Talk:Band Aid (band)
|This is the talk page for discussing improvements to the Band Aid (band) article.|
|A fact from this article was featured on Wikipedia's Main Page in the On this day... section on November 25, 2004, November 25, 2005, and November 25, 2008.|
|This article must adhere to the biographies of living persons policy, even if it is not a biography, because it contains material about living persons. Contentious material about living persons that is unsourced or poorly sourced must be removed immediately from the article and its talk page, especially if potentially libellous. If such material is repeatedly inserted, or if you have other concerns, please report the issue to this noticeboard. If you are connected to one of the subjects of this article and need help, please see this page.|
|This article is of interest to the following WikiProjects:|
- 1 Roger Taylor
- 2 Band Aid 20 participants
- 3 If you had any say in how they run Band Aid...
- 4 REALISATION
- 5 Merge
- 6 Appeal for Brits and for Live Aid/Band Aid supporters
- 7 Band-Aid
- 8 Vocals
- 9 Style
- 10 Requested move
- 11 Bitter sting of tears
- 12 Artist not mention in article but on record
- 13 Bias against Band Aid II version
- 14 Possible copyvio
- 15 Move Artical?
- 16 Today's revenues?
- 17 Format & layout
I see there's a bit of disagreement about which Roger Taylor played on the record. I'm no fan of chode chugger chode Duran Duran, but the discography at the Queen drummer's website here looks pretty comprehensive to me (it includes, for example, "Billy Squier Emotions In Motion. B[acking] v[ocals]'s on title track. 1982"), and it doesn't mention Band Aid. It looks like it was Duran Duran's Roger Taylor to me. --Camembert
- Yeah... I've got the Do They Know It's Christmas 12" on my lap, with a big photo of everyone, and one of those outline maps telling you who everyone is. Seriously... It's the Duran Duran fella. Mintguy's looking at the wrong bloke. -Nommo
- Yeah. I was looking at a picture of the guy from Heaven 17 on a bad quality group photo. Humble apologies. Sorry for the mistake. Mintguy 14:50 Apr 19, 2003 (UTC)
22.214.171.124 said: I have no idea how to edit the chart-thing up there, but everything after Bono's "Well tonight..." is obviously pulled out of someones ***. This is the original version I'm talking about. Please.
- Well, I don't know. The list of who sings what in the 1984 line-up looks fine to me. You should have a look at the video. The guys singing after Bono perfectly look like the Status Quo or Style Council or Heaven 17 blokes to me. Or are you referring to someone else? --DoubleDee
Band Aid 20 participants
- I have the group phot from the day in front of me. Bono, Dido, Robbie, Paul McCartney etc are absent, but everyone else is there, plus a few not on the list (presumably they do appear on the record in some capacity) Dtcdthingy 09:36, 6 Dec 2004 (UTC)
Hey guys! I need your help here: I'm trying to spot all of the participants to the original band aid, not only those who actually sang (I guess the list is complete), but those who left a message in the 12" version... can you help me??? Thanks, Elli
OK. Well, this is Bono here, the singer, with U2 wishing you a Happy Christmas and a Merry New Year. Is that right? Hello, this is Paul McCartney. Sorry, I can't be with you. Hahaha.... Hi, this is Simon from Duran Duran. I'd like to say... I'd like to wish you Happy Christmas. I'm Paul Weller from the Style Council. I wish you all Happy Christmas. Hello, this is Midge Ure from Ultravox. I nearly forgot there's so many beautiful groups here today. Uh... just have a good Christmas and enjoy yourself. Hello, hello, this is Paul McCartney. Feed the world.... Hello, this is Paul McCartney. Hello, this is Paul McCartney. Feed the world.... Sorry, I can't be with you.... This is Jon Moss from Culture Club saying feed the world. There are 11 million people starving in one country. Doesn't it make you think? This is Holly Johnson from Frankie Goes to Hollywood. Feed the world. Hahahahahaha.... I can't get the laugh right, but... yeah, yeah, yeah. Hello, this is Gary Kemp from Spandau Ballet. Happy Christmas everyone. This is John Tailor from Duran Duran. Happy Christmas everybody too. Hello, I'm Siobhan. Happy Christmas. Hello, I'm Sarah from Bananarama. Happy Christmas. And from me too, Karen. Hello, this is Glenn Gregory from Heaven 17 wishing everybody a very Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year. Hello there, this is Stuart Adamson. This is Tony Butler. This is Mark Brzezcki. This is Bruce Watson from Big Country. Feed the people. Stay alive. This is Johnny Fingers from Boomtown Rats and I'd like to wish everyone a Happy Christmas. This is David Bowie. It's Christmas 1984. And there are more starving folk on our planet than ever before. Please give a thought for them this season and do whatever you can, however small, to help them live. Have a peaceful New Year. This record was recorded on the 25th of November 1984. It's now 8 a.m. in the morning of the 26th. We've been here 24 hours and I think it's time we went home. So from me, Bob Geldof and Midge, we'd say good morning to you all and a million thanks to everyone on the record. Have a lovely Christmas. Bye.
