Shining Through

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
For the Gretchen Espina album, see Shining Through (album). For the Miki Howard song, see Shining Through (song).
Shining Through
Poster of the movie Shining Through.jpg
Directed by David Seltzer
Produced by David Seltzer
Carol Baum
Sandy Gallin
Zvi Howard Rosenman
Screenplay by David Seltzer
Based on Shining Through by Susan Isaacs
Starring Michael Douglas
Melanie Griffith
Liam Neeson
Joely Richardson
John Gielgud
Music by Michael Kamen
Cinematography Jan de Bont
Edited by Craig McKay
Distributed by 20th Century Fox
Release dates January 31, 1992
Running time 133 mins.
Country United Kingdom
United States
Language English
German
Budget $30 million
Box office $43,838,238

Shining Through is a 1992 British-American World War II film drama, directed and written by David Seltzer and starring Michael Douglas and Melanie Griffith, with Liam Neeson, Joely Richardson and John Gielgud in supporting roles. Although based on the novel of the same name by Susan Isaacs, the film's plot and characters are considerably different. The original music score was composed by Michael Kamen. The film's tagline is: "He needed to trust her with his secret. She had to trust him with her life."

Plot[edit]

In 1940, Linda Voss (Melanie Griffith), a young woman of Irish/German Jewish parentage, begins a new job as a secretary with a New York law firm. Because she can speak German fluently, she becomes translator to Ed Leland (Michael Douglas), a humourless attorney, who is referred to as the "pallbearer" by his peers due to his lack of humor. She gradually comes to suspect that he hides dark secrets. She is proved right when, after America officially joins forces with the Allies, he emerges as a colonel in the OSS. She accompanies him to confidential meetings in New York and Washington D.C., and before long, they become lovers. When he is suddenly posted away, she is left alone and devastated.

Assigned to work in the War Department, Linda hears nothing of Ed until he reappears as suddenly as he left. Reluctant to resume their affair, he does re-employ her. He and his colleagues abruptly need to replace a murdered agent in Berlin at very short notice. Despite knowing little about intelligence work — only what she's seen in movies — Linda volunteers and Ed allows himself to be persuaded by her fluent German and passion to contribute to the war effort, not to mention her skills in reproducing German-based dishes, as proven by her banging on his front door in the middle of the night and getting him to taste her "German Kompot". Her mission is to bring back data on the V-1 flying bomb. They travel to Switzerland, where he hands her over to master spy Konrad Friedrichs, codenamed "Sunflower" (John Gielgud). Despite being appalled at her dialect ("the accent of a Berlin butcher's wife!"), he installs her in the basement of his Berlin mansion and introduces her to his niece, Margrete von Eberstein (Joely Richardson), a socialite also working as an Allied agent.

Linda is planted as a cook in the household of a social-climbing Nazi, but her first dinner is a disaster and she is sacked on the spot. She is taken on as a nanny to the children of high-ranking Nazi officer Franz-Otto Dietrich (Liam Neeson), who had been a guest at the dinner. Unable to report back to Ed, she is taken to Dietrich's house and effectively drops out of sight. He brings home confidential documents, so she starts searching for them - intending to photograph them. Contrary to orders, she also attempts to locate her cousins, believed to be hiding in Berlin. With the children in her care, she tracks down her relatives hiding place but is too late. They have already been captured and the cellar is empty. As all hope is lost, raid sirens blare in the city as residents, including her and the children, run through the streets as buildings around them are blown apart by the falling bombs.

The preceding attack causes the frightened children to reveal a hidden room, which Linda finds and secretly photographs Dietrich's top-secret papers. An interesting factual hitch is that when she is doing so, Peenemuende is seen to be located in the Ruhr region of Germany, whereas, in reality, it is located on the northern coast. When Dietrich invites her to the opera the next evening, her cover is blown by Margrete's mother, who believes her to be a friend of her daughter's from college. In desperation, she flees from the Dietrich home and seeks sanctuary with Margrete, only to find to her horror that she is a double agent who has betrayed Linda's cousins and has now also betrayed her. She shoots her, wounding her, but she overpowers Margrete and kills her. Though in pain, she manages to slip down the laundry chute, narrowly escaping the German officers raiding Margrete's apartment.

