The tracks "Sidekick", and "Don't Get Mad" were produced by The Package and Mr. Collipark, while "Soulja Girl" was produced by Los Vegaz, and Mr. Collipark. "Pass it to Arab" features, and produced by Arab, and the remaining tracks were produced by Soulja Boy himself. The tracks "Bapes", and "Booty Meat" are both from his original album, Unsigned & Still Major: Da Album Before da Album.
According to website aggregator Metacritic, souljaboytellem.com received mixed reviews from critics. The most positive reviews came from Robert Christgau (an A-) and Allmusic's mildly favorable 3.5 (out of 5) star review. Negative reviews came from Entertainment Weekly, which called the album a "teenage wasteland filled with monotonously looped chants and agonizing blunt-force beats."Entertainment Weekly reviewer Chris Willman ranked the album #1 on his list of the worst albums of 2007. Sputnikmusic gave the album one star out of 5. The popular music site Rate Your Music lists it among the worst full length albums of all time with a rating of 0.78 after 450 ratings. The user score on Metacritic, 0.6 is the worst on the site as of Feb 2011.
souljaboytellem.com debuted at number four on the US Billboard 200 chart with 117,000 copies sold in the first week. The album has since sold 949,000 copies in the US according to Nielsen Soundscan.