Hope this helps. Yves Revi 22:04, 26 December 2006 (UTC)
If you had any say in how they run Band Aid...
You could let all Commonwealth (of Nations) musicians in. I want to see Scribe or the Deceptikonz or even Fast Crew) rapping the lines that Dizzee Rascal added. Scott Gall 10:23, 11 Mar 2005 (UTC)
i felt impelled to post - hope i dont waffle too much.
i have followed the band aid 20 saga from the outset when the nation began pushing for a re-release, and i eagerly watched the media coverage of the recording day and then counted down to the release. i heard the first airplay on radio one and although i got shivers down my spine, i will admit that i initially felt a sense of disappointment as the kick was not the same as the original- except for bono's line which left me lost for words. however, over time i have come to love this as much as the original, and even appreciated the 2nd release for the first time. i think the cause is so important.
but, my overriding feeling hit me just 20 minutes ago when i saw the video of band aid 20 for the first time. i remember watching the video footage 20 years ago at school and seeing boys cry real tears, that hit hard...............when the current video showed excerpted footage and the expressions on stars faces i sat back, realised and sobbed.
thankyou for bringing this back to our attention - well done and god bless you all
Bob Geldof and Midge Ure are extraordinary men
Love Sam xxx
This should be merged with the article for the single - since the band only has one single, the two are pretty much inseparable concepts. Phil Sandifer 20:19, 12 November 2005 (UTC)
Appeal for Brits and for Live Aid/Band Aid supporters
From the article:
- The name "Band Aid" was chosen because it had a double meaning. ...such a gesture is like putting a BAND-AID (a brand of sticking plaster/adhesive bandage) on a gaping wound...
This is accurate and verifiable, in the sense that members of Band Aid said something like this? I ask because it is my understanding that the word Band-Aid, (as a genericized trademark), isn't used outside of American English. Savatar 04:34, 4 June 2006 (UTC)
- Yes, I was wondering about this as well, I'm English, and ... well ... the phrase "band aid" is simply not used here. The term over here is "plaster" so... yeah.
