Santa Cruz–Chembur Link Road
|Santa Cruz–Chembur Link Road (SCLR)|
|Maintained by Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation|
|Length:||6.45 km (4.01 mi)|
|Existed:||18 April 2014 – present|
|West end:||Western Express Highway, Santacruz|
|CST Road in Santacruz (East)
LBS Marg in Kurla (West)
|East end:||Eastern Express Highway,
The Santa Cruz–Chembur Link Road, shortened to SCLR, is a 6.45 km long arterial road in Mumbai, connecting the Western Express Highway (WEH) in Santa Cruz with the Eastern Express Highway (EEH) in Chembur. It contains the city's first and India's second double-decker flyover. The six-lane road was constructed as part of the World Bank-funded Mumbai Urban Transport Project (MUTP) at a cost of 454 crore (US$74 million). The World Bank withdrew funding midway through the project due to repeated delays, and the second phase was financed by the Mumbai Metropolitan Region Development Authority (MMRDA) with its own funds.
The SCLR was severely delayed, taking more than 11 years for the work to be completed. Groundwork for the road, originally slated to start in 2003, did not get underway until 2007. The project missed 12 deadlines since the original deadline of November 2004. The SCLR was termed an "engineering marvel" by the National Geographic Society, and was described by the World Bank as the "world's most delayed road project".
Wilbur Smith and Associates were commissioned in 1962 to study and make recommendations on transportation issues in Greater Mumbai. ) was commissioned to in mid-1962. Their report, filed with the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways on 19 December 1963, proposed the construction of several link roads to improve east-west connectivity in the city. Among the projects proposed was a 4-lane road linking Santacruz in the west with Chembur in the east.
The Mumbai Urban Transport Project (MUTP) was initiated in 2002 to study and propose solutions to Mumbai's transportation issues. The SCLR, along with the widening and improvement of the Jogeshwari – Vikhroli Link Road (JVLR), was one of two east-west road corridor projects implemented under the first phase of the MUTP, and were intended to ease commutation problems and act as links between Mumbai's Eastern and Western Suburbs.
Prior to the SCLR's opening, commuters traveling from the Western Suburbs towards the Eastern Suburbs or Navi Mumbai had to take the JVLR, the Andheri-Kurla Road or a detour from Sion to reach Chembur. During peak hours, this would take 90 minutes to 2 hours. After the SCLR opened, travel time between Santacruz and Chembur reduced to 17 minutes. The SCLR is an important arterial road connecting the Western and Eastern Express Highways. The SCLR is expected to significantly decongest the EEH and the WEH, and ease traffic congestion at the Amar Mahal Junction, Vakola, Kalanagar Junction, Sion and Kurla. It will also decrease traffic congestion on roads in Santacruz, Kalanagar, Dharavi, Sion and Chembur. The Times of India reported that commuters can save 50-60 on auto rickshaw and taxi fares (at April 2014 rates) when traveling between the Eastern and Western Suburbs via the SCLR.
Land acquisition and rehabilitation
Government land measuring 10,705.51 square metres belonging to the MHADA, the BMC, the Railways, and the Kurla Dairy, was transferred for use in the project. However, additional acquisition of private land was necessary to implement the project, and approximately 1091.90 square metres of private land was acquired for the same.
The total land required for Phase II of the project for up to 45.7 m width of ROW was 1,34,358 sq m. Out of which the 88,200 sq. m of the land for the existing 30 m width of ROW was acquired by the Public Works Department (PWD) and handed over to the BMC. Between 30-45.7 m width of ROW, 46,158 sq. m land was required, of which, about 5,596 sq.m of land was in the possession of the BMC (2,047 sq. m.) and the government (3,549 sq m). Land acquisition for the SCLR project was carried out by the BMC. As a result of Phase II of the project, a total 434 structures were affected out of which 235 were residential, 193 commercial and 6 residential-cum-commercial. In addition to this there were 5 other structures affected which consisted of one balwadi, one newspaper library, one post office, a structure on private land, and one Bank.
A total of 3167 structures would be impacted—2575 residential, 540 commercial, 33 residential-cum-commercial, and 19 community/religious structures. As of 30 April 2006, a total of 2591 structures had been resettled—2418 residential, 145 commercial, 26 residential-cum-commercial, and 2 religious/community structures.
People impacted by the project were resettled at a resettlement site in Mankhurd, which is about 7 km from the location of affected structures at SCLR phase-II. The Mankhurd resettlement site had a total of 3,256 residential tenements and 720 commercial tenements.
