Solar updraft tower
||This article's lead section may not adequately summarize key points of its contents. (November 2012)|
The solar updraft tower (SUT) is a renewable-energy power plant for generating electricity from solar power. Sunshine heats the air beneath a very wide greenhouse-like roofed collector structure surrounding the central base of a very tall chimney tower. The resulting convection causes a hot air updraft in the tower by the chimney effect. This airflow drives wind turbines placed in the chimney updraft or around the chimney base to produce electricity. Plans for scaled-up versions of demonstration models will allow significant power generation, and may allow development of other applications, such as water extraction or distillation, and agriculture or horticulture.
As a solar chimney power plant (SCPP) proposal for electrical power generation, commercial investment is discouraged by the high initial cost of building a very large novel structure, and by the risk of investment in a feasible but unproven application of even proven component technology for long-term returns on investment—especially when compared to the proven and demonstrated greater short-term returns on lesser investment in coal-fired or nuclear power plants.
Power output depends primarily on two factors: collector area and chimney height. A larger area collects and warms a greater volume of air to flow up the chimney; collector areas as large as 7 kilometres (4.3 mi) in diameter have been discussed. A larger chimney height increases the pressure difference via the stack effect; chimneys as tall as 1,000 metres (3,281 ft) have been discussed.
Heat can be stored inside the collector area. The ground beneath the solar collector, water in bags or tubes, or a saltwater thermal sink in the collector could add thermal capacity and inertia to the collector. Humidity of the updraft and condensation in the chimney could increase the energy flux of the system.
Turbines with a horizontal axis can be installed in a ring around the base of the tower, as once planned for an Australian project and seen in the diagram above; or—as in the prototype in Spain—a single vertical axis turbine can be installed inside the chimney.
Carbon dioxide is emitted only negligibly as part of operations. Manufacturing and construction require substantial power, particularly to produce cement. Net energy payback is estimated to be 2–3 years.
Since solar collectors occupy significant amounts of land, deserts and other low-value sites are most likely.
A small-scale solar updraft tower may be an attractive option for remote regions in developing countries. The relatively low-tech approach could allow local resources and labour to be used for construction and maintenance.
Locating a tower at high latitudes could produce up to 85 per cent of the output of a similar plant located closer to the equator, if the collection area is sloped significantly toward the equator. The sloped collector field, which also functions as a chimney, is built on suitable mountainsides, with a short vertical chimney on the mountaintop to accommodate the vertical axis air turbine. The results showed that solar chimney power plants at high latitudes may have satisfactory thermal performance.
Solar updraft towers can be combined with other technologies to increase output. Solar thermal collectors or photovoltaics can be arranged inside the collector greenhouse. This could further be combined with agriculture.
In 1903, Isidoro Cabanyes, a colonel in the Spanish army, proposed a solar chimney power plant in the magazine La energía eléctrica. Another early description was published in 1931 by German author Hanns Günther. Beginning in 1975, Robert E. Lucier applied for patents on a solar chimney electric power generator; between 1978 and 1981 patents (since expired) were granted in Australia, Canada, Israel, and the USA.
In 1926 Prof Engineer Bernard Dubos proposed to the French Academy of Sciences the construction of a Solar Aero-Electric Power Plant in North Africa with its solar chimney on the slope of a large mountain. 
In 1982, a small-scale experimental model of a solar draft tower was built in Manzanares, Ciudad Real, 150 km south of Madrid, Spain at . The power plant operated for approximately eight years. The tower's guy-wires were not protected against corrosion and failed due to rust and storm winds. The tower blew over and was decommissioned in 1989.
Inexpensive materials were used in order to evaluate their performance. The solar tower was built of iron plating only 1.25 millimetres (0.049 in) thick under the direction of a German engineer, Jörg Schlaich. The project was funded by the German government.
The chimney had a height of 195 metres (640 ft) and a diameter of 10 metres (33 ft) with a collection area (greenhouse) of 46 hectares (110 acres) and a diameter of 244 metres (801 ft), obtaining a maximum power output of about 50 kW. Various materials were used for testing, such as single or double glazing or plastic (which turned out not to be durable enough). One section was used as an actual greenhouse. During its operation, 180 sensors measured inside and outside temperature, humidity and wind speed data was collected on a second-by-second basis. This experiment setup did not sell energy.
