Self-hating Jew

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

Self-hating Jew is a term used to allege that a Jewish person holds antisemitic beliefs or engages in antisemitic actions. The concept gained widespread currency after Theodor Lessing's 1930 book Der Jüdische Selbsthass ("Jewish Self-hatred"), which tries to explain the prevalence of Jewish intellectuals inciting antisemitism with their extremely hateful view toward Judaism. Jewish self-hate has been described as a neurotic reaction to the impact of antisemitism by Jews accepting, expressing, and even exaggerating the basic assumptions of the anti-Semite.[1] The term became "something of a key term of opprobrium in and beyond Cold War-era debates about Zionism".[2] Similar accusations of being uncomfortable with one's Jewishness were already being made by groups of Jews against each other before Zionism existed as a movement.[2]

According to academic author W. M. L. Finlay, the expression "self-hating Jew" "is often used rhetorically to discount Jews who differ in their lifestyles, interests or political positions from their accusers".[3] Finlay, a member of the Psychology Department at University of Surrey, distinguishes between "Jewish antisemitism" and "Jewish self-hatred," arguing that while the literature is full of examples of Jews who espoused antisemitism with statements dangerous and damning to all Jews, "whether this amounts to self-hatred is not easy to assess." Usage of self-hatred can also designate dislike or hatred of a group to which one belongs. The term has a long history in debates over the role of Israel in Jewish identity, where it is used against Jewish critics of Israeli government policy.[3] Alvin H. Rosenfeld, an academic author who does not use the term self-hatred, dismisses such arguments as disingenuous, referring to them as "the ubiquitous rubric 'criticism of Israel,'" stating that "vigorous discussion of Israeli policy and actions is not in question."[4] Alan Dershowitz limits the term self-hatred to extreme Jewish anti-Zionists who "despise anything Jewish, ranging from their religion to the Jewish state," saying it does not apply to all "Israel-bashers."[5]

The cultural historian Sander Gilman has written, "One of the most recent forms of Jewish self-hatred is the virulent opposition to the existence of the State of Israel."[6] He uses the term not against those who oppose Israel's policy, but against Jews who are opposed to Israel's existence. The concept of Jewish self-hatred has been described by Antony Lerman as "an entirely bogus concept",[7] one that "serves no other purpose than to marginalise and demonise political opponents",[8] who says that is used increasingly as a personal attack in discussions about the "new antisemitism".[8] Ben Cohen criticizes Lerman saying no "actual evidence is introduced to support any of this." [9] Lerman recognizes the controversy whether extreme vilification of Israel amounts to anti-Semitism and says that antisemitism can be disguised as anti-Zionism,[7] [10] which is the concern of Rosenfeld and Gilman addressed above.

The sociologist Irving Louis Horowitz reserves the term for Jews who pose a danger to the Jewish community, using "Jewish self-hater" to describe the court Jew "who validates the slander (against Jews) as he attempts to curry the favor of masters and rulers."[11] The historian Bernard Wasserstein prefers the term "Jewish anti-Semitism," which he says was often termed Jewish self-hatred.[12] He asks, "Could a Jew be an anti-Semite?" And responds, many Jews have "internalized elements of anti-Semitic discourse, succumbed to what Theodore Hamerow has called psychological surrender." Wasserstein goes on to say that self-hating Jews, "afflicted by some form of anti-Semitism were not so much haters of themselves as haters of 'other' Jews."

