A structure editor, also structured editor or projectional editor, is any document editor that is cognizant of the document’s underlying structure. Structure editors can be used to edit hierarchical or marked up text, computer programs, diagrams, chemical formulas, and any other type of content with clear and well-defined structure. In contrast, a text editor is any document editor used for editing plain text files.
Typically, the benefits of text and structure editing are combined in the user interface of a single hybrid tool. For example, Emacs is fundamentally a text editor, but supports the manipulation of words, sentences, and paragraphs as structures that are inferred from the text. Conversely, Dreamweaver is fundamentally a structure editor for marked up web documents, but supports the display and manipulation of raw HTML text as well. Similarly, molecule editors typically support both graphical and textual input. Structure editing predominates when content is graphical and textual representations are awkward, e.g., CAD systems and PowerPoint. Text editing predominates when content is largely devoid of structure, e.g., text fields in web forms. WYSIWYG word processing systems such as Word, which appear to edit formatted text directly, are essentially structure editors for the underlying marked-up text.
In linguistics, syntax is the study of the structure of grammatical utterances, and accordingly syntax-directed editor is a synonym for structure editor. Language-based editor and language-sensitive editor are also synonyms. A language-based editor’s features may be implemented by ad hoc code or by a formal grammar. For example, language sensitivity in Emacs is implemented in the Lisp definition of the edit mode for the given language. In contrast, language sensitivity in an XML editor is driven by a formal DTD schema for the given language.
Structure editing has often been employed in source code editors. Each programming language typically has a well-defined syntax given by a context-free grammar, and accordingly the meaningful structural elements in source code written in the language correspond to the grammatical phrases in the text. Early syntax-directed source code editors included Interlisp-D (for Lisp’s limited syntax) and Emily (for PL/I’s rich syntax).
A syntax-directed editor may treat grammar rules as generative (e.g., offering the user templates that correspond to one or more steps in a formal derivation of program text) or proscriptive (e.g., preventing a phrase of a given part of speech from being moved to a context where another part of speech is required) or analytic (e.g., parsing textual edits to create a structured representation). Structure editing features in source code editors make it harder to write programs with invalid syntax. Language-sensitive editors may impose syntactic correctness as an absolute requirement (e.g., as did Mentor), or may tolerate syntax errors after issuing a warning (e.g., as did the Cornell Program Synthesizer). Strict structured editors often make it difficult to perform edits that are easy to perform with plain text editors, which is one of the factors contributing to the lack of adoption of structured editing in some domains, such as source code editing.
Some syntax-directed editors monitor compliance with the context-sensitive constraints of a language such as type correctness. Such static-semantic constraints may be specified imperatively by actions (e.g., as in Gandalf), or declaratively by an attribute grammar (e.g., as in the Synthesizer Generator) or by unification in a many-sorted algebra (e.g., as in PSG ) or a logic program (e.g., as in Centaur and Pan), with compliance checked by the underlying editing machinery. Structured editors vary in the degree to which they allow its users to perform edits that cause the document to become syntactically or semantically incorrect.
It is common for a language sensitive editor to represent a document as a parse tree with respect to language’s grammar, or as an abstract syntax tree (AST). For example, a DOM tree is essentially an AST with respect to a given DTD. Frequently, the textual view of that underlying tree is generated by prettyprinting the underlying tree. Editors associated with intentional programming and language-oriented programming for general-purpose languages and domain-specific languages share many of the features of language-sensitive editors, but aim for greater separation between the underlying representation (the intention) and the surface representation (text in a programming language).
Although structured editors allow the viewing and manipulation of the underlying document in a structured manner, the file format in which the document is stored on disk may or may not be heavily structured and may or may not be open or standardized (e.g., plain text versus Microsoft Word documents).
- Hansen, Wilfred J. (1971). "User engineering principles for interactive systems". Proceedings of the Fall Joint Computer Conference FJCC 39. AFIPS. pp. 5623–532.
- Donzeau Gouge, V.; Huet, G., Kahn, G., and Lang, B. (July, 1980). "Programming environments based on structured editors: The Mentor experience". INRIA Research report no. 26.
- Teitelbaum, T.; T. Reps (September, 1981). "The Cornell Program Synthesizer: A syntax-directed programming environment". Communications of the ACM 24 (9): 563–573. doi:10.1145/358746.358755.
- Habermann, A. Nico; Notkin, David (1986). "Gandalf: Software Development Environments". IEEE Trans. Software Eng. 12 12 (12): 1117–1127.
- Medina Mora, Raul (1982). Syntax-directed editing--towards integrating programming environments. Pittsburgh, PA: Carnegie Mellon University (PhD Dissertation).
- Kaiser, Gail Elaine (1985). Semantics for structure editing environments. Pittsburgh, PA: Carnegie Mellon University (PhD Dissertation).
- Reps, T. (1984). Generating Language-Based Environments. Cambridge, MA: The M.I.T. Press. (Awarded the 1983 ACM Doctoral Dissertation Award.).
- Reps, Thomas W., and Teitelbaum, Tim (1988). The Synthesizer Generator: A System for Constructing Language-Based Editors. Cambridge, MA: Springer-Verlag.
- Snelting, Gregor; Henhapl, Wolfgang (1986). "Unification in many-sorted algebras as a device for incremental semantic analysis". Proceedings of the 13th ACM SIGACT-SIGPLAN symposium on Principles of programming languages (POPL). New York, NY: ACM Press. pp. 229–235.
- Borras, P.; Clement, D., Despeyrouz, Th., Incerpi, J., Kahn, G., Lang, B., and Pascual, V. (1989). "CENTAUR: The System". "Proceedings of the ACM SIGSOFT/SIGPLAN Software Engineering Symposium on Practical Software Development Environments (PSDE) 24. New York, NY: ACM Press. pp. 14–24.
- Ballance, Robert A.; Graham, Susan L. and Van De Vanter, Michael L. (1990). "Pan language-based editing system for integrated development". SDE 4: Proceedings of the fourth ACM SIGSOFT symposium on Software development environments. Irvine, CA: ACM Press. pp. 77–93.
- Czarnecki, Krzysztof and Eisenecker, Ulrich (June 2000). Generative Programming: Methods, Tools, and Applications, Chapter 11 (Intentional Programming). Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
- "Hierarchical structure editor for web sites", Samir Arora et al.; Patent number: 5911145. Filing date: Jul 29, 1996. Issue date: Jun 8, 1999.
- Designing, implementing and integrating a structured C# code editor
- Research in structured editors
- The graPHIGS Programming Interface: Understanding Concepts
- Lava programming language and environment
- Barista, a structured editor created by the Carnegie Mellon University's Natural Programming Project
- Alice, a structured editor provided to colleges and universities by Carnegie Mellon University
- Code Views, a structured editor for Java by Reality Interactive
- Code Processor (also known as Program Editor Architecture), a structured editor for Java by Michael L. Van De Vanter and Marat Boshernitsan
- Visual Functional Programming Environment (VFPE), a PhD thesis by Joel Kelso that makes use of structured editors
- "Structure editors, IDEs, and another Lisp flashback", an opinion piece by Preston L. Bannister on structured editing
- "Exploring the deep structure of code", an article by Jon Udell on structured editing in Java with the Eclipse IDE
- "On the Usefulness of Syntax Directed Editors", a paper by Bernard Lang on the benefits and drawbacks of structured editing using INRIA's Mentor system
- Martin Fowler: Language Workbenches
- JetBrains MPS, a language oriented programming environment that makes use of structured editors
- Language oriented programming
- Structured editor presentations and publications by Lutz Roeder
- Whidbey may miss the next coding revolution