In December 2010, a tower in Jinshawan in Inner Mongolia, China started operation, producing 200 kilowatts. The 1.38 billion RMB (USD 208 million) project was started in May 2009 and intends to cover 277 hectares (680 acres) and produce 27.5 MW by 2013. The greenhouse is expected to improve the climate by covering loose sand, restraining sandstorms.
A proposal to construct a solar updraft tower in Fuente el Fresno, Ciudad Real, Spain, entitled Ciudad Real Torre Solar would be the first of its kind in the European Union and would stand 750 metres (2,460 ft) tall – nearly twice as tall as the continent's tallest structure, the Belmont TV Mast – covering an area of 350 hectares (860 acres). It is expected to produce 40 MW.
In 2001, EnviroMission proposed to build a solar updraft tower power generating plant known as Solar Tower Buronga near Buronga, New South Wales. The company did not complete the project. They have plans for a similar plant in Arizona, and most recently (December 2013) in Texas, but there is no sign of 'breaking ground' in any of Enviromission's proposals.
In December 2011, Hyperion Energy, controlled by Western Australians Tony Sage and Dallas Dempster, was reported to be planning to build a 1-km-tall solar updraft tower near Meekatharra to supply power to Mid-West mining projects.
Based on the need for plans for long-term energy strategies, Botswana's Ministry of Science and Technology designed and built a small-scale research tower. This experiment ran from 7 October to 22 November 2005. It had an inside diameter of 2 metres (6.6 ft) and a height of 22 metres (72 ft), manufactured from glass-reinforced polyester, with an area of approximately 160 square metres (1,700 sq ft). The roof was made of a 5 mm thick clear glass supported by a steel framework.
In mid-2008, the Namibian government approved a proposal for the construction of a 400 MW solar chimney called the 'Greentower'. The tower is planned to be 1.5 kilometres (4,900 ft) tall and 280 metres (920 ft) in diameter, and the base will consist of a 37 square kilometres (14 sq mi) greenhouse in which cash crops can be grown.
A grade-school pupil's home do-it-yourself SUT demonstration for a school science fair was constructed and studied in 2012, in a suburban Connecticut setting. With a 7 metre stack and 100 square metre collector, this generated a daily average 6.34 mW, from a computer fan as a turbine. Insolation and wind were the major factors on variance (range from 0.12 to 21.78 mW) in output.
A comprehensive review of theoretical and experimental aspects of the solar updraft tower power plant (SUTPP) development is available, with a recommendation for commercial development.
An inflatable solar chimney power plant has been evaluated analytically and simulated by CFD analysis-finite volume method. This idea has been registered as a patent, including the optimal shape of the collector and the analytical profile for the self standing inflatable tower. The CFD simulation has been evaluated by VVUQ standard per ASME 2009 standards.
The solar updraft tower has a power conversion rate considerably lower than many other designs in the (high temperature) solar thermal group of collectors. The low conversion rate is balanced to some extent by the lower cost per square metre of solar collection.
Model calculations estimate that a 100 MW plant would require a 1,000 m tower and a greenhouse of 20 square kilometres (7.7 sq mi). A 200 MW tower with the same tower would require a collector 7 kilometres in diameter (total area of about 38 km²). One 200MW power station will provide enough electricity for around 200,000 typical households and will abate over 900,000 tons of greenhouse producing gases from entering the environment annually. The collector area is expected to extract about 0.5 percent, or 5 W/m² of 1 kW/m², of the solar energy that falls upon it. Concentrating thermal (CSP) or photovoltaic (CPV) solar power plants range between 20% to 31.25% efficiency (dish Stirling). Overall CSP/CPV efficiency is reduced because collectors do not cover the entire footprint. Without further tests, the accuracy of these calculations is uncertain. Most of the projections of efficiency, costs and yields are calculated theoretically, rather than empirically derived from demonstrations, and are seen in comparison with other collector or solar heat transducing technologies.
The performance of an updraft tower may be degraded by factors such as atmospheric winds, by drag induced by the bracings used for supporting the chimney, and by reflection off the top of the greenhouse canopy.
Related ideas and adaptations
- The atmospheric vortex proposal replaces the physical chimney by a controlled or 'anchored' cyclonic updraft vortex. Depending on the column gradient of temperature and pressure, or buoyancy, and stability of the vortex, very high-altitude updraft may be achievable. As an alternate to a solar collector, industrial and urban waste-heat could be used to initiate and sustain the updraft in the vortex.
- Telescopic or retractable design may lower a very high chimney for maintenance, or to prevent storm damage. Hot-air balloon chimney suspension has also been proposed.