History[edit]

In German[edit]

The origins of terms such as "Jewish self-hatred" lie in the mid-nineteenth century feuding between German Orthodox Jews of the Breslau seminary and Reform Jews.[8] Each side accused the other of betraying Jewish identity,[2] the Orthodox Jews accusing the Reform Jews of identifying more closely with German Protestantism and German nationalism than with Judaism.[8]

According to Amos Elon, during 19th-century German-Jewish assimilation, conflicting pressures on sensitive and privileged or gifted young Jews produced "a reaction later known as 'Jewish self-hatred.' Its roots were not simply professional or political but emotional."[13] Elon uses the term "Jewish self-hatred" synonymously with Jewish antisemitism when he points out,"One of the most prominent Austrian anti-Semites was Otto Weininger a brilliant young Jew" who "published 'Sex and Character', attacking Jews and women." Elon attributes Jewish antisemitism as a cause in the overall growth of antisemitism when he says,"(Weininger's) book inspired the typical Viennese adage that anti-Semitism did not really get serious until it was taken up by Jews."

According to John P. Jackson Jr., the concept developed in the late nineteenth century in German Jewish discourse as "a response of German Jews to popular anti-Semitism that primarily was directed at Eastern European Jews." For German Jews, the Eastern European Jew became the "bad Jew".[14] According to Sander Gilman, the concept of the "self-hating Jew" developed from a merger of the image of the "mad Jew" and the "self-critical Jew",[2] and was developed to counter suggestions that an alleged Jewish stereotype of mental illness was due to inbreeding. "Within the logic of the concept, those who accuse others of being self-hating Jews may themselves be self-hating Jews."[15] Gilman says "the ubiquitousness of self-hatred cannot be denied. And it has shaped the self-awareness of those treated as different perhaps more than they themselves have been aware."[6]

The specific terms "self-hating Jew" and "Jewish self-hatred" only came into use later, developing from Theodor Herzl's polemical use of the term "anti-Semite of Jewish origin", in the context of his project of political Zionism.[2] The underlying concept gained common currency in this context, "since Zionism was an important part of the vigorous debates that were occurring amongst Jews at the time about anti-Semitism, assimilation and Jewish identity."[3] Herzl appears to have introduced the phrase "anti-Semite of Jewish origin" in his 1896 book, Der Judenstaat (The Jews' State), which launched political Zionism.[2]

He was referring to "philanthropic Zionists", assimilated Jews who might wish to remain in their home countries while at the same time encouraging the Jewish proletariat (particularly the poorer Eastern Jews) to emigrate; yet did not support Herzl's political project for a Jewish state.[2] Ironically, Herzl was soon complaining that his "polemical term"[2] was often being applied to him, for example by Karl Kraus.[2] "Assimilationists and anti-Zionists accused Zionists of being self-haters, for promoting the idea of the strong Jew using rhetoric close to that of the Anti-Semites; Zionists accused their opponents of being self-haters, for promoting the image of the Jew that would perpetuate his inferior position in the modern world."[8]

The Austrian-Jewish journalist, Anton Kuh, argued in a 1921 book Juden und Deutsche (Jew and German) that the concept of "Jewish anti-semitism" was unhelpful, and should be replaced with the term "Jewish self-hatred", but it was not until the 1930 publication of the German-Jewish anti-Nazi philosopher Theodor Lessing's book Der Jüdische Selbsthass (Jewish Self-hatred) that the term gained widespread currency.[2] Lessing's book "supposedly charts Lessing’s journey from Jewish self-hater to Zionist."[8] Lessing was assassinated by Nazi agents shortly after Hitler came to power.

In English[edit]

In English the first major discussion of the topic was in the 1940s by Kurt Lewin, who was Lessing's colleague at the University of Berlin in 1930.[2] Lewin emigrated from Germany to the United States in 1933, and though focused on Jews also argued for a similar phenomenon among Polish, Italian and Greek immigrants to the USA.[3] Lewin's was a theoretical account, declaring that the issue "is well known among Jews themselves" and supporting his argument with anecdotes.[3] Following Lewin's lead, the concept gained widespread currency. "The 1940s and 1950s were ‘the age of self-hatred’. In effect, a bitter war broke out over questions of Jewish identity. It was a kind of ‘Jewish Cold War’..."[8] in which questions of Jewish identity were contentiously debated. The use of the concept in debates over Jewish identity - for example over resistance to the integration of African Americans into Jewish neighbourhoods - died down by the end of the 1970s, having been "steadily emptied of most of its earlier psychological, social, and theoretical content and became largely a slogan."[16]

