Alex Henderson of Allmusic gave the album a 3.5 out of 5. He suggested that casual listeners "start out with Stay Hungry, not Still Hungry," but added: "for collectors and hardcore fans, Still Hungry paints an enjoyable, interesting picture of the sound that [Dee] Snider and friends originally had in mind for their most famous album."
The album contains seven bonus tracks: Two lost tracks, "Never Say Never" and "Blastin' Fast & Loud", from the original 1984 sessions. Another four, "Come Back", "Plastic Money", "You Know I Cry" and "Rock N Roll Saviors" are brand new 2004 studio tracks. Finally, "Heroes Are Hard To Find" was originally recorded and released in 1998 by the reunited band for the soundtrack of Snider's "Strangeland" movie, written and starring Dee Snider, and based on the character "Captain Howdy" From Horror-Teria (Track 4)