- A saltwater thermal sink in the collector could 'flatten' the diurnal variation in energy output, while airflow humidification in the collector and condensation in the updraft could increase the energy flux of the system.
- Release of humid ground-level air from an atmospheric vortex or solar chimney at altitude could form clouds or precipitation, potentially altering local hydrology. Local de-desertification, or afforestation could be achieved if a regional water cycle were established and sustained in an otherwise arid area.
- The solar cyclone distiller could extract atmospheric water by condensation in the updraft of the chimney. This solar cyclonic water distiller with a solar collector pond could adapt the solar collector-chimney system for large-scale desalination of collected brine, brackish- or waste-water pooled in the collector base.
- Fitted with a vortex chimney scrubber, the updraft could be cleaned of particulate air pollution. Alternately, particulate air pollution caught in the updraft could serve as a nucleation stimulus for precipitation either in the chimney, or at release altitude as cloud seeds.
- A form of solar boiler technology placed directly above the turbine at the base of the tower might increase the up-draught.
- If the chimney updraft is an ionized vortex, then the electro-magnetic field could be tapped for electricity, using the airflow and chimney as a generator.
- Energy production, water desalination or simple atmospheric water extraction could be used to support carbon-fixing or food-producing local agriculture, and for intensive aquaculture and horticulture under the solar collector as a greenhouse.
- Moreno (2006) teaches in U.S. Patent #7,026,723 that a chimney can be economically placed on a hill or mountain slope. Klinkman (2014) in U.S. Patent #8,823,197  elaborates on constructing diagonal chimneys. A structure as simply built as a high hoop tunnel, but much longer in length and on a slope, can permanently generate an airflow for producing electricity. Changing the chimney's height differential from 200m (the Manzanares experiment) to 2000m (Charleston Peak in Nevada has a rise of over 2500m, for example) will transfer a factor of ten more of captured solar heat into electric power. Increasing the temperature differential between chimney air and outside air by a factor of ten increases the same chimney's power by one further factor of ten, assuming that the chimney's walls are engineered to take the extra heat. Concentrating solar heat is often done with reflection.
A solar updraft power station would require a large initial capital outlay, but would have relatively low operating cost.
Capital outlays would be roughly the same as next-generation nuclear plants such as the AP-1000 at roughly $5 per Watt of capacity. As with other renewable power sources, towers have no need for fuel. Overall costs are largely determined by interest rates and years of operation, varying from 5 eurocent per kWh for 4% and 20 years to 15 eurocent per kWh for 12% and 40 years.
Estimates of total costs range from 7 (for a 200 MW plant) and 21 (for a 5 MW plant) euro cents per kWh to 25–35 cents per kWh. Levelized cost are approximately 3 Euro cents per KWh for a 100 MW wind or natural gas plant. No actual data are available for a utility scale power plant.
As with other solar technologies, some mechanism is required to mix its varying power output with other power sources. Heat can be stored in heat-absorbing material or saltwater ponds. Electricity can be cached in batteries or other technologies.
- Martin Kaltschmitt, Wolfgang Streicher, Andreas Wiese, ed. (2007). Renewable energy technology, economics, and environment. Berlin: Springer. p. 223. ISBN 9783540709497.
- "Solar pond tower for 5 €ct/kWh". GreenIdeaLive. Retrieved 2011-09-11.
- Schlaich J, Bergermann R, Schiel W, Weinrebe G (2005). "Design of Commercial Solar Updraft Tower Systems—Utilization of Solar Induced Convective Flows for Power Generation" (PDF). Journal of Solar Energy Engineering 127 (1): 117–124. doi:10.1115/1.1823493.
- Onyangoa FN, Ochieng RM (0000). "The potential of solar chimney for application in rural areas of developing countries". Fuel 00 (0): 000–000. doi:10.1016/j.fuel.2006.04.029. Check date values in:
- Dai YJ, Huang HB, Wang RZ (2003). "Case study of solar chimney power plants in Northwestern regions of China". Renewable Energy 28 (8): 1295–1304. doi:10.1016/S0960-1481(02)00227-6.
- Bilgen E, Rheault J (2005). "Solar chimney power plants for high latitudes". Solar Energy 79 (5): 449–458. doi:10.1016/j.solener.2005.01.003.
- Lorenzo. "Las chimeneas solares:De una propuesta española en 1903 a la Central de Manzanares" (PDF) (in Spanish). De Los Archivos Históricos De La Energía Solar.
