Science and technology in Spain
The topic of science and technology in Spain is here taken to include firstly an account of the historical development of these fields of study, and secondly a description of the current institutional and regulatory framework for continuing this development into the future.
"History of Science and Technology in Spain" is the heading often used to group the history of science and the history of technology in Spain (albeit without an established academic consensus on the matter, with equal currency given to various other bibliographic headings frequently used to cover this subject area: History of Science in Spain, History of Spanish Science, History of Spanish Science and Technology or History of Science and Technical Expertise in Spain).
Just deciding whether something counts as scientific, technical or technological is a subtle business, tackled by the recently established discipline of studies in Science, Technology and Society (STS). Whilst scientific and technical activities are as old as the human race, the founding of a true technology (in the sense of integrating systematic knowledge, material resources, skills and technical procedures to transform a production process through the application of a defined methodology — over and above what can be achieved through craftsmanship —), became possible only with the dawn of the late modern period; in the case of Spain, this came tragically late, in contrast to the verve with which she had become one of the first to enter the early modern period. Very few Spanish scientists (excepting those such as Servet or Cajal) were instrumental in the paradigm shifts characteristic of successive scientific revolutions. As a consequence, in Spain the study of the history of science concerns itself mainly with the effects these paradigms had on reaching Spain, and the same is true of technology transfers. Science and technology in Spain was such a "marginal feature of its administrative and social structures", that this very marginality came to be used as a sort of Spanish national stereotype, sometimes rejected as being pejorative or belittling but on occasion seized on with haughty pride, as in Miguel de Unamuno's immortal phrase, repeatedly used and abused ever since, on both sides of the argument, to the extent of becoming a literary motif or cliché:
¡Que inventen ellos! (Let them invent!)—Miguel de Unamuno, various versions, 1906–1912
The use of the masculine "ellos" is no coincidence either (there are those who would suggest the contrary view: ¡Que inventen ellas! "Let women invent!"). Throughout history science and technology were almost entirely male preserves, until the late decades of the 20th century finally saw the balance shift in quantitative terms. Nevertheless, gender studies and women's history, when dealing with the history of science and technology, have focussed on achieving recognition for significant female contributors in these fields.
Given the absence of written sources, the reconstruction of aspects of pre-scientific and pre-technological thought has been attempted through analysis and interpretation of paleolithic art – of which the Iberian peninsula possesses examples of exceptional value; through studies of stone-working techniques; and through anatomical reconstructions. James Frazer in The Golden Bough proposed similarities between the function of science and that of magic in primitive cultures and in the "primitive mind". More recently André Leroi-Gourhan studied the topic from a structuralist perspective.
The identification of "phases" through which human thought has passed in interpreting nature originate with the positivism of Auguste Comte – theological or fictive state; metaphysical or abstract state; and scientific or positivist state. Many other terms have been proposed: magical thinking, pre-philosophical thought, mythopoeic thought and others.
The pre-neanderthal (Homo Heidelbergensis) finds at the Atapuerca site near Burgos in Spain offer one of the most promising directions for paleoanthropological research: to establish the degree of oral communication in that species by reconstruction of the sound-producing mechanism (hyoid) and hearing apparatus (bone structure and inner-ear cavity). This could be linked with other findings from the site, such as the deliberate accumulation of corpses. All this would necessitate consideration of the capacity for symbolic thought.
The theory of the "Neolithic revolution" implies a diffusionist interpretation of the spread of innovations such as agriculture and pottery. On the other hand it is argued that copper working at Los Millares (near Almería in Spain) during the chalcolithic period (beginning of the third millennium BC) could have arisen independently, together with an increase in agricultural yields due to irrigation as seen at the Cerro de la Virgen de Orce site, as well as walled settlements and social stratification.
During the first civilisations in the Middle East, the part played by the “Far Western” regions in long-distance metal trading was vital for the development there of Bronze Age metallurgical techniques. Next, around 1000BC, Iron Age metallurgy was introduced simultaneously but independently to Iberia by Mediterranean colonisers (Greek and Phoenician) on the southern and eastern coasts, and by Celts from Central Europe in the centre, west and north. Less is known of the introduction of other technologies such as the wheel, the plough and the sail.