The term was used in a derogatory way during the 1940s by "'militant' Zionists",[16] but the 1963 publication of Hannah Arendt's Eichmann in Jerusalem opened a new chapter. Her criticism of the trial as a "show trial" provoked heated public debate, including accusations of self-hatred, and over-shadowed her earlier work criticising German Jewish parvenu assimilationism.[16] In the following years, after the 1967 Six-Day War and 1973 Yom Kippur War, "willingness to give moral and financial 'support' to Israel constituted what one historian called ‘the existential definition of American Jewishness’."[16] "This meant that the opposite was also true: criticism of Israel came to constitute the existential definition of ‘Jewish self-hatred’."[8] This is dismissed by Rosenfeld saying it "masquerades as victimization" and "can hardly be expected to be taken seriously" since criticism of Israel "proceeds across all the media in this country and within Israel itself."[4]

Even Commentary, the Jewish journal which had once been "considered the venue of self-hating Jews with questionable commitments to the Zionist project",[16] came under the editorship of Norman Podhoretz to staunchly support Israel.[16] In his 2006 essay "Progressive Jewish Thought and the New Anti-Semitism", Alvin H. Rosenfeld takes "a hard look at Jewish authors" whose statements go well beyond "legitimate criticism of Israel," and considers rhetoric that calls into question Israel's "right to continued existence" to be antisemitic. The use of the concept of self-hatred in Jewish debates about Israel has grown more frequent and more intense in the US and the UK, with the issue particularly widely debated in 2007, leading to the creation of the British Independent Jewish Voices.[8] The Forward reported that the group was formed by "about 130 generally leftist Jews."[17] It was the Rosenfeld essay, which did not use the term Jewish self-hatred, that led to the 2007 debate. Critics claimed the charge of antisemitism implied Jewish self-hatred to those criticizing Israel. Rosenfeld responded that such claims were "disingenuous" and for some a "dialectical scam validating themselves as intellectual martyrs."[4] The New York Times reported that the essay spotlighted the issue of when "legitimate criticism of Israel ends and antisemitic statements begin." [18]

Social and psychological explanations[edit]

The issue has periodically been covered in the academic social psychology literature on social identity. Such studies "frequently cite Lewin as evidence that people may attempt to distance themselves from membership in devalued groups because they accept, to some degree, the negative evaluations of their group held by the majority and because these social identities are an obstacle to the pursuit of social status."[3] Modern social psychology literature uses terms such as "self-stigmatization", "internalized oppression", and "false consciousness" to describe this type of phenomenon.

Kenneth Levin, a Harvard psychiatrist, says that Jewish self-hatred has two causes: Stockholm syndrome, where "population segments under chronic siege commonly embrace the indictments of their besiegers however bigoted and outrageous", as well as "the psychodynamics of abused children, who almost invariably blame themselves for their predicament, ascribe it to their being "bad," and nurture fantasies that by becoming "good" they can mollify their abusers and end their torment."[19] According to Howard W. Polsky, the social scientist, "feelings about Jewish marginality are often a step away from self-hatred." He then says, "Jewish self-hatred denotes that a person has adopted gentiles' definition of Jew as bad in one way or another and that being Jewish will hinder their success or identity."[20]

Usage[edit]

It is argued by some academics that the concept of Jewish self-hatred is based on an essentialisation of Jewish identity. Accounts of Jewish self-hatred often suggest that criticizing other Jews, and integrating with Gentile society, reveals hatred of one’s own Jewish origins.[3] Yet both in the early twentieth century, where the concept developed, and today, there are groups of Jews who had "important differences in identity based on class, culture, religious outlook, and education", and hostility between these groups can only be considered self-hate "if one assumes that a superordinate Jewish identity should take precedence over other groupings of Jews."[3]