- Günther, Hanns (1931). In hundert Jahren — Die künftige Energieversorgung der Welt. Stuttgart: Kosmos, Gesellschaft der Naturfreunde.
- AU 499934B , "Apparatus for converting Solar to Electrical Energy"
- CA 1023564 , "Utilization of Solar Energy"
- IL 50721 , "System and Apparatus for Converting Solar Heat to Electrical Energy"
- US 4275309 , "System for converting solar heat to electrical energy"
- Christos D. Papageorgiou. "Floating Solar Chimney Technology" (PDF). Retrieved 2012-03-30.
- US 7026723 , "Air filtering chimney to clean pollution from a city and generate electric power"
- "Solar Chimney Manzanares". Sbp.de. 2011-08-19. Retrieved 2011-09-11.
- Mills D (2004). "Advances in solar thermal electricity technology". Solar Energy 76 (1–3): 19–31. doi:10.1016/S0038-092X(03)00102-6.
- Haaf W, Friedrich K, Mayr G, Schlaich J (1983). "Solar Chimneys. Part 1: Principle and Construction of the Pilot Plant in Manzanares". International Journal of Solar Energy 2 (1): 3–20. doi:10.1080/01425918308909911.
- Haaf W (1984). "Solar Chimneys — Part II: Preliminary Test Results from the Manzanares Pilot Plant". International Journal of Solar Energy 2 (2): 141–161. doi:10.1080/01425918408909921.
- Schlaich J, Schiel W (2001), "Solar Chimneys", in RA Meyers (ed), Encyclopedia of Physical Science and Technology, 3rd Edition, Academic Press, London. ISBN 0-12-227410-5 PDF (180 KB)
- "China's first solar chimney plant starts operating in desert". Gov.cn. 2010-12-28. Retrieved 2011-09-11.
- www.margotweb.net (2010-09-30). "NEW about solar chimney power plants". Solar-chimney.biz. Retrieved 2011-09-11.
- "Xianha: China's first solar chimney plant starts operating in desert". News.xinhuanet.com. 2010-12-27. Retrieved 2011-09-11.
- Muñoz-Lacuna, J.V. (13 February 2006). "Ciudad Real tendrá una torre solar que doblará en alturaa las Torres Gemelas". lasprovincias.es (in Spanish). Retrieved 26 March 2007.
- "Ciudad Real Torre Solar, Ciudad Real - SkyscraperPage.com". SkyscraperPage.com. 2007. Retrieved 27 July 2014.
- "Belmont Transmitter". A.T.V (Aerials and Television). Retrieved 26 March 2007.
- Plaza, Julio (28 February 2006). "La Torre Solar". HispaLibertas (in Spanish). Archived from the original on 27 April 2007. Retrieved 26 March 2007.
- "Torre Solar de 750 metros en Ciudad Real". Urbanity.es (in Spanish). 13 February 2006. Retrieved 27 March 2007.
- Davey, R (6 August 2001). "New Green energy technology launches". Australian Securities Exchange. Archived from the original on 26 September 2007. Retrieved 31 March 2007.
- Woody, Todd (2 October 2006). "Tower of Power". CNN. Retrieved 9 March 2007.
- "ENVIROMISSION Operational Overview" (PDF). EnviroMission Limited. July 1 – December 31, 2010. Retrieved 2012-03-30.
- Evans, Nick (31 December 2011). "Dallas Dempster's sky-high comeback". The Sunday Times.
- Ketlogetswe, C (21 February 2007). "Solar chimney power generation project—The case for Botswana". Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews. Retrieved 17 October 2008.
- Cloete, R (25 July 2008). "Solar tower sheds light on little-used technology". Engineering News Online. Retrieved 17 October 2008.
- "solar chimney http://www.unienerji.com". YouTube. 2010-08-21. Retrieved 2011-09-11.
- "Güneş Santrali | Güneş Pili". Unienerji.com. Retrieved 2011-09-11.
- Koyun A, Üçgül İ, Acar M, Şenol R (2007). "Güneş Bacası Sisteminin Termal Özet Dizaynı". Tesisat Mühendisliği Dergisi 98: 45–50.
- St Rose Student Creates Solar Updraft Tower | The Newtown Bee
- A Model Solar Updraft Tower Power Plant | Connecticut's Extreme Weather News | WXedge.com
- Putkaradze, Vakhtang, Peter Vorobieff, Andrea Mammoli, and Nima Fathi. "Inflatable free-standing flexible solar towers." Solar Energy 98 (2013): 85-98.