The Roman period
Romanisation went deep in Hispania, as shown in the construction techniques that gave rise to such completed structures as the Alcántara bridge or the Aqueduct of Segovia; a complex network of roads; the first dams for water storage (although whether these are in fact Roman is still under debate); or different types of mining ranging from large-scale gold mines such as that at las Médulas to the extraction of lapis specularis es:Economía en la Hispania romana#Minería
Some of the most important scientists of the Hellenistic period came to Cádiz, such as Polybius, Artemidorus and Posidonius, who took the chance while there to make measurements of the tides (more visible in the Atlantic than in the Mediterranean) and suggest their causes.
Among the few Hispano-Latin writers on scientific topics were Pomponius Mela from Algeciras, and Columela from Cádiz, both from the Baetica province. The former wrote De Chorographia, a work of geography, and the latter wrote Res rustica and Liber de arboribus, on agronomy. The following quotation from Columela shows clearly how the speculative nature of Greco-Roman scientific activity was disconnected from technology and manual work, reflecting the basic separation between the “otium” (leisure time) fitting for philosophers, and the world of “negotium” (commerce) and slavery.
And I can never cease to wonder, when I consider how those who wish to speak well choose an orator whose eloquence they imitate; those who wish to learn the rules of calculation and measurement seek a master of this learning who pleases them so much; those who love music and dance take great care to find masters of these arts; those who want to construct a building call upon tradesmen and architects; those who wish to sail the sea seek men who know how to manage a boat; those who engage in war seek skilled tacticians; in short, everyone taking pains to find the best guide they can for that field of study to which they want to apply themselves...: only agriculture, which is certainly very close to wisdom, and has some sort of kinship with her, lacks pupils to learn it and masters to teach it.
Subject to its inherent limitations, it was in the Iberian peninsula that medieval science saw some of its greatest developments. These were achieved under both Christian and Muslim rule, with an important Jewish contribution. Already during the "Dark Ages", some of the few scholars were located within the Visigothic kingdom of Toledo and Hispanic monasticism: in particular San Isidoro with his Etymologiae.
The transition from feudalism to capitalism implied technological changes driven forward or hindered by the different socio-economic structures, which in Spain were made manifest in the different forms of innovation in agriculture, livestock farming, food production and other crafts. In some cases these were promoted by institutions – monasteries or craft guilds; in other cases they arose from within the productive activities themselves, which to a greater or less extent kept their “trade secrets” and in the stratified society of the time were deprecated as “vile and mechanical trades”. The most spectacular examples of the technology of this period are the water wheels of South-eastern Spain, together with other irrigation techniques introduced or perfected by the Arab-Hispanic civilisation.
The incorporation of the later medieval kingdoms of Spain into European trade routes between the Atlantic and the Mediterranean stimulated not only seafaring technology and the associated map-making and astronomical studies, but also the introduction of new commercial and financial institutions. Examples from the Kingdom of Aragón include trading halls (es:Lonja de la Seda), money-changing tables (es:Taula de canvi), and codes of law governing maritime trade (es:Consulado del mar); and from the Kingdom of Castile, trade fairs such as those of Medina del Campo, Medina de Rioseco and Villalón, where the first bills of exchange were drawn up.
Early modern science
Arguably it was the effects upon Spain of the conquest of America - in particular the negative effects of inflation, reduction in incentives for productive investment, and social and ideological conservatism – that led to the growth of Spanish economic science. One of its fundamental texts, by Tomás de Mercado, is titled Suma de tratos y contratos (On deals and contracts) (1571), paraphrasing the title of St Thomas Aquinas’ work Summa theologica.
In some cases these trade practices were linked to the Jewish and converted Christian minorities. Lending at interest was considered as the sin of usury, both in Christian and Islamic morality. This lay at the root of some of the issues that determined the course of cultural and intellectual history, such as the dialectic between New and Old Christians, and the shaping of the financial and tax-collecting systems of the nascent authoritarian monarchy after its unification by the Catholic Monarchs. The “most religious” policy of this monarchy also justified a whole series of decisions with important consequences for production, science and technology in Spain. Among these were the expulsion of the Jews in 1492; the expulsion of the Moriscos (Christian converts from Islam, and their descendants) in 1609; the persecution of dissidents of all types – alumbrados, Protestants, followers of Erasmus; in addition to the subjection of conscience to the Inquisition, which universalised suspicion, denunciation and self-censorship.
The economic importance of the Spanish treasure fleet and the exploitation of minerals from the New World called for science and technology of the highest level, above all in the maritime and metallurgical fields. The clear priority for any conceivable “scientific programme” would have been to address the needs of the immense overseas empire.
