Sandy Island, New Caledonia
|Île de Sable|
Landsat satellite image showing the island's supposed location.
|Length||24 km (14.9 mi)|
|Width||5 km (3.1 mi)|
France (New Caledonia)
Sandy Island (sometimes labelled in French: Île de Sable) is a non-existent island that was charted for over a century as being located near the French territory of New Caledonia between the Chesterfield Islands and Nereus Reef in the eastern Coral Sea. The island was included on many maps and nautical charts from as early as the late 19th century, and gained wide media and public attention in November 2012 when the R/V Southern Surveyor, an Australian surveyor ship, passed through the area and "undiscovered" it. The island was quickly removed from many maps and data sets, including those of the National Geographic Society and Google Maps.
In 1774, Captain James Cook charted a "Sandy Island" 420 kilometers due east at approximately 19° S latitude and at just less than 164 degrees of longitude (rather than just less than 160 degrees of longitude for the phantom "Sandy Island" on charts and maps after 1876). The associated map was published in 1776. This "Sandy Island", though at the same latitude, is four degrees of longitude further east and may or may not have been associated with the "standard" location after 1876.
The whaling ship Velocity reported the island in the year 1876, as was noted on various late 1800's maps, including an 1881 German map and 1895 British Admiralty chart. After returning from a voyage in the Pacific, the Velocity's master reported two unusual features. The first was a series of "heavy breakers", the second some "Sandy Islets", or Sandy Island. Both then appeared in an Australian maritime directory for 1879. It noted the islets extended north and south "along the meridian 159° 57' E" and "between lat 19° 7' S and 19° 20' S". Until 1876-79 (and in reality), the nearest charted land or reef was the Chesterfield Islands 100 km westwards on the Bellona Plateau. At the time when the chart was created, it was standard practice for all potential navigation hazards to be listed on such charts as a precaution.
Hydrographic charts later placed the internationally recognized abbreviation "ED" ("existence doubtful") next to Sandy Island, in recognition of subsequent failures to spot the reported island at the expected location. Seafloor mapping in the area by the Australian Hydrographic Service (AHS) determined a minimum depth for the immediate area around and over the island ranging from 1488 to 2353 meters below sea level. Due to a lack of appearance of an island or depths indicating a shallow reef, Sandy Island was removed from the official French hydrographic charts by the French Hydrographic Service in 1979 after a flying recognition campaign and by AHS in 1985. The information about the status of the phantom island was passed on to other national hydrographic services around the world, but Sandy Island remained in global coastline and bathymetry compilations used by the scientific community and was still there when the R/V Southern Surveyor sailed toward the Coral Sea in October 2012. The erroneously reported island persisted because it was included in the World Vector Shoreline Database (WVS), a data set originally developed by the U.S. National Imagery and Mapping Agency (now the National Geospatial‐Intelligence Agency, NGA) during the conversion from physical charts to digital formats, and now used as a standard global coastline data set. Inconsistencies in this data set exist in some of the least explored parts of Earth, due to human digitizing errors and errors in original maps from which the digitizing took place. One of the most commonly used derived products of WVS is the Global Self-consistent, Hierarchical, High-resolution Shoreline Geography Database (GSHHG), which is ported with Generic Mapping Tools (GMT) software. Although it is now an independent data set, an error in the original WVS data would have been present in this data set.
Pumice sea rafts
The Velocity may have observed pumice sea rafts (masses of floating pumice ejected from an underwater volcano) traversing the Sandy Island area in 1876 and mistakenly recorded them as an island. This explanation is supported by a 2004 study of an eruption of a volcano near Tonga that found that pumice sea rafts associated with that eruption traveled more than 3000 kilometers westward. An analysis of the pumice trajectory revealed that pumice rafts passed within 20 kilometers of the location of Sandy Island, approximately 200 days after the initial eruption. A study of coral migration from Tonga to the Great Barrier Reef found pumice rafts to be the mode of transportation, with a predicted path consistent with the 2004 study. Wind and ocean surface currents in the area may combine to funnel pumice rafts through the area between Fiji and New Caledonia on their way to Australia.
