A young striker, Arbeitman joined Maccabi Haifa for the 2005–06 season. He regularly plays for the Israeli under-21 national side and has twice played for the senior national team team, scoring a hat-trick against Azerbaijan on his debut in February 2004.
Prior to joining Haifa, he played for Beitar Jerusalem making his debut on March 3, 2003 against Ashdod as an 87th minute substitute.
He also played for Hapoel Petah Tikva to whom he was controversially sold from Beitar, as he was still owned by his youth club Beitar Nes Tubruk, one game into the 2004–05 season. On January 16, 2008 Arbeitman was transferred on loan to Hapoel Tel Aviv until the end of the 2007–08 season.
On December 12, he held the highest "Goals Per Minute" score worldwide for 2010 based on the criteria of imscouting.com, scoring every 64.17 minutes on average.