A notable example of Spanish scientific aspirations at the time was in 1598, when Felipe III launched an open competition for a method of determining longitude at sea. In 1616 Galileo Galilei himself made an attempt at the attractive prize (with a method based on observing the movements of the moons of Jupiter, unworkable from a moving ship). The ambition of this competition became evident from the fact that its goal did not prove achievable until the development of watches in the 18th century, when naval primacy was passing to England. From 1731 watches were available in England, such as that devised by John Harrison which relied on springs only, not pendulums or weights, and was kept in a box mounted in gimbals to absorb the movement of the ship. Meanwhile Spanish watchmaking technology had fallen behind: despite royal sponsorship (es:Real Escuela de Relojería (1770), es:Real Fábrica de Relojes (1788–93)), the royal collections of Carlos III and Carlos IV turned to the products of John Ellicott or of French watchmakers. This remained the case until the mid-19th century with the notable works of es:José Rodríguez Losada. In another field, but no less indicative of the future, was the chess contest staged by Felipe II in his court in 1575. On that occasion the Spanish master Ruy López de Segura, up to then considered the best practical and theoretical exponent of chess, was dethroned by the Italian Leonardo da Cutri.
While the medieval university renewed itself under the influence of humanism, the Counter-Reformation led to an isolation from outside influences and a general stagnation of the institution, which came to fulfil what had always been its main function: the reproduction of the élites (see es:Colegio Mayor). Nevertheless, we should not exaggerate some aspects of this closure to the exterior. Take for instance the infamous decree of 1559 forbidding Castilian students from attending universities outside the kingdom (in 1568 extended to students from Aragón); in practice this was applied with little rigour and its motivation is debated – it may have been not so much a defence against Protestantism as an attack on the Jesuits and on the University of Louvain, which was not excepted as were those of Bologna, Rome, Naples and Coimbra.
How pitiful and indeed shameful it is that, as if we were Indians, we should have to be the last to receive news and insights already spread throughout the rest of Europe. And likewise, that men who come to realise this take offence at the warning and fester in disappointment. And how certain it is that trying to diverge from the decree of an outdated opinion is among the hardest things that men attempt!—Juan de Cabriada, ’’Philosophical-medical-chemical letter’’, 1687.
The awareness of the poor state of science and technology in Spain arose out of the “negative introspection” of the arbitristas of the 17th and especially the 18th century. In the “light of reason” these sought progress in applied science. Following the debate generated by Masson de Morvilliers’ provocative question “What do we owe to Spain?” it became a commonplace that unlike literature and the arts, science in Spain considerably lagged behind that in other European countries. Indeed this became such a prevalent cliché as to provoke a “complaint about the complaint” among writers such as Cadalso or Larra (Cartas marruecas, En este país).
In reality the field of “science” was not clearly distinguished from that of “letters” or “the humanities” until the Enlightenment; and even much later the width of the breach between the two fields of knowledge was not recognised, as witness the Two Cultures debate of the mid-20th century. It is in this context that we should view the famous speech of Don Quixote on “weapons and letters”: while in the Middle Ages the knight may have distinguished himself mainly by his military adventures, from the Renaissance onward it became clear that high rank did not have to conflict with intellectual development.
"Letters" at this period embraced theology as well as humanities, which had recently emerged as independent disciplines: grammar, law, and what were called "liberal arts" including medicine (then known as "physic" and practised by "physicians"), the different branches of mathematics – among which astronomy was not yet distinguished from astrology -, and philosophy – not then distinct from what we would now term as "science", especially in the adjectival forms "natural philosophy" and "natural history" (both these terms later became obsolete in Spanish use).
Regardless of the adverse circumstances prevailing in the late 18th and early 19th centuries (es: crisis del Antiguo Régimen) , the key to what was more and more coming to be perceived as “Spanish backwardness” was the survival of certain pre-industrial socio-economic structures, at the decisive moment when the Industrial Revolution began in England and the French Revolution occurred in France. This is also the crucial context in which, in the most advanced countries, science and technical progress began to be coordinated – up to then they had remained largely separate spheres. In time such coordination led to the emergence of "technology" in a full sense, and initiated feedback processes arising from the social need for innovation.