Badly wounded, Linda is found and rescued by Ed, who has come to Berlin in the guise of a high-ranking German officer. Pretending to be mute, as he does not speak the language, he takes her to the railway station and they travel to the Swiss border. In the film, the border where the train stops is seen on a sign to be the town of "Altstätten," which is, in fact, not a border town, and never has been. She is barely alive and his travel papers are out of date. His bluff fails to sway the border guards, forcing him to shoot his way out. Still carrying her, he struggles towards the border. The German sniper guarding it wounds him twice, but he manages to get himself and Linda across it before collapsing. The sniper is shot by his Swiss counterpart, an act which is justified by the fact that the German border guard was still shooting at Leland after he had crossed into Switzerland.

The film closes with a continuation of the interview of an elderly Linda. It is revealed that while she and Ed recovered from their injuries in a Swiss hospital, the microfilm of the secret German documents has been retrieved from a hiding place inside her glove. She waves to him and their two sons. He joins her on camera as the film ends.

Cast[edit]

Reception[edit]

The film was neither a commercial nor a critical success, although it did ultimately make a profit of $13,838,238 on a budget of $30 million. The Razzie Awards declared Shining Through the Worst Picture of 1992, with Melanie Griffith being voted Worst Actress and David Seltzer for Worst Director. It also received nominations for Michael Douglas as Worst Actor and for Seltzer in the category of Worst Screenplay.[1]

Roger Ebert wrote in the Chicago Sun-Times, "I know it's only a movie, and so perhaps I should be willing to suspend my disbelief, but Shining Through is such an insult to the intelligence that I wasn't able to do that. Here is a film in which scene after scene is so implausible that the movie kept pushing me outside and making me ask how the key scenes could possibly be taken seriously."[2]

Janet Maslin wrote in the New York Times that the first three-quarters of Susan Isaacs' book "never made it to the screen," including Linda Voss's love affair and marriage to her New York law firm boss, John Berringer. "David Seltzer's film version of Shining Through manages to lose also the humor of Susan Isaacs' savvy novel. Even stranger than that is the film's insistence on jettisoning the most enjoyable parts of the story."[3]

It was while working on this film that Melanie Griffith became aware, for the very first time in her life, that Germans had done bad things to Jews during World War II, and she was quite outraged about it. This earned her the nickname "Brainiac" which was used in Toronto-area print media for some time afterward.[4]

The film is listed in Golden Raspberry Award founder John Wilson's book The Official Razzie Movie Guide as one of the The 100 Most Enjoyably Bad Movies Ever Made.[5]

Production[edit]

The production had intended to shoot in Budapest, but the fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989 made it possible to shoot the film on location in East Germany. The majority of the film was shot in Berlin and Potsdam starting in October 1990, just as Germany was being reunified. Studio work was done at the DEFA Studios, the state film studios of East Germany.

Because all of Berlin's great train stations were destroyed in WWII, the production traveled some distance to Leipzig to shoot scenes in the Leipzig Hauptbahnhof terminus, built in 1915 and the largest in Europe. This was prior to its massive modernization by the Deutsche Bahn.

The finale of the film, set at a border crossing and involving a period train, was shot in Klagenfurt, Austria.

The New York and Washington scenes at the beginning of the film were shot in and around London and at nearby Pinewood Studios. Locations included the Old Royal Naval College in Greenwich, Hammersmith, and St Pancras Station, which doubled for Zurich Station for a brief sequence set in Switzerland.

Notes[edit]

  1. ^ Razzie Awards - Archive
  2. ^ Chicago Sun-Times January 31, 1992
  3. ^ New York Times, February 28, 1992
  4. ^ Movie Stars Do the Dumbest Things, Margaret Moser, Renaissance Books, October 1999 - ISBN 978-1-58063-107-5
  5. ^ Wilson, John (2005). The Official Razzie Movie Guide: Enjoying the Best of Hollywood's Worst. Grand Central Publishing. ISBN 0-446-69334-0. 

External links[edit]


Awards
Preceded by
Hudson Hawk
Razzie Award for Worst Picture
13th Golden Raspberry Awards
Succeeded by
Indecent Proposal