As noted above, French hydrographical charts removed the island starting in 1979. Public claims that the island did not exist began in April 2000 by amateur radio enthusiasts on a DX-pedition. They noted that it was shown on some maps, but not on others such as the 1999 Times Atlas of the World, 10th Edition. A discovery of the island's absence was again made on 22 November 2012 by Australian scientists aboard the R/V Southern Surveyor studying plate tectonics in the area. During the voyage, they noticed a discrepancy between different maps and decided to sail to the supposed location to investigate. The crew found no island and recorded depths never less than 1,300 metres (4,300 ft). They found that "the ocean floor actually didn't ever get shallower than 1,300 meters below the wave base…"
The status of the purported island also became the subject of discussion on scientific mailing lists such as GMT-HELP in late November 2012. Some scientists were initially skeptical that such an error could exist since a signature was present in various global terrain data sets, such as the bathymetric data from the General Bathymetric Chart of the Oceans, which reported an elevation of 1 meter over the location of Sandy Island. Some data sets derived from satellite imagery indicated that sea surface temperatures were absent in the location, suggesting the presence of land. However, it became apparent that a land mask was applied to these data sets during pre-processing to differentiate between land and water. Since the World Vector Shoreline Database (WVS) has become the standard global coastline data set used by the scientific community, errors that existed in WVS propagated into data sets that use a land mask. Therefore, rather than providing independent evidence for the existence of an island, the appearance of Sandy Island in bathymetry and satellite imagery data sets originated from spurious digitized geometries derived from the WVS database.
The Australian Hydrographic Service, a department of the Royal Australian Navy, said that mapping an island as a copyright trap—a practice in cartography to place a fictitious "trap street" on a map for the purpose of trapping potential copyright violators—would not have been standard practice with nautical charts, and that its appearance on many contemporary maps may have simply been (and partly were) due to human error.
The island was displayed on the Google Maps internet mapping service until 26 November 2012, when it was removed. On Google Earth's default view the island area is covered by black pixels, but the program's historical imagery feature displays a satellite image of the southern portion taken by DigitalGlobe on 3 March 2009, showing a darkened sea. On 29 November 2012, the National Geographic Society announced that it was officially striking Sandy Island from its maps. "The Geographer" at National Geographic, Juan Valdes, said, "full evidence has finally been presented. 'Sandy Island' has now been officially stricken from all National Geographic map products".
- Dougherty Island, a phantom island which remained on many maps until the early 20th century
- "South Pacific Sandy Island 'proven not to exist'". BBC News. 22 November 2012. Retrieved 22 November 2012.
- Lecornu, Hélène (12 December 2012). "Sandy Island: le mystère de l’île fantôme dévoilé depuis déjà 33 ans" (.doc). SHOM (in French). SHOM. Retrieved 13 June 2013.
- Richard Chirgwin (25 November 2012). "Sandy Island does exist - on a 1908 chart". The Register. Retrieved 28 November 2012.
- See David Rumsey Historical Map Collection.
- French maps from 1826 and 1875 show "Ile de Sable(s)" at the location of Cook's "Sandy Island".
- Eli MacKinnon (2012-11-27). "Google's phantom island may have 19th-century roots". Fox News. Retrieved 2012-11-28.
- Shaun Higgins (2012-11-23). "The mystery of an island that isn't there". Auckland War Memorial Museum. Retrieved 2012-11-28.
- Luke Harding (29 Nov 2012). "Sandy Island: whaling ship behind land that proved not ahoy". Retrieved 30 Nov 2012.
- Seton, Maria; Williams, Simon and Zahirovic, Sabin (9 April 2013). "Obituary: Sandy Island (1876 –2012)". Eos, Transactions, American Geophysical Union (American Geophysical Union) 94 (15): 141–148. doi:10.1002/2013eo150001. ISSN 2324-9250. Retrieved 19 April 2013.
- "Sandy 'Marie Celeste' Island undiscovered - again: Radio hams beat science by a decade". The Register. 22 November 2012. Retrieved 22 November 2012.
- "TXØDX challenges National Geographic (Bulletin 16)". TXØDX. 10 April 2000. Retrieved 22 November 2012.
- "The Pacific island that never was". The Guardian. 22 November 2012. Retrieved 22 November 2012.
- "Scientists un-discover Pacific island". University of Sydney. 23 November 2012.
- "The mystery of the missing island". The Sydney Morning Herald. 22 November 2012. Retrieved 22 November 2012.
- GMT-HELP (Mailing list). 22 November 2012 https://listserv.hawaii.edu/cgi-bin/wa?A2=ind1211&L=GMT-HELP&T=0&F=&S=&X=5A5927734D113E3E2F&P=105110. Missing or empty
- "Scientists un-discover Pacific island". 3 News NZ. 23 November 2012. Retrieved 23 November 2012.
- Juan José Valdes (29 November 2012). "Sandy Island (Île de Sable or Île de Sables): The Island That Never Was". National Geographic. Retrieved 30 November 2012.