- PDF (1.24 MB) Status Report on Solar Trough Power Plants (1996)
- Trieb, Franz; Ole Langniß and Helmut Klaiß (January 1997). "Solar electricity generation—A comparative view of technologies, costs and environmental impact" (PDF). Solar Energy 59 (1–3): 89–99. doi:10.1016/S0038-092X(97)80946-2. Archived from the original on 15 June 2007. Retrieved 30 March 2007.
- Pretorius JP, Kröger DG (2006). "Critical evaluation of solar chimney power plant performance". Solar Energy 80 (5): 535–544. doi:10.1016/j.solener.2005.04.001.
- Norton, Brian (2013). Harnessing Solar Heat. Springer. ISBN 978-94-007-7274-8.
- Serag-Eldin MA (2004). "Computing flow in a solar chimney plant subject to atmospheric winds". Proceedings of the ASME Heat Transfer/Fluids Engineering Summer Conference 2004. 2 B: 1153–1162.
- El-Haroun AA (2002). "The effect of wind speed at the top of the tower on the performance and energy generated from thermosyphon solar turbine". International Journal of Solar Energy 22 (1): 9–18. doi:10.1080/01425910212851.
- von Backström TW (2003). "Calculation of Pressure and Density in Solar Power Plant Chimneys". Journal of Solar Energy Engineering 125 (1): 127–129. doi:10.1115/1.1530198.
- "Atmospheric Vortex Engine". Vortexengine.ca. Retrieved 2011-09-11.
- Zhou, X.; Yangb, J.; Ochiengc, R.M.; Lib, X.; Xiaob, Bo (2009). "Numerical investigation of a plume from a power generating solar chimney in an atmospheric cross ﬂow". Atmospheric Research 91 (1): 26–35. doi:10.1016/j.atmosres.2008.05.003.
Niewiadomski, M.; Haman, K.E. (1984). "The rainfall enhancement by washout of cooling tower plumes: A numerical experiment". Atmospheric Environment 18 (11): 2483–9. doi:10.1016/0004-6981(84)90019-2.
"Cloud Formation in the Plumes of Solar Chimney Power Generation Facilities: A Modeling Study". J. Sol. Energy Eng. 131 (1): 011009. February 2009. doi:10.1115/1.3028041.
- Kashiwa BA, Kashiwa CB; Kashiwa, C (2008). "The solar cyclone: A solar chimney for harvesting atmospheric water". Energy 33 (2): 331–339. doi:10.1016/j.energy.2007.06.003.
- Zhou, X.; Xiao, B.; Liu, W.; Guo, X.; Yang, J.; Fan, J. (2010). "Comparison of classical solar chimney power system and combined solar chimney system for power generation and seawater desalination". Desalination 250 (1): 249–256. doi:10.1016/j.desal.2009.03.007.
- Cloud condensation nuclei
- Tom Bosschaert (2008-09-26). "Solar Updraft Tower Research: Except Consulting". Except.nl. Retrieved 2011-09-11.
- "The Solar Chimney" by Jörg Schlaich, 1995
- ^ Zaslavsky, Dan (2006). "Energy Towers". PhysicaPlus — Online magazine of the Israel Physical Society (Israel Physical Society) (7). Retrieved 30 March 2007.
- Levelized Costs of Electricity Production by Technology California Energy Commission, 2003
- Groenendaal, B.J. (July 2002). "Solar Thermal Power Technologies" (PDF). Monograph in the framework of the VLEEM Project. Energy research Centre of the Netherlands: ECN. Retrieved 30 March 2007.
- "Integration of Wind Energy into the Grid". European Wind Energy Association — EWEA. 2005–2007. Retrieved 29 May 2007.
- Schlaich Bergermann Solar
- Hyperion project, Western Australia
- video link Spanish solar updraft tower
- video link Australian tower proposal
- video link Solar Updraft Tower — a small model with various substrates
- The Floating Solar Chimney Technology
- Solar Nozzle
- CNN money article 2006-10-26
- Mildura Solar Tower at Structurae
- University of Stellenbosch study
- U.S. Department of Energy's Solar Energy Technologies program
- Atmospheric Vortex alternative to Solar Chimney
- 2nd International Conference on Solar Chimney Power Technology
- 3rd International Conference on Solar Updraft Tower Power Technology