Talk:War poet

Untitled

Charles, I'm afraid that I disagree with you. Mr Steadman just isn't notable enough to appear on this page. You just can't compare` For genre of writing so significant as war poetr, this article is a complete joke. It is badly written, inaccurate and ambiguous in almost every detail it gives. For example it gives an entire category to the Spanish Civil War, yet contributes not one example of war poetry from that war, and where is the citation for the claim that war poetry has declined since then.--Nwe 15:13, 31 July 2006 (UTC)

Vandalism?

Look at the World War I section and read it. Am I blind or does anyone else see it because when I tried to edit it to delete that, I couldn't find it.. =\

'Cause I already took care of it; I'm that awesome. --Gwern (contribs) 04:07, 3 November 2006 (UTC)

I am taking the words "at least" out of the phrase "there was probably at least as much poetry written on the German side but..." I have little doubt this could be true as the Germans were noted poets and musicians as a culture. But without a citation the phrase at least is innacurate, it gives the impression that the Germans wrote more poetry that didn't get heard. This may well be so, and I am willing to take it on faith that they produced as much, but the idea that they created more without citation is innacurate, until proven accurate. Colin 8 19:05, 6 May 2007 (UTC)

War poetry

Wouldn't this article be better if renamed to War poetry (which is currently a redirect), and altered to fit that title? Unfortunately, I don't have the expertise to do it.

-- TimNelson (talk) 00:58, 16 November 2009 (UTC)

I have started down the road to expanding (and hopefully improving?) this article on the basis of its title "War poet". I certainly agree there should be an a separate article "War poetry" - although I certainly would not be competent to start one! Þjóðólfr (talk) 19:18, 1 December 2009 (UTC)

World View

I am removing the world view tag - Doughboy is not tagged as we would not expect much coverage of the British in such an article. Likewise, while I have not checked the nationalities of the sixteen commemorated at Westminster Abbey, I am sure they would include any notable Commonwealth poets. The Americans made the difference in winning WW1 but theirs was a different war to that experienced by the War Poets. Þjóðólfr (talk) 21:13, 1 December 2009 (UTC)

Actually It is 3.5 Welsh, 1 Scot and 11.5 English. Þjóðólfr (talk) 22:55, 1 December 2009 (UTC)

Is this article limited to British or UK authors?

In the discussion above by Þjóðólfr it states: "The Americans made the difference in winning WW1 but theirs was a different war to that experienced by the War Poets." This implies that the term "War Poets" is limited to "Commonwealth poets." If it is so limited, then it should say so explicitly. Instead, the article gives a broader definition of a War Poet: "A War poet is a poet writing in time of and on the subject of war," and while that paragraph states the term was particularly applied to WWI poets it doesn't state that the article is limited to that time period, as other time periods are included. Moreover, a German poet is mentioned. Is it solely European War Poets that are to be discussed or Commonwealth plus European? How many poems do you have to write to be a "War Poet"?

What about Thomas Hardy? Last I heard he was born in England. (see below for page with link to his poetry)

If you are not just limiting this to Commonwealth or WWI poets, Stephen Crane should be included; he wrote poetry as well as prose after the American Civil War but before the First World War. See "War Is kind." http://poetry.about.com/library/weekly/blscranewar.htm

Other American poets wrote about war during this time." Walt Whitman wrote:

Dirge for Two Veterans (1900)

http://poetry.about.com/od/poems/l/blwhitmandirge.htm

"Look down Fair Moon," and especially verses 18 & 19 of "When Lilacs Last in the Dooryard Bloom’d" (1900) :http://poetry.about.com/library/weekly/blwhitmanwar.htm

Robert Frost's "But not to keep" (1917) was written in the WWI period http://poetry.about.com/od/poems/l/blfrostwar.htm

Some other poets that might qualify include:

Herman Melville - Shiloh - A Requiem (1868)

Thomas Hardy “In Time of ‘The Breaking of Nations" & "The Man He Killed"(1915)

Carl Sandburg 1916 & 1918

Elizabeth Barrett Browning "Mother & Poet" (1862)

For these poets and some others, see http://poetry.about.com/od/ourpoemcollections/a/poemsofwar.htm

By the way, in the section titled "Later Wars," some of the names listed are of U.S. born poets.

Ileanadu (talk) 09:08, 14 March 2010 (UTC)

Any Living WWI Poets?

In the section titled World War I it states:

Several poets writing in English were soldiers, and wrote about their experiences of war. A number of them died ....

I should think they all died. Are there any still living? Anyway, I assume this is meant to say they died in battle or during the war they wrote about or something like that. Cheers. Ileanadu (talk) 09:16, 14 March 2010 (UTC)