Resistance to modernisation in Spain was expressed in the strong antagonism between the Francophiles and their opponents the es:’’casticistas’’, who accused the Francophiles of all sorts of religious heterodoxy – Jansenism, Freemasonry, pantheism, freethinking, Voltairianism, agnosticism, atheism – as exemplified in the trial of Pablo de Olavide. Paradoxically, those among the clergy who became victims of persecution were the most scientifically educated group: the Jesuits, who were expelled from Spain in 1767, having been blamed for the Esquilache Riots. Their schools and libraries were closed down and their members dispersed, although many of them based themselves in Rome and continued to publish scientific and literary works in Spanish. The Piarists became the order most engaged with teaching outside the university, although at a much more elementary level – the Jesuits focussed on the social and intellectual élite. The Society of Jesus was re-introduced to Spain during the 19th century, was again suppressed during the Second Republic and was restored under Franco. However, suspicion of science was not confined to Spain: in England and Holland at the end of the 17th and start of the 18th centuries there was strong medical opposition to the use of cinchona ("Jesuit powder").
The Nineteenth Century
The Peninsular War, better known in Spain as the War for Spanish Independence, was truly a disaster for Spanish science and technology, which in some fields had achieved a leading position. Spanish science had contributed to the discovery of two – platinum and tungsten – of the 21 chemical elements identified in the 18th century and then to that of vanadium in 1801; but played no part in the discovery of another 50 elements during the rest of the 19th century. Of greater importance even than the systematic destruction of infrastructure by both French and British armies, such as the textile industry of Béjar or the porcelain manufacture of Buen Retiro in Madrid, was the “brain drain” resulting from the exiling in turn of Francophiles and Liberals. The closure of universities - whose reform, aimed at by proponents of the Enlightenment, had proved just as impossible as any other reform that threatened to disturb the structural underpinnings of the ancien régime – was offset only by the opening in 1830 of a bullfighting school in Seville headed by Pedro Romero.
At any rate, the gathering together of funds scattered during the sackings allowed the opening of the Prado Museum in Madrid, in the building originally intended as the base for the Royal Office for Science, the National Library, and other academic institutions. Gradually, the university sector was renewed: one major act was the move of the former University of Alcalá to Madrid as the Universidad Central. Primary and secondary education were developed as the foundation of a far-reaching educational programme (es:Ley Moyano), which however was not implemented effectively or widely until the Second Republic of 1931-36.
The economy of the 19th-century ”liberal revolution” was hampered by the Carlist Wars and by the confiscation of church property. These factors severely held back an insecure process of industrialisation that had begun much earlier, as with textiles in Barcelona, or steel making in Málaga. The liberal programmes, especially those of the progresistas (in power 1854-56 and 1868–74), but also to a lesser extent of the moderados, included the promotion of railway-building and mining, opening Spain to foreign investment from France, Belgium and Britain. However, the protectionism of the end of the century meant closure of the economy to the outside world. Economic thinking during these periods reflected opposing demands: those of agrarian interests (the landowning oligarchy of Castile and Andalusia) and those of industrial interests (the bourgeoisie of the Catalan textile trade).
Awareness of having fallen behind was growing all the time, especially in the liberal élites, among whom were spreading strongly expressed slogans deriving from the Black Legend of the Spanish Inquisition.
If, overlooking those centuries during which the Arab civilisation made Spain the first country in the world as regards science, we focus only on the modern era, from the fifteenth century onward, you will well understand that this is not, and cannot be, the history of science in Spain, because a people without science can hardly have a scientific history. The flawed account you have heard is an historical summary of mathematical science, yes, but in Italy, France, England, Holland, Germany, Switzerland...; it is not the history of science here, where there was only the whip, iron, blood, prayers, braziers and smoke.
Such views were condemned in their turn as anti-Spanish propaganda, drawing on the studies of Julián Juderías. His 1914 work "The 'black legend' and historical truth" claimed that a wide range of Spanish scientists had been active during the Spanish Golden Age. His list can be found in a footnote to the Spanish Wikipedia article.
The "polemic of Spanish science", in which the reactionary thought of Menéndez and others was opposed by the "krausista" followers of the German philosopher Krause, developed following the restoration of the Bourbon monarchy in 1875. Later, as reaction to the disaster of the Spanish-American War of 1898, a "regenerationist" movement arose.
The Twentieth Century
The award of the Nobel Prize for Medicine in 1906 to the Spanish scientist Santiago Ramón y Cajal, at a time when Spanish science had in general little to be proud of, ushered in what became known as a ”Silver Age” of Spanish letters and sciences during the first third of the twentieth century.
