Silver Dagger (song)
|Song by Joan Baez from the album Joan Baez|
|Joan Baez track listing|
In "Silver Dagger", the narrator turns away a potential suitor, as her mother has warned her to avoid the advances of men in an attempt to spare her daughter the heartbreak that she herself has endured. The 1960 recording by Joan Baez features only a few of the many verses in the 1907 version.
"Katy Dear" uses the same melody but different lyrics, telling a similar story from a different perspective.
|This section needs additional citations for verification. (June 2011)|
"Katie Dear" was brought into country music in the 1930s, recorded by the Callahan Brothers in 1934, and by the Blue Sky Boys in 1938. (Country music authority Bill C. Malone states that the Callahan Brothers learned traditional ballads like "Katie Dear" from their mother). In 1956 it was recorded by the Louvin Brothers. The song was part of the repertoire of the Country Gentlemen, who toured both the bluegrass and folk music circuits during the 1950s and 1960s. In the early 1960s, "Katie Dear" was recorded by folk revival musicians, including Joan Baez, and Ian & Sylvia. Today it is commonly performed and recorded by bluegrass musicians.
The disagreement of the title and some lyrics are a result of the song being handed down through the unwritten, oral tradition for several decades, where each performer would undoubtedly and sometimes unknowingly add their own nuances to the song. However, the melody and events depicted in the song are so similar that most musicologists believe that these two songs trace back to one original source.
Recordings and performances
|This section does not cite any references or sources. (March 2012)|
The song has also been widely performed and recorded by bluegrass musicians, as many songs thought of as traditionally bluegrass songs actually trace back to what is now known as "old-time" music.
- Callahan Brothers, 1934.
- Blue Sky Boys, 1938.
- Tragic Songs of Life, The Louvin Brothers, 1956.
- Joan Baez has been identified with the song, since including it on her 1960 debut album.
- Hootenanny: A Bluegrass Special, The Country Gentlemen, 1963.
- Bluegrass Country, The Country Gentlemen, 1963.
- Four Strong Winds, Ian & Sylvia, 1964.
- "Silver Dagger" also appears on Bob Dylan's The Bootleg Series Vol. 6: Bob Dylan Live 1964, Concert at Philharmonic Hall album, with Baez singing what she refers jokingly to as "one of Bob's earlier songs". Dylan does not sing, but plays acoustic guitar and harmonica in accompaniment.
- The song appears, in the long version, on Dino Valente's (Chet Powers) album, Get Together.
- During their concerts in the early 1970s, The Eagles usually prefaced "Take it Easy" with an a cappella version of four lines from "Silver Dagger", beginning with "My Daddy is a handsome devil..." Glenn Frey, Bernie Leadon and Randy Meisner would harmonise around one microphone at the front of the stage with Don Henley also contributing from behind his drum kit.
- "Silver Dagger" was also recorded from a live performance by Rick Summer Droit and found on the Live at Cousin Andy's CD released in 1995.
- Dolly Parton recorded the song in 1999 for her The Grass Is Blue album.
- Old time revival string band Old Crow Medicine Show has a version of the song on their 2001 album Eutaw.
- Roger Mcguinn, the lead singer and guitarist on many of The Byrds' hits, released a version of the song on the four-CD box set The Folk Den Project 1995-2005.
- Irish-American Celtic group Solas recorded it for their 2006 album Reunion: A Decade of Solas.
- Bluegrass band The Gruff from Victoria, BC, Canada, recorded "Silver Dagger" on their 2006 self-titled album on Goat Tea Records.
- In 2007 it was recorded by Scottish singer Maeve MacKinnon and appeared on her album Don't Sing Love Songs.
- The song has been recorded by White Antelope aka Robin Pecknold of the Seattle band Fleet Foxes.
- This song has also been recorded by Lac La Belle, on their first album, called Lac La Belle, in 2009 (Detroit, USA).
- Jim Moray has recorded a version of this song which is available on his 2010 album In Modern History.
- The song is sung by Marideth Sisco in the 2010 film Winter's Bone.
- English folk trio The Staves often perform the song live. It has been included in their Live at Cecil Sharp House EP (2011).
- In season 5, episode 2 ("Gently with Class") of the British television series Inspector George Gently, the song is performed by Ebony Buckle, who plays the role of singer "Ellen Mallam" in that episode.
- Dame Darcy recorded a quite different version of the song, found on her Greatest Hits album.
- British band Saint Etienne's song "Like a Motorway" is based on the ballad. It was featured on their album Tiger Bay (1994), an homage to folk music presented in a modern style. The melody follows the original closely, but new lyrics paint a darker picture of the suitor's fate.
- Hey Rosetta gave us their own take on this song, which found on her Red Songs EP. The song however, is entitled, "Who Is At My Window Weeping" rather than "Silver Dagger".
- William Gibson in the second book of his Sprawl Trilogy, Count Zero, uses the third stanza of this song to hint at the past of the heroine, Angie Mitchell.
- Come All You Fair and Tender Ladies, another ballad with similar content
- Lyle Lofgren. "Remembering The Old Songs: KATIE DEAR (Laws G21)." 2002-03. Inside Bluegrass. Retrieved 2010-12-15.