St. Matthew's Churches
St. Matthew's Churches, formerly St. Matthew Publishing Inc., is an evangelical Christian ministry. It is primarily a mail-based ministry with an address in Tulsa, Oklahoma, with churches in New York and Houston. In 1999 St. Matthew Publishing Inc. reported $26.8 million in revenue. In 2007, it reportedly earned $6 million a month.
The ministry is led by its founder James Eugene "Gene" Ewing, a former tent minister, who, according to the Trinity Foundation, lives in Beverly Hills, California. Ewing, a native of Kaufman, Texas, was born in 1933 and has written fundraising letters for other evangelists, including Oral Roberts as well as Don Stewart, WV Grant, and Rex Humbard.
Ewing operates Church by Mail Inc., which had a several decade long struggle with the IRS before being denied tax-exemption in 1992, which was appealed. Ewing was a revivalist in the 1960s with revenue at $2 million. He then began writing fundraising letters for Oral Roberts. By 1971 Ewing renamed organization Church of Compassion as a "mail-order church with half a million 'members'" with income exceeding $3 million. In 1979 he started for-profit advertising and printing "to provide printing and mailing services to nonprofit religious groups." Then in 1980 his business Church by Mail applied for tax-exemption. However, by the 1990s his businesses owed back taxes to state and federal agencies. Nonetheless, in 1993 he bought a $2.2 million, 6,400-square-foot (590 m2) home above Beverly Hills. Subsequently, a year later the U.S. Tax Court ruled Church by Mail Inc. is "operated for private rather than public interests" and "is not a church" within the meaning of federal tax laws.
Operations and fundraising
The ministry has been accused of preying on low-income and elderly people by using census records to target their mailings.
Although for several years the ministry operated without a church building and conducted its direct mail donation operation through the Tulsa address, a physical location to hold services—a then-78-year-old Baptist church in a predominantly Hispanic neighborhood—was purchased in Houston in 2004. St. Matthew's Churches' lawyer says weekly services draw about 1,000 people. According to the Trinity Foundation, an evangelical watchdog group, the physical churches are only associated with the mail-based ministry as a cover that allows the lucrative operation to retain tax-exempt church status. The status was granted by the Internal Revenue Service in 2000 after a 17-year court battle.
One of the organization's mailings consists of a paper "prayer rug", on which recipients were encouraged to kneel and pray. This mailing, along with others, have been mentioned by the Attorney General of the State of Arkansas, among others, as not providing information about their financial and fundraising practices. While the ministry does hold tax exemption status under section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code, it has been the subject of numerous complaints to the Better Business Bureau, whose evaluation conclusion was that the organization did not meet two standards for Charity Accountability.
- "Reaping from faith: Lucrative 'seed faith' mail ministry has Tulsa ties". Tulsa World. April 27, 2003. Retrieved 2007-05-17.
- Bransetter, Zita (2007-05-13). "Prayers, cash flow into Tulsa". Tulsa World.
- Salinger, Lawrence M. Encyclopedia of White-collar & Corporate Crime. p. 681.
- Malisow, Craig (2007-03-22). "Christians send in money for prayer requests which may just go up in smoke". Houston Press.
- Swindle, Howard (March 10, 1996). "Mailbox ministry: Direct-market evangelist brings in millions lawyer says it all goes back into his mission". Dallas Morning News. Retrieved 2007-05-17.
- Klimkiewicz, Joann (2006-05-31). "Watchdog group claims prayer rug preys on elderly". Chicago Tribune. Retrieved 2013-08-22.
- Trinity Foundation. Prayer rug to riches
- McDaniel, Dustin (2007-05-25). "Prayer Rug Pitch Wears Thin". State of Arkansas.
- State of South Carolina. Fraud Alert Task Force. Published March 21, 2005.
- Better Business Bureau Wise Giving Guide – St. Matthew's Churches. Published April 2004.