At present, when scientific research has become a recognised profession with State funding... those former times have passed when anyone curious about Nature, shut in the silence of his study, could be sure that no rival would disturb his quiet musings. Nowadays, research is a fever: hardly is a new technique outlined, when many other scholars take it up and apply it almost simultaneously to the same problems, tarnishing the glory of the original inventor... In Spain, where laziness is not just a vice but a religion, people find it hard to grasp those monumental works of the German chemists, physicists and doctors, in which it would appear that just making the diagrams and searching the literature must take decades, and yet those books have been written within one or two years... The whole secret lies in the method of study... in short, in not incurring the mental expense of that witty chat of the café and the social gathering, which takes away our nervous energy and with new and futile concerns distracts us from the main task.—Santiago Ramón y Cajal (1897), Speech on admission to the Spanish Royal Academy of Sciences
The Spanish Civil War was another tragedy for Spanish science, bringing about the exile of a whole generation of scientists – the next Spaniard to win the Nobel Prize for medicine, Severo Ochoa in 1959, had taken American citizenship – and the moribund intellectual life in “internal exile” of many other scientists during the long poverty-stricken postwar period depicted in Luis Martín-Santos’ novel Tiempo de Silencio. It was indicative of the National Catholicism of the time that one of the biggest scholarly projects was the Library of Christian Authors (1944). However, despite censorship, over time the publishing trade diversified and showed a great capacity for innovation, both technically and of content.
The policy of autarky, and the concentration of capital in large banking and industrial corporations, gave some opportunity for scientific and technological development in strategic sectors such as shipbuilding, petrochemicals and hydroelectricity. Later, in 1968, the first nuclear power station was built. Scientific work was centred in the universities – their leading departments deprived of the majority of their pre-war teachers and subject to the "brain drain" of the young – and in the Spanish National Research Council (Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas, CSIC) which in 1939 had purged and taken over from a former research council of the krausista tradition.
We aim at a Catholic science. At this moment we therefore eliminate all the scientific heresies that dried up the channels of our national genius and sank us into lethargy and decay... Our present-day science, in common with that which defined us in past centuries as a nation and an empire, seeks to be above all Catholic
Individual or collective achievements such as the Talgo train or the eradication of malaria were held up as glories of the Franco regime, regardless of their importance – e.g. the heart transplant attempted by the Marquis of Villaverde, son-in-law to Franco himself, in September 1968, when the patient died the next day.
The development drive that got under way in the 1960s speeded up as regards scientific and technical achievement during the final quarter of the century, with the Spanish transition to democracy and the entry into the European Union.
Current situation and regulatory framework
In recent years Spain reached an impressive ninth in the rankings of world science (with 2.5% of publications), but now faces a dismal situation due to the deep budget cuts entailed by the Spanish financial crisis. One of the weaknesses of the Spanish system for science and technology (or national system for innovation) is the lack of investment in R&D by private companies and their consequent dependence on public investment, a distinct contrast to other industrialised countries.
Following much change in recent years, no fewer than three ministries (Ministry of Education, Culture and Sport, Ministry for Economic Affairs and Competition -which includes the office of the Secretary of State for Research, Development and Innovation, formerly a full ministry as the Ministry of Science and Innovation- and the Ministry of Industry, Energy and Tourism) currently share responsibility for this sector under the provisions of Law 14/2011, passed on 1 June concerning Science, Technology and Innovation. There is a State Plan for Scientific and Technical Investigation and for Innovation, and a network of public research bodies (Organismos Públicos de Investigación, OPI), headed by the Spanish National Research Council (CSIC), with Major Science Facilities (Grandes Instalaciones Científicas, GIC), Medium Sized Facilities (Instalaciones de Tamaño Medio, ITM) and science and technology parks (Asociación de Parques Científicos y Tecnológicos de España, APTE).
There is more text to be translated in es:Historia de la ciencia y la tecnología en España and in es:Ciencia y tecnología en España.