Yet such hostility between groups has at times drawn on some of the rhetoric of antisemitism: "criticism of subgroups of Jews which drew on anti-Semitic rhetoric were common in 19th and 20th century arguments over Jewish identity".[3] In practice, according to one academic, whilst there have been Jewish writers in the late 19th and early 20th centuries who consistently employed virulent antisemitic rhetoric without seeming to value any aspects of being a Jew, too often "those who accuse others of being self-haters search for examples of when they have criticized Jews or Judaism but ignore examples of when those they criticize have shown they value being a Jew."[3] He argues that Jewish antisemitism does not necessarily amount to self-hatred, implying that "antisemitic Jew" may be a more accurate term to use. Other authors have also shown a preference for using "antisemitism" rather than "self-hatred."[4][12]

The term is in use in Jewish publications such as The Jewish Week (New York) and The Jerusalem Post (Jerusalem) in a number of contexts, often synonymously with antisemitic Jew. It is used "to criticize a performer or artist who portrays Jews negatively; as a shorthand description of supposed psychological conflict in fictional characters; in articles about the erosion of tradition (e.g. marrying out and circumcision); and to discount Jews who criticize Israeli policies or particular Jewish practices."[3] However the widest usage of the term is currently in relation to debates over Israel. "In these debates the accusation is used by right-wing Zionists to assert that Zionism and/or support for Israel is a core element of Jewish identity. Jewish criticism of Israeli policy is therefore considered a turning away from Jewish identity itself."[3]

Thus some of those who have been accused of being a "self-hating Jew" have characterized the term as a replacement for "a charge of anti-Semitism [that] will not stick,"[21] or as "pathologizing" them.[3][22] Some who use the term have equated it with "anti-Semitism",[23][24] on the part of those thus addressed, or with "so called ‘enlightened’ Jews who refuse to associate themselves with people who practice a ‘backward’ religion."[25] One novelist, Philip Roth, who — because of the nature of the Jewish characters in his novels, such as the 1969 Portnoy's Complaint[16] — has often been accused of being a "self-hating Jew", argues that all novels deal with human dilemmas and weaknesses (which are present in all communities), and that to self-censor by only writing about positive Jewish characters would represent a submission to antisemitism.[3]

Similar terms[edit]