I'm going to delete that bit. People can add it again if they have any link to verify this, I'm going to assume it's not true though, seeing as the term is not used this side of the Atlantic. LupusCanis 10:09, 9 June 2006 (UTC)
- Eh? Band-Aid is a leading brand of sticking plaster in the UK, and was in 1984 as well. And Geldof mentioned in his autobiography that he seized on the name when someone suggested it because he liked the pun. -126.96.36.199 (talk) 10:42, 23 January 2008 (UTC)
Is a citation needed? I believe so, as someone who bought the single at the time of release I had never heard of the brand of sticking plasters, and neither the Band-aid wikipedia page nor the band-aid corporate website make no mention of the product being sold in the UK. — Preceding unsigned comment added by 188.8.131.52 (talk) 22:29, 6 April 2012 (UTC)
In the 1984 version, after the line "The greatest gift they'll get this year is life," there is an "Ohhhhhhhh" sung by somebody, and it is a real standout moment for the song. Who hit that lyric?184.108.40.206 23:29, 2 March 2007 (UTC)
In the second version, I'm sure that the first phrase of 'There's a world outside your window, and it's a world of dread and fear' is sung by Marti Pellow. If someone could double check we should change it to "Marti Pellow/Jason Donovan". — Preceding unsigned comment added by Codegenerator (talk • contribs) 01:59, 16 November 2011 (UTC)
Since I last looked at this article the language has become more casual and chatty. It's more style than substance: e.g. the exchange between Bone and Damon Albarn - are these actual citable quotes? I won't edit unless there is some agreement here. Btljs 08:55, 26 July 2006 (UTC)
Bitter sting of tears
I've been in a slight edit war with 220.127.116.11 - he claims that I work with Bob Geldof and have the original lyrics, and thus changes bitter sting of tears to bitter stream of tears. Now, every lyric site on the net I have ever seen agrees with me on this one, and claims that he shouldn't need to cite a reliable published source. It might be just rolling, but I'm up to three reverts, so figured someone else should take a look. mattbuck (talk) 11:11, 8 December 2007 (UTC)
Artist not mention in article but on record
I have the 7inch original record and artists like Annie Lennox are mention there but not in the article. Why? because she i obviously mentioned on the back of the record case. —Preceding unsigned comment added by 18.104.22.168 (talk) 09:51, 27 January 2009 (UTC)
Bias against Band Aid II version
I've noticed that a lot of self-styled commentators have a poor view of Band Aid II's version, but that a lot of ordinary people quite like it. I think it would be best if people kept their personal opinions about that version out of articles like this.
- The second version is brilliant, nice and poppy. BTW, if Roger Taylor was in it, doesn't that put him alongside Banararama in being someone who appeared in both the first and seocnd versions?? I havn't spotted him in the second video because the drums were played by Luke Goss off Bros (at the time). Fuquit (talk) 12:12, 13 December 2008 (UTC)
Isn't this song copyrighted? If it is - which I'm sure it will be - doesn't that make the Band Aid (band)#Who sings what on each version section a copyright violation? I'm probably wrong, but just in case... Dendodge TalkContribs 20:06, 20 December 2008 (UTC)
- Since no-one's responded yet, I'm removing the section pending discussion. The last thing Wikipedia wants is a copyright violation - especially one which the community has failed to address. Dendodge TalkContribs 13:44, 1 January 2009 (UTC)
- I suggest that instead of showing the lyrics with the singer next to each line, we just show the order as to who is singing in each version. This way, if someone is listening to the recording and following the ordered list, they should be able to figure out what lyric is being sung by each singer (hopefully, the listener will be able to recognize at least some of the performers to help guide them through the list). For example, the list for the original 1984 recording would look like this:
- Paul Young
- Boy George
- George Michael
- George Michael/Simon Le Bon
- Simon Le Bon/Sting
- Simon Le Bon/Sting/Tony Hadley
- It seems to me that the information cannot be presented effectively without being a big copyvio, so it would seem best to just remove it altogether so it doesn't detract from people's understanding. -mattbuck (Talk) 13:16, 25 January 2009 (UTC)
I'm really not sure about the self-rightousness sections claim of it being a boring song. It is one of (if not the) most popular christmas songs across the world. I think claims of it not being popular are absurd! —Preceding unsigned comment added by 22.214.171.124 (talk) 20:16, 16 December 2009 (UTC)
The 1984 version is still played each Christmas. What happens to today's revenue streams, are they still going to 3rd world projects? I think that would be an interesting topic to include in the article. —Preceding unsigned comment added by 126.96.36.199 (talk) 06:02, 7 March 2011 (UTC)
Format & layout
There is no main image on the right hand side of the article meaning the article does not follow the standard layout of a Wikipedia article. It also has very little general information in the banner on the right hand side meaning it does not follow the standard layout of a Wikipedia article. The section titled ‘Background’ is very small and therefore is not of convenient length. The article needs many more images including one of the band itself. - Jonesolivia — Preceding unsigned comment added by Jonesolivia (talk • contribs) 05:21, 5 March 2014 (UTC)