"She Ain't Right for You" had a planned commercial release in the United Kingdom. However, it was subsequently canceled due to lack of promotion and airplay. In the United States, the single became Gray's fourth consecutive solo single that failed to chart on the Billboard Hot 100. It also failed to chart elsewhere.
The planned CD single was due to contain the album track "My Fondest Childhood Memories" along with an Erick Sermon remix of "She Ain't Right for You".