"Self-loathing Jew" is used synonymously with "self-hating Jew." "Antisemitic Jew" can be used synonymously as well. "Self-hating Jew" has also been compared to the term "Uncle Tom" as used in the African-American community.[26][27] The term "auto-antisemitism" (Hebrew: אוטואנטישמיות‎, autoantishemiut) is also used in Hebrew synonymously.[28][29][30] In a column in Haaretz, Uzi Zilber used the term "Jew Flu" as a synonym for Jewish self-hatred.[31]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ Bernard Lewis, "Semites and Anti-Semites," W. W. Norton & Company 1999, pp. 255-256.
  2. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k Paul Reitter (2008), "Zionism and the Rhetoric of Jewish Self-Hatred", The Germanic Review 83(4)
  3. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n W. M. L. Finlay, "Pathologizing Dissent: Identity Politics, Zionism and the 'Self-Hating Jew'", British Journal of Social Psychology, Vol. 44 No. 2, June 2005, pp. 201-222.
  4. ^ a b c d Alvin H. Rosenfeld, "Rhetorical Violence and the Jews," The New Republic, February 27, 2007.
  5. ^ Alan Dershowitz, "The Case for Israel," John Wiley & Sons, Inc. 2004, pg. 220.
  6. ^ a b Sander Gilman, "Jewish Self-Hatred: Anti-Semitism and the Hidden Language of the Jews," Baltimore:Johns Hopkins University Press 1986, pp. 361.
  7. ^ a b Antony Lerman, "Jews attacking Jews", Ha'aretz, 12 September 2008, accessed 13 September 2008.
  8. ^ a b c d e f g h i Antony Lerman, Jewish Quarterly, "Jewish Self-Hatred: Myth or Reality?", Summer 2008
  9. ^ "Anthony Lerman Plays Politics with Antisemitism", The Propagandist, September 12, 2008.
  10. ^ "Anti-Zionism and Antisemitism: Ben Cohen Debates Antony Lerman", The Propagandist, June 18, 2008.
  11. ^ Irving Louis Horowitz, "New Trends and Old Hatreds," Springer New York Society (journal), Vol. 43 No.1, November 2005, ISSN 0147-2011 (Print) 1936-4725 (Online).
  12. ^ a b Bernard Wasserstein, "On the Eve," Simon and Schuster 2012, p. 211.
  13. ^ Amos Elon,"The Pity of It All : a History of Jews in Germany, 1743-1933," Metropolitan Books 2002, pp.231-237.
  14. ^ Jackson, John P, Jr; Jackson, John P (2001). Social Scientists for Social Justice: Making the Case Against Segregation. NYU Press. pp. 121–122. ISBN 978-0-8147-4266-2. Retrieved 2009-02-14. 
  15. ^ Gilman 1986, as described by Finlay (2005:208). Gilman, S. (1986). Jewish self-hatred: Anti-Semitism and the hidden language of the Jews. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
  16. ^ a b c d e f g Glenn, Susan A. (2006), "The Vogue of Jewish Self-Hatred in Post-World War II America", Jewish Social Studies, Volume 12, Number 3, Spring/Summer 2006 (New Series), pp. 95-136
  17. ^ Rebecca Spence, "Left-wing Critics of Israel Launch Blog to Combat Alledged Intimidation", The Jewish Daily Forward, Feb.9, 2007
  18. ^ Patricia Cohen, "Essay Linking Liberal Jews and Anti-Semitism Sparks a Furor". New York Times, Jan. 31, 2007,
  19. ^ Kenneth Levin "The Psychology of Populations under Chronic Siege", Post-Holocaust and Anti-Semitism, No. 46 2 July 2006, Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs. Accessed Feb 2010
  20. ^ Howard W. Polsky, "How I am a Jew, Adventures into my Jewish-American Identity," University Press of America 2002, pp.16-17.
  21. ^ Gibson, Martin (2009-01-23). "No choice but to speak out - Israeli musician ‘a proud self-hating Jew’". The Gisborne Herald. Retrieved 2009-02-14. [dead link]
  22. ^ Marqusee, Mike (4 Mar 2008). "The first time I was called a self-hating Jew". extract from If I Am Not for Myself: Journey of an Anti-Zionist Jew (The Guardian). Retrieved 2009-01-17. 
  23. ^ Huffington Post, The Self-Hating Jew: A Strategy to Hide From Self-Reflection. August 10, 2012.
  24. ^ Jewish Quarterly: Jewish Self-Hatred : Myth or Reality ? Summer 2008, Number 210.
  25. ^ Brackman, Rabbi Levi ("09.01.06"). "Confronting the self hating Jew". Israel Jewish Scene. ynetnews. Retrieved 2009-01-17.  Check date values in: |date= (help)
  26. ^ Eugene Kane, "A phrase whose time has come and gone", Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, December 10, 2002.
  27. ^ Alan Snitow and Deborah Kaufman, BLACKS & JEWS: Facilitator Guide, 1998.
  28. ^ Hendelsaltz, Michael. "Letting the animals live". Haaretz (in Hebrew). Retrieved 2008-08-17. 
  29. ^ Dahan, Alon (2006-12-07). "The history of self-hatred". nfc (in Hebrew). Retrieved 2008-08-17. 
  30. ^ Dahan, Alon (2006-12-13). "Holocaust denial in Israel". nfc (in Hebrew). Retrieved 2008-08-17. 
  31. ^ Zilber, Uzi (25 December 2009). "The Jew Flu: The strange illness of Jewish anti-Semitism". Haaretz. Retrieved 25 December 2009. 

Further reading[edit]

External links[edit]