Swan by-election, 1918
The 1918 Swan by-election was a by-election for the Division of Swan in the Australian House of Representatives, following the death of the sitting member Sir John Forrest. Held on 26 October 1918, the by-election not only led to the election of, what was until 2010, the youngest person ever to be elected to the Parliament of Australia, Edwin Corboy, but also saw the conservative vote split between the Country Party and the Nationalist Party, directly prompting the introduction of preferential voting in Australia.
On 6 February 1918, Forrest was offered a place in the British peerage (he was to be created Baron Forrest of Bunbury), though the relevant letters patent had not at the time been issued. Forrest set out for England to accept the offer and take up his place in the House of Lords, but he died en route on 2 September 1918, off the coast of Sierra Leone, from cancer. Thus, a by-election was called to replace Forrest as the representative for Swan.
Electoral system and political parties in Australia
By 1909, Australia had evolved a two-party system at the federal level, with the conservative Commonwealth Liberal Party and the progressive Australian Labor Party having both alternately won power via general election. This system was upset in November 1916, when the Labor party split over the issue of conscription; Prime Minister Billy Hughes and his pro-conscription supporters left the Labor party and formed a minority government as the "National Labor Party", before merging with the Liberals in February 1917 to form the Nationalist Party of Australia with Hughes as their leader.
However, Hughes was distrusted by some on the conservative side of politics for his past involvement in socialist politics as Labor leader, and disaffected conservative farmers were moved to support the new Country Party, which had been formed in Western Australia in 1913 (and would be formed federally in 1922 from an amalgamation of state-based parties).
At the time of the 1918 Swan by-election, Australia used a first past the post voting system, as was used in the United Kingdom, in all elections at the federal level. Under this system, the winner was simply the candidate with the highest numerical total of votes, regardless of whether it was a majority.
The by-election was the first of what have come to be known in Australia as "three-cornered contests" with two anti-Labor parties both running candidates against Labor. The Nationalist candidate was William Hedges; Basil Murray was the Country Party candidate; Edwin Corboy was the Labor candidate, with William Watson standing as an independent candidate. Hedges was previously a member of the House of Representatives for the Division of Fremantle, from 1906 to 1913. Forrest had won Swan in the previous election unopposed.
In the end, the Nationalist and Country candidates split the anti-Labor vote, Hedges achieving 29.6% and Murray gathering 31.4% of the total; however, both were beaten by the Labor candidate Corboy, who received 34.4% of the total vote. Corboy was duly elected as the member for Swan.
|Swan by-election, 1918|
|Farmers and Settlers||Basil Murray||5,975||31.4||N/A|
|Labor gain from Nationalist||Swing||N/A|
Corboy, who at the time of the by-election was just twenty-two years and two months old, remained the youngest person ever to be elected to either house of the Parliament of Australia, until the 2010 election when 20-year-old Wyatt Roy was elected as a member of the Liberal National Party of Queensland to the seat of Longman.
Shocked by the loss of a previously safe Nationalist seat to Labor, the Nationalist government was moved to initiate electoral reform and replace the first past the post system with preferential voting (also known outside of Australia as instant-runoff voting), as part of a rewrite of the electoral legislation with the Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918. While preferential voting had already been introduced at the state level in Western Australia (1907) and Victoria (1911) and had been considered at the federal level by Sir Joseph Cook's government (1913–1914), it was only these "considerations of partisan advantage [and not] the finer points of electoral theory" which provided the impetus for the change.
Preferential voting was first put to use in the Corangamite by-election for the Victorian seat of Corangamite two months later, where Labor candidate and future Prime Minister James Scullin topped the primary vote, only to be defeated after distribution of preferences by William Gibson of the Victorian Farmers Union. The preferential voting system remains in place to this day and has helped to support a fairly stable three-party system, albeit with the anti-Labor parties (presently the Liberal Party of Australia and the National Party of Australia) regularly forming coalition governments.
At the 1919 election, Corboy once again polled the highest percentage at the first count, with two conservative candidates again splitting the conservative vote; however with the introduction of preferential voting, Corboy was easily defeated by John Prowse of the Farmers and Settlers Association on preferences.
In a twist of fate William Watson, who finished a distant fourth in this by-election with just 4.6% of the vote, was elected to the House of Representatives for the Division of Fremantle at the 1922 election on the back of preferences from Nationalist candidate William Hedges, the same man who had also contested this by-election, and who had previously been the member for Fremantle.
- Green, Antony (2004). "History of Preferential Voting in Australia". Antony Green Election Guide: Federal Election 2004. Australian Broadcasting Corporation. Retrieved 2007-07-01.
- Black, David (2006). "William Hedges". The Federal Electorate of Fremantle: A history since 1901. John Curtin Prime Ministerial Library. Retrieved 2007-07-01.
- Carr, Adam. "BY-ELECTIONS 1917-19" (text file). Adam Carr's Election Archive. Retrieved 2007-07-01.
- Carr, Adam. "RECORDS AND MISCELLANEOUS FACTS" (text file). Adam Carr's Election Archive. Retrieved 2007-07-01.
- Lundie, Rob & Lumb, Martin (1999-02-09). "Update on Selected Australian Political Records". Parliamentary Library. Parliament of Australia. Retrieved 2007-07-01.
- "A Short History of Federal Election Reform in Australia". Australian electoral history. Australian Electoral Commission. 2007-06-08. Retrieved 2007-07-01.
- Reilly, Benjamin (2001). Democracy in Divided Societies: Electoral Engineering for Conflict Management. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. p. 36. 2007-07-01.
- Carr, Adam. "LEGISLATIVE ELECTION OF 13 DECEMBER 1919: VOTING BY CONSTITUENCY: WESTERN AUSTRALIA" (text file). Adam Carr's Election Archive. Retrieved 2007-07-01.
- Black, David (2006). "William Watson". The Federal Electorate of Fremantle: A history since 1901. John Curtin Prime Ministerial Library. Retrieved 2007-07-01.