- José Manuel Sánchez Ron: Cincel, martillo y piedra. Historia de la ciencia en España. Madrid, Taurus, 1999. Leoncio López Ocón Breve Historia de la ciencia española Madrid: Alianza, 2003. ISBN 84-206-5626-7. (Descarta la Edad Media (cristiana y musulmana), para iniciar el libro en el Renacimiento y la España imperial, con su auge y posterior decadencia en el Barroco). Manuel Desantes ¿Cómo que inventen ellos?. Conferencia: Un repaso de los últimos quinientos años de la historia de la ciencia y la tecnología en España explica el retraso estructural actual. El II Congreso de la sociedad española de historia de las ciencias (Jaca, 27 de septiembre–1 de octubre, 1982) fue dedicado a La ciencia y la técnica en España entre 1850 y 1936, teniendo entre otras, ponencias con estos títulos: Antonio Ferraz Perspectivas institucionales de la historia de la ciencia y de la técnica en España; Eduardo Ortiz Sobre la ciencia y la técnica en España en el siglo XIX; José Luis Peset La historia de la ciencia y de la técnica en el curriculum profesional del científico y del ingeniero.
- Thomas F. Glick, Eugenio Portela Marco, Víctor Navarro Brotóns: La historia de la ciencia en España como realidad marginal en su organización y contexto social, Anthropos, 1982, Número 20, especial dedicado a José María López Piñero. ficha en dialnet
- Logros científicos de mujeres en la muestra '¡Que inventen ellas!', El País, 12/09/2003
- Summary in John Lewis (1985), Antropología simplificada, Selector, ISBN 978-968-403-041-1, pp. 80–81
- Henri Frankfort, Wilson and Jacobsen: The Intellectual Adventure of Ancient Man, 1946, later titled Before Philosophy, translated into Spanish as El Pensamiento Prefilosófico, FCE
- Ignacio Martínez, Human Evolution conference, CTIF, Alcalá de Henares 29 April 2009
- Juan Luis Arsuaga, El collar del neandertal (En: The Neanderthal’s Necklace), El enigma de la esfinge (En: The Riddle of the Sphinx) and other works.
- José María Rodanés Vicente (2007) Neolithic, Cæsaraugusta, 78. pp. 49–66, ISSN: 0007-9502, especially p. 52 et seq.
- El calcolítico en la Península Ibérica (España) (The Chalcolithic period in Iberia) in Artehistoria.
- Mérida. Una investigación de cinco años sobre la presa de Proserpina descarta su origen romano: Terrae Antiquae, 26 de abril de 2006 (quotes a range of sources)
- José María Blázquez, Corpus de mosaicos de España, CSIC, 1982, ISBN 8400052439, p. 49.
- First book: Prologue to Publio Silvino, pp. 1–2. Translated by Juan María Álvarez de Sotomayor y Rubio, 1824 edition (printed by Miguel de Burgos) digitalised in Google Books
- Díez, Fernando (1990) Viles y mecánicos. Trabajo y sociedad en la Valencia preindustrial (Vile and mechanical: work and society in pre-industrial Valencia). Valencia, Edicions Alfons el Maganànim.
- Mª Rosario Caballero Carrillo y Pedro Miralles Martínez (2002) El trabajo de la infancia y la juventud en la época del Barroco. El caso de la seda murciana (Child and youth labour in the Baroque period: the example of the silk industry in Murcia)
- Fundación Museo de las Ferias. Documents from the fairs of Medina del Campo, Villalón and Medina de Rioseco, 2002
- Daniel Mediavilla, El GPS de las estrellas (The GPS of the stars), Publico.es, 19 August 2008
- Catalogue of the Spanish Museo Nacional de Ciencias Naturales, p. 68.
- Roberto Moreno José Rodríguez de Losada. Vida y obra (Life and Work). 1995, Madrid: Fundación Juanelo Turriano.
- Quoted in Miguel Ángel Quintanilla and José Manuel Sánchez Ron (1998) Ciencia, tecnología y sociedad (Science, technology and society), Madrid: Santillana, ISBN 84-294-4976-0, p. 89
- Miguel de Cervantes, Don Quixote, ch.38, The Literature Network
- Valentín Moreno Gallego (2005), Letras misivas, letras humanas, letras divinas. La correspondencia del cardenal Granvela en la Real Biblioteca y sus cartas de autores (Correspondence of Cardinal Granvela). Cuadernos de Historia Moderna (Journal of Modern History), 2005 Annex 4, ISBN 84-95215-57-8, pp. 31–55.
- Filosofía e historia natural en la Ilustración (Philosophy and natural history in the Enlightenment), University of Valladolid
- Luis Millones Figueroa (2006), Filosofía e historia natural en el Inca Garcilaso (Philosophy and natural history in Inca Garcilaso), in Ensayos de cultura virreinal latinoamericana (Essays on Latin American culture under the viceroys), Lima: University of San Marcos.