The SCLR was commissioned in 2003 under the World Bank-funded MUTP, and was originally scheduled to be completed by November 2004. The SCLR and JVLR projects were initially entrusted to the Public Works Department (PWD). Responsibility for the project was later transferred to the Maharashtra State Road Development Corporation (MSRDC), and the Mumbai Metropolitan Region Development Authority (MMRDA) was appointed as the nodal agency. The SCLR project was implemented in two phases. The first phase was executed by the MSRDC and the second phase was executed by the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC). Phase I comprises the 3.45 km long section from the east end of the 6-lane Mithi River Bridge up to the Amar Mahal Junction of the Eastern Express Highway. Phase II consists of the 3 km section from the WEH to the Mithi River. Phase I was funded by the World Bank, while Phase II was financed by the MMRDA with its own funds.
Section 1 and 2 were contracted to Patel Engineering Ltd and Gammon India Ltd. respectively. The Louis Berger Group Inc. served as Project Management Consultants for both sections. The contract for civil work for Section 1, signed on 29 September 2003, had a value of 33.81 crore (US$7.514 million).
Construction of the SCLR was contracted to Patel Engineering Ltd and Gammon India Ltd. for 35 crore and 79.9 crore respectively. Gammon was awarded nearly 75% of the total civil work on the project. The Louis Berger Group Inc. served as Project Management Consultants. The notices to proceed with work (or work orders) for section 1 and 2 were issued on 29 September 2003 and 10 May 2004. However, the project was severely delayed. The MMRDA later hiked the values of both contracts by 15% to keep up with cost escalation caused by delays. Patel Engineering briefly halted construction on the project for several months in 2011, asking for another hike in contract value. The MMRDA agreed to hike both contract values by 30-35%, and Patel Engineering resumed work in January 2012. As of April 2011, Gammon had already spent 113.1 crore, and Louis Berger had reportedly spent nearly five times the original amount.
In September 2013, the MMRDA invited agencies to prepare a Detailed Project Report (DPR) for three proposed bridges. The first flyover is planned from Bandra-Kurla Link Road to CST Junction in Kurla, and the second will be from Mumbai University junction in Kalina to CST Road. The third DPR concerns the remodelling of the existing CST Bridge. After remodelling, the 40m long and 30m wide bridge would be 100m long and will 45m wide.
Although, the groundwork for the link road was originally planned to commence in September 2003, it began only in 2007. The SCLR was severely delayed, taking more than 11 years for the work to be completed. The project missed 12 deadlines since the original deadline of November 2004. Following this, 11 other deadlines have been fixed and missed for the project: September 2006, December 2008, December 2009, June 2010, June and December 2011, December 2012, March 2013, October 2013, December 2013 and 31 March 2014. The cost of constructing the SCLR was originally estimated as 114.96 crore in 2003. This was revised to 254.76 crore in August 2011. According to the reply from the MMRDA to a Right to Information (RTI) request filed by RTI activist Anil Galgali, the latest estimated project cost is 454 crore (US$74 million), an escalation of 391.30%.
Thousands of displaced residents had to be relocated, leading to delays. The World Bank initially provided loans to the project, but later withdrew. Roberto Zagha, India head of the World Bank, called it the "world's most delayed road project". An MMRDA official defended the delay in the project stating, "It was huge project ... We had to resettle more than 3,500 project-affected people. There were also issues will relocation of a religious structure, and a politician's interference, too, did not help. It is easy to lay the blame, but the work was challenging. We also had to face several court cases. We have learnt many lessons from this project."
A major delay occurred in getting clearance from Central Railway (CR) to construct a 50.9-metre bridge over the Central Line. Despite receiving the request in 2007, CR took 5 years and asked for 4 changes in design before finally approving construction in July 2012. The approval came with the rider that MMRDA could only start construction in October 2012, after the monsoon. A railway official defended CR stating, "MMRDA blamed us for the delay. But the design of the road overbridge across the tracks was such that it would not have got the commissioner of railway safety's approval. The consultants should have thought about this long ago. We had also given blanket approval to launch girders more than a year ago. But the girder-launching work was carried out six months ago as they did not arrive from Punjab at the site, where, too, no preparations were made." The MMRDA also faced challenges launching the 14 girders, each weighing 140 tonne, as they could only carry out work for 3 hours at night to avoid affecting rail traffic. All girders were launched in 21 days. According to Jitendra Gupta of the Citizens' Transport Committee, "There is no accountability and coordination among the government agencies involved. We had met the railway chief engineer in charge of the project around four years ago and were told that he had 200 proposals like the SCLR to examine because of his wide jurisdiction. He said he couldn't make an exception for the SCLR and speed up clearances."
According to the reply from the MMRDA on 24 March 2014 to an RTI request filed by RTI activist Anil Galgali, construction work on the SCLR was complete on the sections from the Mithi river to Ghazinagar, Kurla (W), and from Ghazinagar, Kurla (W) to Rahul Nagar, Tilak Nagar. However, the section from Rahul Nagar to Eastern Express Highway via Amar Mahal flyover was incomplete. MMRDA Executive Engineer M.A. Wani noted that part of the delay was caused by a change in the specification for a girder from concrete to steel. The decision was approved by executive committee of MMRDA in its meeting held on 11 January 2012.
