laura Welman
Stuart Laing as Ted Horlick
Jack Galloway as Marsden
Geoffrey Beevers as Seddon
Alistair Findlay as Prosecuting Counsel
Linda Spurrier as Mrs. Bishop
Timothy Carlton as Judge

Sad Cypress was filmed on location at Dorney Court, Buckinghamshire.

Publication history[edit]

  • 1940, Collins Crime Club (London), March 1940, Hardcover, 256 pp
  • 1940, Dodd Mead and Company (New York), 1940, Hardcover, 270 pp
  • 1946, Dell Books, Paperback, 224 pp (Dell number 172 [mapback])
  • 1959, Fontana Books (Imprint of HarperCollins), Paperback, 191 pp
  • 1965, Ulverscroft Large-print Edition, Hardcover, 239 pp
  • 2008, Poirot Facsimile Edition (Facsimile of 1940 UK First Edition), HarperCollins, 1 April 2008, Hardback, ISBN 0-00-727459-9

The book was first serialised in the US in Collier's Weekly in ten parts from 25 November 1939 (Volume 104, Number 22) to 27 January 1940 (Volume 105, Number 4) with illustrations by Mario Cooper.

The UK serialisation was in nineteen parts in the Daily Express from Saturday, 23 March to Saturday, 13 April 1940. The accompanying illustrations were uncredited. This version did not contain any chapter divisions.[10]

International titles[edit]

  • Bulgarian: Загърни ме в мрачен покров /Zagarni me v mrachen pokrov/ ("And in sad cypress let me be laid"("Twelfth Night",
    Shakespeare)); 2007 edition - Тъжният кипарис /Tazhniyat kiparis/ (Sad Cypress)
  • Czech: Temný cypřiš (A dark cypress)
  • Dutch: Schuldig in eigen ogen (Guilty in her own eyes)
  • Estonian: Nukker küpress (Sad Cypress)
  • Finnish: Teetä kolmelle (Tea for three)
  • Farsi: سرو غمگین (Sad Cypress)
  • French: Je ne suis pas coupable (I am not guilty)
  • German: Morphium (Morphine)
  • Hungarian: Vádol a rózsa! (The rose is accusing!), Cipruskoporsó (Cypress coffin)
  • Indonesian: Mawar Tak Berduri (Thornless rose)
  • Italian: La parola alla difesa (The word to the defence)
  • Japanese: 杉の柩 (Pall of Cypress)
  • Norwegian: Kom til meg, død (Come to me, death)
  • Polish: Zerwane zaręczyny (Broken engagement)
  • Portuguese: Poirot salva o criminoso (Poirot saves the criminal)
  • Brazilian Portuguese: Cipreste triste (Sad Cypress)
  • Romanian: Chiparosul trist (Sad Cypress)
  • Russian: Печальный кипарис (=Pechal'ny kiparis, Sad cypress)
  • Spanish: Un Triste Ciprés (A sad cypress)
  • Swedish: Samvetskval (Remorse)
  • Turkish: Esrarengiz Sanık (Mysterious suspect)

References[edit]

  1. ^ a b Chris Peers, Ralph Spurrier and Jamie Sturgeon. Collins Crime Club – A checklist of First Editions. Dragonby Press (Second Edition) March 1999 (Page 15)
  2. ^ John Cooper and B.A. Pyke. Detective Fiction – the collector's guide: Second Edition (pgs 82, 86) Scholar Press. 1994. ISBN 0-85967-991-8
  3. ^ a b American Tribute to Agatha Christie
  4. ^ The Times Literary Supplement 9 March 1940 (Page 125)
  5. ^ The New York Times Book Review 15 September 1940 (Page 19)
  6. ^ The Observer 10 March 1940 (Page 6)
  7. ^ The Scotsman 11 March 1940 (Page 9)
  8. ^ The Guardian 2 April 1940 (Page 3)
  9. ^ Barnard, Robert. A Talent to Deceive – an appreciation of Agatha Christie – Revised edition (Page 204). Fontana Books, 1990. ISBN 0-00-637474-3
  10. ^ Holdings at the British Library (Newspapers – Colindale). Shelfmark: NPL LON LD3 and NPL LON MLD3.

External links[edit]