- Francesc Gómez Morales (2006), Cómo los jesuitas inundaron Europa de científicos (How the Jesuits flooded Europe with scientists). Forum Libertas
- Vicente Faubell Zapata (2008), Historia de la acción educativa de los Escolapios en España de 1733 a 1845 (History of educational activities of the Piarists in Spain, 1733-1845), Universia
- Malaria. Exhibition in the National Library, 2009. La Condesa, los Jesuitas, el Cardenal, el Demonio, Linneo y sus Polvos (The Countess, the Jesuits, the Cardinal, the Devil, Linnaeus and his Powders)
- José Manuel Sánchez Ron (2009), ¡Viva la ciencia!, pp. 93–94. Barcelona: Crítica, ISBN 84-8432-916-9.
- José Luis Comellas (1988), Historia de España Contemporánea, p. 83. Ediciones Rialp, ISBN 978-84-321-2441-9. 
- Mariano José de Larra (1836), De 1830 à 1836, ó, La España desde Fernando VII hasta Mendizabal: resumen histórico critico, p.13. Imprenta Repullés
- Mariano José de Larra, Artículos Varios, p. 124. Editorial Castalia, 1976 ISBN 978-84-7039-225-2.
- Museo Pedagógico de Huesca website: standing exhibition on education.
- Ángel Bahamonde, Política económica y liberalización, in Artehistoria.
- Julián Juderías (1914), La leyenda negra y la verdad histórica: contribución al estudio del concepto de España en Europa, de las causas de este concepto y de la tolerancia política y religiosa en los países civilizados. Madrid, Tip. de la Revista de Archivos.
- Official webpage of the Nobel Prize committee, stating that "Titles, data and places given above refer to the time of the award".
- Quoted by Carlos Elías, in Los científicos piden que el CSIC no tenga carácter político. Denuncian el espíritu anticientífico que rige este organismo en su 60 aniversario (Scientists call for CSIC to be non-political, condemn the anti-scientific spirit prevailing in that body on its 60th anniversary) , El Mundo, 15 October 2000.
- La erradicación del paludismo en España Catalogue of the exhibition “Malaria”, National Library of Spain, May 2009. The official declaration coincided with the 25th anniversary of the end of the Civil War
- La Gaceta, Report of the 40th anniversary of the 1968 heart transplant, 17 September 2008
- España se sitúa como novena potencia científica mundial - España se ha situado como novena potencia científica mundial con el 2,5% de total de publicaciones científicas, según el estudio denominado "Conocimiento, redes y países: colaboración científica global en el siglo XXI" realizado por la Royal Society británica, Europa Press, 29/03/2011.
- The CSIC has lost 10% of its workforce in a year and a half. Until 2010 staff numbers had been rising in spite of budgetary cutbacks., El País, 1/08/2013
- es:Mikel Buesa, El sistema nacional de innovación en España: Un panorama, en Innovación y Competitividad, noviembre-diciembre 2012 ....investigates the recent evolution of support for innovation in Spain in the light of strategic aspects of resource allocation for this purpose during the period from 2000-2010. The author reviews scientific research activities with reference to cost-benefit and results. Technological activity by innovative businesses is analysed on the same basis, and is shown to be insufficiently productive to meet the country's needs. The paper also addresses the role played by policies for science and technology. Its conclusions show that, despite moving closer to the model characteristic of EU countries in general, Spain continues to demonstrate a significant weakness in the area of innovative businesses.
- 16/11/2010.- El INE presenta la Estadística sobre Actividades de I+D en 2009. Análisis del I+D en España en 2010: desequilibrio empresarial en la inversión que hay que corregir. Informe COTEC 2012, I+D+i en España: falla la inversión, no el rendimiento, in eldiario.es, 19/06/2013: In the past decade, the Spanish R&D sector has doubled scientific output in quantity, quality and the extent of technology transfer. When the figures for scientific and technological production are adjusted to reflect levels of investment in R&D, the performance of Spain's science and technology sector compares favourably with those of Germany, France and the USA. These facts call into question the official view that Spain produces "science in great quantity but of poor quality" and has failed to improve knowledge transfer. Although Spain still has great potential for improvement in science and innovation, lack of finance continues to be the main limiting factor,
- Plan Estatal de Investigación Científica y Técnica y de Innovación 2013-2016