The MMRDA issued a press note on 13 April stating that the SCLR was complete. Bitumen work was pending at the Chembur end, apart from which streetlights had also not been installed on the entire length of road. The approach road to the landing at Nehru Nagar had also not been completed, and road medians were still being placed at the Chembur end. The Opposition alleged that the project saw delays due to the government's "inefficiency" and was being opened ahead of elections as a "pre-poll stunt". Mumbai Bharatiya Janata Party President Ashish Shelar wrote a letter to the Election Commission on 14 April, calling the SCLR opening a "publicity stunt" and opposing the inauguration stating that the Congress party would "reap undue credit for it". RTI activist G.R. Vora and Action for Good Governance and Networking in India activist Shyama Kulkarni both questioned why the opening took place so close to the election.
The SCLR was inaugurated by MMRDA officials at 8:15 am IST on 18 April 2014. Unlike most projects in India, the SCLR was opened without fanfare, and no politicians were present at the opening, as the code of conduct for the 2014 general elections was in force at the time. Traffic was sparse on opening day, which officials believe was because it was a public holiday due to Good Friday. Inadequate signage meant some motorists had to ask for directions. MMRDA officials installed additional signboards by 21 April, but they failed to improve the situation because they were too small.
According to then DCP (traffic) Pratap Dighovkar, about 22,000 vehicles used the SCLR on opening day. Traffic remained skeletal on the second day as well. More than 50,000 vehicles used the road on the third day. Increased traffic caused jams on the third day, mainly due to a Congress election rally at BKC. On 28 April, a Monday, the first working day since the road opened, an estimated 55,000-60,000 vehicles travelled on the SCLR. Heavy congestion was reported on certain stretches of the road, particularly on Hans Bhugra and Mohammad Raza Road junctions in Santa Cruz (E). Mumbai Traffic Police officers stated that Mohammad Raza Road needs to be widened as it is a main feeder to SCLR.
Joint commissioner of traffic B.K. Upadhyay noted that the MMRDA had failed to complete widening of feeder routes before completion of the project. The Citizen Transport Forum carried out an audit of the SCLR on the third day after opening, and identified seven major bottlenecks along the road. Upadhyay told the Mumbai Mirror on 29 April that these issues could be fixed by widening the roads and installing traffic lights. However, he noted that an eighth problem, at Mohammed Raza Chowk, where traffic from BKC Road and the SCLR merge, accounted for 90% of the jams. He felt that the situation could be improved by installing traffic signals at the junction, but even that would not resolve the entire problem.
The SCLR is 6.45 km long and 45.7 metres wide. The SCLR has three flyovers: CST Road flyover (the main flyover spanning a total length of 3.45 km), the 560 metre Kurla-Kalina flyover above LBS Marg, and the double-decker flyover (combined length of 1.8 km) crossing over the Central and Harbour Line tracks at Tilak Nagar. The SCLR also has two arms—one for Lokmaniya Tilak Terminus and the other one for Kurla Dairy. The 1096 metre long Amar Mahal junction flyover connects the SCLR with the EEH. The flyover is 17 metres wide. The S-shaped steel girder is 92 metres long and 8.5 metres in width, and its actual cost is 59.51-76.41 crore. Access to the road is available from CST Road, Amar Mahal Junction, Nehru Nagar and Lokmanya Tilak Terminus.
|Stretch||Length (km)||Details of existing road||Details of road constructed for SCLR|
|Phase I (3.45 km section from Mithi River to EEH)|
|Mithi River–LBS Marg||0.650||4-lane concrete road||10-lane concrete road + Flyover + Slip roads|
|LBS Marg–Old Agra road||0.250||4-lane (intermediate) concrete||Flyover + slip roads (4 Lane + 6 Lane)|
|Old Agra Road–Buddha Colony||0.205||2-lane concrete road||10 lane concrete + replacement of existing steel bridge|
|Buddha Colony–LTT||1.095||Virgin Land||6 lane concrete road + 6 lane RoB + Viaduct|
|LTT–Tansa Pipeline||0.300||2-lane road||Viaduct|
|Tansa Pipeline–Rahul Nagar||0.650||Virgin Land||Viaduct + 6 lane concrete road|
|Rahul Nagar–Amar Mahal junction||0.300||One side carriageway||10-lane split carriageway|
|S.G. Barve Marg junction–Kurla Dairy||0.380||4 lane road||4lane + footpath + median|
|Kurla Dairy–LTT junction||0.420||Virgin land||4 lane ROB + approaches|
|Phase II (3 km section from the WEH to the Mithi River)|
- Phadke, Manasi (20 December 2011). "MMRDA hikes contract values". The Indian Express. Retrieved 17 May 2012.
- "Santacruz-Chembur Link Road expected to commission soon". Financial Express. 2014-03-13. Retrieved 2014-04-01.
- Express India. Express India. Retrieved 16 July 2013.
- Rajendra Aklekar (2011-10-10). "Citizens committee photograph incomplete work of Mumbai roads". Daily News & Analysis (DNA). Retrieved 2014-04-02.
- "Roads to nowhere". Hindustan Times. 2009-08-19. Retrieved 2014-04-02.
- Ranjeet Jadhav (2014-04-02). "Rs 428-cr link road in Mumbai ready, but netas stall opening". Mid Day. Retrieved 2014-04-02.
- "Rs 428-crore link road in Mumbai ready, but netas stall opening". NDTV.com. 2014-04-02. Retrieved 2014-04-02.
- Shukla, Alka (March 22, 2011). "The man who saw tomorrow...". Mumbai Mirror (Mumbai). Retrieved 31 March 2014.
- "Mumbai Urban Transport Project". MMRDA. Archived from the original on 23 February 2014. Retrieved 2014-10-19.
- Mumbai Metropolitan Region Development Authority (MMRDA) (May 2006). "Resettlement implementation plan for the Santacruz Chembur Link Road. Vol. 7 of India–Mumbai Urban Transport Project : resettlement action plan.". Mumbai: World Bank. Retrieved 31 March 2014. This article incorporates text from this source, which is in the public domain.
- "Jogeshwari-Vikhroli Link Road Under M.U.T.P". MSRDC. 2003-07-17. Retrieved 2014-04-02.
- Ranjeet Jadhav (2014-03-30). "Poll Vault: Metro, S'cruz-Chembur road to open in April?". Mid-day.com. Retrieved 2014-04-01.
- "Santa Cruz-Chembur road to make Kalanagar tunnel plan redundant". The Times of India. 2014-01-17. Retrieved 2014-04-01.
- Ateeq Shaikh (2014-03-26). "Delayed SCLR project cost stands at Rs 450 crore". Daily News & Analysis (DNA). Retrieved 2014-04-01.
- "Executive Summary, Resettlement Implementation for Santa Cruz Chembur Link Road (SCLR)". Archived from the original on 7 April 2014. This article incorporates text from this source, which is in the public domain.
- "Santacruz Chembur Link Road". MSRDC. Retrieved 2014-04-01.
- "Bank Management Response to Request for Inspection Panel Review of the India–Mumbai Urban Transport Project". World Bank. World Bank. pp. 8–13. Retrieved 1 April 2014. This article incorporates text from this source, which is in the public domain.
- "MMRDA hikes contract values". The Indian Express. 2011-12-20. Retrieved 2014-04-01.
- "JVLR and SCLR costs hit the roof due to delays". Financial Express. 2011-10-18. Retrieved 2014-04-01.
- "37 months on, skywalk still delayed". The Asian Age. September 23, 2013. Archived from the original on September 2013. Retrieved 2014-04-01.
- "MMRDA to build two flyovers near CST Bridge". The Indian Express. 2013-09-01. Retrieved 2014-04-01.
- "MMRDA to build two new bridges in Mumbai". Economic Times. PTI. 2013-08-31. Retrieved 2014-04-01.
- "MMRDA to build two new bridges in Mumbai". Business Standard. 2013-08-31. Retrieved 2014-04-01.
- Philip Varghese (March 26, 2014). "Threefold rise in cost!". Afternoondc.in. Retrieved 2014-04-02.
- Anil Singh (March 26, 2014). "Vital Link Road Project in Limbo". Free Press Journal. Retrieved 2014-04-01.
- Finally, railway nod for taking link road over Kurla tracks. Indian Express (13 July 2012). Retrieved 16 July 2013.
- "Santacruz-Chembur Link Road project cost jumps 278%". Financial Express. 2012-07-17. Retrieved 2014-04-02.
- New flyover to link Kalina, Kurla from Friday. The Times of India. (8 August 2012). Retrieved 16 July 2013.
- "Finally, Santacruz-Chembur Link Road will be opened to traffic this week". Mid-Day. April 14, 2014. Retrieved 2014-04-16.
- "SCLR to be thrown open to the public this week". Free Press Journal. April 14, 2014. Retrieved 2014-04-16.
- Ateeq Shaikh (2013-10-22). "Santa Cruz–Chembur link road to open later this week". Daily News & Analysis. Retrieved 2014-04-16.
- "BJP writes to EC over Mumbai flyover inauguration". The Hindu. 2014-03-31. Retrieved 2014-04-16.
- Anand Mishra (April 14, 2014). "BJP to write to EC over SCLR opening". The Asian Age. Retrieved 2014-04-16.